Titanic Submersible

The newest in adventure tourism! All new experimental submersible takes you to BOTH the wreck of the Titanic and the debris of the Titan implosion! Two for the ridiculously exorbitant price of one🤑💰💰💰
 
The stresses and strengths of materials are well understood and routine engineering.

Designing a submersible that can descend to more than 35K feet is 'routine engineering'? And a guy like James Cameron who holds no post-secondary education in any discipline whatsoever, let alone engineering, would have enough understanding of complex stresses and strength of materials to design the vehicle himself? Sure, that could happen. C'mon man....really?
 
a guy like James Cameron who holds no post-secondary education in any discipline whatsoever, let alone engineering, would have enough understanding of complex stresses and strength of materials to design the vehicle ?

Agree. But it has been reported, by non terbs, that adequate testing was never done after each dive checking for stress fatique.
 
  • Like
Reactions: johnd5050
There's a grieving mother of a 19 year old who didn't even want to go. The US coast guard knew the outcome 4 days before oxygen ran out and they still had a 4 day futile search.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shakenbake
The newest in adventure tourism! All new experimental submersible takes you to BOTH the wreck of the Titanic and the debris of the Titan implosion! Two for the ridiculously exorbitant price of one🤑💰💰💰

and you get to go in an exact replica of the Titan and place bet with Vegas. If you implode they keep money if you dont you win. It is international waters so you cannot stop them and desperate people would borrow against everything they own. Make a good reality show
 
Agree. But it has been reported, by non terbs, that adequate testing was never done after each dive checking for stress fatique.

We're talking about a different submersible vehicle (Deepsea Challenger) that Cameron piloted to the bottom of the Trench, not specifically about the Titan
 
I understood Cameron was the submersible pilot, and took part in testing of the craft, but pretty sure he wasn't the brainchild behind the actual design, engineering and build of the craft. Very few people exist on the planet with those type of credentials.
Probably. I thought I heard him say he had a part in designing it. I could be wrong.
 
Probably. I thought I heard him say he had a part in designing it. I could be wrong.

I suspect he was a principal visionary in getting the initiative setup and moving forward, and provided a lot of what I would term 'end user input' all through the process. But the lead technical engineer was Ron Allum, an Aussie engineer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Allum
 
  • Like
Reactions: carvesg
Designing a submersible that can descend to more than 35K feet is 'routine engineering'? And a guy like James Cameron who holds no post-secondary education in any discipline whatsoever, let alone engineering, would have enough understanding of complex stresses and strength of materials to design the vehicle himself? Sure, that could happen. C'mon man....really?
As an engineer, I concur with Danny’s comment. There are also many self-taught individuals who can put educated engineers to shame.
 
As an engineer, I concur with Danny’s comment. There are also many self-taught individuals who can put educated engineers to shame.

Having worked in aerospace engineering at a very senior level for many many years, I'd say the instances of what you're talking about do occur, but typically in much less complex or sophisticated situations/contexts. Designing a bridge or designing a robotic assembly plant is very different from designing a space vehicle or a deep sea submersible.
 
Having worked in aerospace engineering at a very senior level for many many years, I'd say the instances of what you're talking about do occur, but typically in much less complex or sophisticated situations/contexts. Designing a bridge or designing a robotic assembly plant is very different from designing a space vehicle or a deep sea submersible.
You are correct. However, we should not discount the possibility. My experiences are from working across many disciplines, academic, private sector and government, for the last 46 years. We might have even crossed paths at some point in time. 😀
 
I suspect he was a principal visionary in getting the initiative setup and moving forward, and provided a lot of what I would term 'end user input' all through the process. But the lead technical engineer was Ron Allum, an Aussie engineer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Allum

If I remember correctly....two guys one of whom was Dr Ballard being interviewed about the Titanic a few years ago and saying as a side note that Cameron was quite legit in the deep sea submersible community not only for his knowledge of Titanic but about submersibles .

He is a shareholder/partner of Triton submersibles which builds a full range of deep sea submersibles
 
Auguste Piccarde designed a deep diving vessel in 1930s that successfully explored the depths. His son, Jaques, took another design to the deepest place on the planet over 50 years ago. This technology is not new by any stretch of imagination and, with proper industrial support, readily executable. The designers of the modern submarines are not really inventing anything new.
 
Auguste Piccarde designed a deep diving vessel in 1930s that successfully explored the depths. His son, Jaques, took another design to the deepest place on the planet over 50 years ago. This technology is not new by any stretch of imagination and, with proper industrial support, readily executable. The designers of the modern submarines are not really inventing anything new.
In particular, the structural integrity of the vessel is not an issue, because the stresses and strengths of materials are well understood and routine engineering.
There has been no implosions of deep sea vessels for 60 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jcpro
choppa.png
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Jenesis
Auguste Piccarde designed a deep diving vessel in 1930s that successfully explored the depths. His son, Jaques, took another design to the deepest place on the planet over 50 years ago. This technology is not new by any stretch of imagination and, with proper industrial support, readily executable. The designers of the modern submarines are not really inventing anything new
Which is why this industry needs to be government regulated.
As of right now submersives arent required to be certified, that needs to change
 
Which is why this industry needs to be government regulated.
As of right now submersives arent required to be certified, that needs to change
I think that the ocean has its own way of regulating the industry. It often takes a tragedy for the common sense to break out and hard rules to be instituted, even in the government. Like after the loss of USS Thresher the US Navy REALLY got serious about sub safety, led by Hyman Rickover, and instituted rules that became hollier than the Bible for the underwater navy.