Would anyone on here buy a smartcar

  • Thread starter Thread starter superman
  • Start date Start date
Those crash test are where the car is drove in to a wall at 50 km/h or so. Why not take a big SUV and drive that in to each car at 50 km/h to see what happens ? Most accidents are were cars hit each other, not driving in to a wall.

I don't believe SUV's are as safe as they might seem either, many times they flip or roll over after a crash because they are so high off the ground. Those big tanks are harder to steer and takes longer to stop.

I think cars like the crown victoria are the best type to be in if you have an accident. Now if Ford could just get rid of the wimpy 4.6 motor :p
 
I asked someone who owns a Smart Car about crash safety.

He mentioned that the car does not fall apart on impact.

I told him I thought that the falling apart on impact dispersed the energy so that it is not transmitted to the driver.

He answered that the car fills up with air bags to protect the driver, and the lack of falling apart protects the driver from being impaled by fragments of car.
 
Agree!

stang said:
Had fun in one in Switzerland.
They look out of place here.

They are great in some European cities. Pretty dumb in North America. Only two seats and barely room for a briefcase in the back. Why not buy a Toyota, Yaris, Suzuki or Honda Fit if you want a small car. At least they have four doors and can seat four people.

The smart cars are a menace on the 400 highways.
 
vsailor said:
A lot safer than all the motorcycles on the road!!!


Very true, I am all in favor of banding motorcycles for safety reasons-but it never happen.
 
Damondean said:
They are great in some European cities. Pretty dumb in North America. Only two seats and barely room for a briefcase in the back. Why not buy a Toyota, Yaris, Suzuki or Honda Fit if you want a small car. At least they have four doors and can seat four people.

The smart cars are a menace on the 400 highways.

I think SMART Cars are seen as a "lifestyle" statement and perceived as more cool than a Yaris. With the new gasoline engine, it's my understanding there isn't a HUGE difference in mileage between a Yaris and Smartfortwo V2.0

As a sidenote I drive a Miata as my ONLY vehicle. I can only get away with it coz I live 15 minutes from work, by myself, and don't carry luggage. The Miata was OK in 10-15cm of snow (with winter tires) but storms with 20-30cm I stayed home.
 
vsailor said:
"Until these Hummer's and other oversize SUV's are off the road, driving a smart car is too risky in my book."

A lot safer than all the motorcycles on the road!!!



You neglected to add tractor trsilers off the road.
 
S.C. Joe said:
Very true, I am all in favor of banding motorcycles for safety reasons-but it never happen.
what type of banding would you like?
 
Damondean said:
They are great in some European cities. Pretty dumb in North America. Only two seats and barely room for a briefcase in the back. Why not buy a Toyota, Yaris, Suzuki or Honda Fit if you want a small car. At least they have four doors and can seat four people.

The smart cars are a menace on the 400 highways.


At 6'4" I don't fit in any of the above mentioned Sub-compacts.

But I fit just fine in my Smart car. It is made for two passengers and has lots of space. I can fit a laptop bag & a airline size carryon in the trunk. I have to put my extended shaft golf clubs in the passenger seat though.

With a top speed of about 135 km/hr I don't understand how they are a menace on the highway. Cars don't kill people. Stupid drivers kill people.
 
superman said:
LOL is this really true...please provide turth
I said truck. Turth movers are heavy equipment.

Yes, no one makes a truck smaller than a mini-van, and they're bigger (not smart) than I need or want. Once the price of second-hand Scions and Honda Elements comes down to where throwing away the unwanted upholstery makes sense, then maybe I can get something with dull-normal intelligence in truckability.

Still waiting for the North American market to catch up to the Asia and Europe where such things are common. Given the number of posters above who say, "scientific crash tests may be all well and good, I still don't think they're safe", i ain't holdin' my breath.
 
oldjones said:
I said truck. Turth movers are heavy equipment.

Yes, no one makes a truck smaller than a mini-van, and they're bigger (not smart) than I need or want. Once the price of second-hand Scions and Honda Elements comes down to where throwing away the unwanted upholstery makes sense, then maybe I can get something with dull-normal intelligence in truckability.

Still waiting for the North American market to catch up to the Asia and Europe where such things are common. Given the number of posters above who say, "scientific crash tests may be all well and good, I still don't think they're safe", i ain't holdin' my breath.


opps typo, i meant truck, u got pics
 
Vespa is the way to go...stylish, sophisticated, civilized open road riding...and free parking too
It just doesn't get any better for this old wop.
 
vsailor said:
It's hilarious that people are saying the Smarts aren't safe, but where are they when talking about motorcycles???

Canada is full of motorcycles but no one is discussing their safety on the roads!!

The question should be: Would you buy a Smart or a Harley!!


agreed, plus most smart drivers dont drive fast
 
anon1 said:
Thanks, but they want me to register just to see the ad. I had a Civic Wagon years ago that was brilliantly designed for utility. Had its back door been 4' in at least one dimension, it would have been a mini-truck contender. The Nissan Axxess that sold here for a few years in the 90's (and for just one year in the US where they don't get small and sensible) wasn't quite as practical, but you could put a half sheet of plywood inside lying flat and still close the hatch.