Which investment would you make?

Lou Siffer

Evil Prick
Nov 15, 2007
1,790
131
63
A friend and I have been discussing some opportunities. For simplicity's sake, I will say that the 3 opportunities all require an investment of $300k.

If presented with the following 3 opportunities...

1. Provide a 2nd mortgage on a large estate with a return of 17% per year. Borrower has good credit rating. 2nd mortgage puts debt ratio at 80%. All appropriate T&Cs in place.
2. Buy a house to flip. Cost of house plus renos should be ~300k. Should sell for ~$350k.
3. Buy commercial rental property. Rent for $1500/mth +TMI

...which would you be most inclined to pursue?
 
Not enough info Lou

A friend and I have been discussing some opportunities. For simplicity's sake, I will say that the 3 opportunities all require an investment of $300k.

If presented with the following 3 opportunities...

1. Provide a 2nd mortgage on a large estate with a return of 17% per year. Borrower has good credit rating. 2nd mortgage puts debt ratio at 80%. All appropriate T&Cs in place.
2. Buy a house to flip. Cost of house plus renos should be ~300k. Should sell for ~$350k.
3. Buy commercial rental property. Rent for $1500/mth +TMI

...which would you be most inclined to pursue?

Lots more huge variables (None of the above would be my pick)

However, PM me and I will give you my office #. Free consult for a TERBite.
(NO, I will not try to sell u anything)

And to ALL- buy

"The Sleuth Investor" Avner Mandelman

If you are not doing it his way, you are not an investor- just a gambler.
 
Too complicated for a layman to understand.

Too cute to explain definite outcome

Lots of unknown risk and variables

No info on the fine print, say possible lock-in period.

Too broke to have $300K down payment/fun money to profit or squander for average Joe like me.

Buy VNQ in NYC instead when the loonie is very closed to par, or JNK for high risk appetite.
 
VNQ- Vanguard REIT

Too complicated for a layman to understand.

Too cute to explain definite outcome

Lots of unknown risk and variables

No info on the fine print, say possible lock-in period.

Too broke to have $300K down payment/fun money to profit or squander for average Joe like me.

Buy VNQ in NYC instead when the loonie is very closed to par, or JNK for high risk appetite.

Why?
 
A friend and I have been discussing some opportunities. For simplicity's sake, I will say that the 3 opportunities all require an investment of $300k.

If presented with the following 3 opportunities...

1. Provide a 2nd mortgage on a large estate with a return of 17% per year. Borrower has good credit rating. 2nd mortgage puts debt ratio at 80%. All appropriate T&Cs in place.
2. Buy a house to flip. Cost of house plus renos should be ~300k. Should sell for ~$350k.
3. Buy commercial rental property. Rent for $1500/mth +TMI

...which would you be most inclined to pursue?

I would not do any of them.

1. 17% is too good to be true.

2. Do you have nothing else to do?

3. Commercial rental property is questionable in todays down economy.

I would (and did) invest in a basket of dividend paying stocks,
at around 7%, ($1750/month), and with preferential tax treatment.
 
I would go with commercial rental, if rent is late you can change the locks right away, whatever is inside stays inside until rent is paid or it becomes yours, it is far easier to evict bad tenants in a commercial rental.

17% is too good to be true

flipping a house can be good but too many things are beyond your control in terms of contractors, time lines, and cost over runs.

just my 2 cents, thanks for asking.
 
If the borrower really has good credit, and the 80% valuation on the property is valid, that sounds like the best one. You make close to $50k in year one on interest. If they default, you have plenty of room to foreclose and sell the property below market value to get your principal out (although I'd check in to see how that's done with a second mortgage; you may have to assume the debt of the first mortgage). Worst case they default and you get your money out plus whatever you can get over the 80%. Again, talk to a lawyer about the worst-case there.

I'm most familiar with #2, and given some of the deals available out there 6 months ago, it is worth it, provided you have a contractor you can trust, or partner with.
 
foolish to think you know the values of return when you don't understand the risk involved.

for example,

1. good credit rating on funding a 2nd mortgage and using proper contracts only goes so far to protect you. credit rating is a hindsight fallacy.
2. 'should sell for' is the most dangerous game you can play in investing... and besides, a $50k gain for all that trouble isn't worth it.
3. buying a commercial property and only gaining an income of $1500+TMI is rediculous. especially when one can buy a 4-plex + commercial unit in front of building for around $300k just slightly outside the gta and get $1050/per 2bdrm apartment unit (x4) + the $1500 TMI /mth for the commercial storefront... atleast when you have 5 units of income to diversify your risk over the single investment, you are much less likely to lose money.

btw- I've invested in similar scenarios to all 3 ways however, the risks you disclosed weren't the ones I was concerned with. when I look at risk, I actually look for risk... as in it I find opportunity.

Now, you asked to pick 1 of the 3. I'd definitely go with #3, the commercial income property for the simple reason of 1)minimizing speculation and 2)the power position it puts you as an owner/investor in.
 
Buy a condo, $300K cash! Hold it personally, sell it after property gain in value, hold the first mtg.
Live in moms basement! Lol
Risk free long term investment!
 
Mutual Funds In Canada, Another Scam Of Thugs!

After getting badly burnt with mutual funds, and the DFi's of Canada its too risky to invest over here. Presently just buy Swiss Gold Bars, Buy Rental Properties and keep your money to yourself than to give your money so mutual fund agents and their mangers to enjoy the perks and the investor looks like a fool with no return on his investments, whereas the agent broker or mutual funds mangers they all get their monthly stipends and other perks with the money the investor had invested
Mutual Funds over here in Canada is another scam for Ripping-Off investors. Another white collar crime in a legal manner palyed by many financial firms and their agents, there should be some check and balance from the govt. side also.
 
Not enough information to make a sound decision.

Let's start with the commercial property (#3): today's commercial vacancy rates are soaring, and any profitability will rely on (a) being able to find a tenant, (b) the ability to build-up the property to suit that tenant, to the extent of landlord's responsiblities, and (c) the ability of that tenant to maintain timely rent payments.

The landlord will still be responsible for taxes, property maintenance, and some insurance regardless of whether it's occupied or not. Some commercial tenancies will require a rent-free interval for fit-up, as well as requiring the landlord to do certain work to make the property fit for the purpose (tenant incentives).

At the end of the lease, the tenant might decide to move elsewhere (cheaper), or they could suffer the effects of the economic downturn and go under at any time (perhaps doing a midnight move to protect their assets from seizure over non-payment of rent). Not a solid game for a part-time player based on the facts as presented above unless all of these risk factors can be priced into the deal.

Buying a house to flip (#2) can be profitable based on an evaluation of time and materials, but who will be the primary contractor, and who will be the subcontractors. Will the investor be doing all the work themselves? Eating the cost overruns and errors (e.g. when the hardwood floor is installed, and has a "bump" in the middle, who is going to pay to fix it?) is a risk factor, as is carrying the property for the duration of the project (how long can the house remain unsold after the renovations before it turns into a financial disaster?).

Profit is available to those who know what they're doing, and financial disaster is available to those who get caught in the wrong set of circumstances. From the description given the direct carrying costs would be minimized by not having a mortgage on the property (in effect, providing a "mortgage" payment from the profit of the "renovation" business to the profit of the "ownership" business). But that's a tough one to evaluate: is the business profitable only because it's not carrying a mortgage? If so, then there are other considerations at work (e.g. making money by being paid as a contractor is never a bad thing, especially if one has complete control over the project).

Finally, as others have indicated above, holding a second mortgage on a property raises some questions. 17% return indicates a high risk, and an 80% debt ratio sounds pretty high. Is this the Total Debt Service Ratio? Living on 20% of one's income is the very thinnest edge of the wedge. If I recall correctly, approvals for a first mortgage for most of us would require a TDR below 32%, and if it's up to 80% then there's an urgent need for more income. Is there visibility into credit card debt levels? Any unexpected financial hiccups could wipe out the assets pretty quickly.

In all, no investment is without risk, but the above options are not anything I would recommend to a friend. I'm not an investment professional, though, so there may well be additional details makin the opportunities worthwhile.
 
Interesting feedback. The lack of details was intentional as I just wanted to speak in general terms.

The 17% return on a 2nd mortgage in the first year is not unrealistic. There are risks, as with any investment, but as ms4m suggests, the mitigation is in the foreclosure and assumption of the first. There are a variety of reasons why someone would choose to pay that kind of interest to a private lender. It's not all about credit rating.

Flipping houses is risky and does require a lot of work. You really need to know your stuff to make this scenario work. I've done it a few times with personal properties but never as a separate business pursuit.

Not too much feedback on the commercial property investment. I do know some people who have done very well in this area.

21pro, I'd be interested to hear what kind of risk you look for and see an example of a property that can be had for $300k and brings in $5700/mth in rent. that would certainly be worth looking at.
 
...
Finally, as others have indicated above, holding a second mortgage on a property raises some questions. 17% return indicates a high risk, and an 80% debt ratio sounds pretty high. Is this the Total Debt Service Ratio? Living on 20% of one's income is the very thinnest edge of the wedge. If I recall correctly, approvals for a first mortgage for most of us would require a TDR below 32%, and if it's up to 80% then there's an urgent need for more income. Is there visibility into credit card debt levels? Any unexpected financial hiccups could wipe out the assets pretty quickly.

Sorry Anynym, I was putting together my last response when yours was posted. The 80% I was referring to is not the Debt Service Ratio but the Debt Ratio (maybe there's a better term), meaning that the total amount owed on the property is 80% or less than the currently appraised value of the property. The appraiser is hired by me, of course. There is visibility into all of the debtors financial records.
 
Sorry Anynym, I was putting together my last response when yours was posted. The 80% I was referring to is not the Debt Service Ratio but the Debt Ratio (maybe there's a better term), meaning that the total amount owed on the property is 80% or less than the currently appraised value of the property. The appraiser is hired by me, of course. There is visibility into all of the debtors financial records.

Thanks for the clarification. That definitely sounds better, but there's still something that doesn't quite pass the smell test: if the loan (2nd mortgage) is fully secured based on current assessments, then paying 17% still sounds very high. Or, even more, depending on exactly what this 17% is referring to. E.g. in the latter days of the loan, the principal outstanding is low, so profit on the whole $300k is reduced. Meaning that the profit initially must be higher to average it out. Or that the 17% is referring to something else.

Either way, 17% sounds very high for secured loans of any description.
 
All depends on how quickly you can exit. Option 1 what type of commercial real estate is it, is there anything else to secure the loan. (80 % that means you are SOL if there is a default)

Option II - House and renos - how fast can you get this bought renoed and sold -

Option III what is the cost of the property and how easy is it to keep rented.