tboy said:Since you're so good at researching stats I shall leave it up to you but the problem with a "rule of thumb" is that it doesn't apply to everyone and there are those that think it applies to them yet it doesn't.
I agree. By the time someone is 22 they probably have sorted out what rule of thumb they should apply to themselves.
Just like your smoking argument: one drink affects someone's ability, so why put everyone at risk?
I agree, but there's no evidence that one drink affects your ability in any significant way once you've waited long enough that it's no longer significant in your blood.
We agree 100% on the principle here, which is that no-one should be behind the wheel if they are in any way affected by alcohol. We're quibbling over some technical details now about exactly how long you have to wait, or how low your BAL has to be, for there to be no effect, but we agree there should be no effect.
I'm more than willing to be persuaded that the rule of thumb is inadequate and that people should wait longer before driving--I'd want that to be based on some credible data, but I have no objection to the rule being updated to reflect a better, more modern appreciation of the way the human body processes alcohol. The 1hr/drink is simply my current best understanding of it for the "average male" (170-200lbs).

