Toronto Maple Leafs 2011/12

Give us the best goalie in the league and it will make the coach and GM look like genius's in no matter what they do . The Coyotes are off to the playoffs and they won last night but gave up 50 plus shots against the worse team in the league .

Ok let me clarify. I don't mean having a better goalie would not make the leafs better. It's not going to make a difference if we keep the core players we have supporting our goalie.
Phoenix does allow alot of shots, but what kinda shots are they allowing? The leafs too put alot of shots on opponents. Alot of the time Phil Kessel just shoots its on goal from far distance, its not because he has a clear path to the net. But obviously the more you shoot, there's a higher probability some would go in. The shots we are allowing are very clear path.
 
Marc Crawford agrees with me that the Leaf's defense is not very "mobile". Luke Schenn is almost useless with the puck (sometimes without the puck as well). Jake Gardiner is a good skater and has offensive skills but still too early to say if he will be the best of a bad lot.
 
Marc Crawford agrees with me that the Leaf's defense is not very "mobile". Luke Schenn is almost useless with the puck (sometimes without the puck as well). Jake Gardiner is a good skater and has offensive skills but still too early to say if he will be the best of a bad lot.

Thanks Rockslinger for clarifying it. That's the point I been trying to make. Will having a new goalie really be better with the D that we support them?
 
I guess his coach is Ron Wilson. He didn't want to fire him. He had no choice. In fact, Wilson should be fired when Burke took over.

I actually blame the GM more than the coach. The GM hires the players. Give us the best coach and the best goalie in the nhl to the leafs, leafs will still not make the playoffs. Our players just don't mesh together on D. As good as Phil Kessel is on O, his D is atrocious. He doesn't lay the wood on anyone. 12 hits or so all year long. The better teams always have good defensive forwards, and more importantly better defensive defencemen. New Jersey not counting this and previous year has always known for their d. It's the reason why they have been so consistent year after year.

Watching last nights game already shows what kinda d this leafs team plays.


Ok let me clarify. I don't mean having a better goalie would not make the leafs better. It's not going to make a difference if we keep the core players we have supporting our goalie.
Phoenix does allow alot of shots, but what kinda shots are they allowing? The leafs too put alot of shots on opponents. Alot of the time Phil Kessel just shoots its on goal from far distance, its not because he has a clear path to the net. But obviously the more you shoot, there's a higher probability some would go in. The shots we are allowing are very clear path.

That is exactly what you said.

If the Leafs had a consistent top ten goalie, they would be ahead of Ottawa and Wilson would still be coach ... hell, it may have been the second year in a row for the Leafs in the playoffs.





News Flash !

Charles, Kessel was not brought in to vie for the Selke.
 
Tampa tonight, Montreal on Saturday.
The heartache/heartbreak is almost over.

heavy sigh
 
The on ice officials should be back to following all the rules of the NHL tonight.

NHL tonight;
Go Flyers !
Go Caps !





78.5 Disallowed Goals – Apparent goals shall be disallowed by the Referee and the appropriate announcement made by the Public Address Announcer for the following reasons:


(v) When an attacking player has interfered with a goalkeeper in his goal crease.


(ix) When a goalkeeper has been pushed into the net together with the puck after making a save.
 
That is exactly what you said.

If the Leafs had a consistent top ten goalie, they would be ahead of Ottawa and Wilson would still be coach ... hell, it may have been the second year in a row for the Leafs in the playoffs.





News Flash !

Charles, Kessel was not brought in to vie for the Selke.

The reason why I said its not going to make a difference is because of the core defencemen we have.

Phaneuf really sux on D. People may think he is tough grit and all that. How many times have he loss the puck on the defensive end and allow opposing forwards blow by him? Same goes for the other guys like Liles, Gunnarson, Franzen, and of course our overpaid Komisarek.

I want to say its the goalies fault, but if our core d isn't fix, whatever goalie you bring won't make that big of a difference.
Reimer and Gus aren't bad goalies, but the pressure our d gives them every night is too much for them to handle.

Not to mention, we lack a bunch of defensive forwards. Majority of our forwards are not reliable to get back on D. Steckel being the exception.

If it was me, I rather have 6 solid defencemen with a medicore goalie, then 6 crappy defencemen on d, and 1 superior goalie. That's the point I am trying to get.

I know this is old news, but you guyz remember Andrew Raycroft? Why was he so good in Boston and so crap here in Toronto?
It's obvious Boston provided him better protection at the net.

I wanna see how good halak and elliot is if we traded our defencemen for theirs.
 
Phaneuf really sux on D. People may think he is tough grit and all that. How many times have he loss the puck on the defensive end and allow opposing forwards blow by him? Same goes for the other guys like Liles, Gunnarson, Franzen, and of course our overpaid Komisarek.

.

Phaneuf 6th ? He maybe overpaid but 6th defenseman on worst defensive teams don't make allstar games . His salary doesn't reflect his pay
 
The reason why I said its not going to make a difference is because of the core defencemen we have.

Phaneuf really sux on D. People may think he is tough grit and all that. How many times have he loss the puck on the defensive end and allow opposing forwards blow by him? Same goes for the other guys like Liles, Gunnarson, Franzen, and of course our overpaid Komisarek.

I want to say its the goalies fault, but if our core d isn't fix, whatever goalie you bring won't make that big of a difference.
Reimer and Gus aren't bad goalies, but the pressure our d gives them every night is too much for them to handle.

Not to mention, we lack a bunch of defensive forwards. Majority of our forwards are not reliable to get back on D. Steckel being the exception.

If it was me, I rather have 6 solid defencemen with a medicore goalie, then 6 crappy defencemen on d, and 1 superior goalie. That's the point I am trying to get.

I know this is old news, but you guyz remember Andrew Raycroft? Why was he so good in Boston and so crap here in Toronto?
It's obvious Boston provided him better protection at the net.

I wanna see how good halak and elliot is if we traded our defencemen for theirs.

So everybody sucks on the Leafs with few(if any) exceptions ... is that it ?

Somehow the Leafs, who were in a playoff spot until mid February, would not have benefited from a top ten goalie during the Feb-Mar swoon ? You mentioned Lundqvist and Halak. Neither of these goalies could have won three or four extra games ?
A top goalie would steal a game here and there, then there is the general idea, with the rest of the team overall, that they would have confidence in their goalie.

The Leafs are easily in the playoffs with a top goalie. The confidence alone would propel the Leafs forward. They would now be prepping for the playoffs, maybe in as high as sixth place.
 
So everybody sucks on the Leafs with few(if any) exceptions ... is that it ?

Somehow the Leafs, who were in a playoff spot until mid February, would not have benefited from a top ten goalie during the Feb-Mar swoon ? You mentioned Lundqvist and Halak. Neither of these goalies could have won three or four extra games ?
A top goalie would steal a game here and there, then there is the general idea, with the rest of the team overall, that they would have confidence in their goalie.

The Leafs are easily in the playoffs with a top goalie. The confidence alone would propel the Leafs forward. They would now be prepping for the playoffs, maybe in as high as sixth place.

My whole argument, the issue is more on the players than the goalie itself. The goalie can only do so much.
if our D doesn't support them, of course they sux.
Are we going to put the all the blame on the goalie for our bad PK too? We are like 2nd last or last on penalty kill as well.
 
My whole argument, the issue is more on the players than the goalie itself. The goalie can only do so much.
if our D doesn't support them, of course they sux.
Are we going to put the all the blame on the goalie for our bad PK too? We are like 2nd last or last on penalty kill as well.

Holy monkeys

Let me try a different approach.
Charles, are you aware of the Leafs record and/or position in the East standings until February 1st ?
 
Holy monkeys

Let me try a different approach.
Charles, are you aware of the Leafs record and/or position in the East standings until February 1st ?

Yup! What's is the point you are trying to prove? It's all Reimer and Gus fault for this leafs landslide?

Let me use another approach for you. Put Reimer and Gus in St Louis, and give us Halak and Elliot. Would St Louis go from nearly top of the west to near dead last in the West?

Will the leafs go from almost dead last to nearly top of the conference?

I been trying to tell you, its on the players for this leafs landslide. But for some reason you keep defending them and put the blame on the leafs for not having the better goalie.

We were playing better on D when we were still up in the standings. There was a period of time when we actually haven't allow a goal on the PK for a whole month. We were getting it done with Reimer and Gus when our core D was defending better.
 
No matter what happens, the Leafs are in for a lottery pick. Too bad Sid Crosby isn't available this year.
 
I see I will have to do this myself.






Were the Leafs in sixth back in Feb ?

Correct.





Now you say no goalie could have saved the Leafs.
I am damn sure Lundqvist or Quick or Smith, etc, would have the Leafs in a playoff spot, locked into seventh or sixth.

When the goalie plays well, the team's confidence goes up and they can play easier, breath easier because they know the goalie can and will make one or two saves while they get back into their defensive assignments.

A goalie making a big save can make everyone look good and/or better then they are. A big save can forgive an error or two.
Thinking back late in some of those game lost in the final five minutes, a top goalie would have won/stole two or three of them.
During February and March a top goalie would not have given up soft, momentum killing goals and some of those losses would have been wins, some of the regular losses would be OT losses.

Goalie makes a great save the team picks up and feeds off that. The players are a little looser, able to play a more relaxed game, play better, the goalie feeds off that ... it is a circle.

Lundqvist or Quick or Miller(the way he is playing now) and the Leafs are selling out the ACC for games next week.
 
Good goaltending is the key to any successful team. Although the Black Hawks did it with a mediocre goalie when they won the cup, a good goalie is mint.
 
Look Ironhead! I am not at all saying having a better goalie would not make the leafs better. I am saying all along if we do not give the right support for our goalie, it won't make that big of a difference. A better goalie with give us a few more wins maybe. Have you been watching the leafs when we were on a landslide? How many times do opposing forwards blow by our d? How many coughups do our D give up? So, you are going to blame it on the goalie for letting in those goals? Yea sure, you can say a better goalie will make those stops.

How about you try letting Lundquist face 8 or 9 breakaways a game, or clear path to the net. I like to see how many times he can stop before letting one in.

I can assure you too both Reimer or Gus would have a better GAA and SV% if they play in St Louis, if you want to say Lundquist or Quick will get us in the playoffs.
 
Look Ironhead! I am not at all saying having a better goalie would not make the leafs better. I am saying all along if we do not give the right support for our goalie, it won't make that big of a difference. A better goalie with give us a few more wins maybe. Have you been watching the leafs when we were on a landslide? How many times do opposing forwards blow by our d? How many coughups do our D give up? So, you are going to blame it on the goalie for letting in those goals? Yea sure, you can say a better goalie will make those stops.

How about you try letting Lundquist face 8 or 9 breakaways a game, or clear path to the net. I like to see how many times he can stop before letting one in.

I can assure you too both Reimer or Gus would have a better GAA and SV% if they play in St Louis, if you want to say Lundquist or Quick will get us in the playoffs.

Did I just read what I read ?






I am not at all saying having a better goalie would not make the leafs better.

I believe that is exactly what you said back when this discussion started.






I am saying all along if we do not give the right support for our goalie, it won't make that big of a difference. A better goalie with give us a few more wins maybe.

Better D makes for less scoring chances and leads to less goals ... well duh.






Have you been watching the leafs when we were on a landslide? How many times do opposing forwards blow by our d? How many coughups do our D give up?

Yes, pretty much every painful moment. I saw them play well before the slide when the GOALIE was hot, giving them(the forwards and defenseman) confidence to do their jobs better and more relaxed.






So, you are going to blame it on the goalie for letting in those goals? Yea sure, you can say a better goalie will make those stops.

Some of the soft goals ? Damn straight I blame the goalie.
A better goalie makes the stop, Leafs win.






I can assure you too both Reimer or Gus would have a better GAA and SV% if they play in St Louis, if you want to say Lundquist or Quick will get us in the playoffs.

errr ... Not exactly sure what your point is here. I never denied that Reimer or Gustavsson would not have better numbers on a better team.
 
I still think the Leafs made the right choice to go with Reimer this year as the number one,

The Leafs were still not at a period in their success cycle that they would be top contenders. It was the right time to see if Reimer was the guy (the data was still so limited entering 2011/12 as good as it was), and having another #1 on the team would not have allowed for a good read on him. What I never quite understood is why they gave Reimer a three year contract before the year.

Now the Leafs should a better understanding of what they have and be able to act accordingly, Even with less points, I prefer the status of the Leafs roster at the end of the 2012 year vs the end of 2011. Burke has improved the roster overall, but it has been a slow process.