U2 - Criticism or Stupidity?

Reuben Feffer

Banned
Jan 14, 2005
29
0
0
Does terb have any U2 fans present? If so, I've read what appears to be some rather constructive criticism from a particular dolt who decided to spew his lack of knowledge regarding a great band known to many around the world.

While the American and English bands of the sixties were a result of civil rights movement and Vietnam, U2 grew out of the Irish situation. The parallels are enormous between early U2 and the Jefferson Airplane, Doors, etc of a decade or so earlier.

I believe that U2 broke down the eigthies cliché of pseudo new romantic hairdos singing in falsetto, or the regular MTV pop song standard plenty of synclaviers and electronic drumming. That was a good thing. And then, they became a very popular rock band with good songs and a somehow studied atittude: the sort of thing that generates ¨love them or hate them¨postures.
But I´m very grateful for the music that they crafted. And it became the soundtrack of interesting moments of my life.


However, what I present to you all this very moment is a post made by an angry person? a delusional person? someone confused about music? Or all of the above?

Here is that post: U2: Need I say more, a critic manufactured band for the weak minded. Bono will tell anyone that wants to listen how “relevant” he thinks they are to music (sure pal) and that they are “just a poor little band from Ireland” (ok pal). In 25 years has the bas player and drummer ever been on the same page in a song as far as a rhythm section goes (hell no). The scam called the Edge hasn’t learned more than 1 fucking effect on his guitar and has the WORST vibrato in music, but hey when a credible magazine like Rolling Stone (LOL) call you the best, hey all of the no minds will believe it, and with this new high school band sounding album with their version of Loverboy’s “Everybody’s Working For The Weekend” (Verttigo), not to mention that ever annoying All Because of You, they could easily get 1-5 on my list..They just suck.


Can someone reply to this post? I will personally post the best response to this nonsense and forward it to this music board. I know there must a true die hard U2 fan or two here! Let's hear from you people! :mad:
 
I gotta agree about the guitarist...Too boring and predictable. Every lead is the same (worse than Rush).

Bono likes to play the humanitarian role...Who cares! It's easy to play the role when you have the dough to afford it, but when you're a struggling musician sucking cock to earn a living, the humanitarian role doesn't pay the bills.

U2 is over-rated and under talented
 
Last edited:
xarir said:
Not to be snide or anything, but what's the big deal? It's one guy who doesn't like U2 - so what? He's entitled to his opinion.

I agree with xarir ...big deal! I like U2 but if this dude doesn't then whatever.
 
WhOiSyOdAdDy? said:
Are you not capable of writing your own reply?

What makes you think that the author of any reply would give you permisssion to copy their post to another board?


Right. Because copyright law now also precludes "derivative use" of copyright material, people cannot develop new material based on copyrighted work without permission, yada yada yada :rolleyes: This is an escort board, we better be careful to get permission on a more serious level especially if its about a rock and roll band! I was directing this towards U2 fans (obviously you aren't) not a question if I'm capable of of writing my own reply, again you missed the point.
 
I don't care enough about egotistical millionaire musicians. They're not the heros. The single mom living on welfare in the slums raising a child to be a doctor is hero. Bono's a bum. How's that for an ignorant statement?
 
I've never been into U2. As far as I'm concerned they are extremely popular AND extremely over-rated.
 
xarir said:
Not to be snide or anything, but what's the big deal? It's one guy who doesn't like U2 - so what? He's entitled to his opinion.


... I have to agree with our Master of Ass Slapping.
 
So far we agree with the poster in a landslide. Bono is nothing more than a singer in a band, he has no more credibility on humanitarian and peace-keeping issues that Ozzy or Ashlee Simpson. The fact that he is Irish is irrelevant, he is simply playing a new and creative angle to gain publicity for his band, which (oh by the way) makes good business sense and lines his pockets with umpteen millions of dollars of ticket and CD sales.

The real tragedy are the fans who buy into this hogwash and turn him into an icon with a cult-like following. The only thing separating him from Jim Jones is a vat of grape Kool-Aid and a slightly better singing voice. (and i'm just kidding.... J.J. actually had some pretty good pipes)

If you want to post an adoring response in support of your favorite band, do it yourself and make it meaningful. We need something new to tear apart next week. LOL
 
I agree Muffin. Just because Bono spends months of his own time every year working on humanitarian causes doesn't make him credible. Neither does the millions he has given, nor does the 6 months he spent working in Africa with his wife. It makes me sick to think that just because an intelligent guy dedicates a large portion of his life and money to something makes him think he knows something about it - truly sickening.
 
Reuben,

Don't waste your time on that poster from other music board. He's just an olde fart jealous of all the attention U2 is getting. For all we know, he could be a has-been musician.

Sold kazillion albums around the world, getting inducted into Rock & Roll Hall of Fame while still at the top of the game. Must be doing something right after 25 years! Each U2 band member on their own is not that talented (compared to other outstanding peers), but when they play together, that's when they are very strong.

Bono is Jesus! He preaches through U2's music and campaigns on other issues worldwide. They are a cult & have a strong following - that's why we all sing along at their concerts, even outside after the shows. I worship them.
 
Westerner said:
I agree Muffin.

I agree too. I like U2's music and all but wish Bono would shut up about his politics and how much he cares and etc.. He's a musician and I'd wish he'd stick to it. Because he's made it as a rock star doesn't mean he's earned the right to use his popularity for his political beliefs or personal causes.

Bill Gates' Foundation probably donates in a day what Bono probably has given in his whole life. Bill Gates' Foundations main goal is to provide necessary health care and educational tools in developing and 3rd world countries. He's actually donated more money than the next 20 richest men combined. It's a cause important to his foundation but he doesn't try and mug for the spotlight like Bono does. Gates realizes his place. He's a business man, not a politician. I wish Bono would get a clue. I like him as the frontman of a great band and nothing more.
 
I like U2 and like the fact the Edge will pop into the pub next to his place in Cork and pick up a round or two for everyone and anyone there. He also tends to know most of them by first name.
The only thing i don't appreciate is the dude from the Pogue's renting the upper level of Bono's place standing in the window naked. I think it is Shamus. They did not change the course of music history but at least Bono speaks his mind and gives his time to help out.
Al ot of people with money just give money none of their own time.
 
Westerner said:
I agree Muffin. Just because Bono spends months of his own time every year working on humanitarian causes doesn't make him credible. Neither does the millions he has given, nor does the 6 months he spent working in Africa with his wife. It makes me sick to think that just because an intelligent guy dedicates a large portion of his life and money to something makes him think he knows something about it - truly sickening.

Thankyou for a brilliant post.

Why is it that a lot of people hate it when someone is sucessful?

Bono could be like every other celeb and sit on his fat ass with legions of minions running around picking the red smarties out, but instead he TRULY tries to give something back to the people who need it the most. And he's been doing this for over 20 years now. So, this is not some flash in the pan gig for him. 99.9% of the celebs out there are the most self absorbed freakazoids on the planet (Michael Jackson and his entire entourage of "friends" comes to mind.)

Someone else mentioned Bill Gates giving cash, well, that's true and that's noble. But Bono isn't Bill Gates, and as rich as Bono is, he doesn't have anywhere near Bill Gate's money.

But Bono does give a lot ot time and effort (and cash I am sure too.) Bill does not give the time and effort that Bono gives, sorry. Bono has been trying to do some good for the world and I believe he really has made a difference. The world is a far better place with Bono in it (and Edge, Larry, and Adam.)

To those who say "he's a musician for christ's sake and should stick to being a musician" I say what do you care? If he wants to devote his time and energy to trying to help the less fortunate, and by all accounts is good at it and quite sincere - why do you care? Even John Snow the current US Secretary of Treasury stated last week that he has a lot of respect for Bono and said that Bono is very sincere about what he is doing to help out. And this from a guy who probably doesn't know "Pride" from "All Hail to the Chief"
 
james t kirk said:
Even John Snow the current US Secretary of Treasury stated last week that he has a lot of respect for Bono and said that Bono is very sincere about what he is doing to help out.
As an extension of that, the number of audiences he is granted with world leaders in general is an indication that he's taken seriously by people a lot more important than TERB critics.