Scenario for moralists vs. realists.......

seth gecko

Well-known member
Nov 2, 2003
3,744
81
48
http://www.stripes.com/article.asp?section=104&article=66597


See picture #3 in slideshow. You are there. What would you do? Everyone has an opinion, so lets hear yours in this simple situation. Don't be shy. Like your 3rd grade teacher told you, there are no wrong answers.

If possible, try to limit your answers to what YOU would do, rather than critisizing someone else's answer. No flaming, please
 
Last edited:
They should have sent the boy on his way after confiscating the bags of fertilizer. Then tell the boy to tell the 'farmers' who need it, that they can come claim it.
 
Thanks for your input Woody.
I was hoping more guys would hazard an answer.

Hope to hell it really is intended for farming, escort the little guy to the destination, do an inspection, advise the elders why you must take away the fertilizer and promise to provide them with urea-based fertilizer, try to get some urea-based fertilizer to fulfill your promise, maybe be forced to return the ammonium nitrate fertilizer in case you can't fulfill your promise to provide urea-based fertilizer.

Hearts & minds is alot of work!!
(btw, I'm not worried too much about the kid, or the fertilizer. I'd be worried about the donkey's reaction. Will he be an ass about this?)
 
Obviously, writing titles just ain't my forte. I should have stuck with the tried and true "what would you do?"

I was hoping to hear from more of the members. Its easy to sit back and opinionate, critisize, second-guess, pontificate, cite, etc etc after the fact on things that have already happened.
But these guys on the ground must make instant decisions that may contravene any numbers of laws, rules, conventions, etc. So here's a real-life scenario...... you are in charge, you know the rules, now how will you handle it?


So, what would YOU do?
 
Last edited:
Well being the suspicious SOB that I am, I let the little guy go and make sure the bags of fertilizer get followed home and then to where ever they end up.

High percentage amonium nitrate fertilizer is of limited use for the average farmer but then again I don't know what type of farm the lad was headed for
 
There is a more general problem here, this one incident is part of a bigger picture.

One of the reports on Afghanistan identified the problem: Canadian soldiers are not well able to distinguish ordinary farmers from Taliban. In this case soldiers decided the kid was an ordinary farmer and sent him on his way. In other cases ordinary farmers has been mistakenly arrested as Taliban, handed over to Afghan security forces, and tortured. No doubt in still other cases, unknown to us, Taliban insurgents have slipped through our fingers.

What we need in order to win this war, and resolve cases like this, is more involvement from the local community. We need a trusted person in the local community who soldiers can bring in who can say, "I know that kid, he's a good kid, his family are good people, I'll make sure the fertilizer winds up on a field." We won't get it right every time, in some cases our local advisor will turn out to be a Taliban spy. We have to deal with that as best we can, and over time build more and more relationships with more and more locals.

Until or unless we have that level of community involvement we WILL lose the war. That is why building trust relationships trumps everything else, and why above and beyond everything our reputation with the locals is paramount.
 
Thank you for your input Fuji.
I'm embarrassed to say I'm not too sure what you would do? Would you seize the fertilizer or let the kid go on his way with it?

You are the patrol leader. We are waiting on your orders.
 
Thank you for your input Fuji.
I'm embarrassed to say I'm not too sure what you would do? Would you seize the fertilizer or let the kid go on his way with it?

You are the patrol leader. We are waiting on your orders.

I would try and find someone, like a village elder from his community, who knows the kid and the family and ask them to vouch for him and to take responsibility for making sure the fertilizer winds up on a field.
 
There is a more general problem here, this one incident is part of a bigger picture.

One of the reports on Afghanistan identified the problem: Canadian soldiers are not well able to distinguish ordinary farmers from Taliban. In this case soldiers decided the kid was an ordinary farmer and sent him on his way. In other cases ordinary farmers has been mistakenly arrested as Taliban, handed over to Afghan security forces, and tortured. No doubt in still other cases, unknown to us, Taliban insurgents have slipped through our fingers.

What we need in order to win this war, and resolve cases like this, is more involvement from the local community. We need a trusted person in the local community who soldiers can bring in who can say, "I know that kid, he's a good kid, his family are good people, I'll make sure the fertilizer winds up on a field." We won't get it right every time, in some cases our local advisor will turn out to be a Taliban spy. We have to deal with that as best we can, and over time build more and more relationships with more and more locals.

Until or unless we have that level of community involvement we WILL lose the war. That is why building trust relationships trumps everything else, and why above and beyond everything our reputation with the locals is paramount.

Well we are still waiting for some actual proof of torture , but aside from that.

One of the taliban's favorite tricks is to pitch the weapons and play farmer when they get cornered.

To combat that the Canadian Forces have been using gun powder test kits similar to what you see on CSI. If they suspect a farmer has a part time job they test him and if it comes up positive they take him into custody until either he or somebody known to both sides can vouch for him. If a third party can not be found he is held in custody.
 
Well we are still waiting for some actual proof of torture , but aside from that.

Canada's top general has categorically stated that it happened, the government has before and after photographs, we have field notes from Canadian soldiers stating that it happened. What, in your mind, constitutes proof?

There is a good deal of information cited in Colvin's testimony that the government is refusing to release to the media. The opposition has passed a motion in Parliament requiring the release of that information, but the government already has it. Those who have seen it (Colvin) say that it indicates that ALL detainees handed over to the Afghans were likely beaten or tortured.

Walter Natynczyk: Clearly, an individual who was in custody of the Canadian Forces and the Afghan police assumed custody and that individual was abused and I am responsible for providing that information.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/gen-natynczyks-press-conference/article1394802/

You do a good job of describing Taliban tactics and some of the techniques Canadians use to try and discover Taliban posing as farmers. I don't dispute any of that, I have some thoughts on how it can be done better, but none of that is what is controversial here.

What's controversial is what happens to ANYONE, whether they are Taliban or not, after they are arrested by Canadians.
 
You know Fuji, your posts really make for them, the 'classic argument' made by a fair number of line officers (combat arms officers) that in order to get things to really go to Hell, all senior commanders need to do is to decide to bring JAG (Legal Branch) Officers in to second guess everything.
 
One individual was abused , by Afghan forces after being turned over as required by treaty . That seems to be a long way from farmers plural or stating that all prisoners turned over were tortured, or stating that the Germans treated our POWs in the second world war better than we treat Afghans.
 
You know Fuji, your posts really make for them, the 'classic argument' made by a fair number of line officers (combat arms officers) that in order to get things to really go to Hell, all senior commanders need to do is to decide to bring JAG (Legal Branch) Officers in to second guess everything.

If you really want things to go to hell just continue torturing and abusing the locals. Then instead of having a village elder who will help you sort out whether or not that kid is just trying to make a living as a farmer, or is he an insurgent, you'll have nothing but enemies.

Your argument is ridiculous.

You are asserting that because the JAG is overly difficult to work with we should throw all morality to the wind and commit war crimes galore, such has seeing to it that every single prisoner we capture is tortured.

Do you have any argument to make other than this slippery slope fallacy?
 
You continue to beat a dead horse. Iinstead of merely saying the problem with the abuse of locals is:
instead of having a village elder who will help you sort out whether or not that kid is just trying to make a living as a farmer, or is he an insurgent, you'll have nothing but enemies.
You keep trying to make civil legal arguments, and accuse everyone you can think of in the Government of War Crimes - and seeming Canadian Soldiers in the field of the same as well.
 
You continue to beat a dead horse. Iinstead of merely saying the problem with the abuse of locals is: You keep trying to make civil legal arguments, and accuse everyone you can think of in the Government of War Crimes - and seeming Canadian Soldiers in the field of the same as well.

No. I have consistently said that it is people at the general officer level and above who should be prosecuted for war crimes with respect to the handover of Afghan prisoners.

Individual soldiers in the field should be held accountable only for their own behavior, but I am not aware of any cases of any of them having been accused of beating anyone.

It is only at the general level or above where the big picture would have been known--where the evidence of widespread abuse could be collected and examined, and where policies to respond are set.

If it turns out, as Colvin has said is the case, that those people knew of widespread torture of Afghan prisoners and nevertheless continued to direct that they be handed over to known torturers, then those peopel should be prosecuted.
 
Well, since this thread derailed in record time, and only a couple people dared to make a decision rather than cite precedent and regulation ....here's my critique:

Remember when I said there's no wrong answers. I said that only to encourage participation. There's really no right answers. Let the kid leave with the fertilizer, which is illegal in A-stan, and somebody from our side could hold you responsible for that contravention of the law. Enforce the law by confiscating the fertilizer, and you've broken local customary law which will require the local council (jurga) to determine a punishment...could range anywhere from NOT supporting NATO/ISAF activities, to joining the insurgency. Just by making the little kid cry could cause these responses, depending on whose kid he is.
Different cultures have different laws. We're trying to have them use our laws. Taliban, having the advantage of being locals, sought to enforce the local laws. Add that they were the winners and ended 18ish years of fighting, locals were slightly more tolerant of them than they are of the Karzai government, which they see as corrupt and ineffective. Steal a goat under Taliban regime, you may not get the goat back but you'll know someone got a beating (acceptable punishment under their system). Break a law under the existing central government, chances are you'll have to bribe the ANP just to show up.

Thanks for reading
 
The bad guys are obviously having no trouble getting their hands on explosives so I would do as the soldiers did.. The net gain of taking the boys fertilizer is dwarfed by the net loss of having and angry family in a closed community telling their neighbors about what happened and likely exaggerating the loss and its effects to boot.

The right answer of course would be to seize the fertilizer and say tough @#!% to the kid and his family... But it's a case of winning the battle and losing the war.