Trans Canada Highway Closed Indefinitely

Engineers were from Spain.

Somebody please tell me why we have to hire Spanish engineers, are there no Canadians who can do the job??! :confused:

I have no idea where SUN gets their info from but it seems like a fluff piece designed to push a xenophobic agenda

The bridge in question (which is the first of its kind in Canada) was done by Bot who's head office is in Oakville

They have been bragging about it for a few years

http://www.botconstruction.ca/pdf_projects/BPP_2013-6000-Nipigon.pdf
 
No you do not
It is recommended but you can cross into US with a Canadian drivers license
Passport is only required for air travel
They changed the law again in 2009, you need an enhanced drivers license now. Regular DL wont do
 
They changed the law again in 2009, you need an enhanced drivers license now. Regular DL wont do

when I drove truck I had a FAST card but it was not mandatory
 
It is not as though there are no cable stay bridges in places in the northern U.S. where it can get as cold as (if not for quite so long) as Nipigon, Ontario.
 
It is not as though there are no cable stay bridges in places in the northern U.S. where it can get as cold as (if not for quite so long) as Nipigon, Ontario.

where are they

four types of cable stay

cablestays.gif


the Nipigon bridge looks like a fan

th


remember it is the rate that temperature changes that is the bigger factor and Nipigon temp can fall quickly


they also have timber roads in Nipigon that can be used but they need to be upgraded

they made a blunder in pulling down the old bridge

WTF where they thinking


nipigon is not canadas first cable stay



The Alex Fraser Bridge is a cable-stayed bridge Vancouver, British Columbia


th
 
I have no idea where SUN gets their info from but it seems like a fluff piece designed to push a xenophobic agenda

The bridge in question (which is the first of its kind in Canada) was done by Bot who's head office is in Oakville

They have been bragging about it for a few years

http://www.botconstruction.ca/pdf_projects/BPP_2013-6000-Nipigon.pdf
Maybe it was a joint operation??

To be fair to the Sun they are only reporting what Andro Perruzza, CEO of the Ontario Society of Professional Engineers (OSPE) told them over the phone
 
they made a blunder in pulling down the old bridge

WTF where they thinking

They weren't,... they're Fiberals.

Just add this to the list.

FAST
 
I crossed the bridge tonight and they had concrete barriers stacked on the west end to make it level. Word is they did not allow for the cables to contract in severe cold which caused the bridge to lift at the end and snapped the bolts right off

If that's true, then there's no excuse. This is why you contract people who've got experience designing and installing bridges in cold climates. What a clusterfuck!

nipigon is not canadas first cable stay

The Alex Fraser Bridge is a cable-stayed bridge Vancouver, British Columbia

th

Where it rarely dips below 0 C.
 
it occurred to me the other side might snap as well

I wonder if they are laying down weights on the other side as a preventative then fix the bridge in the summer

might as well as one lane is closed anyways

a lot of stress on the engineers and crew to do this right when it is -30

my hat is off to them

amazing job

tons of overtime well deserved

poor truckers sit in their fucking trucks for free and now they are supposed to hurry up

that is why I left the fucking business

if a long distance trucker got what he deserved he would get a 100 grand a year

the get no respect and work damn hard driving all night



they do have logger roads but best used in winter when they are frozen I would think but they would have to be upgraded before use

the stresses of a cable stay are tremendous esp in a harsh winter and if that bridge snaps again with heavy truck traffic on it ....

this is an interesting situation to say the least

where is tim hortons giving out their free coffee like they did in Afghanistan as this would be great for their advertising nonsense as the all Canadian coffee
 
Last edited:
If that's true, then there's no excuse. This is why you contract people who've got experience designing and installing bridges in cold climates. What a clusterfuck!

oh come on

do you seriously think they never calculated for the cold and the rate of change of the cold and the wind and the ice etc

this is a learning situation and a fortunate one as it is a small bridge with non catastrophic collapse nor any injury although I think a pick up truck was damaged then a citizen stood out in the cold and stopped traffic for a half hour before the OPP arrived

citizen deserves an award

they learned from the Tacoma bridge and they will learn from this

the whole engineering world is watching


 
oh come on

do you seriously think they never calculated for the cold and the rate of change of the cold and the wind and the ice etc

Maybe their calculations were wrong. Obviously someone screwed up big time. It was either an engineering or manufacturing error. There's no way a new bridge should collapse like that.
 
The engineers were from Canada, not that it makes any difference as any engineer would have to consult with many tables to determine the linear coefficients of thermal expansion of the various materials, specifically the cables. This is Engineering 101.

However there is also another factor in engineering that is less cut and dried and that is "tolerance stacking"

This means that a whole bunch of little things that are within tolerances can add up to create a situation that is out of tolerance.

In this situation, from what the eyewitness said, there was huge gust of wind that she saw lifted the bridge deck.

Wind is very powerful and its effects are very hard to model. Especially so in valleys and other places subject to terrain based turbulence. A few degrees difference in wind direction and difference in wind speed at difference altitudes can create chaotic winds. And the speed of the wind increases its power exponentially, not linearly.


Cold temperatures that would have already shortened the cable stays, thereby putting uplift forces on the longest stays near the ends. This could have been within the design limits given the design assumptions they were working with. You cannot design for everything. Plus, the cables would have had to be designed and tensioned according to the weight of heavy trucks moving fast etc.

Plus high grade steel bolts tend to be more hard and brittle than low grade bolts which are more ductile. The brittleness of steel increases quite dramatically with lower temperatures. Even just 10 deg Celcius makes a huge difference in shipbuilding. A ship with a thick steel hull designed for having excellent impact resistance in normal sea temperatures can become dangerously brittle in sea temperatures of -3 C.

So, combine cold-shortened cables putting high tension on the bridge ends, cold-embrittle steel bolts, and a freak gust of wind and the bridge can simply pop up as it did.

These lessons in engineering are fortunately few and far between but serve to advance engineering. Engineers wear an Iron Ring to remind them of the obligations and responsibility they have for the safety of society.

rings.jpg
 
Maybe their calculations were wrong. Obviously someone screwed up big time. It was either an engineering or manufacturing error. There's no way a new bridge should collapse like that.

then I would suspect a flaw in the algorithms, software etc that is used industry wide

new bridges do collapse because we will never know everything


but I am curious if it is common to build a cable stay in such harsh conditions

those cables pull up causing a horizontal stress on the roadbed and we see the result

parts that failed were built in china but it could be the cables that failed and they were built in Spain or something

interesting
 
There are cable stayed bridges in Maine, Massachusetts, Ohio, and Iowa, all places where it can get down to very low temperatures if not quite to -30 celsius /-22.00 fahrenheit

http://www.johnweeks.com/cablestay/

Schlong puts this much better in his post, three above this.

the quickness in temp change is just as important as how cold it gets

yes, Schlong did well as per norm for him. He seems bright to me. But I think he may be wong with his steel comment. The titantic sunk because the waters were so cold it caused the hull to become brittle but we are well past the Titanic era when it comes to steel manufacturing.

My humble and pedestrian opinion it is the cables that put extra stress on the bolts because they shrunk

that could mean the way they were twisted together which is quite a engineering challenge in itself

quality control must be a huge challenge when building such a bridge

there should be lots of redundancy built into tolerance stacking or do not build the bridge

if the problem is the cables then they might have to change them and the design of the sister bridge to be opened this year

if so they may open logging roads to traffic and send the trucks through the USA which was quite common until 9 11 rules made it too slow and expensive with all the red tape

somebody must be having kittens wondering if it is their fault

I find myself wondering why a cable stay is needed for such a small bridge instead of a cantilever design
 
Last edited:
yoga... it is not about the quality of the steel, it about the alloy used.

Material science is subject that fascinates me.

Tool steel is very hard. However it is also relatively brittle. Other steel alloys are designed to be flexible without breaking, or to be corrosion resistant, or to have high yield strengths in tension or in shear. It is always a been a balancing act as the material cannot be all things.

Except in the case of the material Unobtainium.
 
yoga... it is not about the quality of the steel, it about the alloy used.

Material science is subject that fascinates me.

Tool steel is very hard. However it is also relatively brittle. Other steel alloys are designed to be flexible without breaking, or to be corrosion resistant, or to have high yield strengths in tension or in shear. It is always a been a balancing act as the material cannot be all things.

if I could make a wish and graduate from MIT with a PHD it would be in material science - because of its practicality it seems more interesting than physics

the whole steel thing changed mankind as we went from iron to the steel age although I do not believe they call it an official steel age , they should

changed farming, tool making and war

just pounding on iron as you temper it makes steel

crazy

not to change the topic but

the craziest new material is graphene or a one-atom-thick form of carbon

we are moving into the nano tech age and it is going to be the next great leap for mankind





 
Last edited:
if I could make a wish and be an engineer material science would be it


Me too!

Graphene is an incredible material and will change the world. And the cost of it is plummeting. Just need to find out more ways to use it.

After all is said and done I would not be surprised if hydrogen embrittlement had a role in the galvanized bolts failure.

Here is a similar situation in a brand new bridge in California whose bolts failed in warm weather and before the bridge even was opened!

http://www.mercurynews.com/ci_23629435/cascade-poor-decisions-led-broken-bay-bridge-bolts
 
Cool you guys, I learned a lot about metals and bridge structures ITT