Yes and No, depending on where you dine. If it clearly states that the gratuity will be included for certain reasons, and you've met those reason, it is legally binding just like taxes. I for one am not a fan of it either, but if clearly stated...?
Legally binding?
Absolutely not
Any legal beagles on the board care to chime in on this one
I have only observed the pre-fill on the tip a couple of times & when inquired it was not explicitly stated upfront, other wise I would walked away upfront
As far a restaurateur threatening me with legal action for not complying with his / her unacceptable billing practices goes, once I stopped laughing I would just walk away after leaving zero tip

