Not enough information to make a sound decision.
Let's start with the commercial property (#3): today's commercial vacancy rates are soaring, and any profitability will rely on (a) being able to find a tenant, (b) the ability to build-up the property to suit that tenant, to the extent of landlord's responsiblities, and (c) the ability of that tenant to maintain timely rent payments.
The landlord will still be responsible for taxes, property maintenance, and some insurance regardless of whether it's occupied or not. Some commercial tenancies will require a rent-free interval for fit-up, as well as requiring the landlord to do certain work to make the property fit for the purpose (tenant incentives).
At the end of the lease, the tenant might decide to move elsewhere (cheaper), or they could suffer the effects of the economic downturn and go under at any time (perhaps doing a midnight move to protect their assets from seizure over non-payment of rent). Not a solid game for a part-time player based on the facts as presented above unless all of these risk factors can be priced into the deal.
Buying a house to flip (#2) can be profitable based on an evaluation of time and materials, but who will be the primary contractor, and who will be the subcontractors. Will the investor be doing all the work themselves? Eating the cost overruns and errors (e.g. when the hardwood floor is installed, and has a "bump" in the middle, who is going to pay to fix it?) is a risk factor, as is carrying the property for the duration of the project (how long can the house remain unsold after the renovations before it turns into a financial disaster?).
Profit is available to those who know what they're doing, and financial disaster is available to those who get caught in the wrong set of circumstances. From the description given the direct carrying costs would be minimized by not having a mortgage on the property (in effect, providing a "mortgage" payment from the profit of the "renovation" business to the profit of the "ownership" business). But that's a tough one to evaluate: is the business profitable only because it's not carrying a mortgage? If so, then there are other considerations at work (e.g. making money by being paid as a contractor is never a bad thing, especially if one has complete control over the project).
Finally, as others have indicated above, holding a second mortgage on a property raises some questions. 17% return indicates a high risk, and an 80% debt ratio sounds pretty high. Is this the
Total Debt Service Ratio? Living on 20% of one's income is the very thinnest edge of the wedge. If I recall correctly, approvals for a first mortgage for most of us would require a TDR below 32%, and if it's up to 80% then there's an urgent need for more income. Is there visibility into credit card debt levels? Any unexpected financial hiccups could wipe out the assets pretty quickly.
In all, no investment is without risk, but the above options are not anything I would recommend to a friend. I'm not an investment professional, though, so there may well be additional details makin the opportunities worthwhile.