Canada's International Reputation

Thanks for clarifying that not all "war crimes" are equal. I would think that the "war crime" of handing an AFGHAN pow to the AFGHAN authorities rank pretty low in the hierarchy of "war crimes".

The systematic torture, rape, and/or beating of all or almost all prisoners ranks pretty damn high actually, although plainly lower than their systematic murder. It ranks much higher than, say, an isolated incident of a single soldier doing something they shouldn't.

Since when does domestic law apply in a theatre of war

It doesn't, hence my use of the word "analogy". The law that applies is the Statute of Rome, Geneva Conventions, and associated protocols.
 
The systematic torture, rape, and/or beating of all or almost all prisoners ranks pretty damn high actually, although plainly lower than their systematic murder.

Been going on in Afghany since time immemorial and somebody would now blame this on Canada? Ridiculous. Can't change a 30,000 year old culture in 2 years.
 
Rather like Cyrano de Bergerac , Canada repeatedly does honourable things for honourable motives, but instead of being thanked for it, it remains something of a figure of fun. It is the Canadian way, for which Canadians should be proud, yet such honour comes at a high cost.

I ask the question again: "What has the "international community" ever done for Canada?"

We keep forgetting the old Irish proverb: "No good deed goes unpunished."
 
Been going on in Afghany since time immemorial and somebody would now blame this on Canada? Ridiculous. Can't change a 30,000 year old culture in 2 years.

Dude, wriggle and squirm all you like, but our obligations under the Geneva Conventions are crystal fucking clear: You do not place POW's in situations where they are liable to be tortured, and if you do, you are guilty of one of the more serious war crimes. End of story.

If you do not see torture as wrong then you are a pond scum, and an individually wholly at odds with every single thing that Canada stands for. That's a moral claim, if you want a legal version of it, you are arguing that Canada should ignore the rule of law whenever it's convenient, which is dangerous and reprehensible in and of itself: The rule of law is fundamental to our way of life.
 
I ask the question again: "What has the "international community" ever done for Canada?"

Provided us with the overwhelming majority of our income.

Provided us with safety and security via security alliances and the United Nations.

Created the legal framework under which we have troops in Afghanistan in the first place.

A better question is what HASN'T the international community done for us?
 
That's a moral claim,

To be perfectly blunt, I think a lot of things are immoral in the abstract (including imprisoning people, torture, killing, etc.) but I will unhappily commit "immoral" acts when circumstances warrants.
 
Provided us with the overwhelming majority of our income.
Canada provides more income to the international community than vice versa.

Provided us with safety and security via security alliances and the United Nations.
Canada provides more safety and security to the international community than vice versa.

Created the legal framework under which we have troops in Afghanistan in the first place.
The benefit of our troops in Afghany accrues to the Afghans not us. They are building bridges, roads, schools, etc. in Afghany not in Canada. Actually, I prefer to bring the troops home and spend the money building more hockey rinks here in Canada.
 
POW's were not sent to concentration camps.

Well for clarificaiton *Western* POW's weren't. The Germans treated Soviet POW's horribly.
It is always dangerous to make such definitive statements about WW2. You should have said that MOST Western POWs were not sent to concentration camps. Although Hitler had ordered that captured commandos be executed, a number were sent to concentration camps instead. Also, several prisoners recaptured after the “Great Escape” were sent to concentration camps. In addition, at least one Canadian air crew was sent to a concentration camp.
 
It is always dangerous to make such definitive statements about WW2. You should have said that MOST Western POWs were not sent to concentration camps. Although Hitler had ordered that captured commandos be executed, a number were sent to concentration camps instead. Also, several prisoners recaptured after the "Great Escape" were sent to concentration camps. In addition, at least one Canadian air crew was sent to a concentration camp.

OK, I'll accept that. The statement therefore is this:

The Germans in WW2 treated MOST Canadian POW's better than Canada treats ANY Afghan POW. To wit, the Germans credibly extended GC protections to most Western POW's, while Canada extends GC protections to none of the Afghans.
 
Canada provides more income to the international community than vice versa.

Citation?

First that seems to be a misunderstanding of econonics, my understanding is our trade relations with the international community are a win for both sides.

Second we run a surplus, not a deficit, in our trade relations, and therefore your statement would appear to be false in nominal terms.

Canada provides more safety and security to the international community than vice versa.

I think that is an indefensible statement. Canada does not even maintain an army sufficient to defend our own territory and we rely extensively on our NATO partners for our security. We have been routinely criticized in NATO for not pulling our own weight in terms of the size and capability of the military that we operate.

The benefit of our troops in Afghany accrues to the Afghans not us.

I think that is a false statement in as much as I think our goal in doing any of the things we do there is ultimately for the benefit of our own security. In other words, it is our goal not to have threats arising from Afghanistan, and our strategy for doing that is to build a stable society there.

We are not doing anything simply because we want to help the Afghans, we are there for self-serving reasons.
 
You Fuji, TAKE THE CAKE......


German treatment of POW's is not what you saw on TV on shows like Hogan's Heros. Many allied POW's were starved, malnourished, mistreated and murdered in cold blood by those Nazi's. The Russians were treated even worse.

Canadians have gone and served where others dont dare. So before you shoot your mouth off about something you have ZERO knowledge about, check your facts.

Since you're hell bent on asking us to provide those facts, HOW ABOUT YOU SHOW US THE FACTS THAT YOU'RE USING TO BASE YOUR COMMENTS ON. My family lost so many members to those NAZI criminals that you speak well of. These men were sailors and soldiers. Dont forget the many Canadian and British pilots that were shot down as well.

Least but not last, the millions of Jews that were murdered in cold blood by those same Nazis.

My god man, I hope I never meet you face to face because I will SLAP it



Bravo
 
Yet it's purely voluntary contribution to the cause of freedom in two world wars was perhaps the greatest of any democracy. Almost 10% of Canada 's entire population of seven million people served in the armed forces during the First World War, and nearly 60,000 died. The great Allied victories of 1918 were spearheaded by Canadian troops, perhaps the most capable soldiers in the entire British order of battle.

Canada was repaid for its enormous sacrifice by downright neglect, it's unique contribution to victory being absorbed into the popular Memory as somehow or other the work of the 'British.'
Unfortunately part of it was also the whole idea, which was in vogue a few decades ago, that Canadians were slaughtered by incompetent British Generals. Rather than 'as the best of the best, we were called upon to due the impossible, when the impossible had to be done, and we paid accordingly'.
 
my understanding is our trade relations with the international community are a win for both sides.
Ok, let's settle that it benefits both sides.

We have been routinely criticized in NATO for not pulling our own weight in terms of the size and capability of the military that we operate.
Canada is 6th out 28 NATO members in military spending, behind the U.S., the U.K, France, Germany and Italy. We are definitely punching above our weight.

it is our goal not to have threats arising from Afghanistan, and our strategy for doing that is to build a stable society there
A stable society benefits Afghans.
 
I would think that the "war crime" of handing an AFGHAN pow to the AFGHAN authorities rank pretty low in the hierarchy of "war crimes".

I think this is the most intelligent comment anyone in here has yet to make on this issue.

fuji is throwing accusations around as though the CF and the Canadian government deliberately and knowingly set out to have Afghans tortured and beaten as part of their plan in Afghanistan. He is placing the behaviour of well-meaning people (yes, even Conservatives are nice people) on par with that of murderous monsters like the NAZIs, who DID deliberately set out to torture, beat and murder people. Such comparisons to the caring and thoughtful Canadian soldiers and to muddling politicians is beyond belief. It is also horribly offensive to those who have been victimized by true war criminals - the Khmer Rouge who murdered a million people, Serbs in Bosnia (and the rest of those clowns), Stalin's murderous henchmen, etc. Peter McKay is none of those. Good fucking grief.
 
Citation?

We have been routinely criticized in NATO for not pulling our own weight in terms of the size and capability of the military that we operate.

I'm not gone yet!
You're a pretty interesting character, Fuji. For a guy who's so high on rules and ethics and moral perogatives, you're pretty quick to become dismissive if not downright rude to those whose expression of free speech and opinion provides a different perspective from yours. Seems somewhat contradictory to me, and I don't know you or your motivations, but I still suspect that you're some sort of bubble-boy, fairly devoid of normal interpersonal relations. You just don't seem to interact well with others, and in an anonymous forum where you could just as easily choose to be amiable, you seem to usually choose to be controversial if not downright combatitive. Kind of revealing, but I've been wrong before.
As for the above quote, Canadian troops are routinely praised, if not sometimes almost exalted, by nearly all our NATO allies and UN partners. Canadian troops are internationally recognized for their professionalism, training, conditioning, motivation, courage, etc etc. We have been, sadly, derided for the ridiculous constraints and limitations often imposed on us by our political leadership. The UN Mission in the former Yugoslavia....remember the Canadian soldier kidnapped and handcuffed to a pole by the Serbs? Think that was a random pick they made? Rwanda, waiting for permission to act against an obvious threat to innocents, from a bureacracy in NYC that went home for the weekend. Sometimes, Fuji, strict adherence to these rules and conventions can cause the exact horrific situations they were intended to prevent. And sometimes, they can can prevent them. Nothing in the real world is absolute......if I'm right about your bubble-boy situation, you just haven't been exposed to realities regarding compromise, bad or insuffienct info, Hobson's choice, etc. Again, I don't know you, so I can't say for sure.
A-stan represented a bit of a pendulum swing, where political AND military leadership wanted to show the world that we aren't just eager, but impotent, tag-alongs (not Tagalogs!). Sadly again, political leaders of both major parties didn't plan, man, fund or equip properly, leaving the entire Canadian contingent with some pretty freakin tough decisions to improvise, so as to not look like the Canadians of CANTBAT (look that up).

Lets work on whats achievable before we start demanding whats ideal. And maybe you can start practicing the spirit of these ideals here on this board. A little civility and respect generally earns you more goodwill that always being right.

What would YOU do, Fuji, in the Moralists vs. realists thread I started in the case of the little kid carrying bomb-making material.....or is it fertilizer badly need by his family, subsistance farmers?

Okay, the boss is finally packed so now I really have to go, so have a good weekend all.
 
You Fuji, TAKE THE CAKE......


German treatment of POW's is not what you saw on TV on shows like Hogan's Heros. Many allied POW's were starved, malnourished, mistreated and murdered in cold blood by those Nazi's. The Russians were treated even worse.

You haven't got the foggiest clue what you are talking about.

You seem to be unable to reason your way out of a paper bag, so let me give you some help here. Here is what is NOT in dispute:

1. That a lot of Canadians died fighting the Germans

2. That the Germans committed atrocities against Soviet POW's

3. That the Germans commited atrocities against Jews and others in concentration camps

4. That WW2 military tactics were often brutal and illegal

However it remains a historic fact that the Germans abided by the Geneva Conventions with respect to Western POW's who were captured in uniform.

It is true that the POW's had a sparse diet, which you could call "malnourished", but the reality is they got pretty much the same level of nutrition that Germany provided to its own soldiers. The sad fact is that towards the end of the war the German state was falling apart and there was not a lot of food to go around. They did not treat their POW's particularly worse than their own soldiers.

Canada has failed to provide that level of care to Afghan POW's.
 
A stable society benefits Afghans.

Sure, it happens to, but that is not our motive. We are there for self-serving reasons. It happens that what is in our interests is in some cases also in the Afghan interest.

That does not mean we are doing it for them. We are doing it for ourselves.
 

Thanks for conceding the debate seth, I note you've switched to personal attack from rational argument.

For the record I'm happily married, have a girlfriend in addition to the wife, speak multiple languages, work in a management role, and have lived in about eight different countries. I would hazard a guess that I have been exposed to more situations in more countries with more people than most people have.

I do, however, appreciate your conceding the debate by switching to personal attack.

We have been, sadly, derided for the ridiculous constraints and limitations often imposed on us by our political leadership.

This is the only point you make. You talk about limited rules of engagement for Canadian soldiers which you think were inappropriate and somehow imply that this means war crimes are acceptable.

Note that a soldier who defies the rules of engagement, while they may be disciplined for insubordination, has not necessarily committed any war crime.

The two concepts are not comparable.

What would YOU do, Fuji

In this case the right action is clear as fucking day, this is not a hard one:

1. Revert to the detention system we had in place before we started handing prisoners over to the Afghans

2. Work to educate the Afghans on the rule of law, and start a limited, monitored prison system under Afghan control that does respect the GC, as a pilot that can hopefully be expanded later to a larger system

3. Prosecute those in leadership roles (General and up) who knew about this policy and allowed it. This presumably includes Peter MacKay.

4. Issue a statement to soldiers on the ground that they are expected to follow the rules of war, and to report any violations known to them

5. Issue a formal apology to the Afghan people for the mistreatment of their POW's and begin negotiating restitution
 
However it remains a historic fact that the Germans abided by the Geneva Conventions with respect to Western POW's who were captured in uniform.

Please read up on what happened to captured American uniformed soldiers at the Battle of the Bulge.
 
Canada is 6th out 28 NATO members in military spending, behind the U.S., the U.K, France, Germany and Italy. We are definitely punching above our weight.
Given that those are the only 6 NATO countries I can think of that are bigger than Canada, I don’t see how you reach your conclusion when it comes to spending. Moreover, much of our current capital spending on the military is to make up for rust out due to years of neglect and keeping old equipment in services fall longer than it should have been (e.g. the Sea Kings, navel supply vessels, etc). In other words, we had no choice but to spend it now before our troops have nothing to work with.

In terms of commitment to dangerous situations and the willingness to place our troops in danger when necessary for the greater good, I completely agree that we are punching beyond our weight. Other NATO countries may have a better record in terms of spending but having large armies that never contribute in a useful way to situations like Afghanistan is of limited use.