Trans Canada Highway Closed Indefinitely

Trailer is sealed and doors have electronic locks that can only be unlocked by dispatch upon delivery via satellite.

I am sure the brilliant minds of terb can figure out a workaround

Let's get this one trending folks!!!
#piggysterbBBQbash
 
The bridge was designed by MMM Consulting Engineers. MMM was originally called Marshall Macklin Monahan (or however you spell it) and were / are based in Thornhill.

MMM had bought McCormick Rankin maybe 7 or 8 years ago. McCormick Rankin was probably THEE bridge design firm in Ontario and they are in Mississauga.

MMM was recently acquired by WSP (formerly Genivar) a Quebec based consulting engineering firm.

I would hazard a guess that MMM through McCormick Rankin did the design of the bridge. Maybe Ferrovial was involved, maybe not. Ferrovial is a company that owns toll roads all over the world, like the 407 as previously stated above. Typically, they would subcontract out the engineering work.

Hatch Mott did the Construction Administration work for MTO. Which means they oversaw the construction process on behalf of MTO.

BOT was the General Contractor. Whether BOT is tied up with Ferrovial or not I don't know.
 

So from that photo (and the previous photo showing the deck of the bridge 2 feet higher than the approach), anyone can tell that the cables are pulling up on the end of the bridge. The cold has caused the cables to contract and up went the deck. Now they are loading up the cables to pull the deck down.

It's an interesting design, but I question the logic of building a cable stayed bridge in such an environment.

They should have just stuck with something more traditional. Box beams, a truss, whatever. They got all fancy and it bit them in the ass.
 
So from that photo (and the previous photo showing the deck of the bridge 2 feet higher than the approach), anyone can tell that the cables are pulling up on the end of the bridge. The cold has caused the cables to contract and up went the deck. Now they are loading up the cables to pull the deck down.

It's an interesting design, but I question the logic of building a cable stayed bridge in such an environment.

They should have just stuck with something more traditional. Box beams, a truss, whatever. They got all fancy and it bit them in the ass.

http://www.cbc.ca/beta/news/canada/thunder-bay/nipigon-river-bridge-bolts-1.3399777

Looks like testing on the bolts and investigations into design are underway.

Maybe this pushes them to have a back up route to make sure this never happens again.

Hopefully this never happens again.
 
It's an interesting design, but I question the logic of building a cable stayed bridge in such an environment.

They should have just stuck with something more traditional. Box beams, a truss, whatever.

They got all fancy and it bit them in the ass.

Yes, it would be good to know why they selected this type at this location.

http://trid.trb.org/view.aspx?id=1125211
 
Yes, it would be good to know why they selected this type at this location.
But as Mark Green professor of structural engineering at Queen's University in Kingston is quoted in the first article you linked to: http://www.cbc.ca/beta/news/canada/thunder-bay/nipigon-river-bridge-bolts-1.3399777

"We always do have to bear in mind — whenever constructing in such regions — to really make certain that we think doubly about what the effects of the cold climate are, and not to underestimate it."

Sometimes, at low temperature, bolts and steel can become more brittle. It's also possible for cables to shorten in colder temperatures.

That doesn't mean cable-stay bridges aren't suitable for the North, he said, adding the reason we don't have more cable-stay bridges in Ontario is because they are ideal for longer crossings, and the province doesn't have many of those longer crossings.

While one does have to be mindful of thermal effects on cable bridges, with proper design there should be no problem
, Green noted. He said he was confident the problem would be fixed and the overall structure of the bridge would be fine.

Nevertheless, news of the bridge's failure was shocking, he said.

"It's a really unusual situation … I've never heard of this type of situation."
 
http://www.cbc.ca/beta/news/canada/thunder-bay/nipigon-river-bridge-bolts-1.3399777

Looks like testing on the bolts and investigations into design are underway.

Maybe this pushes them to have a back up route to make sure this never happens again.

Hopefully this never happens again.

Testing the failed bolts is the obvious first move

Bolt failure is probably the best case scenario as the correction is to change the bolts rather than the cables

Worse job in the world right now is

the crew that has to sit under the bridge and watch the remaining bolts for movement

job is esp bad if you are on the night shift

I mean fuck, sitting in the snow at -40c under a bridge at night watching bolts freeze while drinking your Tim Hortons in the middle of no where

I would dig a hole in the ice and stick a pole in
 
It amazes me that this bridge wasn't sourced strictly to Canadian companies for the design. This is government money going into this. On top of that, the steel coming from China and no doubt the structural bolts used came from offshore as well as the rebar used. Our short sighted federal and provincial governments throwing money away and not pumping it back into the Canadian economy.
We have steel plants working at less than 50% capacity while while projects like the 407 bring in rebar from Turkey. Structural steel has been coming in from China at great rates. Both the rebar and structural steel are inferior, failing test done by Canadian steel manufacturers, with approx a 25% failure rate. And still our governments allow buying of inferior products. As was told to me, by time our steel manufacturers prove this, those countries shift production to another type of steel that isn't on the list of products that cannot be sold here.
 
But as Mark Green professor of structural engineering at Queen's University in Kingston is quoted in the first article you linked to: http://www.cbc.ca/beta/news/canada/thunder-bay/nipigon-river-bridge-bolts-1.3399777

"We always do have to bear in mind — whenever constructing in such regions — to really make certain that we think doubly about what the effects of the cold climate are, and not to underestimate it."

Sometimes, at low temperature, bolts and steel can become more brittle. It's also possible for cables to shorten in colder temperatures.

That doesn't mean cable-stay bridges aren't suitable for the North, he said, adding the reason we don't have more cable-stay bridges in Ontario is because they are ideal for longer crossings, and the province doesn't have many of those longer crossings.

While one does have to be mindful of thermal effects on cable bridges, with proper design there should be no problem
, Green noted. He said he was confident the problem would be fixed and the overall structure of the bridge would be fine.

Nevertheless, news of the bridge's failure was shocking, he said.

"It's a really unusual situation … I've never heard of this type of situation."

Thanks for the requote of the article and your opinion of it. Although, I did not say it was not appropriate, I mentioned it would be good to know why they selected this one over the others considered. What were the benefits that caused them to select this type at this location. The 2nd link I posted talks about some benefits, still it would be good to know for this specific location. http://trid.trb.org/view.aspx?id=1125211
 
In the photos on line in google, you can see an existing CPR railway bridge right beside the new fancy dancy cable stayed bridge. Just a nice simple steel bridge. Probably been there for 100 years with no major problems.

Trains weigh 400 percent more than the heaviest highway truck. (A locomotive clocks in at about 450,000 pounds.)

Keep it simple stupid.
 
In the photos on line in google, you can see an existing CPR railway bridge right beside the new fancy dancy cable stayed bridge. Just a nice simple steel bridge. Probably been there for 100 years with no major problems.

Trains weigh 400 percent more than the heaviest highway truck. (A locomotive clocks in at about 450,000 pounds.)

Keep it simple stupid.

bottom line

cable stay is prettier

elegance does count when you are going to be looking at it for 200 years
 
According to the Wikipedia article on the Nipigon River Bridge, it is the first and only cable stayed highway bridge ever constructed in Ontario.

The problems with this bridge design may be case studied in engineering schools for decades to come like the Tacoma Narrows bridge was.
A lot of weird physics involved with cable stayed bridges which makes them higher risk I guess.

As noted by someone above cable stayed bridges are more beautiful and iconic compared to traditional concrete/steel composite bridges that are all over the place and I guess that's why the designers and MTO went ahead with this design.
Simple steel truss structure over concrete deck was just too easy and boring for them.

Maybe the Nipigon area is so beautiful and scenic in the summer, that they just wanted to sex the bridge up a bit and they got bit in the ass with the riskier design.


e7e233ff089a7c18c4a4199016467aa0.jpg
 
Millau bridge

worlds greatest cable stay




ca731__Millau-Viaduct-Bridge-France-1.jpg
 
should have built a Henderson wave bridge


henderson-waves-bridge-singapure.jpg
 
not according to the mayor of Nipigon

I stand corrected. There is a bridge at Cameron Falls and yes, timber road would be an accurate description. At this time of year it would be an Ice Road Trucker type of road but yes, it is a road.
 

Wait just a minute. This picture really scares me. What I see is a choke point on the only east/west highway connection in Canada. It is in the middle of nowhere , and there is easy access to the bridge's pylons. Hell, they even built a road right up to them!

If I were an evil genius, I would park a couple of U-hauls full of fertilizer and diesel fuel right by those pylons and make 'em go "boom" real good. If I were particularly evil and especially well-financed, I would do the same thing to the railway bridge that somebody mentioned is to the north of the highway bridge but does not appear in this picture.

Since I'm neither evil nor a genius, and since The Man and The System have been really good to me I have no intention of doing anything like this (stand down, CSIS, stand down...Actually, since I've attracted your attention, could you please look into securing that bridge's access points? Kthxbye).

But you gotta presume that there's some disgruntled engineering grad student here in Canada on a student visa who has discovered Religion as a way of coping with the dissonance he feels when trying to reconcile his traditional upbringing with the realities of the modern Canadian society in which he is living. And he is looking at that picture and thinking the same thing I am...
 
I stand corrected. There is a bridge at Cameron Falls and yes, timber road would be an accurate description. At this time of year it would be an Ice Road Trucker type of road but yes, it is a road.

correct

and the mayor was emphatic in stating to stay off it

there are contingency plans to use the road but it must be upgraded
 
Wait just a minute. This picture really scares me. What I see is a choke point on the only east/west highway connection in Canada. It is in the middle of nowhere , and there is easy access to the bridge's pylons. Hell, they even built a road right up to them!

If I were an evil genius, I would park a couple of U-hauls full of fertilizer and diesel fuel right by those pylons and make 'em go "boom" real good. If I were particularly evil and especially well-financed, I would do the same thing to the railway bridge that somebody mentioned is to the north of the highway bridge but does not appear in this picture.

Since I'm neither evil nor a genius, and since The Man and The System have been really good to me I have no intention of doing anything like this (stand down, CSIS, stand down...Actually, since I've attracted your attention, could you please look into securing that bridge's access points? Kthxbye).

But you gotta presume that there's some disgruntled engineering grad student here in Canada on a student visa who has discovered Religion as a way of coping with the dissonance he feels when trying to reconcile his traditional upbringing with the realities of the modern Canadian society in which he is living. And he is looking at that picture and thinking the same thing I am...

now consider the st catherines bridge

close that and all usa bound trucks and back through buffalo and Niagara are fucked

also

all bridges to the usa and back to Canada check trucks after they cross

WTF! the bridge is a terrorist target