Will TTC hold Toronto hostage?

Skoob

Well-known member
Jun 1, 2022
8,086
5,098
113
Another public sector union threatening a strike which will impact millions of people.

Ridership is down, $60 million per year lost in fare evasion, yet they want "job security" (whatever that means).

Time to scrap public sector unions and avoid extortion rackets that negatively impact the public which they are intended to serve.




"Unfortunately, as a result of not being able to have the progress needed to avoid a strike, yes, people should be preparing to have us withdraw our services on Friday."
https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/people-s...lks-ahead-of-friday-strike-deadline-1.6911373
 
Ah, here we go. Another anti-union post. Look, nobody wants to see them go on strike, but they have a legal right to do so. Unions are not perfect, but they've made life significantly better. They pushed for the 40 hour week, weekends off, holidays etc. Imagine if that didn't happen. Being an operator for the TTC is a tough job. They work hard and front-line workers take a lot of abuse. I don't know what they make, but I'm sure you'll say its too much...
 
Ah, here we go. Another anti-union post. Look, nobody wants to see them go on strike, but they have a legal right to do so. Unions are not perfect, but they've made life significantly better. They pushed for the 40 hour week, weekends off, holidays etc. Imagine if that didn't happen. Being an operator for the TTC is a tough job. They work hard and front-line workers take a lot of abuse. I don't know what they make, but I'm sure you'll say its too much...
Ah here we go, another pro-union response about something they accomplished almost a century ago. Let's move on. They are irrelevant these days with all the labour laws in place.

"Taking a lot of abuse" is a subjective term. And if someone can't handle a demanding job, they should look for a different line of work. Last thing we need is public employees staying doing a job they hate.

Enough excuses for why union members have it so hard and need to constantly be coddled while affecting public services.
 
Duggo will order them back after 2 or 3 days of chaos. Always happens with a TTC strike. Non event.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76
Duggo will order them back after 2 or 3 days of chaos. Always happens with a TTC strike. Non event.
But why put the public through any chaos at all and use them as bargaining chips (ie hostages)?

Time to privatize it all and fast. Unions have not added any value to public transit over the decades. Zero.
 
I hope they walk. I want to see all the lefties whine and bitch about how hard their life is now.
Then Chow will go crying again to the Provincial and Federal government crying for more money. As she always does.
The cry baby GTA is always good for laughs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: southpaw
Ah, here we go. Another anti-union post. Look, nobody wants to see them go on strike, but they have a legal right to do so. Unions are not perfect, but they've made life significantly better. They pushed for the 40 hour week, weekends off, holidays etc. Imagine if that didn't happen. Being an operator for the TTC is a tough job. They work hard and front-line workers take a lot of abuse. I don't know what they make, but I'm sure you'll say its too much...
I disagree, it was rising productivity that allowed the shorter workweek and getting children out of the factories. Unions are a break on productivity.
There is no way that we wouldn't have that today, it suggest otherwise is to not know anything about economics.

Also legal, yeah, but telling customers of either your labour or your cheese that they must buy X amount at Y price or they will shut you down is flat out extortion. However it seems it is only illegal when the Mafia does it [which is apparently why pizza places in Montreal use more cheese than elsewhere.]
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skoob
I disagree, it was rising productivity that allowed the shorter workweek and getting children out of the factories. Unions are a break on productivity.
There is no way that we wouldn't have that today, it suggest otherwise is to not know anything about economics.
Nah. The owners would just pocket more profits and buy more swag and keep the 7-day work week.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SchlongConery
Nah. The owners would just pocket more profits and buy more swag and keep the 7-day work week.
The employees would just quit and then the owners would have to pay and treat them better or they go out of business.
How well would they treat & pay them?
Enough to keep them helping the business thrive and succeed. It's a two-way street.

In the public sector, all that goes out the window due to the perception that there is an endless amount of money and people are just owed a living regardless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76
But why put the public through any chaos at all and use them as bargaining chips (ie hostages)?

Time to privatize it all and fast. Unions have not added any value to public transit over the decades. Zero.

You can't de-certify any workplace once it has become unionized. If you buy a business that is unionized, change the name, ownership, fire all the employees, pay them the contracted severance etc etc, that workplace is still unionized if you carry on any related business.

The TTC and Metrolynx are GROSSLY mismanaged and incompetent. Look at the fucking chaos the construction of the St Clair streetcar line or whatever it is, caused. And it isn't working, and won't be for another year.

Fucking Eglinton Cross town couldn't even manage to have the most rudimentary quality control and specification inspection/contract enforcement to set the tracks at the correct width. Who got fired for it? Nobody.

Most unions workers that are inefficient are because of management.

When a larger electrical contractor calls down to the Union Hall for 4 guys for a week or three.. those guys perform! Get it done right and quickly. Otherwise the slacker or fuckup gets a bad rep and isn't asked back. Smaller mom and pop non union electricians seem cheaper but in the end, they often cost more because they are not as well managed as the bigger ones.

Plus, we only see the public facing TTC workers. Drivers etc. The maintenance barn is full of really hard working people to "keep the trains running". Now the Railway Engineers are another story.
 
The employees would just quit and then the owners would have to pay and treat them better or they go out of business.
How well would they treat & pay them?
Enough to keep them helping the business thrive and succeed. It's a two-way street.

In the public sector, all that goes out the window due to the perception that there is an endless amount of money and people are just owed a living regardless.

The restaurant industry is about as exploitive as there is. And yet restaurants can make tons of money without paying or treating their employees decently.
 
The employees would just quit and then the owners would have to pay and treat them better or they go out of business.
How well would they treat & pay them?
Enough to keep them helping the business thrive and succeed. It's a two-way street.

In the public sector, all that goes out the window due to the perception that there is an endless amount of money and people are just owed a living regardless.
Yep. All the workers had to do in 1879 - when everyone worked 80 hour weeks for just enough money to buy a few loaves of bread and live in an unheated garret - was everyone quit at the same time. You nailed that one, genius!
 
Another public sector union threatening a strike which will impact millions of people.

Ridership is down, $60 million per year lost in fare evasion, yet they want "job security" (whatever that means).

Time to scrap public sector unions and avoid extortion rackets that negatively impact the public which they are intended to serve.




"Unfortunately, as a result of not being able to have the progress needed to avoid a strike, yes, people should be preparing to have us withdraw our services on Friday."
https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/people-s...lks-ahead-of-friday-strike-deadline-1.6911373

Its Metrolinx and DoFo that's screwing up the TTC, not the workers.
 
But why put the public through any chaos at all and use them as bargaining chips (ie hostages)?

Time to privatize it all and fast. Unions have not added any value to public transit over the decades. Zero.
So....you think privatization would make things better some how? Explain, please. How would privatizing the TTC improve service or reduce costs?

Look at how privatization has worked for other jurisdictions. Look at the UK, where they privatized rail lines 30 years ago.


Higher costs, lower service and angry people. Show me a service like transit or utilities that have been privatized and actually resulted in lower costs or better service in the long-term. You can't. It doesn't exist. It's a unicorn. And I beg of you, to prove me wrong.

As for the TTC union, they are the value of public transit. You need humans to maintain vehicles and track, drive the buses and trains etc. Plus, they a union is more likely to whistle blow when safety is a concern, so there is a greater chance they've improved the safety and reliability in the system.

From what I can tell by your response, you likely do not depend on public transit. Which is fine. You probably don't or have never worked in a union shop (disclosure, neither have I). But you certainly seem to have disdain for them. Yes, there are the stereotypes of lazy workers and what not, but that is the exception, not the rule.
 
I disagree, it was rising productivity that allowed the shorter workweek and getting children out of the factories. Unions are a break on productivity.
There is no way that we wouldn't have that today, it suggest otherwise is to not know anything about economics.

Also legal, yeah, but telling customers of either your labour or your cheese that they must buy X amount at Y price or they will shut you down is flat out extortion. However it seems it is only illegal when the Mafia does it [which is apparently why pizza places in Montreal use more cheese than elsewhere.]
So....you think that if unions didn't fight for improved working conditions and breaks that the owners in charge would graciously just come up with the idea on their own? If that were the case, why has productivity surged by probably 1500% due to machines and what not, but we're still working 40 hour weeks? Or why have wages been suppressed compared to this surge in productivity? Or, why don't we work 20 hours per week for the same pay, and they hire another shift to maintain production. The reason: It does not provide enough of a return for investors. That might not have been top of mind 80+ years ago when many of these concessions were won,

I'm not sure what your experience has been in the working world, but employers wouldn't give you vacations unless they were obligated to.
 
So it is not the TTC holding the city hostage, as the title says. It is the union.
So, are you saying that any strike is holding a company hostage? I mean, there was a three month strike at a Nestle plant in Toronto that was just resolved. Were they holding Nestle hostage?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
You can't de-certify any workplace once it has become unionized. If you buy a business that is unionized, change the name, ownership, fire all the employees, pay them the contracted severance etc etc, that workplace is still unionized if you carry on any related business.

The TTC and Metrolynx are GROSSLY mismanaged and incompetent. Look at the fucking chaos the construction of the St Clair streetcar line or whatever it is, caused. And it isn't working, and won't be for another year.

Fucking Eglinton Cross town couldn't even manage to have the most rudimentary quality control and specification inspection/contract enforcement to set the tracks at the correct width. Who got fired for it? Nobody.

Most unions workers that are inefficient are because of management.

When a larger electrical contractor calls down to the Union Hall for 4 guys for a week or three.. those guys perform! Get it done right and quickly. Otherwise the slacker or fuckup gets a bad rep and isn't asked back. Smaller mom and pop non union electricians seem cheaper but in the end, they often cost more because they are not as well managed as the bigger ones.

Plus, we only see the public facing TTC workers. Drivers etc. The maintenance barn is full of really hard working people to "keep the trains running". Now the Railway Engineers are another story.
Privatize it.
Like any privatized organization or business, efficiency is baked in.
Need maintenance? Hire a company to perform it based on a Statement of Work (SoW) with penalties for missing deadlines.
Have staff that are slacking off? Fire them and replace them with quality employees that care about what they do.
Losing $60+ million per year in fare evasion? That wouldn't happen to that extent if it was privatized.
Too much inefficiencies in management? Fire them and only hire the most qualified that are rewarded based on performance not tenure.
 
Yep. All the workers had to do in 1879 - when everyone worked 80 hour weeks for just enough money to buy a few loaves of bread and live in an unheated garret - was everyone quit at the same time. You nailed that one, genius!
Why is it that whenever the topic of unions come up, it immediately goes back 100+ years.

If someone doesn't like their job, they should find a new one.
If someone values the work someone does, they should reward them so they don't leave.

It's pretty simple. Convince me its not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76