Canada's International Reputation

I'm not clear why we are debating this still: Is there anyone who disagrees that the Germans generally extended GC protections to typical front line Canadian soldiers?
It depended to a great degree on a) when during the War you were captured, b) by whom you were captured Heer (Wehrmacht) or SS, c) who was responsible for you after your capture.
 
Did you need to post that twice?

I pointed out in the other thread that your post is a ridiculously irrational slippery slope fallacy.

In your view Canadian soldiers should commit war crimes galore, see to it that every Afghan is tortured, who knows what else, all because the legal branch is difficult to work with.

Reality time:

It is well within the powers of officers in the Canadian army to see to it that egregious war crimes are not committed on their watch.
 
On that point what got the Germans in trouble in W.W.II was not the execution of those captured out of uniform, it was agreed that was largely legal. Rather it was the execution of those in uniform such as commandos and special operations forces and escaped POWs.

In addition to how the Russians were treated Polish POWS were treated nearly as bad, hundreds of thousands of French soldiers were put into forced labor camps, and as you mentioned Hitler put out a number of decrees targeting commandos, and POWS that had escaped, for execution. The Red Cross seal of approval in regards to POWS camps means little to me, especially considering how easily they were duped by the Nazis at the supposed model Jewish concentration camp at Theresienstadt.
 
The Red Cross seal of approval in regards to POWS camps means little to me, especially considering how easily they were duped by the Nazis at the supposed model Jewish concentration camp at Theresienstadt.

Do you disagree that the majority of regular front line Canadian troops captured in uniform were treated properly by the Germans? Do you have a citation to back up your view?
 
I'm not clear why we are debating this still: Is there anyone who disagrees that the Germans generally extended GC protections to typical front line Canadian soldiers?

I agree with your points of view Fuji.
 
Do you disagree that the majority of regular front line Canadian troops captured in uniform were treated properly by the Germans?

No, they were probably treated generally in accordance with Geneva, but I wouldn't rely on what the Red Cross thought was happening at the time as significant. They were clueless. There were many other Allied POWS in captivity besides Canadians, Brits, and Americans, and they were treated horribly. They might have gotten around to us eventually, but they had plenty of other people to dispose of in the meantime.
 
No, they were probably treated generally in accordance with Geneva, but I wouldn't rely on what the Red Cross thought was happening at the time as significant. They were clueless. There were many other Allied POWS in captivity besides Canadians, Brits, and Americans, and they were treated horribly. They might have gotten around to us eventually, but they had plenty of other people to dispose of in the meantime.

Do you have evidence that Brit and American POW's were treated horribly? My understanding is that they were treated exactly the same way as Canadians.

It was the Soviet POW's who faced atrocities. The Soviet Union had not signed the GC and the Germans took that as an excuse to treat them in absolutely inhumane ways--a high percentage of them were murdered.
 
Do you have evidence that Brit and American POW's were treated horribly? My understanding is that they were treated exactly the same way as Canadians.

I didn't say they weren't, which is why I listed the Canadians, Brits and Americans as a group. The other POWS who were horribly treated were those I mentioned before, and doutless it extended to anyone considered lacking in Germanic heritage.
 
OK, good, so we agree torture is bad, we agree Klaus deserved to rot in jail for engaging in it,

I was trying to make 2-3 very important points by differentiating Canadian soldiers from Klaus Barbie. Maybe I was too subtle, I will be more explicit below.

Under the Canadian (and hopefully international) system of justice, there are degrees of culpability, and intent and remedial actions also play a very important role in determining degree of guilt and punishment. For example, just because you kill (or torture?) someone does not automatically mean 1st degree murder, it could be justifiable homicide.

When it comes to "torture", the first question is whether it is actually torture. I think the U.N. definition is causing "severe pain". Severe pain is a fairly high threshold. Remember, it is not just pain, it is severe pain. There is no doubt that Klaus Barbie engaged in serial torture as many of his victims died agonizing deaths.

Culpability - There is no doubt that Klaus Barbie personally or ordered people under his command to commit torture. Hence, 100% culpability. Canadian soldiers did not commit torture and did not order other people to commit torture and Afghan guards were not under the command of Canadian soldiers. General Menard correctly said this is THEIR country and this is THEIR prison system.

Remedial action - The Afghan prison system is much better to-day than it was when the Canadians first arrived. This is due in large part to Canadian actions.
 
It's almost 8 years old!!

Eggleton confirms JTF2 has taken prisoners in Afghanistan
Last Updated: Wednesday, January 30, 2002 | 12:18 PM ET
CBC News
The federal government has revealed that Canadian troops have already captured prisoners in Afghanistan - and turned them over to U.S. forces.
Defence Minister Art Eggleton says members of Canada's Joint Task Force Two (JTF2) commando unit have taken prisoners. Up until now, the government maintained Canadian troops had not captured any Taliban or al-Qaeda fighters.

When Prime Minister Jean Chrétien was asked Monday about how Canadian soldiers in Afghanistan would treat any prisoners they captured, he brushed aside the question. "You are asking me a purely hypothetical question at this time," he said.

But Eggleton revealed Tuesday, the question is anything but hypothetical. "We have been involved in the capturing of prisoners, yes," he said.

Eggleton says members of Canada's JTF2 commando unit have taken prisoners. In fact, he says a photo of Canadian troops with their captives appeared on the front page of the Globe & Mail last week.

"There was this picture. And underneath the picture it said: U.S. soldiers. But did you notice the fact they had forest green uniforms those three soldiers that were in that picture? Well, they were Canadian, JTF2."

The picture appeared in the paper last Tuesday. But Eggleton says he didn't find out the soldiers in the photo were Canadian until last Friday and didn't tell cabinet until Tuesday.

In question period Tory Leader Joe Clark accused Eggleton of misleading the public and Parliament by sitting on vital information for four days.

"Why in the world did he not tell? Why in the world did he not tell his prime minister? Who's in charge of this bunch of keystone cops?" asked Clark.

The New Democrats say the government has betrayed Canadian values by turning prisoners over to U.S. forces and leaving them to face a military tribunal and possible death sentence.

Eggleton says the U.S. wants to bring terrorists to justice and Canada supports that.

Eggleton says he's confident any prisoner held by the U.S. will receive a fair trial.
 
I think you have the wrong view of this. What is in dispute is when Canadian officials actually knew that the Afgan authorities were abusing the prisoners that Canadian troops were handing over.

Yes this is key, because if they continued the handovers after they knew there was torture and abuse, then they are war criminals.

You might want to read Colvin's Affidavit:

http://www3.thestar.com/static/PDF/Colvin_Affidavit.pdf

In that affidavit he testifies that his report from the field, KANDH-0032 following the earlier KANDH-0029, contained evidence of the torture, asserted that detainees were at risk of being tortured when transferred, and was circulated to all key military and political directors on 2 June 2006. From that moment forward it is ridiculous to assert that no-one knew, yet the transfers continued unabated.

Note that Colvin, although a diplomat, was not some pencil pusher in Ottawa. He was on the ground in Afghanistan, visited the prisoners and the prisons, interviewed soldiers and officers, and worked out of the main military base in Kandahar. He got the job after his predecessor, Berry, was killed in the line of duty by the Taliban.

My understanding of this is that when it was discovered measures were placed to prevent it happening again.

Were that the case we wouldn't be having this discussion.

It was not corrected, even after people knew, that is the substance of the allegation.

If we learn that in fact this was a deliberate public policy, then yes it should be prosecuted but right now their isn't enough evidence to back your charges.

Nothing but Colvin's KANDH-0029 and KANDH-0032 reports, his affidavit, and all the evidence that has since come out corroborating his testimony.

Moreover at the time the system was set up, back in 2006, there were many journalists who pubically grilled the government and military officials at the time, over the possibility that detainees would be tortured.

It is not like the quesiton had not been asked.

For example, see the 29 May 2006 Globe & Mail article titled "Troops Told Geneva Rules Don't Apply To Taliban" in which an exchange between LGen Gauthier was grilled by reporters over the possibility that Afghan prisoners would be abused.

So it was known. Well known, not only to people in the army, but even to journalists, who raised it with the army.

Desipte it being apparently common knowledge among the rank and file in Afghanistan, and widely reported internally to Ottawa, and a topic raised repeatedly by the media, the program went on for over a year further, while Peter MacKay stood in commons and denied anything was happening.

It was not until the media blew the lid off the lies that anything changed.

We need for this to be properly looked at and I hope Harper's Torys will do just that.

Yes. There needs to be a public inquiry. If it turns out that Colvin's accusations are true, then there furthermore needs to be prosecutions of the appropriate officers and officials up to and including Peter MacKay.
 
Hello KF:
google "BAGRAM TORTURE", or something to that effect. Note the dates. Should be around Christmas 2001. Remember that it takes time for info to trickle up, so what was an open secret at one time and place may not be known elsewhere until a later date elsewhere. Maybe also google Robert Semrau.

The only point that I want to make in all my posts related to A-stan (which is most of them in this forum), is how completely f*cked-up the entire situation was from Oct 7, 2001. Anyone who thinks they understand or can rationalize or impose some order on this situation cant really comprehend its magnitude. Heads of states involved in the situation are often at a loss. If you're interested in info on the subject, I have tons of it that many, if not most, people here don't. Feel free to ignore whatever you think is irrelevant (I happen to think discussing WW2 POW camps really doesn't fit the current situation. But everyone is entitled to their opinions, aren't they).

Thanks for reading
 
Canadian soldiers did not commit torture and did not order other people to commit torture and Afghan guards were not under the command of Canadian soldiers. General Menard correctly said this is THEIR country and this is THEIR prison system.

Canadians did, however, transfer prisoners under their control to a third party they well knew would beat and torture the prisoner.

You are aware that is a war crime in and of itself?
 
Canadians did, however, transfer prisoners under their control to a third party they well knew would beat and torture the prisoner.
You are aware that is a war crime in and of itself?

If what you are saying is true, then international law is even more bizarre than I ever thought possible. We capture Afghans in Afghanistan and turn them over to Afghan authorities and what the Afghans do to their nationals under Afghan law is our fault. Who writes these laws:confused:?
 
If what you are saying is true, then international law is even more bizarre than I ever thought possible. We capture Afghans in Afghanistan and turn them over to Afghan authorities and what the Afghans do to their nationals under Afghan law is our fault. Who writes these laws:confused:?

Rocky, look up pashtunwali. That means more to them than anything drafted by the UN or Geneva. Under their code of conduct, drawing blood may often be required as penalty or punishment. Usually, its a token gesture rather than a fatal wound. But for anything from an insult to a goat-theft, blood may be deemed necessary by the local jurga. The ANP or ANA take or recieve a prisoner...they'll rough him up a bit to draw blood, and that may be enough for them and they'll release him. NDS are professional torturers, similar to the CIA (except they are hands-on while the CIA usually contracts out).
Is a beating same as torture? You guys debate that all you want. Compare what the US did to those 2 saps at Bagram around Dec2001 and compare that to a plain ol' beating. One is much worse than other, clearly torture, wjile the other is customary application of penalty often requied under PAshtun law.
 
If what you are saying is true, then international law is even more bizarre than I ever thought possible. We capture Afghans in Afghanistan and turn them over to Afghan authorities and what the Afghans do to their nationals under Afghan law is our fault. Who writes these laws:confused:?

Yes I can see that you are confused, I do not think you really understand, so I will try and explain.

Canadians are NOT being accused of torturing the POW's, Canadians are being accused of putting them into a dangerous situation.

Let's look at that in greater detail:

Under international law, binding on Canada, it is illegal to knowingly put a POW in harms way. For example, you cannot force a POW to work under dangerous conditions, or leave them out in the cold all night long. This war crime is similar to the domestic crime of criminal negligence causing bodily harm, or criminal negligence causing death, depending on whether they die or not.

The key here is that you KNOW (or at least SHOULD know) that it's dangerous. Inadvertently putting someone into a dangerous situation is not a crime, provided you learn your lesson and don't do it twice.

Following me so far?

Once Canadians knew that Afghans were abusing and torturing prisoners then the act of transferring them to Afghan custody meant knowingly putting them in harms way.
 
Under international law, binding on Canada, it is illegal to knowingly put a POW in harms way.
This international law is a strange beast. (I think I'll stay in Canada this Winter.) These POW's seem to have a pretty sheltered life.

For example, you cannot force a POW to work under dangerous conditions,
I worked on a construction crew for two Summers and guys got hurt all the time. Occupational hazard.

or leave them out in the cold all night long.
When I was younger we use to go camping and some of those nights were pretty cold.
 
Rocks, by analogy (analogy, note, analogy) consider this domestic law situation:

The police catch a guy raping a young girl, but instead of holding him in jail, they release him into the custody of the girls' brothers, who kill him.

The brothers are guilty of murder. The police are guilty of criminal negligence causing death.

The police aren't responsible for the murder of the bad guy, but they are certainly responsible for handing him over into what they either knew or should have known was a dangerous situation.

The war crime Canadians are charged with is the Geneva Convention equivalent of that ordinary domestic law.