Boy are you ever wrong and simply can't admit it.
You can say that over and over again, but it won't be true.
You have erred in your reading of the convention. You have mistakenly read "enemy power" as if it were describing one single specific power. In reality, it refers to any power who is hostile to the fighter who has been captured.
That is a reading error on your part, one that appears to have been an honest error initially, but if you persist with it I will start to wonder about your motives.
Please re-read. What you are describing is a situation around an OCCUPYING POWER, similar to Germany in WW2, which for what ever reason you can't get out of your head.
Whether or not we are an occupying power is controversial. In fact, in almost ALL conflicts such questions are controversial. The two sides almost never agree about the legitimacy of the other side. As in many other wars in this war both sides assert that the other is entirely illegitimate. This is similar to the case of the ongoing conflict between Taiwan and PR China, North and South Korea, or Israel and Hamas.
Fortunately the convention entirely sidesteps this issue. It asserts that the GC applies whether or not there is an occupation, and no matter whether the occupation is complete or partial.
It subsequently uses the words "Party" and "Power" to avoid having to resolve questions around who is or isn't an occupier and who is or isn't an invader and whose government is or isn't legitimate.
Those are questions for the two sides to sort out, either via negotiation, or by armed conflict.
After two elections, all be it a tad bit tainted, the Afgans have a legitimate Constitutional Government that is fighting a Civil War with the Taliban
That is your view, and it also happens to be my view, but I am well aware that it is not a view shared by the Taliban, who claim that democracy is illegitimate and immoral and that only their way of selecting a government is proper.
Note well that it may well be the historic reality too: If we do pull out, as our politicians say we will, there is some probability that the Taliban will win the war and reassert their government. We will no doubt eventually come to some understanding with them, which some day would no doubt entail recognizing the legitimacy of their rule.
Hopefully not.
Fortunately the GC is written in such a way that we do not have to resolve this issue today.
We can all agree that each Power is a Party to the conflict, even if we want to describe the other side as an "entity" rather than a "state" due to disputes over its status.
with NATO changing it's role from Occupier to Allie (which happened within a year of the 2001 invasion).
According to us and our allies, but not according to the other side in the war...
Please note how Mullah Omar offers the possibility of negotiations with the Afgan Government if Nato leaves --- kind of tells me ole Omar is admitting to the legitimacy of the current Government in Afghanistan.
No it doesn't. Hamas negotiates with Israel without acknowledging the legitimacy of the Israeli state. China negotiates with Taiwan while asserting that Taiwan is an illegal entity. North and South Korea manage to engage in dialogue and negotiation while asserting that the other does not properly exist.
So you are wrong in your claim that an offer to sit down at the bargaining table indicates recognition of legitimacy.

