Question about tipping

Yes and No, depending on where you dine. If it clearly states that the gratuity will be included for certain reasons, and you've met those reason, it is legally binding just like taxes. I for one am not a fan of it either, but if clearly stated...?



Legally binding?
Absolutely not
Any legal beagles on the board care to chime in on this one

I have only observed the pre-fill on the tip a couple of times & when inquired it was not explicitly stated upfront, other wise I would walked away upfront

As far a restaurateur threatening me with legal action for not complying with his / her unacceptable billing practices goes, once I stopped laughing I would just walk away after leaving zero tip
 
Legally binding?
Absolutely not
Any legal beagles on the board care to chime in on this one

I have only observed the pre-fill on the tip a couple of times & when inquired it was not explicitly stated upfront, other wise I would walked away upfront

As far a restaurateur threatening me with legal action for not complying with his / her unacceptable billing practices goes, once I stopped laughing I would just walk away after leaving zero tip

So explain how a number of other businesses (e.g.mechanics) can charge sevice?
 
So explain how a number of other businesses (e.g.mechanics) can charge sevice?
gonna have to explain that a little better. mechanics charge for parts and labour. by your theory they should be tipped as well since they are service industry.
 
gonna have to explain that a little better. mechanics charge for parts and labour. by your theory they should be tipped as well since they are service industry.

Once a charge is stated before services rendered (e.g. in the menu) then the customer must pay for services as provided.
 
Once a charge is stated before services rendered (e.g. in the menu) then the customer must pay for services as provided.
mechanics give estimates, they don't tell you how much as a 100%. they have an hourly charge, they give you an estimate based on everything going right. you picked the wrong industry to go after for a comparison.
 
mechanics give estimates, they don't tell you how much as a 100%. they have an hourly charge, they give you an estimate based on everything going right. you picked the wrong industry to go after for a comparison.

I think presenting a menu that states the prices and percentage that will be added for large groups is a pretty accurate estimate. You are not then forced to dine.

Ever book a wedding? Same thing applies.
 
I think presenting a menu that states the prices and percentage that will be added for large groups is a pretty accurate estimate. You are not then forced to dine.

Ever book a wedding? Same thing applies.
i have seen what you are talking about on the bottom of the menu. 15% gratuity for dinners over whatever price, i ignore that completely, i will tip what i think is fair. there is nothing binding about a tip. sorry man, you are wrong on that one. if a bill comes to my table with a tip added i will ask for the manager and i will have that removed. they cannot force me to give something that is a gift for service.
 
i am probably gonna regret asking this one then. i been in a hotel for 10 days now. what would be an acceptable tip with them making the room up every other day. then on top of that how do i split the tip up cuz i know there was at least 3 different girls came in here.
 
i have seen what you are talking about on the bottom of the menu. 15% gratuity for dinners over whatever price, i ignore that completely, i will tip what i think is fair. there is nothing binding about a tip. sorry man, you are wrong on that one. if a bill comes to my table with a tip added i will ask for the manager and i will have that removed. they cannot force me to give something that is a gift for service.

Sorry, but when prices are posted you are not in a position to refuse payment. You may challange it (and the manager would use his/her judgement to agree or not), but refusal for charges stated before any service was provided are to be paid following service. Same as when you go to the store, mechanic, or barber. What is the point of declaring charges if everyone could refuse to pay after?

Just a question. Would you do the same at an MP? Why or why not?
 
Sorry, but when prices are posted you are not in a position to refuse payment. You may challange it (and the manager would use his/her judgement to agree or not), but refusal for charges stated before any service was provided are to be paid following service. Same as when you go to the store, mechanic, or barber. What is the point of declaring charges if everyone could refuse to pay after?

Just a question. Would you do the same at an MP? Why or why not?
you go to that place you are told the price of the room and the price of what you want in the the room. you don't get told the room price, the options price, then the mandatory tip price. also where i see on the bottom of the menu is not being stated as mandatory it is saying a suggested amount to tip. if i tol that i have to give a mandatory tip even if the service is shit, i will leave, then tell my friends never to go there. a ti is not mandatory.

tell me my steak dinner is 45$ i will pay the 45$ to the restaurant. you tell me my steak dinner is 45$ and i have no choice but to tip the waitress 15%, i will mozey on down the street to the next steak joint. you want me to pay your waitress so you don't have to, that's fine but she is not leaving my table side and i am not going without anything while i am there. do away with tips and raise the price of my steak dinner then give her a cut. don't tell me what i have to give on top of the bill.
 
you go to that place you are told the price of the room and the price of what you want in the the room. you don't get told the room price, the options price, then the mandatory tip price. also where i see on the bottom of the menu is not being stated as mandatory it is saying a suggested amount to tip. if i tol that i have to give a mandatory tip even if the service is shit, i will leave, then tell my friends never to go there. a ti is not mandatory.

tell me my steak dinner is 45$ i will pay the 45$ to the restaurant. you tell me my steak dinner is 45$ and i have no choice but to tip the waitress 15%, i will mozey on down the street to the next steak joint. you want me to pay your waitress so you don't have to, that's fine but she is not leaving my table side and i am not going without anything while i am there. do away with tips and raise the price of my steak dinner then give her a cut. don't tell me what i have to give on top of the bill.

You make it sound as if this does not happen at many, many places (many of which I'm sure you patron). $45 for the steak and that's all? Tax isn't listed beside the price (it's at the bottom near the gratuity lingo). Not leave your table side? I think you're looking for a servant. Then again, judging by some of the comments here, seems like many are for 10-15% (if we could only be so lucky).
Don't worry, this is just a conversation between 5-10 participants and many others reading. It's a topic that has been discussed here, and many of places, for a long time. I'm just glad that most people I serve don't think like the above comments indicate. If that is how you feel, then tell the server, or better yet the management since I'm guessing the servant/-er would be busy standing table-side, and let them know you have no intention of tipping otherwise. Sure you can play ignorant if you want, but if anything, whether a custom or extortion attempt, the expectation in this country is that the server will be tipped according to service.
 
Thats why it is best to tip each time you are having your room made up, just leave it on the night stand with a note for housekeeping.
i didn't even think about my room getting made up the first few days i was there, i was out doing other shit then i came back and the room was fixed. i thought it was the same girl but the times i was out during the day was either the morning girl or afternoon girl. i as busy out having fun and it was not something that even crossed my mind. i figured i was there for 10 days, they only got in and took care of the room every other day, so maybe 6 times total, 2 girls. i left a 20$ for each other them. so either 1 girl is honest and splits it or 1 girl got a 40$ tip. either way i probably won't see them again.
 
You make it sound as if this does not happen at many, many places (many of which I'm sure you patron). $45 for the steak and that's all? Tax isn't listed beside the price (it's at the bottom near the gratuity lingo). Not leave your table side? I think you're looking for a servant. Then again, judging by some of the comments here, seems like many are for 10-15% (if we could only be so lucky).
Don't worry, this is just a conversation between 5-10 participants and many others reading. It's a topic that has been discussed here, and many of places, for a long time. I'm just glad that most people I serve don't think like the above comments indicate. If that is how you feel, then tell the server, or better yet the management since I'm guessing the servant/-er would be busy standing table-side, and let them know you have no intention of tipping otherwise. Sure you can play ignorant if you want, but if anything, whether a custom or extortion attempt, the expectation in this country is that the server will be tipped according to service.
tax is a gov't induced cost on everything, that is not even a valid argument.
 
I've never heard this version. Perhaps it's true in some places but wait staff I've spoken with and know have never brought this up.

Besides, with the introduction of the HST, the single tax amount covers both food and alcohol so you'd actually hace to do the math to separate the two.

In Canada, the standard tip amount is 15% on the before tax total. Up to 20-25% should service exceed standard expectations. Another thing people seem to forget is that tip should be included on the food total only. Subtract any alchohol ordered off the bill and tip on that amount. Easy way to do it is to simply look at the tax amount and round up to the nearest $ and tip that amount. Since ontario tax is only 13% now, you may want to add a dollar or two more then the tax amount depending on the size of the bill. The reason I say food total only is because servers only tip out on the food sales total to bartenders, bussers ect... That is why you always see food and alchohol totals added seperately on the bill. This is something that I was told by a few friends of mine that work as servers (The Keg, Milestones).
paying tip on food total only is bullshit since I work in a bar and 90% of the bill in booze
 
 
i have seen what you are talking about on the bottom of the menu. 15% gratuity for dinners over whatever price, i ignore that completely, i will tip what i think is fair. there is nothing binding about a tip. sorry man, you are wrong on that one. if a bill comes to my table with a tip added i will ask for the manager and i will have that removed. they cannot force me to give something that is a gift for service.
If you have a problem with this policy, you should discuss it before you order or go elsewhere.
Knowing about the policy and then unilaterally deciding that it is not applicable to you, after you have finished, is extremely arrogant and rude.

I personally don`t like the practice of including tips but I am free to not go.
At Sushi on 7 they add 10% tip and we always tip another 15% or so because we get great service and very good food at a very reasonable price.
Places that add 15% would be highly unlikely to get any more from me and I would tend to avoid such places.
 
I usually tip 15-20% for good service but I will tip more or less when warranted.
This is simply the reality of the cost of going out in our society.

Not knowing the local customs is ignorant but knowing them and just saying fuck it is pathetic rude anti-social behaviour.

I have never considered excluding alcohol at a restaurant as this doesn`t make sense to me.
This makes about as much sense as excluding food at a bar.
I can understand a smaller percentage for an expensive bottle of wine or something like that but for typical $10 or so drinks it seems like a ridiculous cheap maneuver.
Plus many places are a bar and restaurant.
So if you sit at the bar or a table in the bar area you tip on the alcohol but if you are seated at a table in the dining area you don`t?