The Truth On Iraq: It's Devastated

langeweile said:
Your assesment on isolationism is correct. Even I have a hard time resisitng it. With all the whining that goes on about what we do and what we don't do, it makes it hard to stay positive.

I would love for us to step back and let some of the armchair quarterbacks run the show namely France, Germany, Russia, China and Canada.

I posted a thread about 6-9 months ago asking if the US should just pull it's military back to the US and roll up the bridges. It degenerated into a US bashing thread (inevitable I guess) but I think it's an option that is being explored. Rummy announced quite a while back that we were going to move 70k troops home, from Germany (why we have a single guy there is beyond me - lazy farking euros), South Korea and Japan. I think this is a phase one.

If Iraq ends badly for the US (a HISTORICAL CERTAINTY says Ranger) it will have a Vietnam effect on the US. We will move in a huge way back to isolationism. Genocide in Africa - send a couple of guys, peace with Israel - send money. We could easily descend into a Japan like foreign policy - send money to people we want to sell stuff to.

The funny thing is, even when candidates run on anti-American platforms (current President of South Korea let's say), when they get in power we're all of a sudden a good friend.

I can only imagine the tax cut I could get if we'd let the EU protect the world for a while and stay home;-) Anyone want to buy a dozen aircraft carriers?

OTB
 
danmand said:
Why stop there? Let the poor people everywhere determine their own affairs!

Like in Sudan, Somalia, Yugoslavia, Kuwait, the West Bank and Gaza......

I like it actually.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
...Kuwait...

OTB

People in Kuwait are poor? And you mean all this time the people in the West Bank and Gaza have enjoyed total self-determination? Wow.

As I've said many, many, many times in this forum, the question is not whether the US should become more or less isolationist, it's that they should exercise better judgement in doing so. Being an expansionist for transparently self-interested motives is no better than being an isolationist for the same reasons.
 
onthebottom said:
Like in Sudan, Somalia, Yugoslavia, Kuwait, the West Bank and Gaza......

I like it actually.


With the possible exception of Yogoslavia, none of your examples are better off because of western intervention.

Let us agree on the objective of letting people everywhere, rich and poor, determine their own affairs.
 
Notice that OTB *doesn't* answer the question, even remotely. He just makes vague references to past wars and opinion.
LOL
Wow.
 
Drunken Master said:
People in Kuwait are poor? And you mean all this time the people in the West Bank and Gaza have enjoyed total self-determination? Wow.

I was thinking poor from an "oppressed by US foreign policy" perspective not economic.

Drunken Master said:

As I've said many, many, many times in this forum, the question is not whether the US should become more or less isolationist, it's that they should exercise better judgment in doing so. Being an expansionist for transparently self-interested motives is no better than being an isolationist for the same reasons.

I guess some would say we're guilty of one and Canada another.

OTB
 
Ranger68 said:
Notice that OTB *doesn't* answer the question, even remotely. He just makes vague references to past wars and opinion.
LOL
Wow.

Put me back on ignore.

OTB
 
I've got you on Ignore, OTB.
:)
I can't help it if people quote the idiots in here.
LOL

Don't tell me what to do Lange.
I thought YOU'D put ME on Ignore.
Guess you were lying.
 
yychobbyist said:
Should we all put you on ignore or just Ranger?

Well I was quoting Ranger and the term "back" would seem to indicate I was previously on ignore. Fine line between smartass and dumbass.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I don't think you are the least bit sensitive but I'll answer a direct question (a rare event on TERB).

I think many people don't view any war as valid, that unless directly attacked a country should never go to war. People felt this way in 1915, 1935, 1965, 1990 and now. I can understand this.

I think a majority of Americans are uncomfortable with our foreign affairs beyond aid and trade. PJ O'Rourke had a great line, why do we need a foreign policy, sure we deal with foreigners but we deal with dogs and we don't have a dog policy. Americans are isolationist by nature, I've been saying for 2 years that the backlash to Afghanistan and Iraq will be a much more isolationist US.

Many are suspect of our military (in and out of the US), to use that power is to invite disaster. They worry about Ike's "Military Industrial Complex" and see Halliburton conspiracies everywhere.

I think some didn't see Iraq as any threat to the US directly, or US interests. The strength of this argument I think is, why now. Why not wait.

That answer your question.

OTB

Well, no. It doesn’t tell me what you think. You take no clear position. But you have defined generally that some people do not recommend war, regardless, others say the US should have waited, and still others that compare dealing with foreigners as similar to dog control, whatever that means. The answer is eye-wash. It doesn’t get to the core issues. To use your word, the answer is a deflection, avoiding the responsibility of ownership. Remember Powell, you guys just ‘bought it’ (when you broke it.)

It does not speak to the current issue of America invading another country, why they invaded, nor what they should do now, that the invasion is, to put it mildly, a mess. If you feel honestly that the US should not have invaded Iraq, as you seem to imply, I for one would like to hear why, from the heart. It would speak to your character as man, and to me that’s significant for me personally, to understand your point of view (truthfully) in as much as it represents some portion of the 59,000,000 Americans that are behind this debacle.

The fact that you would elect a President in the first place that has never been anywhere outside the US, makes perfect sense in terms of a lack of concern for US isolationism. The fact that this President, the one who has never been anywhere, as soon as he has the reins, immediately invades another country and then destroys it, is one thing, but for those same people to continue their support, without questioning properly the issues, is another. I think we are all questioning the issues, and therefore yes I am sensitive to your answers. Especially because you are a microcosm spokesman for the prime movers of this whole affair.

The answer was more a doctor treating the symptoms of the illness, not proposing a cure.
 
It's a total deflection Mcluhan.
Because they HAVE no answer.
There WERE no WMDs. Iraq WAS no threat. It's NOT about freeing the Iraqi people.
50% of Americans now think that the invasion was a mistake. This number is sure to rise.
Come on, guys - get ahead of the wave.
 
BTW, I think America entering the war in 1915 WAS a mistake. WWI was sheer idiocy - imperial ambition and paranoia run amok - and led *directly* to WWII. 1965 was a mistake to, I think most would agree. No?

In 1990 they had the full support of the UN - read, the rest of the world. Few nations were opposed to the coalition mission to eject the Iraqis from Kuwait. And that's where Bush Sr., rightly, stopped. You see, he *cared* about what the rest of the world thought - about the primacy of international law.

In 1935, nobody was at war, and nobody - but NOBODY - was proposing another war to stay Hitler's hand at that point. The policy of appeasement, which came to the fore a few years later, turned out to be (probably) a mistake, in the end - but Hussein was no Hitler. ;) Iraq was more a case of *tolerance* over outright war. Hussein was in no position to demand appeasement - it was the other way around.
 
No Ranger and Mcluhan, we just don't have the answer that you want to hear.
The both of you are a prime example of why Americans don't give a shit about the rest of the world.

Both of you consistently speak down to us and you constantly ask questions, which you expect a certain answer. if you don't get what you expect you ignore us or put us off as idiots.

Your whole attitude towards Americans is that we are just a bunch of stupid, uneducated rednecks that don't know shit about the rest of the world. You acuse us being loud and obnoxius and constantly critize every move we make.

Guess what? Some of the adjectives that you put on Americans, fit very well on to Canadians, Europeans, Russians to every other country of the world.
I have lived in four different countries for an extended period of time and by far the USA is the best place to live.

Assholes and Rednecks are alive and well in evry part of the world. In very single post of yours there is at least one deragatory comment on the USA. How do you think you going to engage us in a serious discussion? If all you want play is " Gotcha". Just the arrogancei n that kind of behaviour makes you look stupid.
Americans are as diverse as any other country i have lived in. Your narrow minded view of Americans shows your lack of education and tolerance.

Do you really think that we don't see through your childish games. The "Gotcha" game is very popular all over the world. Unless you are interested in a true exchange of ideas, you will never get to the heart of the matter.
IMHO
 
langeweile said:
No Ranger and Mcluhan, we just don't have the answer that you want to hear.
The both of you are a prime example of why Americans don't give a shit about the rest of the world. IMHO

Actually I don't lump any on my American friends into this basket...but its your perspective.

I take it you see yourself as a redneck then? I do have a couple of reneck buddies, ex-pats living abroad. You could be right about them, let me think on it..
 
We're still waiting for an answer.
Any answer.
What "good reasons" (in your opinion) did the US have for invading?

blah blah blah "Nobody likes us." waa waa waa "You guys are a bunch of children." blah blah blah "You think we're all stupid. You just hate us so much." blabbedy blah blah blah

Spare me your rhetoric. If that's all you've got, just admit you have no answer and put us back on Ignore.
Please.