What makes a person cheap?

JamesDouglas

Active member
Nov 10, 2011
1,219
0
36
Cheapness means different things to different people, what do you define as being cheap? I'm not talking about that show "Extreme Cheapskates", which is just beyond ridiculous, those people have serious mental issues, but I'm talking about cheapness for everyday folk.

To me cheap is tipping 5-10%, or even worse, not tipping at all, when you receive good service when you have the money to afford it. To me cheap is buying an old used second hand car with lots of mileage when you can easily afford a new car, not a fancy car, but a new economy car. To me cheap is living in an old dirty decrepit apartment when you can afford to live in a new condo. And so on.
 
Cheap is when you have money, but you would rather hoard it rather than spend it.

I'm not saying that one should spend every dime that one earns, but on the other hand, life is all about balance and allot of people have the money, but won't part with it.

I'm thinking of a good friend of mine. He's a great friend and a great guy, but he's as cheap as the day is long. He makes about 150k a year. He has 2 kids that are grown up. He pays no support because he has the kids half the time and his wife makes as much as him and she has them half the time.

He lives in a townhouse in Georgetown where he has lived for almost 20 years. He's never so much as painted over the builder biege. His shower faucet broke a few years ago and rather than redo his bathroom - which it REALLY needed, he went to Canadian Tire and bought some garden hose and some how rigged up this garden hose and garden sprayer to make a temporary shower. 5 years later - he's still using it.

He drives a POS car

He is always claiming he's got no money, but the truth is that he saves pretty much everything. He pours a huge amount into RRSPs and his savings with every pay cheque.

Maybe some day he will have millions and I will have nothing, but even then, he won't spend it.
 
James, I think that the details that you have provided go to a mindset that calls into question the person's sense of self worth. And by extension such a mindset precludes properly valuing others. So the pecunary modesty is only part of the problem.
 
To me, cheap is when a person needs something (or wants something that will genuinely add to his/her quality of life), has more than enough money for it (while still taking care of other financial responsibilities like paying bills, short and long term savings, etc), yet still denies him/herself so that the bank account can pile up for no apparent reason.

IMO, this is in contrast to greed, when a person spends freely on him/herself, but is extremely stingy when it comes to spending on others (gifts, tipping, etc).

I don't think spending money on used cars instead of new, tipping poorly, buying inexpensive food or clothes, etc. necessarily makes one cheap... it all depends on what one values. If you don't value something, it seems irrational to spend lots of money on it. However if one does not spend money on the things that one truly values, that makes one cheap.
 
A friend with connection to the banking business told me it has happened
once in a while that there are accounts loaded with a huge sum of money left
idle with no one to attend to. According to my friend he knew a banker
who actually got rich by getting his hand on such money having found out
that the owner of the account had deceased without a will and apparently
without any friends and relatives whom he cared about. To my knowledge
unclaimed cash has to be transferred to the Bank of Canada after a certain length
of time sitting idle in an expired account. Apparently there is little risk for a con man
in a bank to transfer the cash to his own account.

I guess one cannot get any cheaper by leaving his lifetime savings behind
this way.
 
A friend with connection to the banking business told me it has happened
once in a while that there are accounts loaded with a huge sum of money left
idle with no one to attend to. According to my friend he knew a banker
who actually got rich by getting his hand on such money having found out
that the owner of the account had deceased without a will and apparently
without any friends and relatives whom he cared about. To my knowledge
unclaimed cash has to be transferred to the Bank of Canada after a certain length
of time sitting idle in an expired account. Apparently there is little risk for a con man
in a bank to transfer the cash to his own account.

I guess one cannot get any cheaper by leaving his lifetime savings behind
this way.

May not be cheap just a lonely life.
 
My father's wife is the cheapest piece of work I've ever known. She buys reduced fruits and vegetables and day old bread, in order to save money! They have a 5 bedroom house in Richmond Hill and she goes around telling everyone they're poor!
 
My father's wife is the cheapest piece of work I've ever known. She buys reduced fruits and vegetables and day old bread, in order to save money! They have a 5 bedroom house in Richmond Hill and she goes around telling everyone they're poor!

Probably mortgaged to the hilt - house rich and cash poor!
 
A local bar is a well-known NHL hangout. According to the staff scuttlebut, hockey players are the cheapest tippers around (at least pre lockout - now they don't even show up). The waitress has a hilarious story about 3 players who each make $5 million plus arguing over who would leave the tip for a pitcher of beer. They ended up compromising and throwing in a looney each...
 
Nope, house was paid off years ago. Mortgage free!

When you grow up poor, it is really hard to kick the mentality as you grow up. When you know what it's like to have no money, you become very determined to never go back there.. and in doing so you condemn your self to a state of poverty even though you have money.. it's a little nuts. I think like that sometimes and it is hard to break.
 
I'm not sure it's cheap. From the time some people are born they aren't taught to think of other people. Arrive for dinner without a bottle of wine or something for the hostess. Even Christmas cards. I send them but I know some really nice people who don't.

Had a chap ask me how to make a favourable impression with an SP. I suggested bringing a box of chocolates for the lady. Nope. Already costing a lot (in his mind).
 
I would never have called myself "cheap", but "frugal" certainly. At one point I had no issue living in a dive of an apartment building (painted and decorated nicely, of course) in order to save money. My first apartment was a mix of IKEA and discontinued/damaged items from The Brick even though I could afford much better. It was also a shady 2 bedroom in East End Hamilton...again, to save money.
Despite a very good dual income during my time outside the business, I still moved us into a building full of people on welfare. I saved us about $10,000 living there for 5 months versus the house we had previously lived in. I gave up my car and made my ex husband trade in his high end SUV for a Ford sedan.

I roll change and bring it to the bank. If I see a coupon, I will use it. I buy all my meat in bulk and cut and package it myself.

It was only this month that I slapped myself and decided to rent a nice house for myself. I move in tomorrow!
 
I hate cheap people. Being cheap is when you have money and try to bargain, dont tip or tip little ( as stated above), having money and being selfish, counting loose change and pennies.I can understand if you are cheap because you are struggling financially, but otherwise..come on... you can't take your money with you when your gone.
 
These are all good points, and I think it's important to differentiate between being cheap and being poor. If you're poor and take serious cost cutting measures you have little choice, but if you have money and choose to do the same, that's what makes someone cheap. It's not to say that money should be wasted, I know someone who refuses to buy items that are on sale because he thinks it's cheap to do so. Buying something on sale does not make you cheap, refusing to buy an item you want that's on sale is just stupidity. You're showing that you're not cheap by wanting to always pay full price for an item, but you're also showing how moronic you are.

I believe the same thing goes for coupons or groupon/teambuy vouchers. A business creates these vouchers to attract customers out of their own volition, you're not ripping the business off by using it, the business is the one who created it for you to use. Many people seem to misunderstand the meaning of being cheap, the word gets thrown around a lot, but the term is not often properly used.
 
Cheapness means different things to different people, what do you define as being cheap? I'm not talking about that show "Extreme Cheapskates", which is just beyond ridiculous, those people have serious mental issues, but I'm talking about cheapness for everyday folk.

To me cheap is tipping 5-10%, or even worse, not tipping at all, when you receive good service when you have the money to afford it. To me cheap is buying an old used second hand car with lots of mileage when you can easily afford a new car, not a fancy car, but a new economy car. To me cheap is living in an old dirty decrepit apartment when you can afford to live in a new condo. And so on.

This is one reason why some people are cheap... :biggrin1:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MksU56yrKzs