There are a few reasons why fighting is in the game, one of which I believe is the players want it. Many consider it a code of honour, rightly or wrongly depending on your perspective.
The players always react to the impact of the hit. If it's against one of their better players while they're on the ice, they don't have that instant ability to analyze if it is a clean or dirty hit but if they don't respond right away, they risk being labelled soft, weak or not coming to the aid of their teammates.
Similar situation when a player makes a bit clean hit, he's expected to accept the challenge to fight or risks being labelled a turtle.
Until the players change their mentality, fighting will always remain in the game...........