Toronto Maple Leafs 2011/12

Hard to fire a guy you just gave an extension to though, no?
No. It was only a one year extension so that he would not coach this year in a "lame duck" situation.

I suspect, playoffs he returns, no playoffs he's gone. The organization can easily swallow one year's salary.

The Leaf season reminds me of an old Paul Simon song, "Slip Sliding Away". The only thing that's saving their collective asses is that they had a bit of a cushion and the teams behind them are sucking just as bad
 
No. It was only a one year extension so that he would not coach this year in a "lame duck" situation.

I suspect, playoffs he returns, no playoffs he's gone. The organization can easily swallow one year's salary.

The Leaf season reminds me of an old Paul Simon song, "Slip Sliding Away". The only thing that's saving their collective asses is that they had a bit of a cushion and the teams behind them are sucking just as bad

Okay so who do you bring in then? Dallas Eakins?
 
No. It was only a one year extension so that he would not coach this year in a "lame duck" situation.

I suspect, playoffs he returns, no playoffs he's gone. The organization can easily swallow one year's salary.

The Leaf season reminds me of an old Paul Simon song, "Slip Sliding Away". The only thing that's saving their collective asses is that they had a bit of a cushion and the teams behind them are sucking just as bad

That is what I was going to say.
I agree he is gone if no playoffs .... almost makes me hope the Leafs miss the playoffs.
So true about the trailing teams, but Winnipeg has vaulted into first in their division and pushed Florida down to eighth and the Leafs down to ninth.

Good news/bad news ...
Leafs get into playoffs(good) / Wilson likely stays around and gets another one extension(bad).
Leafs miss the playoffs(bad) / Wilson is fired(good).





Okay so who do you bring in then? Dallas Eakins?

Previously I would have said yes to Eakins, but now I am not so sure.
It may workout. He seems to be a good young coach and the Leafs are a good young(non contender) team.
The thing which gives me pause is Eakins inexperience.
 
Okay so who do you bring in then? Dallas Eakins?
I don't pretend to know (and nobody else on TERB should, either) what the market is like for coaches as much as any GM. They know who's available for what, what their strengths and weaknesses are, contract demands, personality, personal problems, personal histories with others in the organization etc. etc.

The GMs have the pipelines for this info which all come into play when making the decision. We do not.
 
I don't pretend to know (and nobody else on TERB should, either) what the market is like for coaches as much as any GM. They know who's available for what, what their strengths and weaknesses are, contract demands, personality, personal problems, personal histories with others in the organization etc. etc.

The GMs have the pipelines for this info which all come into play when making the decision. We do not.

Are you saying Fletcher's pipeline sucked?
 
Instead of tweaking the team what if I could tweak Burke ?

I do not mind his manner at all, but there are some changes I would make.
- a little more flexible in signing RFAs.
- willing to admit "I made a mistake in signing this guy" or "I could have got him for less". Do not jump so quick into 'sign a FA' pool.
- in some cases less info, other cases more informative. "I am going to make this team a tough, contending team", where "I will try to make this team better" would have sufficed. Go ahead and attempt the 'tough' part, but just keep that part to himself or within a small circle.
 
Okay so who do you bring in then? Dallas Eakins?

I may not know much about hockey but aren't

two of Burke's previous coaches unemployed ?

Crawford and Carlyle
 
a little more flexible in signing RFAs.

Agree 100%! The stars will just be re-signed by their teams anyhow but why should he care.

willing to admit "I made a mistake in signing this guy" or "I could have got him for less". Do not jump so quick into 'sign a FA' pool.

I disagree there. I believe he has no problem fixing (therefore admitting) a mistake (i.e. Versteeg, Beaucheman) if he can correct it. That is the key. He would dump Komisarek if he could. He can't declare he made a mistake on a guy who is still on his roster. No one wants him at his salary so Burke is stuck with him and has to continue to defend him.

What GM would say he could have got a guy for less?
 
I disagree there. I believe he has no problem fixing (therefore admitting) a mistake (i.e. Versteeg, Beaucheman) if he can correct it. That is the key. He would dump Komisarek if he could. He can't declare he made a mistake on a guy who is still on his roster. No one wants him at his salary so Burke is stuck with him and has to continue to defend him.

What GM would say he could have got a guy for less?

I did not mean publicly. Maybe he does realize he overpaid for Komisarek.
You may be correct. I guess he does admit mistakes.


Now that I am on the subject there are a few other mistakes he has made in my opinion.
Naming Phaneuf captain almost as soon as he got here was a mistake in my opinion. Naming him captain at all was a mistake in my opinion. Should have just let him be a guy on the team and allow him to become a dressing room leader if he so chose.
Acquiring Connolly period. Money could have been better spent even if it was not spent.
I am not happy with Liles either. Even before the injury I did not like him. Then signing a 31 year old soft, smallish defenceman for $3.875 in each of the next four seasons beginning in '12/'13. The good thing is he is movable with a cap hit of under $4.mil.
 
Darryl Boyce and Jay Rosehill have been put on waivers.
Could be a prelude to a trade or more likely just giving a farm hand a look.
 
I really like Ron Wilson as the coach. His teams don't play the trap.

With the Washington Capitals, with Kolzig in goal, that team made it all the way to the finals only to lose to Detroit.

With the San Jose Sharks, with Nabokov in goal, that was one of the best teams in the league year after year. However, not being able to get over the hump and reach the finals, they blamed Wilson for that too, and fired his ass.

In Toronto, there was Vesa Toskala, JS Guiere letting in soft goals, Jonan Gustavsson, and James Riemer. When the Leafs had periods of decent goal-tending, they did well, and not many complained about Wilson. When the goalie blows a game, or a few like they have lately, then the knives come out.

No center down the middle. There is an idea in sports, that you should be strong down the middle. Baseball, the catcher and center fielder. Football the QB, inside middle linebacker and safties. Basketball, the center is the most important position.

Last year, Garborski and Bozak were the team's number 1 and 2 center, and they did not make the playoffs. This year, Garborski and Bozak are the team's number 1 and 2 center. Connolley plays like he's already washed up.

Burke just has not acquired enough top 6 forwards. The team best three forwards who are top 6 material are Kessel, Lupal, and Garborski, and lets remember they were all acquired via trades. Seems like around 5 to 6 years that the Leafs were unable to produce a top 6 forward from their drafting or farming system. That is shocking. Not a single player.

The world's greatest coach still cannot make chicken salad out of chicken crap. Firing the coach only lets the players off the hook. Get rid of the players!

Bottom six forwards, Armstrong, Kulemin are solid players. Brown, Crabb are okay. The top six forwards, Kessel, Lupal, Graborski, and they still need a big center. Playing Garbovski against Thornton last night seemed like a mismatch, but they did okay. This goes to show how thin the Leafs really are up front.
 
if Ron Wilson was still coaching Washington, I would like him too. In fact I would love to see him coaching anywhere but Toronto.
How many years has been an NHL head coach and how many rings does he have?
 
You can only go so far in blaming the coach for the players not preforming.
Burke has to get the players that can do the deed.
 
one of the coaches jobs is to motivate the players. In the SJ game they were flatter than pancakes and that was a game they needed to win.
You have to get the most out of the players you have and Wilson has not done that.
Tonight Washington lets see what happens.
 
A coach who is sarcastic to and has a poor relationship with the media.

A coach who criticizes and singles out his own players.

A coach who has not won a cup with the resources of one of the richest teams in the league after 3 years.

I suspect most people would complain if John Tortorella was our coach. How many points more would the Leafs have if we had Lundqvist between the pipes?
 
OK. When it comes to a final grade on Wilson we disagree toward a solution.
I am NOT against bring in a new coach, but at the sametime I do not think he is the main clog to the Leafs problem of getting over the hump.
If I and some of my friends, my friends and I have played hockey all our lives, were on the Leafs we would play for 5-7 hundred thou each, and Wilson would have very little problem motivating us for each game, getting our 100% effort every shift. Result ... the Leafs would be worse then Columbus because we do not have it anymore, we never had it in fact. My point ? If a coach does not have the players to do the job, it does not matter if he can install a system and/or motivate.
 
A coach who is sarcastic to and has a poor relationship with the media.

A coach who criticizes and singles out his own players.

A coach who has not won a cup with the resources of one of the richest teams in the league after 3 years.

I suspect most people would complain if John Tortorella was our coach. How many points more would the Leafs have if we had Lundqvist between the pipes?

Somehow I don't think it would matter who played for Wilson, I think he would piss them off and he would get little out of them.
Wasn't there a "secret" poll (last year) or at least a poll, that suggested he was the coach that most players did not want to play for?!?
As for Lundqvist, 1 bad goal and he Wilson would bench him.
 
Wasn't there a "secret" poll (last year) or at least a poll, that suggested he was the coach that most players did not want to play for?!?
And Kessel is the most easily intimidated.

And Phaneuf is the most overrated.

And Kessel is the last pick in the All-Star game.

Is there possibly an anti-Toronto bias in these polls.
 
And Kessel is the most easily intimidated.

And Phaneuf is the most overrated.

And Kessel is the last pick in the All-Star game.

Is there possibly an anti-Toronto bias in these polls.

well Kessel was the last pick and Phaneuf is somewhat over rated, I don't see Kessel as being easily intimidated, however,

I still see Wilson as a useless tit that needs to be replaced.

I agree with you most of the polls are crap. I remember that coaches poll because I don't believe he will ever create a winner here

and my dislike of him causes me to believe all the negative shit I hear/read about him.