Trans Canada Highway Closed Indefinitely

I dont think you need a passport anymore if you're crossing into US by car, only by air.

Not 100% sure though. Somebody correct me if I'm wrong

You must have proof of citizenship when entering the US by car.
 
Seems they put a stack of concrete guard rails, the kind they use on construction sites, on one end of the bridge to lower it back into position.
 
It would appear someone fucked up designing that bridge. Luckily nobody was hurt.

The "fuck-up" could be anywhere.

Could be the cables not behaving as they were supposed to.

Cables could have been incorrectly tensioned.

Could have been a mistake in the calculations.

Who knows. It's not a simple thing to design a bridge I would think. Certainly not one like that.
 
The "fuck-up" could be anywhere.

Could be the cables not behaving as they were supposed to.

Cables could have been incorrectly tensioned.

Could have been a mistake in the calculations.

Who knows. It's not a simple thing to design a bridge I would think. Certainly not one like that.

Probably built by the same crew who built Toronto condos. Shoddy workmanship.

They built the Brooklyn Bridge with underwater caissons 130 years ago and it is still standing
 
I wonder how long it will take to fix. This week I'm going to ask logistics how it affects them.

I guess they have to get the carriers to take the US route.
 
cable stay bridge (this is the first one in Ontario) puts on lot of tension on the road as the cables pull up but the positive is the bridges are very flexible so the situation is not catastrophic

“It’s the rate of how quickly it gets cold, and can the material expand and contract quickly?”


Sources say municipal politicians in northern Ontario have long been concerned about the material used for the bridge. the pre-cast deck, towers and structural steel were all sourced in Canada, the cables came from Spain and the expansion joints were manufactured in China.



it will be an excellent learning situation to make these bridges even stronger

probably a combination of cold and wind and ice

the bolts holding the roadway down probably snapped causing a sudden uplift

they have put weights on the roadway to hold the road down

amazing 20 hour job out in the middle of no where to get the bridge running

hats off to the work crew and the engineers in -30 c

sounds like they may need new cables and this will also slow down the twin bridge

clearly the bridge will be shut down for repairs then WTF will the trucks do

everyone goes through the usa

this will destroy some trucking companies but others will profit
 
Last edited:
Engineers were from Spain.

Somebody please tell me why we have to hire Spanish engineers, are there no Canadians who can do the job??! :confused:

http://www.torontosun.com/2016/01/11/nipigon-bridge-engineers-based-in-spain

Nipigon bridge engineers based in Spain

Question of the day:

How the hell can you build a bridge in northern Ontario that buckles when it gets cold?

A new bridge, which opened in November in Nipigon, buckled in the cold over the weekend, severing the Trans-Canada Highway, essentially splitting the country in two.

What went wrong? Well, perhaps the province should have handed the engineering to a Canadian company familiar with the temperatures in the North.

While Sandro Perruzza, CEO of the Ontario Society of Professional Engineers (OSPE), cautions it’s early in the investigation, he noted the engineers for the project are based in Spain.

“It’s all speculation at this point,” he said.

“The engineering company that was hired to do this is based out of Spain, so do they have the experience and knowledge to design a bridge in the cold weather we have in Canada that they don’t have in southern Europe?” he said in a phone interview Monday.

Engineering giant Ferrovial, based in Madrid and part of the same company that owns Hwy. 407, was responsible for the engineering. The $106-million project is the first cable-stayed bridge in Canada.

“When it was designed, were the design specifications put forward that would meet the requirements of the weather?” Perruzza asked.

He said the issue is not so much how cold it is, but how quickly it can get cold in northern Ontario, where temperatures can fluctuate by 10C or 15C from one day to the next.

“It’s the rate of how quickly it gets cold, and can the material expand and contract quickly?” he says.

“If a Canadian engineering company is doing the work, they would take those things into consideration and the design would account for that.”

Sources say municipal politicians in northern Ontario have long been concerned about the material used for the bridge. According to a PowerPoint presentation on the Ontario Good Roads Association website, while the pre-cast deck, towers and structural steel were all sourced in Canada, the cables came from Spain and the expansion joints were manufactured in China.

That raises questions about whether those materials were made to standards that would withstand the Canadian winter.

Perruzza says the OSPE advocates for a qualification-based selection process so that when contracts such as this are awarded, in addition to awarding it to the lowest bidder, the government also looks at how qualified all the people in that bid are in doing these type of projects.

“Canadian suppliers would have all have experience in supplying this kind of equipment and these types of materials that are tested in these types of environments,” he says.

A spokesman for the Ministry of Transportation says broken bolts were at fault.

“Uplift occurred at the northwest corner of the structure due to broken bolts at a bearing connection. Our engineers are on site and continue to investigate. At this point, it’s too soon to say if cold weather was a factor,” adds Annemarie Piscopo.

Whatever happened, this is deeply troubling. This is the government that’s selling Hydro One to pay for infrastructure. Are we really getting value for money? When you put money into the Ontario Retirement Pension Plan, the government has vowed to spend it on infrastructure.

Is that how you want your pension invested — in bridges where vital parts are imported from China? Why not just cut to the chase and pick them up at the Dollar Store? What could possibly go wrong?

Look, we don’t yet know what went wrong. But, we really shouldn’t be looking to Madrid or China to find out what happened in Nipigon.

NIPIGON RIVER BRIDGE

The same company that owns Hwy. 407 built the Nipigon River Bridge. Ferrovial International Inc. is owned by Cintra Infraestructuras Internacional S.L. — a wholly owned subsidiary of Ferrovial S.A., which owns 43% of Hwy. 407. Cintra Infraestructuras is the largest shareholder of 407 International Inc., which operates Hwy. 407 under a 99-year lease from the Ontario government.
This is not the first Ontario highway disruption that involves engineers and architects from Spain. Girders on Herb Gray Parkway, near Windsor, did not meet the standards of the Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code. That project was built by a Spanish-led consortium, the Windsor Essex Mobility Group.
WHAT THE POLITICIANS SAY

Premier Kathleen Wynne:

“It is the lifeline in terms of product and transportation in northwestern Ontario and as people have said, it connects east to the west.

“It’s very concerning to me and we’ll get to the bottom of it and make sure it doesn’t happen again.”

Michael Mantha, NDP MPP for Algoma Manitoulin:

“Right now, the Liberal government’s infrastructure plan for northern Ontario seems to be: ‘Drive through the United States.’”

Nipigon Mayor Richard Harvey:

“We opened the community centre. People opened their homes to anyone who needed a place to stay and said, ‘bring your kids over.’ Churches put on breakfasts. People brought food for anyone who needed it. Everyone takes it in stride.”
 
Engineers were from Spain.
No winters in Spain so no need to build bridges that can withstand a Northern Ontario Winter.

P.S. Not sure if there is a connection but the major owner of Highway 407 is a Spanish company.

Reminds me of Quebec Hydro when they hired engineers or whatever they're called from the south of France to build the hydro lines from James Bay to Montreal (and they wonder why they have broken transmission lines in Winter).
 
No winters in Spain so no need to build bridges that can withstand a Northern Ontario Winter.

P.S. Not sure if there is a connection but the major owner of Highway 407 is a Spanish company
Uhm yeah, pretty sure there's a connection cause it says so right in my post
 
I'm shocked to learn that we only have one landlink between Eastern and Western Canada.

If you look at the map there is another bridge further north near Cameron Falls but it only leads to what looks like a small road that heads south and dead ends. If that road went east around the North end of Polly Lake it would join up with highway 11, providing a back up route. However, that gap of a couple of miles has never been connected.

It is amazing that nobody has ever joined that up.
 
I crossed the bridge tonight and they had concrete barriers stacked on the west end to make it level. Word is they did not allow for the cables to contract in severe cold which caused the bridge to lift at the end and snapped the bolts right off
 
Wonder if you are hauling my stuff? Lumber on that truck? I see now they have one lane open alternating each direction with a safety/lead truck in use.

I bet it takes a day or two to clear based on the backlog.

You are right someone needs to be fired and the contractor needs to fix it for free for this kind of problem

No lumber, just 53,000 lbs of Alberta beef.
 
I'm shocked to learn that we only have one landlink between Eastern and Western Canada.

Don't be shocked it's been like this for as long as I've been driving up that way. Ontario is way behind on the Trans Canada Highway being a 4 lane highway. There is about 20 km of 2 lane once you cross into Manitoba then it's 4 lane right through to the BC border.
 
I crossed the bridge tonight and they had concrete barriers stacked on the west end to make it level. Word is they did not allow for the cables to contract in severe cold which caused the bridge to lift at the end and snapped the bolts right off

So the bridge is now re-opened, with stuff placed there to level it out?

That's a disaster waiting to happen.
 
Don't be shocked it's been like this for as long as I've been driving up that way. Ontario is way behind on the Trans Canada Highway being a 4 lane highway. There is about 20 km of 2 lane once you cross into Manitoba then it's 4 lane right through to the BC border.

Although that part of country is sparse, it still is the only link (transport). So is this part of the Trans still busy with traffic?

I say that because if it's down to 2 lane and weather conditions up there can get nasty, is slow ass traffic/weather a major factor there?..... as people don't want to go around other vehicles?
 
Don't be shocked it's been like this for as long as I've been driving up that way. Ontario is way behind on the Trans Canada Highway being a 4 lane highway. There is about 20 km of 2 lane once you cross into Manitoba then it's 4 lane right through to the BC border.

Is there a need for 4 lanes? I drove a few times between Dryden and Soo(5 years ago last time) and the highway was always pretty empty. The biggest problem being sleep and the damned moose.
 
Is there a need for 4 lanes? I drove a few times between Dryden and Soo(5 years ago last time) and the highway was always pretty empty. The biggest problem being sleep and the damned moose.

There is no need for four lanes until you are stuck behind a slow car. Actually, three lanes is enough to solve that. Where every 5 or 10 km or so the extra lane switches direction (after merging back to two lanes obviously). This allows traffic to pass the slow car safely.