Canada's International Reputation

The police catch a guy raping a young girl, but instead of holding him in jail, they release him into the custody of the girls' brothers

Let's make the analogy more analogous. The police release the guy into the custody of his OWN family.
 
This international law stuff gets stranger and stranger. Who writes this stuff? Must be a bunch of LLL's in ivory towers.

It is no wonder we flounder when a bunch of "refugees" get washed up on our shores. We can't return them back to their home country because they might somehow come to some "harm". So we end up feeding and sheltering them. They are now our "responsibility".

Was this "no return" law in effect in 1945 when we repatriated 50 million "displaced persons" back to their home country, including millions back to Stalinist Russia?
 
Rocks, by analogy (analogy, note, analogy) consider this domestic law situation:

The police catch a guy raping a young girl, but instead of holding him in jail, they release him into the custody of the girls' brothers, who kill him.

The brothers are guilty of murder. The police are guilty of criminal negligence causing death.

The police aren't responsible for the murder of the bad guy, but they are certainly responsible for handing him over into what they either knew or should have known was a dangerous situation.

The war crime Canadians are charged with is the Geneva Convention equivalent of that ordinary domestic law.

When in Rome...

That's how they do things over there and to try to transplant Canadian morals and laws is silly. Are we supposed to build our own parallel legal system there and provide legal aid?

Apparently many of the captured alleged terrorists had gunpowder residue on them from presumably building IED's. I'm not terribly concerned about those people. Is it even relevant to discuss the Geneva Convention with non-uniformed terrorists?

All the hand-wringing liberals and muck-raking politicians don't give a rat's ass about the people living over there compared to the soldiers on the ground who are trying to help them build a decent society where women have rights and less people live in terror. Oh I forgot, someone took the asinine position that we are over there for our own benefit; not to help the people there.

Those terrorists are probably pissing themselves laughing at Canada all in a knot about some of these poor terrorists being abused. They are probably using their own people for propaganda and would sacrifice them in a second while we waste all this time flagellating ourselves about some potential abuse.

Anyways, back to your little theoretical scenario: if the guy was raping a young girl I wouldn't care about his fate and if the brothers exact their own revenge then that is justice I can live with. I would be more concerned about the young girl you so casually dismissed so we could debate over the scumbag's fate. A very good analogy to the current topic I would say. All worried about potential terrorists without a second's regard for who really matters: the civilians we are trying to help and the soldiers risking their lives.

Get your priorities straight or go over there and work pro bono for abused terrorists.

If my redneck attitude offends you then I guess we won't be having crumpets over tea anytime soon.

D.
 
Who writes this stuff? Must be a bunch of LLL's in ivory towers.
Unfortunately Canada has decided to ratify several treaties that the U.S. had the foresight not to.

In a world in which Libya is elected to the U.N. Human Rights organization, it pays to be cautious and envision lunatic worst case scenarios.
 
Unfortunately Canada has decided to ratify several treaties that the U.S. had the foresight not to.

In a world in which Libya is elected to the U.N. Human Rights organization, it pays to be cautious and envision lunatic worst case scenarios.

A desperation to be liked can be dangerous.....

OTB
 
Unfortunately Canada has decided to ratify several treaties that the U.S. had the foresight not to.

In a world in which Libya is elected to the U.N. Human Rights organization, it pays to be cautious and envision lunatic worst case scenarios.

Unfortunately not every country has an outstanding human rights record like the United States.
 
This international law stuff gets stranger and stranger. Who writes this stuff? Must be a bunch of LLL's in ivory towers.

It is in no way, shape, or form strange. It is exactly like the domestic law around criminal negligence. It is good, straight forward, simple law, that holds the right people to account for the right things.

Here are some more examples:

1. A parent puts a young child into a car, without any seat belt or restraint, and then goes street racing, gets into an accident in which the child is killed.

2. A nightclub owner nails shut all the emergency exits to a club to prevent people from sneaking in, and hires an unqualified individual to set up a fireworks display on stage. A fire breaks out, and many people in the club are killed trying to escape through the nailed-shut exits.

3. Police hand a suspect accused of a horrifying crime over to relatives of the victim, knowing full well that he will be beaten possibly to death.

4. Canadian soldiers capture a prisoner and hand him over to a faction hostile to that individual, who they know from prior experience will likely beat, torture, or possibly even kill him.

5. A babysitter working from her home learns that the man next door to her is a convicted sex offender who has previously raped young children, nevertheless she hands other people's children over to his care one afternoon so that she can attend a family event. The man rapes one of the children.

In each case it is the crime of putting a person you had a duty of care over into a situation you knew, or should have known, was liable to result in greivious injury. You either intentionally put them in harms way, or you were willfully blind to the dangers. Either way you to to jail.

It is a good and necessary law without which things like the above examples would go unpunished.
 
That's how they do things over there and to try to transplant Canadian morals and laws is silly.

No-one is suggesting that we do that.

I am discussing what CANADIANS should do, and asserting that Canadians should follow the laws that bind Canada, and adhere to the morals that hold this country together.

Anyways, back to your little theoretical scenario: if the guy was raping a young girl I wouldn't care about his fate and if the brothers exact their own revenge then that is justice I can live with.

Right. So your values are inconsistent and incompatible with Canadian values. Here in Canada we place a high value on something called the rule of law and we do not support vigilante justice.

I would be more concerned about the young girl you so casually dismissed

I never casually dismissed anything. I want the guy held accountable for his crime--I want him to rot in jail.
 
You don't exactly have the law stated properly here.

The concept behind the law is the same: You cannot transfer someone to a situation you know to be dangeorus. The conventions enumerate every such situation explicitly rather than relying on a general principle backed by case law.

The text you quoted makes it clear that it is illegal to transfer a prisoner to another entity unless you know that they have both the ability and the willingness to comply with the terms of the convention. It is in violating that requirement that Canada commits a war crime.

What we don't know Fugi is whether that diplomat who is making the current charges is covering the period between when it was discovered to when a political decision was made to correct the issue.

Yes we do. He made those reports in May and June of 2006. Others, specifically the Canadian Press, had raised the issue with the government even earlier. The government did not take corrective action until the story exploded into the news over a year later in 2007 when the Globe and Mail broke stories of ongoing torture. The timeline is WELL known.

For more than a year after they knew torture and abuse were commonplace the government continued to lie about it, and do nothing. MacKay stood up in commons and made sweeping denials that there was any reason to suspect torture or abuse, meanwhile he actually had Colvin's report on his desk. Others in the Canadian military made similar denials to the media, yet Colvin produced positive evidence that they had received his report to the contrary. They not only committed a war crime, per your law above, in addition, it appears that MacKay outright lied to Parliament.

Even then it appears the corrective actions taken in 2007 after the media shitstorm finally forced their hand were wholly insufficient.
 
1) During the time frame you listed was the Government gathering facts and then made a political decision - we just don't know the real circumstances here until we have the Government discussion papers for this period.

Sure, it's possible. Unlikely, given that MacKay outright lied to Parliament about the issue, but possible. Hence we should have a public inquiry, and the evidence should be reviewed by a prosecutor to determine if it should go to trial--where MacKay would have the right to present his defense, if any.

Please re-read Article 12. If the Canadian Government received assurances from the Afgan authorities on treatment of turned over prisoners then Canada followed it's requirement --- plain and simple.

That covers the government for the INITIAL handover, prior to the evidence of abuse and torture arising. At that point it became clear that the Afghans were either unwilling or unable to follow the proper protocols.
 
You will note that the sole responsibility for treatment of prisoners falls to the Enemy Power (Afgan forces) as stated in the first paragraph.

By the way your reading is incorrect here, "Enemy Power" and "Detaining Power" refers to the Canadian forces. A POW is captured by their own enemy. The Canadians capture the Taliban, that makes the Canadians the "Enemy Power" from the perspective of the Taliban prisoners they capture, and literally in either case the "Detaining Power".

At the point of capture Canada has sole responsibility for the welfare of the prisoners.

Canada can transfer prisoner only when it it is satisfied that the receiving power will adhere to the conventions. It was in no way, shape, or form reasonable to think that this was true after June 2006.

For Prisoners ALREADY transferred fine, corrective action can be taken--but no further prisoners could legally be transferred from that moment forward.

For each individual prisoner transferred after 2006 there is one count of a war crime. For prisoners transferred before that date there is an additional count of a war crime if corrective action was not taken.
 
I never casually dismissed anything. I want the guy held accountable for his crime--I want him to rot in jail.
It seems to me that this thread indicates that you are far more interested in arguing that Politicians and General Officers should be prosecuted for various ridiculously minor violations of International Law than seeing terrorists imprisoned.

Fortunately I believe that most M.P.s of all parties, have the common sense to see that down that path lie political prosecutions and anarchy.
 
It seems to me that this thread indicates that you are far more interested in arguing that Politicians and General Officers should be prosecuted for various ridiculously minor violations of International Law than seeing terrorists imprisoned.

I hereby correct your mistaken impression.
 
that makes the Canadians the "Enemy Power"
Clearly Fuji your services are urgently needed by the Office of the Judge Advocate General for the Canadian Forces and/or the Minister of Justice. I'm surprised that you aren't bombarding them with letters.
 
Apparently so as our resident ant eater has failed to reply.

Perhaps he missed the sarcasm???????????

The level of the dabate have gone disastrously downhill here since you were here last.