Will TTC hold Toronto hostage?

It's a moot point since they reached a tentative deal. I believe it would really suck for Toronto if the TTC went on strike. But, they deserve to be paid for their labours, and the cost of living has eaten into their salaries. I know my employer has raised base pay inline with inflation, but few employers do that.

And, to be honest, it always sounds like union envy for people who bitch about these contracts and deals. Like, you get treated badly by your private sector employer, so everyone should as well. I don't agree with that sort of thinking. There have been times I wish I had the protection of a union, especially when management tries to squeeze blood from a stone...
But TTC workers ARE paid for their labour! Overpaid, in my view.

And cost of living increases? They have to be absorbed by EVERYONE. Why should unionized public servants be insulated? Private sector employees, unionized or not, have had to suffer.

You seem to believe in some kind of mythical "fair wage" for different kinds of work. Reality is - work is worth what an employer can justify paying for it while making a profit that is commensurate with the risk and ingenuity it takes to run his business. Reality is - the TTC is a massive money-losing proposition that couldn't continue in business were it not massively subsidized by taxpayer money. Reality is - a pay hike for TTC workers who want to be insulated from the effects of inflation means higher taxes and therefore a higher cost of living for all of us!

Our system of labour laws and collective bargaining is not designed for the public sector. In the private sector, both sides risk serious harm to the business and possible long term loss of market share (and therefore employment) when a labour disruption carries on for too long. Where does this business go during labour disruptions? To COMPETITORS, of course. Governments have given transit workers a MONOPOLY over the labour associated with public transit. There are no private transit operators waiting to take over the TTC's subway or light rail services to the public. There is no serious concern that a long labour stoppage could cost workers their jobs. There is little to no financial threat felt by the TTC either. They actually save money by not operating, since their funding is set in stone. The only thing that motivates them to settle is the politics of public uproar. Politicians, looking after themselves as usual, are happy to spend someone else's money to settle a strike if it improves their chance of re-election.

Labour relations in the public sector is not a system whereby the parties can determine the true demand and price for labour. Instead it's just political extortion that's created an entitled public servant class of citizens. There should not be a right to strike in the public sector at all, except in areas where public services overlap with services provided by the private sector.
 
But TTC workers ARE paid for their labour! Overpaid, in my view.

And cost of living increases? They have to be absorbed by EVERYONE. Why should unionized public servants be insulated? Private sector employees, unionized or not, have had to suffer.

You seem to believe in some kind of mythical "fair wage" for different kinds of work. Reality is - work is worth what an employer can justify paying for it while making a profit that is commensurate with the risk and ingenuity it takes to run his business. Reality is - the TTC is a massive money-losing proposition that couldn't continue in business were it not massively subsidized by taxpayer money. Reality is - a pay hike for TTC workers who want to be insulated from the effects of inflation means higher taxes and therefore a higher cost of living for all of us!

Our system of labour laws and collective bargaining is not designed for the public sector. In the private sector, both sides risk serious harm to the business and possible long term loss of market share (and therefore employment) when a labour disruption carries on for too long. Where does this business go during labour disruptions? To COMPETITORS, of course. Governments have given transit workers a MONOPOLY over the labour associated with public transit. There are no private transit operators waiting to take over the TTC's subway or light rail services to the public. There is no serious concern that a long labour stoppage could cost workers their jobs. There is little to no financial threat felt by the TTC either. They actually save money by not operating, since their funding is set in stone. The only thing that motivates them to settle is the politics of public uproar. Politicians, looking after themselves as usual, are happy to spend someone else's money to settle a strike if it improves their chance of re-election.

Labour relations in the public sector is not a system whereby the parties can determine the true demand and price for labour. Instead it's just political extortion that's created an entitled public servant class of citizens. There should not be a right to strike in the public sector at all, except in areas where public services overlap with services provided by the private sector.

Perfectly stated.
And if I may add...
- if someone doesn't believe they are paid fairly or treated well by their employer, they should find other work. Not just stay in their current job and be miserable, especially when dealing with the public.
- were TTC employees laid off during the pandemic or afterwards due to significantly lower ridership? No. Not the case in private businesses.
- no one ever brings up benefits when crying about public sector wages. ie pensions. That's all part of compensation.
 
It's a moot point since they reached a tentative deal. I believe it would really suck for Toronto if the TTC went on strike. But, they deserve to be paid for their labours, and the cost of living has eaten into their salaries. I know my employer has raised base pay inline with inflation, but few employers do that.

And, to be honest, it always sounds like union envy for people who bitch about these contracts and deals. Like, you get treated badly by your private sector employer, so everyone should as well. I don't agree with that sort of thinking. There have been times I wish I had the protection of a union, especially when management tries to squeeze blood from a stone...
It's not envy. It's dealing with people who are never happy and apparently never have enough and who always bitch like they have it so bad, when they actually don't. A lot of that comes from the constant narrative fed to employees by their union. ie "everyone else has it so much better than you."
If they are really that unhappy, they should just find another line of work. Not just stay and complain until the next negotiation (i.e. hostage taking).
 
Last edited:
- if someone doesn't believe they are paid fairly or treated well by their employer, they should find other work. Not just stay in their current job and be miserable, especially when dealing with the public.
Good advice that's seldom taken, regardless of a worker's ideology.

- no one ever brings up benefits when crying about public sector wages. ie pensions. That's all part of compensation.
Gold plated, indexed to inflation pensions. In a world where more and more people in the private sector are having to continue to work after retirement in order to make ends meet, public sector pensions are perhaps the most glaring inequity of all.
 
Gold plated, indexed to inflation pensions. In a world where more and more people in the private sector are having to continue to work after retirement in order to make ends meet, public sector pensions are perhaps the most glaring inequity of all.
...and don't forget no tax on the employer contribution...oh the irony!


As a Plan member, you contribute a percentage of your earnings each pay period to the Plan, and these contributions are matched by your employer—essentially doubling your contribution. The amount you contribute is based on a percentage of your earnings and are tax deductible. You pay no income tax on the matching portion that your employer contributes.

https://ttcpp.ca/membership/plan-features/
 
Why do you post stuff and then accuse me of as being clueless when you can't even track your own remarks?
Maybe stop attacking people and review your own posts first.

YOU brought up DoFo's education...that was what my response was about.

DOFO was poorly educated no doubt. Where did I mention that Ford had anything to do with the Privatization of the 407ETR? The disastrous 407ETR privatization occurred under the previous Conservative Government!!

But like the Beer Stores etc that he wants to expand means that he has to dish out $225 million of taxpayers money to end the Beer Store contracts.
That seems okay with you and just like the sweetheart deal with the 407ETR that now makes the Toll Highway out of reach of most of the Ontario residents who financed the construction etc. makes your arguments about "Privatizing the Transit System" a non starter. It will NOT HAPPEN as the greedy monopolies who take it over will not have the interests of the Canadians who do not own a car or have to depend on the public transport. But you seem to think that if Ford wastes Tax Payers money, then it is perfectly okay. No one is holding the Public to ransom, like you claim as the Union demands have been met!!
 
I get that but it doesn’t mean people not even related to your work or union should suffer and be at risk of losing their job or income because of their situation. Yes I know they reached a deal I was just saying in general terms.

So you think cops shouldn't have a union as well?
 
...and don't forget no tax on the employer contribution...oh the irony!


As a Plan member, you contribute a percentage of your earnings each pay period to the Plan, and these contributions are matched by your employer—essentially doubling your contribution. The amount you contribute is based on a percentage of your earnings and are tax deductible. You pay no income tax on the matching portion that your employer contributes.

https://ttcpp.ca/membership/plan-features/

DoFo just gave half his party raises by making them cabinet members then gave them 5 months of work.
That's way more expensive than any union.

Why don't you care about that?

 
But TTC workers ARE paid for their labour! Overpaid, in my view.
Yes. I assumed this. Everything else is just bullshit. Yes, the cost of living hurts everyone. Why shouldn't your boss raise your wages inline with inflation? But, if your employer doesn't, don't get mad that others do.

I understand the envy. I really do. I wish I could get a gig that paid well and offered the job security of a union, one where management cannot fuck with you.
 
It's not envy. It's dealing with people who are never happy and apparently never have enough and who always bitch like they have it so bad, when they actually don't. A lot of that comes from the constant narrative fed to employees by their union. ie "everyone else has it so much better than you."
If they are really that unhappy, they should just find another line of work. Not just stay and complain until the next negotiation (i.e. hostage taking).

I cannot talk about your experiences. I'm sure there are a lot of people who work at the TTC who LOVE their jobs, just as sure as I'm sure there are a lot who HATE is. The point is, I'm willing to bet that most people feel the same about their jobs. But, keep in mind, they also have the golden handcuffs of a good pension. It is worth their while to stick with it and earn that nice retirement plan.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Yes. I assumed this. Everything else is just bullshit. Yes, the cost of living hurts everyone. Why shouldn't your boss raise your wages inline with inflation? But, if your employer doesn't, don't get mad that others do.

I understand the envy. I really do. I wish I could get a gig that paid well and offered the job security of a union, one where management cannot fuck with you.
WTF? Why shouldn't your boss insulate you from inflation? How about - because money doesn't grow on trees, and inflation has hit his bottom line every bit as much as it has hit yours! Honestly, you seem to lack basic financial literacy. Unfortunately, the changes coming to the Ontario school curriculum have come too late for you.

Having a union in the private sector does not ensure that "management cannot fuck with you". It does force employers to make hard choices about where they should operate and how much technology to introduce to replace labour. For the most part, in industries that can relocate (like manufacturing) their choice has been to relocate. Of course, most public services (like garbage collection) have to be performed by local manpower - thus the opportunity to extort the public.

However, as I've already said, unions in the public sector are a square peg in a round hole. The only leverage public sector unions have is the monopoly GIVEN to them by government. Stupid government policy. The largest of the Ontario public sector unions didn't even have to unionize employees (persuade them to join). It was given bargaining rights by statute! Foolish.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76
DOFO was poorly educated no doubt. Where did I mention that Ford had anything to do with the Privatization of the 407ETR? The disastrous 407ETR privatization occurred under the previous Conservative Government!!

But like the Beer Stores etc that he wants to expand means that he has to dish out $225 million of taxpayers money to end the Beer Store contracts.
That seems okay with you and just like the sweetheart deal with the 407ETR that now makes the Toll Highway out of reach of most of the Ontario residents who financed the construction etc. makes your arguments about "Privatizing the Transit System" a non starter. It will NOT HAPPEN as the greedy monopolies who take it over will not have the interests of the Canadians who do not own a car or have to depend on the public transport. But you seem to think that if Ford wastes Tax Payers money, then it is perfectly okay. No one is holding the Public to ransom, like you claim as the Union demands have been met!!
You asked me about where you mentioned Ford's education not about the 407ETR.

I showed you where you mentioned it.

Are you trying to distract again?
 
WTF? Why shouldn't your boss insulate you from inflation? How about - because money doesn't grow on trees, and inflation has hit his bottom line every bit as much as it has hit yours! Honestly, you seem to lack basic financial literacy. Unfortunately, the changes coming to the Ontario school curriculum have come too late for you.

Having a union in the private sector does not ensure that "management cannot fuck with you". It does force employers to make hard choices about where they should operate and how much technology to introduce to replace labour. For the most part, in industries that can relocate (like manufacturing) their choice has been to relocate. Of course, most public services (like garbage collection) have to be performed by local manpower - thus the opportunity to extort the public.

However, as I've already said, unions in the public sector are a square peg in a round hole. The only leverage public sector unions have is the monopoly GIVEN to them by government. Stupid government policy. The largest of the Ontario public sector unions didn't even have to unionize employees (persuade them to join). It was given bargaining rights by statute! Foolish.

Man, I just love the right-wing and the fictitious pull your-self up from your bootstraps bullshit. I don't know about you, but most good companies raise salaries every year. It might not be much, but it is usually in line with inflation (or maybe 3/4 inflation). The reason should be fairly obvious: If you feel your wages are shrinking due to higher costs, and the company ain't helping, you start looking for a new gig that will pay better.

Now, you can cry about unions all you want. They are here. They protect their members, and your jealousy over them is noted. Your lack of financial literacy and history is truly astounding.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Man, I just love the right-wing and the fictitious pull your-self up from your bootstraps bullshit. I don't know about you, but most good companies raise salaries every year. It might not be much, but it is usually in line with inflation (or maybe 3/4 inflation). The reason should be fairly obvious: If you feel your wages are shrinking due to higher costs, and the company ain't helping, you start looking for a new gig that will pay better.

Now, you can cry about unions all you want. They are here. They protect their members, and your jealousy over them is noted. Your lack of financial literacy and history is truly astounding.

Unions gave us 5 day work weeks, lunch hours, sick days and worker protections.
All things the skoob hates.

They'd be happy if we went back to 14 hr working days, child labour and coal fired businesses.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: silentkisser
Unions gave us 5 day work weeks, lunch hours, sick days and worker protections.
All things the skoob hates.

They'd be happy if we went back to 14 hr working days, child labour and coal fired businesses.
Another "let's go back 100 years" to find something the unions did rather than admitting they are useless these days.
 
If you feel your wages are shrinking due to higher costs, and the company ain't helping, you start looking for a new gig that will pay better.
Public sector union members should do the same since they always cry about how bad they have it when they hold everyone hostage during "negotiations."
 
I cannot talk about your experiences. I'm sure there are a lot of people who work at the TTC who LOVE their jobs, just as sure as I'm sure there are a lot who HATE is. The point is, I'm willing to bet that most people feel the same about their jobs. But, keep in mind, they also have the golden handcuffs of a good pension. It is worth their while to stick with it and earn that nice retirement plan.
Do you want public servants just sticking around to collect their pensions years from now? How well do you think they perform until then if that's their motivation?
And if they acknowledge that they will have it good once they retire, then why are they always crying about how bad they have it?
 
Another "let's go back 100 years" to find something the unions did rather than admitting they are useless these days.

Why are you so against other people making a living wage?
Why do you blame poor people for your own problems?
 
You asked me about where you mentioned Ford's education not about the 407ETR.

I showed you where you mentioned it.

Are you trying to distract again?

You compared Ford to entrepreneurs. What did Ford do that was so groundbreaking? Maybe that street vending of cocaine was what you appreciate!! LOL!!
 
Why are you so against other people making a living wage?
Why do you blame poor people for your own problems?
Ah yes avoiding the "what have unions contributed to society in modern times" question and pivoting elsewhere...ok.

What's a living wage and tell me why you think unionized employees aren't earning one?
Why do you blame successful people for your problems?