Rape By Deception???

yung_dood

Banned
Jul 2, 2011
1,695
2
0
Should it be rape if you rape lie about your race/ethnicity to someone and they have sex with you?

 
I can't view the youtube at this time but I remember quite a few years back, a girl brought a charge against a man who said he was a Hollywood producer just to get her to have voluntary sex. The judge threw out the case suggesting that if they charge every guy who enhanced his status to get a date with a woman, the court system would be clogged with an overwhelming number of cases. He also suggested that an adult woman should be able to use her own judgement without using the law to screen suitable suitors.

I don't think it was appealed - certainly made sense to me.
 
Any woman who would have sex with a guy because he says he's a Hollywood producer is an idiot.
 
No. The Supreme Court said "no dice" already.

The sort of "deception" that'll get you charged w rape is not telling the woman you have AIDS or herpes. I had an argument w After Hours a couple years ago where I also suggested that posing as a doctor and performing a gynecological exam on a woman when actually you're a taxi driver would probably also get you nailed w a sexual assault charge. But simply lying to get laid in the normal sense is not against the law.
 
I've never lied to a woman....

If they assumed I was a pilot just because I was wearing a uniform and hanging out in airport hotel bars that's their problem.......
 
Can't wrap my head around how any form of major Orthodoxy (which this is) would be okay with a woman having pre-marital sex (story said they were "dating") and then charge and convict a guy in this regard...

Should it be rape if you rape lie about your race/ethnicity to someone and they have sex with you?

 
Uh, no.

That's as stupid as that guy from China(?) who is suing his wife because they had an ugly daughter. He claims she tricked him into believing she was beautiful with plastic surgery and make-up.
 
Last edited:
Wow , the jews are acting out like hitler . Keeping the race pure. Really.
Since when did people have to date, marry, have sexual relations with people they don't want to for any damn reason they choose? How is that in anyway "acting out like Hitler?!"
 
It seems like this thread is developing into one where it needs to be mentioned again that merely because something is not criminal, doesn't mean that it is morally or ethically right.
 
Wow , the jews are acting out like hitler . Keeping the race pure. Really.

There is a major difference between unjust convictions in the name of ethnic purity, and the senseless, brutal torture used in efforts to exterminate Jews. I don't think Jews put millions of people in gas chambers or conduct "medical" experiments to see what would happen by things like freezing people, amputating their body parts or removing major organs without anesthesia.

While I do not agree with this conviction whatsoever, this seems to only be about Orthodox Jews, not ALL of them. Most forms of Orthodoxy - in any religion - are the extreme end of a continuum.
 
There is a major difference between unjust convictions in the name of ethnic purity, and the senseless, brutal torture used in efforts to exterminate Jews. I don't think Jews put millions of people in gas chambers or conduct "medical" experiments to see what would happen by things like freezing people, amputating their body parts or removing major organs without anesthesia.

While I do not agree with this conviction whatsoever, this seems to only be about Orthodox Jews, not ALL of them. Most forms of Orthodoxy - in any religion - are the extreme end of a continuum.

But you have to admit persuit of ethnic purity is a beginning and slippery slope.