U2 - Criticism or Stupidity?

It's amazing how stupid some terbites remarks are.

I mean, putting a guy down for trying to help the poor. That it's just an act to get publicity. Sure he makes tons of money but instead of doing nothing but what most of the rich rock stars do (doing drugs and doing as many groupies as they can), he's trying to make a difference to reduce the debt of third world nations which results in helping tens of thousands of people if not more. For all you critics, what the hell have you done to help the needy? I would think, probably zilch!
If you don't like their music, that's fine. I probably dislike the music you like.
 
Cun'g-linguist said:
I mean, putting a guy down for trying to help the poor. For all you critics, what the hell have you done to help the needy? I would think, probably zilch!
We're not putting him down for helping the poor, we're criticizing his motives for doing so. Furthermore, his personal charitable donations in proportion to his personal assets and annual income is probably LESS than the corresponding ratio for many TERBites.

I would appreciate his efforts more if he didnt make such a show of it, and that is the reason I suspect that it is just as much "business" as it is true "humanitarianism". If it were just about helping the needy, he wouldnt need a publicist, camera crew, tour bus and entourage to record the charade.
 
I think it's good he puts on a show of helping others, it's leading by example.
Third world debt, starvation, poverty, AIDS etc. are situations that need publicity to get action.
Their music is okay, I get a bit tired of that ringing guitar sound though.
 
I prefer early Zeppelin or late sixties Stones, two bands that treated their influences so differently.
Led Zeppelin's Jimmy Page stole so much and had to be forced to credit old blues artists while Jagger and Richards directed fans to their heroes and renewed their faltering careers.
 
If he didn't go public with eliminating the debt of poor nations...

MuffinMuncher said:
We're not putting him down for helping the poor, we're criticizing his motives for doing so. Furthermore, his personal charitable donations in proportion to his personal assets and annual income is probably LESS than the corresponding ratio for many TERBites.

I would appreciate his efforts more if he didnt make such a show of it, and that is the reason I suspect that it is just as much "business" as it is true "humanitarianism". If it were just about helping the needy, he wouldnt need a publicist, camera crew, tour bus and entourage to record the charade.

...politicians would not even give him the time of day. That is politics and he knows he has to do that to get anything done from politicians. Man, I hate it when people criticize people who make a difference thinking they are better than someone who could choose not to do anything or very little, like most of us.
 
Westerner said:
Ah, James, you did get that I was being sarcastic, correct?

yes.

I liked your post. After reading all the cynics, I thought yours was a great reply. I probably should have just done a separate reply to voice MHO after I quoted yours.
 
MuffinMuncher said:
We're not putting him down for helping the poor, we're criticizing his motives for doing so. Furthermore, his personal charitable donations in proportion to his personal assets and annual income is probably LESS than the corresponding ratio for many TERBites.

I would appreciate his efforts more if he didnt make such a show of it, and that is the reason I suspect that it is just as much "business" as it is true "humanitarianism". If it were just about helping the needy, he wouldnt need a publicist, camera crew, tour bus and entourage to record the charade.

What motives would that be?

If he did what he did, say once, and then returned to having servants clean his feet with their tongues, I might agree with you.

But because Bono has been helping the poorest people on the planet since the Joshua Tree (1987), I think you don't know what you are talking about.

You state talk about his personal charitable contributions in relation to his income; well, how do you know what this is? This is purely cynical speculation on your part. For all you know, Bono gives 50% of every dime he makes. You don't know, so you are not in a position to speculate. What Bono can do with his celebrity far out weighs him merely signing a cheque for a couple of million. He's out there lobbying George Bush (to little avail), Tony Blair, Paul Martin, and the rest of the politicos who really can make a difference.

What we do know is that Bono gives his time and effort. Lots of time and effort to helping the poor. I see this as a noble sentiment. Bono needs a camera crew, publicist, etc. to get the word out there to the public. If people don't know what's going on, nothing will happen to fix it.

To say that his actions are about "business" to me is insulting. I don't see where you get off saying something like that.
 
By the way, U2 tickets go on sale at ticketmaster this Saturday for 2 shows at the ACC in September.

I bet they sell out in about 4 minutes.
 
I'd also expect it would be difficult for a celebrity to do ANYTHIGN without a camera crew being interested in it. Britney Spears walking out of a gas station bathroom is newsworthy. Bono could hardly do anything in secret, without everyone in the world being interested in it.
 
james t kirk said:
By the way, U2 tickets go on sale at ticketmaster this Saturday for 2 shows at the ACC in September.

I bet they sell out in about 4 minutes.

I bet Toby Keith sells out when he tours in the southern US. Ashlee Simpson has a multi-platnum debut. Britney Spears has record sales of over 55 million and she feels we should support our president while chewing bubble gum.
 
Don said:
I bet Toby Keith sells out when he tours in the southern US. Ashlee Simpson has a multi-platnum debut. Britney Spears has record sales of over 55 million and she feels we should support our president while chewing bubble gum.

That's not Toronto.

Boondockville as far as I am concerned.

When your favourite groups get inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, we will talk. Till then, well, pick up that banjo

http://entertainment1.sympatico.msn...=0&showbyline=False&subtitle=&detect=&abc=abc
 
Wow, we got a 4 page thread on whether or not U2's humanitarian efforts are legitimate, a comment from what's probably the only person alive that will admit in public that they like Tommy Hunter, and the original poster still doesn't have enough to string to together collectively to form a reply about their music.

Message boards......*sigh*





Will fuck for U2 tickets. ;)
 
james t kirk said:
That's not Toronto.

Boondockville as far as I am concerned.

When your favourite groups get inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, we will talk. Till then, well, pick up that banjo

http://entertainment1.sympatico.msn...=0&showbyline=False&subtitle=&detect=&abc=abc

Ever try to get Britney tickets in Toronto? I tried a few years back as a gift for my niece and it sold out as fast.... as a U2 concert..

Anyway my favorite band has been in there for 12 years

http://www.rockhall.com/hof/inductee.asp?id=84

So lets talk.

While speaking of brilliant trios, of my next two favs, one is already in:
http://www.rockhall.com/hof/inductee.asp?id=2025

but the other is not and may never get in (RUSH). :confused:
 
Heather said:
Wow, we got a 4 page thread on whether or not U2's humanitarian efforts are legitimate, a comment from what's probably the only person alive that will admit in public that they like Tommy Hunter, and the original poster still doesn't have enough to string to together collectively to form a reply about their music.

Message boards......*sigh*





Will fuck for U2 tickets. ;)

U2 is a great band. Unfortunately some people get so defensive about U2 like they get upset at anyone not recognizing their greatness. It's like because of their humanitarian causes you are not allowed to criticize them. Anyway they have a tight rhythm section, Edge is very underrated (among the most underrated along w/Andy Summers and Tom Morello IMHO) and does a great job as a single guitarist without overplaying (brilliant use of effects) and Bono has a distinct voice. Great songwriting and they stood the test of time.
 
If the Hollies aren't good enough for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame then there's something wrong.
 
james t kirk said:
By the way, U2 tickets go on sale at ticketmaster this Saturday for 2 shows at the ACC in September. I bet they sell out in about 4 minutes.
And his being in the public eye non-stop for the past few years has alot to do with this, hence my "business" comment. He's a smart guy, all publicity is good publicity, and it helps sell out his concerts. I never said it was his only motive just that it was part of the equation.
 
MuffinMuncher said:
And his being in the public eye non-stop for the past few years has alot to do with this, hence my "business" comment. He's a smart guy, all publicity is good publicity, and it helps sell out his concerts. I never said it was his only motive just that it was part of the equation.

I saw my first U2 concert in 1983. It sold out in minutes.

I saw them again at Maple Leaf Gardens in 85- sold out in minutes.

Again in 87 at CNE, sold out.

92 at Maple Leaf Gardens - sold out in seconds, couldn't get tickets, bought scalper tickets - $150 at the time I remember.

92 twice at CNE - both shows sold out

96 or 97 ? - Skydome - sold out

2001 ACC sold out, I couldn't get tickets, friend ended up having extras

2001 Copps Coliseum - sold out, couldn't get tickets, another friend ended up with tickets.

2005, I'll be on the net first thing saturday morning at 10:00 am.

I really don't think that U2 need help selling out their concerts do you?

You can go on ticket master, everyone of their concerts in their first leg is sold out.
 
I finally get it.... advocating international debt reform to ensure a string of sold out concerts -- genius.

I really don't understand how Bono's position and the advocacy work he is doing makes people so angry. Do you get pissed on when sports and entertainment personalites speak out for charitable organizations?