The Truth On Iraq: It's Devastated

Ranger68 said:
...Its MUCH worse to have foreigners in your country killing your own citizens than for countrymen to kill countrymen. ...
Not to anyone who has had a loved one killed; death is death regardless of who serves it to those that are left to live forever with that burden.
 
All rhetoric aside .......
:rolleyes:

I disagree. I think history clearly proves you wrong. People are MUCH more easily stirred *to violence* when the people doing the killings are foreign invaders than when they are your own people.

Even Soviet citizens who'd had many loved ones killed during Stalin's purges fought FANATICALLY (there's that word again) against the German invaders. The SS death squads weren't doing anything all that different from Stalin's death squads.
 
Ranger68 said:
These people weren't being killed until the Americans invaded. So, yes - it's the Americans' fault. It is the Americans' fault that many insurgents feel the need to fight.

Do you really think that a similar number of people was being killed on a daily basis in Iraq before the invasion? If you do, there's probably no hope for you.

Again, do you have anything to back up *your* opinion? ...... No? ...... Not surprising.

and further to this point, the US rolled a secular state, which allowed women the right to education, right to careers and religous freedom probably into a Shiite controlled theocracy that will emerge after some brutal civil war in 6 years. Sometimes you have to be arbitrary in these high minded objectives, and keeping the Baath party in power, possibly without Saddam would have been the way to go. Women are increasingly being forced to accept Sharia law, wear hajib or chadour and are at person risk on the streets, which didnt exist before. So no, the quality of life in Iraq has not been enhanced by any measure.

The US had a perfect overthrow under Clinton, and failed the Iraqis division that would have taken out Saddam the opportunity - which is how it should have been done, - not at the cost to the world economy, or US lives.
 
The only reason that anyone is getting killed in Iraq right now is that a Sunni minority is using terror of it's own citizens to affect a political process. There are only 4 regions where violence is high, all Sunni.

Guess what, if no one shoots at US troops.......

Under Saddam - Sunni minority exploiting, killing, gassing, rapping the Iraq public.

Current Situation - Sunni minority killing, terrorizing, US troops and Iraq citizens.

I see a common thread.

OTB
 

gee and you dont think that shooting has anything to do witha foreign power invading and occupying? a foreign power dismantling a governemnt and an army, destroying a country's infrastructure, killing 100,000 civilians in the process....

nah, its just sour grapes by a few terrorist's who dont appreciate a good thing.

No, it's a minority desperately trying to stay in power.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
No, it's a minority desperately trying to stay in power.

Are you saying that the Sadr and Faluja fighters are Bathist trying to stay in power???? Jeeesh
 
danmand said:
Are you saying that the Sadr and Faluja fighters are Bathist trying to stay in power???? Jeeesh

Are you saying that Sadr isn't making a power play.... jeeesh.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
The only reason that anyone is getting killed in Iraq right now is that a Sunni minority is using terror of it's own citizens to affect a political process. There are only 4 regions where violence is high, all Sunni.

Guess what, if no one shoots at US troops.......
OTB

OTB, you never answered the previous question I put to you..so what is your position? I think your answer is important as you seem to be a statesman on behalf of this war effort.

Mcluhan said:
OTB, do you think using cluster bombs on civilian populations is a good thing? Or a bad thing. Or are you somewhere in between..

Usually when a country is invaded, people do shoot back, not throw buckets of roses...but then I haven't read all of history.
 
Mcluhan said:
OTB, you never answered the previous question I put to you..so what is your position? I think your answer is important as you seem to be a statesman on behalf of this war effort.



Usually when a country is invaded, people do shoot back, not throw buckets of roses...but then I haven't read all of history.

When was the last time a cluster bomb was dropped? I'm not going to even bother argue the "on civilians" part.

The violence that is standing between Iraqi citizens and a better life is not coming from the US. It is coming from people who want to keep, or grab power.

I completely understand being anti-war, I think there are very valid reasons to think (regardless of WMD) the US should not have done what we've done. You can hold the US accountable as you see fit.

OTB
 

gee and you dont think that shooting has anything to do witha foreign power invading and occupying? a foreign power dismantling a governemnt and an army, destroying a country's infrastructure, killing 100,000 civilians in the process....

nah, its just sour grapes by a few terrorist's who dont appreciate a good thing.

Yeah, I guess no Americans would have been killed if they hadn't revolted against the British.
:)
 
onthebottom said:
The violence that is standing between Iraqi citizens and a better life is not coming from the US. It is coming from people who want to keep, or grab power.

Because everybody on this planet should recognize that the US knowns (guided by the God of the white people) what is best for them, and has the moral obligation to invade and occupy any territory it sees fit.

The US military is incapable of violence?
 

i'm skeptical..... for the longest time the u.s. was claiming that the "terrorists" were foreign agitators. this was proved dead wrong.

now theyre saying it's all former baathist's. i'm sure thats part of it, but the reports i've seen in non-mainstream media suggest that there are a lot of ordinary iraqis who are pissed off and setting up roadside bombs etc.....

just read the diaries and blogs of some iraqis and you can see the hatred the u.s. has stirred up.... but again, no one seems to care what actual iraqis have to say (witness the complete dismissal of the "River" blog earlier in this thread.....)

their country got invaded..... they are resisting.

There are purely resistance fighters, I am sure - those who are opposed to being invaded by a foreign nation.
There are terrorists who really don't care who they kill as long as it makes the Americans look bad or retaliate.
There are Baathists who are trying to cling to power.

I'm certain that *all* of these groups are fighting.

To paint them all as one or the other is false.
 
onthebottom said:

I completely understand being anti-war, I think there are very valid reasons to think (regardless of WMD) the US should not have done what we've done. You can hold the US accountable as you see fit.

OTB

Thank you for that. Now, pursuing this just a little, because I am sensative (politely so) to how you, as an American are above being advised by others, on your own foreign policy, may I ask... what are those valid reasons...in your mind.
 
danmand said:
Because everybody on this planet should recognize that the US knowns (guided by the God of the white people) what is best for them, and has the moral obligation to invade and occupy any territory it sees fit.

The US military is incapable of violence?

Yes, I think it's important to remember that the US BEGAN the violence.
Now, they're decrying it, ostensibly because they can't finish what they started.
:rolleyes:
 
Mcluhan said:
Thank you for that. Now, pursuing this just a little, because I am sensative (politely so) to how you, as an American are above being advised by others, on your own foreign policy, may I ask... what are those valid reasons...in your mind.

This should be fun.
 

i'm skeptical..... for the longest time the u.s. was claiming that the "terrorists" were foreign agitators. this was proved dead wrong.

now theyre saying it's all former baathist's. i'm sure thats part of it, but the reports i've seen in non-mainstream media suggest that there are a lot of ordinary iraqis who are pissed off and setting up roadside bombs etc.....

just read the diaries and blogs of some iraqis and you can see the hatred the u.s. has stirred up.... but again, no one seems to care what actual iraqis have to say (witness the complete dismissal of the "River" blog earlier in this thread.....)

their country got invaded..... they are resisting.

Thanks for mentioning River's blog. It an incredible window into the world we are trying to understand, from our remote positions. Here's on excerpt I find revealing..

OTB, you might ask 'Who is funding' ..the organisations River refers to in this passage on the possibility of civil war...

http://riverbendblog.blogspot.com/2003_12_01_riverbendblog_archive.html

Sunnis and Shi'a have always lived in harmony in Iraq and we still do, so far. I'm from a family that is about half Shi'a and half Sunni. We have never had problems as the majority of civilized people don't discriminate between the two. The thing that seems to be triggering a lot of antagonism on all sides is the counterinsurgency militia being cultivated by the CPA and GC which will include Chalabi's thugs, SCIRI extremists and some Kurdish Bayshmarga.

The popular and incorrect belief seems to be that if you are a Kurd or Shi'a, this step is a positive one. Actually, the majority of moderate Kurds and Shi'a are just as exasperated as Sunnis about this new group of soldiers/spies that is going to be let loose on the population. It's just going to mean more hostility and suspicion in all directions, and if the new Iraqi force intends to be as indiscriminate with the detentions and raids as the troops, there's going to be a lot of bloodshed too.

I once said that I hoped, and believed, Iraqis were above the horrors of civil war and the slaughter of innocents, and I'm clinging to that belief with the sheer strength of desperation these days. I remember hearing the stories about Lebanon from people who were actually living there during the fighting and a constant question arose when they talked about the grief and horrors- what led up to it? What were the signs? How did it happen? And most importantly… did anyone see it coming?
 
Mcluhan said:
Thank you for that. Now, pursuing this just a little, because I am sensative (politely so) to how you, as an American are above being advised by others, on your own foreign policy, may I ask... what are those valid reasons...in your mind.

I don't think you are the least bit sensitive but I'll answer a direct question (a rare event on TERB).

I think many people don't view any war as valid, that unless directly attacked a country should never go to war. People felt this way in 1915, 1935, 1965, 1990 and now. I can understand this.

I think a majority of Americans are uncomfortable with our foreign affairs beyond aid and trade. PJ O'Rourke had a great line, why do we need a foreign policy, sure we deal with foreigners but we deal with dogs and we don't have a dog policy. Americans are isolationist by nature, I've been saying for 2 years that the backlash to Afghanistan and Iraq will be a much more isolationist US.

Many are suspect of our military (in and out of the US), to use that power is to invite disaster. They worry about Ike's "Military Industrial Complex" and see Halliburton conspiracies everywhere.

I think some didn't see Iraq as any threat to the US directly, or US interests. The strength of this argument I think is, why now. Why not wait.

That answer your question.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I don't think you are the least bit sensitive but I'll answer a direct question (a rare event on TERB).

I think many people don't view any war as valid, that unless directly attacked a country should never go to war. People felt this way in 1915, 1935, 1965, 1990 and now. I can understand this.

I think a majority of Americans are uncomfortable with our foreign affairs beyond aid and trade. PJ O'Rourke had a great line, why do we need a foreign policy, sure we deal with foreigners but we deal with dogs and we don't have a dog policy. Americans are isolationist by nature, I've been saying for 2 years that the backlash to Afghanistan and Iraq will be a much more isolationist US.

Many are suspect of our military (in and out of the US), to use that power is to invite disaster. They worry about Ike's "Military Industrial Complex" and see Halliburton conspiracies everywhere.

I think some didn't see Iraq as any threat to the US directly, or US interests. The strength of this argument I think is, why now. Why not wait.

That answer your question.

OTB

Your assesment on isolationism is correct. Even I have a hard time resisitng it. With all the whining that goes on about what we do and what we don't do, it makes it hard to stay positive.

I would love for us to step back and let some of the armchair quarterbacks run the show namely France, Germany, Russia, China and Canada.
 
langeweile said:
Your assesment on isolationism is correct. Even I have a hard time resisitng it. With all the whining that goes on about what we do and what we don't do, it makes it hard to stay positive.

I would love for us to step back and let some of the armchair quarterbacks run the show namely France, Germany, Russia, China and Canada.

Why stop there? Let the poor people everywhere determine their own affairs!