They changed the Klingons again

So I'm up to Episode 3 of Season 2 and I need a "Coles' Notes" to figure out just what the fuck is going on in the first 3 episodes. It seems like Discovery comes at you from 5 different directions in each episode at the same time. And unlike the shows of old, where most episodes were stand alone episodes, this one is one great big story line.

And I see that the Klingons have been changed up a bit. They no longer look like they are wearing black face and as was announced in the last episode, they are growing their hair out.

 
They left a big fat spoiler in episode 1, guess who's coming back. I'm a degenerate Trekkie, I can put aside my revulsion to Anthony Rapp for the sake of the series.

That shape shifting alien is a big wild card.

Remember, remember the 5th of November....

 
Captain Pike is a great new addition to the show. I suspect we will end up seeing a Pike TV series set on the Enterprise in the near future.
 
Anson Mount as Captain Pike isn't bad, just not great. Star Trek: Discovery could get cancelled, it's too safe. The writing isn't very good and one of the shows couldn't even break a 7 on audience scores. They're drawing out the search for Spocco to a point where no one really cares. They need to get their "edge" back, like they promised in E1. For the sake of saving the series Captain Lorca must return.

Jason Isaacs commitment to Brit Marling is done for the time being, ST: Discovery will go the way of Rome if he doesn't come back.

 
Chris Pine failed. Jason Isaacs is the only one that can match the charisma of The Great Shat.

 
I was about the biggest Star Trek fan ever when I was younger. Even went as a Borg drone for Halloween when I was like 10. The new movies and Discovery are not doing it for me. Just don’t interest me at all.

The movies just seem like overly slick, generic sci-fi action movies. The casting is alright, though I can’t stand Chris Pine, but it just feels like a pale imitation. The Enterprise has to get blown up every movie for some reason, and I’m really not sure why they had to “soft-remake” Wrath of Khan. Did anyone think Wrath of Khan left something on the table? Did anyone walk away from that movie feeling like it wasn’t enough? Just seemed completely unnecessary.

Discovery just bores and confuses me. Like, first off, it doesn’t seem to understand what Star Trek is. It also seems very smug about all the “diversity”. Star Trek always had diversity, but it wasn’t smug about it. It wasn’t diversity for diversity’s sake, it was portraying a utopian future wherein race was meaningless (which is what Gene Roddenberry’s vision for the franchise was), whereas Discovery seems to revel in it. I am a liberal, I don’t like to inject politics where it’s not needed, but Discovery, as well as many other shows these days, really does seem to be more about “progressive” pandering. It just turns me off. Also not a fan of the Klingons living in flying funeral parlors. This obsession with death that they seem to have in Discovery was never a thing before. Just seems strange. The series also does have that “slick, generic sci-fi” feel that the new movies suffer from.

I dunno, I may give Discovery a rewatch, I only got through the first season before I decided it wasn’t for me. Star Trek just doesn’t feel like Star Trek anymore, y’know?
 
^^^^ I agree with everything you said above about Star Trek Discovery.

It's awful. As a fan of Star Trek it's sad to say, but I feel like I'm forcing myself to watch it, it's that bad. There is not a single character, in what was a traditionally character driven show, that I have any emotional investment in. It is like new wave Science fiction set in star trek background. The entire "red angel" plot line (the image being copied from Nirvana's In Utero album cover) is just bizarre as is the very notion that Spock was in a psychiatric hospital and killed 5 people.

Star Trek used to be about space exploration, adventure, conflict and conflict resolution, and interesting characters. The producers of Discovery seem to be completely unaware of that and made the show entirely about interpersonal (and never ending) conflict. I have the feeling that none of them have ever even watched Star Trek and are new age TV producers who just want to put out their own TV show to make a name for themselves.

As bad as Jar Jar Abrams Star Trek movies are, they are better than Discovery.
 
Chris Pine failed. Jason Isaacs is the only one that can match the charisma of The Great Shat.


Those clips of jimmie and "spocko" and them fancy heaters ...brought back fond memories. No one, NO ONE, overacts like the great Bill Shatner. Thus always a Kirk 'n Spock guy, Shatner and Nimoy style. But a bigger fan of Uhura...even back then the young kherg spilt seed over her voluptuous loveliness. Even in her later days she was the oldest lady I'd still like to take for a romp (well, maybe tied w Pam Grier)..
 
^^^^ I agree with everything you said above about Star Trek Discovery.

It's awful. As a fan of Star Trek it's sad to say, but I feel like I'm forcing myself to watch it, it's that bad. There is not a single character, in what was a traditionally character driven show, that I have any emotional investment in. It is like new wave Science fiction set in star trek background. The entire "red angel" plot line (the image being copied from Nirvana's In Utero album cover) is just bizarre as is the very notion that Spock was in a psychiatric hospital and killed 5 people.

Star Trek used to be about space exploration, adventure, conflict and conflict resolution, and interesting characters. The producers of Discovery seem to be completely unaware of that and made the show entirely about interpersonal (and never ending) conflict. I have the feeling that none of them have ever even watched Star Trek and are new age TV producers who just want to put out their own TV show to make a name for themselves.

As bad as Jar Jar Abrams Star Trek movies are, they are better than Discovery.
Exactly. Star Trek is supposed to be optimistic. Like I said above, Roddenberry’s vision was a series about a utopian future where humanity has evolved beyond racism, greed, and petty political bickering. He didn’t even want to show the federation as being imperfect. He hated the TNG episode where the parasite things were taking over high-ranking members of the federation. That was supposed to be an entire arc in the series, but he vetoed it. Granted, the franchise has moved away from that sometimes, like the Dominion war is DS9, but it’s still always maintained the spirit of adventure, and the notion that humanity, at its core, was good.

Discovery is not about that. It’s about a ship full of incredibly flawed people doing morally questionable things and bickering with one another. I also feel like the format takes away a lot of the spirit of the franchise. Other series have had overarching stories, again, the Dominion war from DS9 comes to mind, but they still managed to be episodic. They’ll take a break every now and then to have Dax go fight with the Klingons or have Sisko play a baseball game or something. Discovery doesn’t really do this. It’s a true series. You need to watch it in order or you won’t know what’s going on. I caught one episode on TV from the latest season the other day, and I had no clue what was happening. There were characters I didn’t know, and the plot revolves around enemies I knew nothing about. Obviously, with the other series, there are things you won’t know as well, but you can still pick out almost any episode of TOS or TNG and show it to someone who isn’t terribly familiar with the series, and they could still get something out of it, because each episode is usually self-contained enough.
 
Sorry Trek fans. The Orville is now kicking it's ass royally. The last two episodes rocked.
 
Just when I thought I was out, they draw me back in...Spock revealed!

He's Ethan Peck and he has the timbre of his grandfather Gregory Peck. His resume is an exercise in dues paying, apparently being the grandson of the most famous voice of his generation isn't enough.

And a good episode as well, Emperor Georgiou (Michelle Yeoh) makes her power play. It's about time they stopped fucking around.

 
For example, I'm obviously fine with an Asian captain and black first officer. ?

Sad thing is that I pretty much assume they were made Asian* and black not out of some sort of random choice or because of some serious plot reason but for political correctness and that makes me sad.

*[really Asian, 4/7ths of the worlds people are Asian, it's meaningless as an identifier]
 
Exactly. Star Trek is supposed to be optimistic. Like I said above, Roddenberry’s vision was a series about a utopian future where humanity has evolved beyond racism, greed, and petty political bickering. He didn’t even want to show the federation as being imperfect. He hated the TNG episode where the parasite things were taking over high-ranking members of the federation. That was supposed to be an entire arc in the series, but he vetoed it. Granted, the franchise has moved away from that sometimes, like the Dominion war is DS9, but it’s still always maintained the spirit of adventure, and the notion that humanity, at its core, was good.

Discovery is not about that. It’s about a ship full of incredibly flawed people doing morally questionable things and bickering with one another. I also feel like the format takes away a lot of the spirit of the franchise. Other series have had overarching stories, again, the Dominion war from DS9 comes to mind, but they still managed to be episodic. They’ll take a break every now and then to have Dax go fight with the Klingons or have Sisko play a baseball game or something. Discovery doesn’t really do this. It’s a true series. You need to watch it in order or you won’t know what’s going on. I caught one episode on TV from the latest season the other day, and I had no clue what was happening. There were characters I didn’t know, and the plot revolves around enemies I knew nothing about. Obviously, with the other series, there are things you won’t know as well, but you can still pick out almost any episode of TOS or TNG and show it to someone who isn’t terribly familiar with the series, and they could still get something out of it, because each episode is usually self-contained enough.

Yup...Discovery doesn't look like a Star Trek. The sci-fi in Discovery seems way beyond even Picard and TNG. Hard to follow. Too many story lines. No main character - just too many of them. And being a Toronto production,. it seems to keep pushing the gender issue. The original Star Trek had Uhura, a black woman. But not every episode was about her being black. But Discovery keeps pushing the gay/gender issue. Fine - the engineer is gay. But let's move on and get back to Star Trek. And is he the chief engineer? Dunno. And I still don't know their names. There is no sick bay, no engineering, no transporter room (ok, there's a transporter room but it could be any room in the ship for that matter). There's a bridge, ok.

All in all, I keep watching it since I have always watched Star Trek. But it doesn't do it for me.
 
I liked how Season 1 started, but hated the ending... I wasn't a fan of Season 2's beginning, but I think it is getting better. You have to give shows time, I guess.

I'll take as much Sci-Fi as I can get.

Netflix ruled last year for me with the OA and Altered Carbon. Special mention to Black Mirror and their "Metalhead" episode.
 
Yup...Discovery doesn't look like a Star Trek. The sci-fi in Discovery seems way beyond even Picard and TNG. Hard to follow. Too many story lines. No main character - just too many of them. And being a Toronto production,. it seems to keep pushing the gender issue. The original Star Trek had Uhura, a black woman. But not every episode was about her being black. But Discovery keeps pushing the gay/gender issue. Fine - the engineer is gay. But let's move on and get back to Star Trek. And is he the chief engineer? Dunno. And I still don't know their names. There is no sick bay, no engineering, no transporter room (ok, there's a transporter room but it could be any room in the ship for that matter). There's a bridge, ok.

All in all, I keep watching it since I have always watched Star Trek. But it doesn't do it for me.
See, this is a big thing for me. I cannot for the life of me understand why so many shows now seem to feel the need to shoehorn in characters just for “diversity”. People used to make such a fuss over a show having a “token black character” or whatever, but isn’t that exactly what these new “progressive” shows are doing? If a character’s main personality trait is their race/gender/sexuality/whatever, or if you go out of your way to drop the fact that the character is gay or whatever every chance you get, aren’t you reducing those characters to one-dimensional caricatures? Real gay people don’t do that. They’re just people. They don’t go around announcing that they’re gay every chance they get. One of my oldest friends is gay, and I don’t even remember it most of the time. Pretty much, unless we’re talking about dating or sex, it just doesn’t come up. He’s just my friend. I don’t think of him any other way.

People very often criticize shows from earlier periods for being offensive, but characters like Sulu, Uhura, Laforge, Sisko, etc. are far more progressive than any of the shallow “diversity” characters nowadays. They were people. Real characters with real traits, real devopment, real personalities, and their race wasn’t really relevant, so it was rarely discussed. That, to me, is more inclusive. Treating everyone as human, rather than treating everyone as something different while trying assure audiences that these characters are special and powerful BECAUSE they’re different.
 
I started this rant when Discovery hit rock bottom by bringing Dr. Cubler back from the dead - that was too much fromage for me to digest. Anthony Rapp is a bad actor, Stamets should be killed off not redeemed. Some have said that I'm being homophobic regarding the Kevin Spacey ordeal. Maybe, but Rapp is a D - list actor, I have a very negative response to having him rubbed in my face. The probability is high that he may not have gotten a shot at ST if not for Spacey. Sorry sensitive types, I hate his guts!

Lets not be too harsh on Michelle Yeoh, her Malay/Chinese ethnicity isn't a major part of the story. And I prefer Empress Giorgiou (whom I believe is Romanian) to the Captain...you can have only so many do-gooders to make a series work. As for Spocco, brilliant casting, before they even showed his face I recognized the voice. Didn't know that Gregory Peck's grandson is an actor. He is the most physically imposing Spock ever, he also has his grandfather's height. Like his grandfather he commands the screen, it works for me.

Episode 5 registered a 6.8 in audience score, that's low! Apparently I'm not the only one who thinks Stamets should be killed off.

 
Seriously guys, end your pain. Watch the Orville.
 
Where do I stream the Orville, haven't found it anywhere.

Is there anyone that can match the charisma of The Great Shat?

 
Where do I stream the Orville, haven't found it anywhere.

Is there anyone that can match the charisma of The Great Shat?


I watch it on Kodi. Not sure about legit sources.

It has its homage moments to ST. Also it's own flavor. It's not a joke a minute. It has serious themes.

No one can match Shat's scenery chewing prowess. But Seth does match up for the ability to be a Star Ship Captain in the best tradition of the genre.
 
Seth MacFarlane is a ST fan and produced Cosmos II, he knows what it takes to live up to The Shatness.

As for Discovery, Ethan Peck makes for an imposing Spocco. The show has been renewed for a 3rd season, probably Ethan Peck came in and picked up the show. I was about to give up on Discovery now I want to see what he can do.

I love Gollum!