Canada's International Reputation

was illegal, just as was the US decision to execute Germans infiltrators captured on US soil.
Where the Hell are you coming from with that nuts idea. It was even approved by the U.S. Supreme Court albeit after most of the saboteurs had already been executed.

Are you sure you aren’t the spirit of William Kunstler reincarnated in Canadian form. :mad:
 
Where the Hell are you coming from with that nuts idea. It was even approved by the U.S. Supreme Court albeit after most of the saboteurs had already been executed.

The Germans also believed that their execution of "terrorists" caught behind their line was legal. I happen to disagree with their courts as well. Secret executions following secret trials are anathema to democracy, freedom, and the rule of law. The US made a mockery of its justice system, undermining the notion that the courts are independent, and, in my view, demonstrating that the US Constitution isn't worth the paper it's written on.

All that said you are right, the USSC did rule that it was legal, and it's pointless to go on arguing about that, so I'll concede this point to you: Secret executions arising out of secret trials are legal in the United States, according to the USSC.

I can't make a strong case for the illegality of that, in light of that SC ruling, such as I can for something blatantly illegal like handing over a POW to be tortured.
 
something blatantly illegal like handing over a POW to be tortured.

This makes it sound like everything was pre-planned and numerous Afghans were picked up off the street and hand-delivered to Afghan guards rubbing their hands in glee at fresh meat. Still curious what is meant by "tortured" (images of "the rack") and what injuries, if any, were suffered.
 
Are you sure you aren’t the spirit of William Kunstler reincarnated in Canadian form.

William Kunstler, RIP.
GREAT American hero, Patriot and civil rights activist who KNEW the US Constitution was more much than a god-damned piece of paper that many in the right delude it to be!...:cool:
 
For anyone interested, look up KLAUS BARBIE, Nazi and master torturer. He was the villian who tortured French resistance leader JEAN MOULIN.
 
.....And KLAUS BARBIE is germane to Canada's International Reputation because?....:rolleyes:
 
This makes it sound like everything was pre-planned and numerous Afghans were picked up off the street and hand-delivered to Afghan guards rubbing their hands in glee at fresh meat.

Yup, that's more or less what happened. At the very beginning perhaps the Canadians didn't know what was going on, but soon enough they did, and so that more or less sums up how things operated from that point forward.

Still curious what is meant by "tortured" (images of "the rack") and what injuries, if any, were suffered.

The documentation submitted to the Parliamentary committee investigating the matter indicates:

-- Rape / sexual assault
-- Electrocution
-- Severe beatings

That's for starters. Since you may not think that rape, electrocution, and beatings during an interrogation count as torture I have been careful to say "beaten or tortured" throughout this discussion.

If you would like to assert that the beatings and electrocutions and rapes did not count as torture then I'm happy to give you the point so that we can get on to discussing the matter of prosecution. It's the same crime either way.
 
For anyone interested, look up KLAUS BARBIE, Nazi and master torturer. He was the villian who tortured French resistance leader JEAN MOULIN.

Presumably you brought him up to illustrate how important it is to go after people who commit war crimes? I'm trying to fathom his relevance here. He had nothing to do with POW's, but he did rot in jail for war crimes involving torture, yes.
 
I kind of wonder what you had enough of.
The first sentence of post #58 showed very poor judgement when you consider he was responding to a senior moderator. Personally, I think that OVERALL Fuji does make a positive contribution to the board. His problem is that he absolutely refuses ever to admit that he could have been wrong about anything or let things drop if it is clear he is not going to win an argument (or even admit that when it comes to moral/ethical issues there is no objective right or wrong so arguing about an objective right and wrong is useless). I do find that he is right more often than he is wrong and on balance his contributions are positive. However, he seems so afraid of ever losing face that he gets himself into these problems (sometimes I am like that, so I can sympathize)
The issue of Canadians handing over prisoners to Afgan authorities is a contentious issue here in Canada. The main issue is when did the Canadian Government headed by Harper's Conservatives know that their prisoners were being abused and did they disregard those concerns and place Canadian troops in harms way of being accused of violations of International law.
I think that the most puzzling issue is why the conservatives ever took ownership of this issue the way they have. The agreement to hand over prisoners to the Afghans was signed by the liberals so they would not have to hand over prisoners to the Americans. The main reason indication that the conservatives knew something was wrong were the changes they made to insure better safe guards. A number of commentators have expressed puzzlement that the conservatives did not just say, they inherited a problem and fixed it. Of course, they could still be criticised for being too slow to address the problem, but those criticisms would have gone away much faster. Now the question in the public minds is why they are denying absolutely any knowledge.
Putting the politics aside, no one has really suggested a better alternative than the one that has developed. I am not sure that handing the prisoners over to the Americans would have been better and NATO did not seem willing to set up their own facilities. It may be the case that Canada could have acted faster to rewrite the agreements with the Afghans but other than that, I don’t see any other realistic course of action.
 
The ban did not survive a review by other moderators. I'll for my part try and keep this debate a little more civilized, Mervyn I should probably not have called you a fool, it's your position I think that is foolish, not you :)
 
Fugi is wrong in the sense that the only part of the German forces that did it's best not to violate International Law was the German Air Force and that was at Goering's insistence.

The Germans violated International Law left right and center, it has never been my position that they didn't--such a position is absurd. I am only making the narrow point that for the majority of POW's captured from Western countries they followed the GC, and such has been documented by the Red Cross.

WW2 was a large war, and in a large war it is possible to find all sorts of exceptions to the rule: The classification of commandos as sabateurs, the decision to treat soldiers caught out of uniform as spies (e.g., escapees), the rogue decisions of some field commanders on both sides, and so on. As a general rule, though, the Germans treated front-line Canadian soldiers captured in uniform tremendously better than we are treating Afghan POW's.

When we can get over arguing about whether that's true we can look at the WHY: The Germans were aware that we were capturing a lot of their soldiers too, and it is apparent to anyone with a brain that if you treat the other side's soldiers well that they are likely to return the favour; while if you abuse their soldiers, they are likely to abuse yours too.

What's the relevance of that? If we treat captured Afghans well there is a much better chance that the Taliban will treat our guys well if or when they are captured. If we are well known for torturing the Taliban when we capture them, what do you think is going to happen to our troops when they fall into enemy hands? The Germans figured this one out, why can't we?

At the end of the day does anyone still dispute any of the following:

1. It is criminal to hand a POW over to someone you know will beat or torture them

2. Canadian soldiers in Afghanistan were doing exactly that

I haven't heard anyone seriously dispute either of those points. Peter MacKay and Canadian generals have admitted to #2 and I think #1 follows pretty directly from the GC.
 
The relevance is the general topic of torture. Probably the same relevance as the treatment by Germany of Canadian and Soviet POW's in WW II.

OK, good, so we agree torture is bad, we agree Klaus deserved to rot in jail for engaging in it, and Peter MacKay as an accessory to it? Same for him?
 
Sheik made a decision and acted. I think the banning was in line with TERB guidelines, and said so.

Now, having been duly chastised, will behaviour be modified?

But, since Fuji is back, I really am interested in his opinion (personal info, not so much). Here`s what I was alluding to: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=265267

Because either I didn`t understand your answer (you`d arrest the little guy?), or you didn`t understand my question.




Lets work on whats achievable before we start demanding whats ideal. And maybe you can start practicing the spirit of these ideals here on this board. A little civility and respect generally earns you more goodwill that always being right.

What would YOU do, Fuji, in the Moralists vs. realists thread I started in the case of the little kid carrying bomb-making material.....or is it fertilizer badly need by his family, subsistance farmers?

In this case the right action is clear as fucking day, this is not a hard one:

1. Revert to the detention system we had in place before we started handing prisoners over to the Afghans

2. Work to educate the Afghans on the rule of law, and start a limited, monitored prison system under Afghan control that does respect the GC, as a pilot that can hopefully be expanded later to a larger system

3. Prosecute those in leadership roles (General and up) who knew about this policy and allowed it. This presumably includes Peter MacKay.

4. Issue a statement to soldiers on the ground that they are expected to follow the rules of war, and to report any violations known to them

5. Issue a formal apology to the Afghan people for the mistreatment of their POW`s and begin negotiating restitution
 
Sheik made a decision and acted. I think the banning was in line with TERB guidelines, and said so.

Now, having been duly chastised, will behaviour be modified?

Fred did not agree, and I note your personal attack on me, insulting me by calling me a "bubble boy". Will you modify your behavior? I apologized to Mervyn for calling him a fool of my own volition, I think this thread is getting a little heated and that we should all tone it done and stick to rational arguments.

But, since Fuji is back, I really am interested in his opinion (personal info, not so much). Here`s what I was alluding to: https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=265267

I will post to that thread.
 
Hello Fuji:
No insult was intended. I was using "bubble boy" as an example of how you seem to be insulated from what I consider to be fairly normal interpersonal relations. I'll gladly apologize to anyone for any insult, perceived or intended. And I apologize to you, Fuji.

Now, although I think you were rude to several other posters and feel you should apologize to them as well, there's also no need for this to become a 12-steps exercise. Emotions ran high, maybe tempers flared, mistakes get made. Don't hold anyone to a standard you yourself cannot maintain, and who among us is perfect.

I'm a veteran of the Afghan mission. Some things rub me the wrong way. Sheik lost relatives to Germany during WW2. Some things will rub him the wrong way. I don't know what Fred's buttons may be, but once he tells us, what's to be gained by pushing a point?

I do look forward to reading your response to the referenced scenario. I wish I could get more guys to post, because the different answers would be interesting.
 
The Germans also believed that their execution of "terrorists" caught behind their line was legal.
On that point what got the Germans in trouble in W.W.II was not the execution of those captured out of uniform, it was agreed that was largely legal. Rather it was the execution of those in uniform such as commandos and special operations forces and escaped POWs.
 
On that point what got the Germans in trouble in W.W.II was not the execution of those captured out of uniform, it was agreed that was largely legal. Rather it was the execution of those in uniform such as commandos and special operations forces and escaped POWs.

The escaped POW's and special operations forces were generally out of uniform when caught. The commandos are a bigger issue, the Germans claimed that they were actually sabateurs even though they were in uniform. Their job was in fact sabotage, but given that they were in uniform that in and of itself doesn't seem like enough, so I agree their treatment was illegal.

Furthermore I think GC protections should be extended to all soldiers whehter in or out of uniform, but that is not currently written in law.

I'm not clear why we are debating this still: Is there anyone who disagrees that the Germans generally extended GC protections to typical front line Canadian soldiers?
 
You know Fuji, your posts really make for them, the 'classic argument' made by a fair number of line officers (combat arms officers) that in order to get things to really go to Hell, all senior commanders need to do is to decide to bring JAG (Legal Branch) Officers in to second guess everything.