But TTC workers ARE paid for their labour! Overpaid, in my view.It's a moot point since they reached a tentative deal. I believe it would really suck for Toronto if the TTC went on strike. But, they deserve to be paid for their labours, and the cost of living has eaten into their salaries. I know my employer has raised base pay inline with inflation, but few employers do that.
And, to be honest, it always sounds like union envy for people who bitch about these contracts and deals. Like, you get treated badly by your private sector employer, so everyone should as well. I don't agree with that sort of thinking. There have been times I wish I had the protection of a union, especially when management tries to squeeze blood from a stone...
And cost of living increases? They have to be absorbed by EVERYONE. Why should unionized public servants be insulated? Private sector employees, unionized or not, have had to suffer.
You seem to believe in some kind of mythical "fair wage" for different kinds of work. Reality is - work is worth what an employer can justify paying for it while making a profit that is commensurate with the risk and ingenuity it takes to run his business. Reality is - the TTC is a massive money-losing proposition that couldn't continue in business were it not massively subsidized by taxpayer money. Reality is - a pay hike for TTC workers who want to be insulated from the effects of inflation means higher taxes and therefore a higher cost of living for all of us!
Our system of labour laws and collective bargaining is not designed for the public sector. In the private sector, both sides risk serious harm to the business and possible long term loss of market share (and therefore employment) when a labour disruption carries on for too long. Where does this business go during labour disruptions? To COMPETITORS, of course. Governments have given transit workers a MONOPOLY over the labour associated with public transit. There are no private transit operators waiting to take over the TTC's subway or light rail services to the public. There is no serious concern that a long labour stoppage could cost workers their jobs. There is little to no financial threat felt by the TTC either. They actually save money by not operating, since their funding is set in stone. The only thing that motivates them to settle is the politics of public uproar. Politicians, looking after themselves as usual, are happy to spend someone else's money to settle a strike if it improves their chance of re-election.
Labour relations in the public sector is not a system whereby the parties can determine the true demand and price for labour. Instead it's just political extortion that's created an entitled public servant class of citizens. There should not be a right to strike in the public sector at all, except in areas where public services overlap with services provided by the private sector.

