Fugi is wrong in the sense that the only part of the German forces that did it's best not to violate International Law was the German Air Force and that was at Goering's insistence.
The Germans violated International Law left right and center, it has never been my position that they didn't--such a position is absurd. I am only making the narrow point that for the majority of POW's captured from Western countries they followed the GC, and such has been documented by the Red Cross.
WW2 was a large war, and in a large war it is possible to find all sorts of exceptions to the rule: The classification of commandos as sabateurs, the decision to treat soldiers caught out of uniform as spies (e.g., escapees), the rogue decisions of some field commanders on both sides, and so on. As a general rule, though, the Germans treated front-line Canadian soldiers captured in uniform tremendously better than we are treating Afghan POW's.
When we can get over arguing about whether that's true we can look at the WHY: The Germans were aware that we were capturing a lot of their soldiers too, and it is apparent to anyone with a brain that if you treat the other side's soldiers well that they are likely to return the favour; while if you abuse their soldiers, they are likely to abuse yours too.
What's the relevance of that? If we treat captured Afghans well there is a much better chance that the Taliban will treat our guys well if or when they are captured. If we are well known for torturing the Taliban when we capture them, what do you think is going to happen to our troops when they fall into enemy hands? The Germans figured this one out, why can't we?
At the end of the day does anyone still dispute any of the following:
1. It is criminal to hand a POW over to someone you know will beat or torture them
2. Canadian soldiers in Afghanistan were doing exactly that
I haven't heard anyone seriously dispute either of those points. Peter MacKay and Canadian generals have admitted to #2 and I think #1 follows pretty directly from the GC.