Whiskey/Scotch Recommendation?

The 12 year old was my brother's in law last bottle and I would recommend as well.

I may eye the 15 year old but now we are getting into the $90 range.

Try a comparison and learn It's not alway age that improve the flavour. It just changes. I often find that any over 15 aren't worth the price increase, but that's just a personal observation.

I once had an opportunity to compare the line of great Glenfarclas malts, a very fine selection of 10, 12, 15, 18 , 21, 23, 25 year old malts. The only time I ever spit in my life. Wouldn't have made it through the tasting without doing it. Each was different and unique, but my point made quite clear.
 
Oban; nice smooth single malt

.... and a very beautiful part of the country. During my last visit one of the stores had a 60 year bottle of Oban on display that was found after the death of a resident and the estate agent were going through his property. Note, I did not say a bottle of 60 year old. since then, a Japanese business man (who else) bought it for, I believe, $10,000.
 
The 15 year Highland park is unbelievable, I need to try out the 18.
 
Visit Vintages and get one of the lesser-known brands. There's quite a few introduced to Ontario in the past year that are remarkable. I travel to Europe and Asia a great deal and always bring a bottle of something I can't get here back.
 
Maybe I don't have a sophisticated pallet but I couldn't tell the difference between that and black.

I wasn't that impressed with the jw blue. Much more offerering at a better price.

Klute
 
Much of scotch consumption is driven by pretence, even the Japanese who have got the art of copying many things Western down to a science have their own brand of pompous scotch. Scotch drinking is much more than just labels.
 
What do you guys think about laphroaig? More specifically, what tastes close to it?

I enjoy the smokey, peaty scotches.
Laphroaig used to be the poor cousin to Lagavulin, but its not as good as it used to be.
Talisker is my favourite these days, give it a try.
 
Much of scotch consumption is driven by pretence, even the Japanese who have got the art of copying many things Western down to a science have their own brand of pompous scotch. Scotch drinking is much more than just labels.

Before you try and preach pomposity and pretense, check your facts. The Japanese do not make Scotch, They make Japanese whisky, note the missing 'e'. Just like the Indian whisky. They're not Scotch whiskies.
 
I got a half a bottle left of Canadian Club 20 years old whisky from my thanksgiving weekend and now deciding to either pick up another bottle or try something new, preferably get back into a single malt, if at a comparable price of 50-70ish dollars.

I am uncertain on the year but preferably something drinkable for sipping.

Any recommendations on scotch/whisky please?

Thanks.

Jack Daniels all the way baby.. black label!
 
You did read he was looking for a malt whiskey? Not something that is 50%+ corn.




you can not hate him for his tastes
I actually prefer Pussers British Navel to most whiskeys
 
I don't hate him, just want to keep on topic a tad. As for Pussers, and I thought we were kindred 'spirits', oh well.

don't get me wrong I still love a fine whiskey
But Pussers offers a unique flavor and has its place on the shelf of any whiskey lover

Beside all of that

You forget I am not only Irish but also a sailor.
 
First of all Canadian whisky is not rye whisky it is barley whisky. Alberta Premium is the only Rye I am aware of.

Hey DD, I saw your comment and was very surprised, thinking all Canadian whisky was primarily made with rye; e.g. rye and ginger, rye and coke. So I went to the website for Wiser's and found the following:
•Even though Canadian whisky is often referred to as "rye", this misleading name is derived from the distinct blended flavouring, rather than its primary ingredients of corn.
Check out the Wiser's site, they have a concise history and explanation on the difference between Irish, Scottish, Canadian and American whiskies.
http://www.wisers.ca/en/heritage#making-wisers
 
I'm not an avid drinker, but don't mind once in a while. Jim Murray writes the Whisky Bible, so I like
to see what he has to say, and then compare on my palate.

Glenmorangie 10y scored a 94 Nice. And I like it's smooth finish.
Ardbeg 10 ( not for everyone, but it's fantastic , a veritable peat utopia ) scored 97

Yum
 
For those of you who like Scotch based liquors such as Clayva and Drambuie, a new release at the LCBO is Atholl Brose, very nice, very subtle apéritif. As are most Scotches, not inexpensive, but worth the try. The story behind it is also interesting. It has taken my top choice in this category for me. No idea how long it will be around if it does catch on/get noticed.