Rape By Deception???

You and Fuji really need to stop your pathetic, non fact based ....

Amusing coming from you. Try arguing the points in my post if you can.

I would also like to see you or one of the rest of the crew explain why it is so important to comment on issues in Israel while staying completely silent on the horrendous 150,000 or so dead, over 2 million refugees, and 4 million internally displaced in the Syrian conflict.
 
...
Jewish terrorist groups were around long before Christian, Muslim or any others
One needs only look at the Sicarii who murdered Romans and their allies...

Wow. This has to be one of the worst arguments yet. Are you seriously trying to justify Palestinian terror attacks on purely civilian targets by saying that some 2,000 years ago some Jews killed some Romans?
 
History lesson for you
1929 was already terror between Jewish & Palestine
Both sides had terrorists and both sides committed atrocities...

You should really take a look at that history.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_killings_and_massacres_in_Mandatory_Palestine

Nebi Musa riots: 1920: responsible party - Arabs
Jaffa riots: 1920: responsible party - Arabs
Palestine riots: 1929: responsible party - Arabs
Safed Massacre: 1929: responsible party - Arabs

And you claim that somehow Jewish actions in 1937 was the root of the issue?

p.s. Irgun didn't even exist until after 1931 and a few hundred Jews were killed by well organized Arab attacks.
 
I reject attempts to say hey this is a two sides conflict they must both be to blame. Israel is a modern western democracy with full rights for all. The Arab citizens of Israel have full equality.

With all due respect - bullshit. If I may quote a joint Israel group fighting for equal rights: ' Israel's 1.37 million Arab citizens vote, pay taxes and speak Hebrew, yet suffer pervasive discrimination, unequal allocation of resources and violation of their legal rights. Housing, education, and income all substantially lag that of the Jewish majority. Only 3 percent of the land in Israel proper is owned by Arabs; permits are rarely granted to Arab families to expand their housing; and most Jewish towns and neighborhoods remain off-limits.'

There are ample examples of Israel evicting Palestinians off their land as Israel continues a program of new settlements in territory that exceeds the UN boundaries laid out in 1948. The settlements not only displace the native owners but affect more territory as it impedes the flow of the native people between them. So Israel wants peace but not at the expense of returning territories seized in 1967.

This may come as a shock to you but in any area that people are oppressed by strong military that would annihilate a frontal confrontation - terrorism will spring up. It is the only hope that these people have to reverse the tide. I'm not condoning it - but to sit back and suggest that Israel is an innocent victim here is extremely naive. BTW: I do believe in the right of Israel to exist - I just believe they have intentionally put their own civilians at risk in the move to solidify more territorial expansion.

Finally, how did Jews react when fighting for their homeland in similar circumstances ? When they had no country and were in the population minority up sprung Irgun headed by Menachem Begin. If I may quote ...'The Irgun has been viewed as a terrorist organization or organization which carried out terrorist acts. In particular the Irgun was branded a terrorist organisation by Britain (sic : who occupied the Palestine Mandate). The Irgun believed that any means necessary to establish the Jewish State of Israel, including terrorism, was justifiable'

It is the unconditional support that you support that allows Israel to continue to repress the Arab minority. BTW: How does the news item that started this thread fit in with your utopian view of Israel ?
 
With all due respect - bullshit. If I may quote a joint Israel group fighting for equal rights: ' Israel's 1.37 million Arab citizens vote, pay taxes and speak Hebrew, yet suffer pervasive discrimination, unequal allocation of resources and violation of their legal rights. Housing, education, and income all substantially lag that of the Jewish majority. Only 3 percent of the land in Israel proper is owned by Arabs; permits are rarely granted to Arab families to expand their housing; and most Jewish towns and neighborhoods remain off-limits.'

I love these quotes, what percent of the land in Israel proper is owned by Jews? What percent is owned by ANYONE?

Hint: Israel is mostly desert.

Are there cases of discrimination? In a country where neighbouring Palestinians are hell bent on the annihilation of Israel, it would be surprising if there weren't. But it remains the case that not only do Arabs in Israel enjoy full legal equality, they have better rights than Arabs any other middle eastern country. Better than in Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, etc.

There are ample examples of Israel evicting Palestinians off their land as Israel continues a program of new settlements in territory that exceeds the UN boundaries laid out in 1948.

The borders defined in 48 were militarily indefensible. Had there been no war, had the Palestinians not attacked, that might not matter. But there have been repeated Arab attacks on Israel, so it is obvious that to survive, Israel needs defensible borders.

I don't think there is anyone who thinks Israel should go back to 48 borders.


The 67 borders are the usual starting point, although why exactly Arabs should keep territory they lost in a war of aggression they started is unclear. In any case, there is a lot of political momentum behind making a land for peace deal with that as a starting point.

However, again there are military concerns. Israel will not accept the wasp waist which would enable the Arabs to bisect Israel with abb armored column from the West Bank to Netanya. If you look at the most controversial settlement building, a great deal of it is about obtaining an advantageous military position against a future attack.

Thus the sensible outcome are land swaps that alleviate Israeli security concerns by exchanging land around the wasp waist in exchange for equally good but less strategically important land elsewhere.

Unfortunately, the Palestinians have refused to consider any such proposal, and have walked away from, or refused to attend any piece deal. They are apparently not interested in peace.


This may come as a shock to you but in any area that people are oppressed by strong military that would annihilate a frontal confrontation - terrorism will spring up.

Except the Palestinians began their genocidal attacks, their terrorism, before any of that. The PLO formed while the West Bank and Gaza were not under Israeli control.


Finally, how did Jews react when fighting for their homeland in similar circumstances ? When they had no country and were in the population minority up sprung Irgun headed by Menachem Begin.

Except that Irgun was a fringe group. The mainstream Jewish forces never engaged in terrorism, opposed Irgun, fought them during the civil war at times to defend Arabs from their attacks, and when war was over, disarmed Irgun at gunpoint. They were offered political inclusion in order to achieve peace, an offer that has been extended to the Palestinians as well.

On the Palestinian side on the contrary it is the mainstream groups that are terrorists, and one repudiated them. On the contrary they elected Abbas president, even though he was one of the organizers of the Munich massacre, and in Gaza, Hamas is openly terrorist.

Why haven't the Palestinians disarmed Hamas, the way Haganah disarmed Irgun? Seventy years later, the Palestinians still have terrorists in all offices.
 
... Only 3 percent of the land in Israel proper is owned by Arabs;...

Around 90% of Israeli land is state owned. Arabs represent 20% of the population and own 30% of the private land. Hardly seems discriminatory to me. Yes there is discrimination in Israel (both ways) just like there is discrimination in Canada. What bothers me (and why I post on the topic) is the desire of many to target Israel for criticism while ignoring far far worse situations in the world. Obviously there must be something else at play here to explain why there is so much criticism of Israel while next to no mention about things like the Syrian conflict that has created far more death and destruction in the past few years than any other events. But of course, people see the need to devote their time to distorting facts (like the land one) to serve their pathetic agendas.

I'll also respond 'with due respect' that the Palestinians hold a large share of blame in the conflict as well. Maybe Mandela will be reincarnated as a Palestinian leader that actually wants peace.

p.s. Abbas just turned down Kerry's offer today, another offer in line with the Arab League plan.
 
... BTW: How does the news item that started this thread fit in with your utopian view of Israel ?

The news article fits precisely in my my issue here. The story is that a guy was charged with violent rape and agreed to a plea bargain on a lesser charge but instead of looking at the facts, people found it more interesting to make all sorts of claims about Israel's evilness.
 
Citation needed. Over the entire seventy year conflict perhaps but Israel does not target civilians.



You yourself said it was collateral damage, so you have already admitted it is not mass murder. Israel's attacks on those firing rockets at Israel are legal warfare, and great efforts are made to reduce or avoid civilian casualties.

The reality is that civilians die in wars despite efforts to minimize civilian casualties.

What is it you think Israelis should do about the genocidal Palestinian attacks on Israeli civilians? Just die?



Sorry but scientists working on nuclear weapons are combatants. That is nothing like Palestinians infiltrating into Jewish communities and slitting the throats of children in their beds.




Irgun/Stern was a terrorist group. The Irgun attack on Deir Yassin was horrendous.

However Haganah has not attacked civilians, in fact on several occasions it got into a firefight with Irgun protecting Arab civilians. In the end, Haganah disarmed Irgun at gunpoint, ending its terrorism.

I certainly distinguish between Palestinians in general, and Palestinian terrorists like Hamas. It sounds like you want to justify attacks on all Jews, and on the Israeli state, because of the actions of some radicals seventy years ago. Thinly disguised racism seems like the one explanation, if so.

The Israeli state does not attack civilians.

And, I note, the Palestinians have not disarmed Hamas at gunpoint, the way Israel disarmed Jewish terrorists when they were active.

Fuji Believes wanton disregard for the safety of civilians is a massive moral difference then actually trying to kill off duty soldiers.
 
Fuji Believes wanton disregard for the safety of civilians is a massive moral difference then actually trying to kill off duty soldiers.

Israel does not ratify wantonly disregard the safety of civilians. Israel clearly seeks to minimize civilian casualties, and tries to ensure that it targets only legitimate military targets. That is hard to do when the enemy uses human shields and fires missiles from the street outside a school, but they do clearly try.

I realize you hate the laws of armed conflict, and disparage the moral principal behind the prohibition against attacks on civilians. You have repeatedly justified terrorism, and the bombing civilian targets. You have shown repeatedly that you have no moral compass.

In fact your hypocrisy knows no limits: you argue that the Palestinians should be able to engage in terror because they have no other choice, then rail against Israel for any accidental killing people in vicinity a rocket launcher aimed at an Israeli town. The no choice logic appears to justify only attacks on Jews in your mind.
 
I reject attempts to say hey this is a two sides conflict they must both be to blame. Israel is a modern western democracy with full rights for all. The Arab citizens of Israel have full equality. Israel defends itself from external attack without targeting civilians. Israel has reached reasonable peace agreement, formal or informal, with any if it's neighbors actually interested in peace (Jordan and Egypt formally, Saudi Arabia etc informally).

On the other side you have avowed terrorists who primarily target civilians, ethnically cleansed all territory under their control of all Jews, explicitly commit to further ethnic cleansing if they get the chance, and resist democracy their own territory. Hamas had a crack at democracy, winning control of their congress, and they immediately dismantled it, carried out a violent coup to seize presidential power, and have refused to hold new elections since. Hamas openly say they will never accept peace with Israel.

There is no equivalency. If you value democracy, human rights, and the rule of law, Israel must be supported against the forces of tyranny and genocide arrayed against it.

Isn't it true that usually the side with better military, more money, advanced equipment seem to act more civilized and able to suppress and marginalized the weaker group without use of force - through such means as unjust laws, taxation and subtle discrimination. The weaker side usually resorts to violence and gorilla warfare. Just look at American revolution - against better equipment British who seem to act more civilized and adhere to "laws" they passed in their "democratic" parliment to marginalized colonists, and create a system to take away their rights and freedom.

Similar situation is happening with Israel and Palestine - Israel is disguising itself behind the veil of "democracy" to marginalize the weaker group of Arabs to their own advantage.

Fuji, you are a blind believer of so called "democracy", in fact I have in many occasions contradicted your thesis that the ideal of democracy does not exist in reality, - much like ideal of communism is just a dream. Many democratic countries are run by secret government agencies, and many are corrupt and poor. On the other hand, there are many countries benefited from stable government and economic growth guided by benevolent authoritarian government.
 
Isn't it true that usually the side with better military, more money, advanced equipment seem to act more civilized and able to suppress and marginalized the weaker group without use of force

In 1947 conventional wisdom was that the Palestinians would defeat the Jews. The expectation was that they had a huge numerical advantage, and that they were directly supported by multiple nation states. Everyone, including the British, thought that the Jews were going to lose the war. The Palestinians were absolutely sure that they would win. In fact, for the first few months the Jewish war position was collapsing, and everybody thought they would lose, right up until they put Plan D into effect.

That didn't stop the a Palestinians from explicitly stating that their war goal was the complete ethnic cleansing of all Jews, something that they have done in all territory under Arab control: not even one Jew is left living there. On the other side, while there were terrorist groups like Irgun around, the mainstream Jewish forces like Haganah extended offers of full equality to Arabs willing to live in peace, and lived up to that promise, those Arabs are still there, and have full Israeli citizenship.

So no, in this conflict when the Jews have been the underdog it was still the case that they acted humanely, extended rights, and at least the factions that became IDF avoided unnecessary civilian casualties. The Palestinians, when they had the upper hand, expressly committed to genocide, and carried that genocide out where they could.

Fundamentally the behavior of the two sides has been the same ever since. The Palestinians have reiterated their commitment to ethnically cleanse Jews from the territory, and have continued to attack civilians wherever they can, and Israel has generally continued to avoid undue civilian casualties, and concentrated on strictly military targets.
 
Isn't it true that usually the side with better military, more money, advanced equipment seem to act more civilized...

Is that what we are seeing in Syria? Or saw in Rwanda? Bosnia?

As for terrorism as a valid response, is that what we see in Tibet? Is that what made Mandela a world icon?

The 'veil of democracy' in Israel is a true democracy. The vast majority of Israelis support a two state peace. Meanwhile, Abbas just rejected Kerry's two state plan, just like they rejected Olmert's even better offer, Clinton's plan, the offer at Camp David, the UN Partition of Palestine, the Peel Commission plan ... (Not to mention that one of the two Palestinians governments refuses any peace where Israel continues to exist and promotes attacks on civilians as a method to destroy Israel).

I doubt anyone says that Israel is perfect but to wantonly ignore the faults on the Palestinian side and purposely ignore far worse situations in the world is pathetic.
 
The borders defined in 48 were militarily indefensible. Had there been no war, had the Palestinians not attacked, that might not matter. But there have been repeated Arab attacks on Israel, so it is obvious that to survive, Israel needs defensible borders.

I don't think there is anyone who thinks Israel should go back to 48 borders.

By anyone, I'm guessing those sympathetic to Israel. You obvious not implying that the displaced Palestinians or any of their Arab neighbours feel that way. Sheesh !

.. although why exactly Arabs should keep territory they lost in a war of aggression they started is unclear.

China, Stalin, Hitler, Japan ... you are in good company !

If you look at the most controversial settlement building, a great deal of it is about obtaining an advantageous military position against a future attack.

Yes, most military strategists prefer building civilian communities instead of military outposts to protect against armed aggression. Makes total sense.

Unfortunately, the Palestinians have refused to consider any such proposal, and have walked away from, or refused to attend any piece deal. They are apparently not interested in peace.

If they are not willing to accept Israel's territorial expansion and any other hard line Israel position - like Tibet with China - they really aren't interested in peace.

Except that Irgun was a fringe group. The mainstream Jewish forces never engaged in terrorism, opposed Irgun, fought them during the civil war at times to defend Arabs from their attacks, and when war was over, disarmed Irgun at gunpoint. They were offered political inclusion in order to achieve peace, an offer that has been extended to the Palestinians as well. .... Why haven't the Palestinians disarmed Hamas, the way Haganah disarmed Irgun?

There was no mainstream Jewish forces, the Jews were still the minority (before the huge immigration influx). Irgun was fighting for a Jewish state - they got it. Their mandate was complete - terrorism had won ! Their leader Menachem Begin was hailed a hero and his terrorist ... oops .. patriotic fighting past helped his political future.
 
Most serious peace proposals are close to the Green Line (1948 borders) with mitually agreed upon swaps so yes I agree with Green Line and so do most serious people. The majority of the settlements have to go.