The Truth On Iraq: It's Devastated

Ranger68 said:
The Islamists are NOT in power in Iran - this was an Islamic Revolution, with little to do with the Islamists involved in these affairs.
The VAST majority of the Islamists are Arab. Iran is primarily Persian. It is no surprise that few of the Al Qaeda or associated Islamist terrorist operatives who have been captured or are being sought are Iranian. There is little doubt that the Iranians sponsor terrorism - they aren't part of the Islamist movement, though. The Islamists detest the ruling Shia theocracy as much as anybody.

Afghanistan is the one example - and it may be a telling one, since they came to power after a very similar episode to the one we're looking at - the defeat and withdrawal of the USSR.

May there be something akin to an *Islamic Revolution*? Involving Iranian influence? Drawing them closer into the Iranian sphere? Perhaps. Again - the law of unintended consequences. This would *still* have nothing to do with the Islamists.

I don't know where to start on this one because starting necessarily means I'll have to write fourteen posts worth of response. So, I will say this. I disagree. I stand by my earlier post.
 
bbking said:
Reasons to invade

Trying to invalidate the Iraq war because of the lack of actual WMDs is just dumb. Let me ask you a question - lets suppose Sadaam did the smart thing and agreed to the US and UN demands and ended up with everyone agreeing that Sadaam's Iraq didn't have any WMDs in it's arsenal. Do you honestly belive it ends there?
bbk

BBK Saddam actually did comply with the WMD inspections..in fact he was practically down on his hands and knees pleading with the US...at least by Arab standards...the US went to war because the the architects of the invasion (singled out in the excerpt below), and the people whose financial interests they represent, wanted the invasion. Plain and simple. The questions behind their wanting war are of much more significance.

A bigger issue (i find) is why was there was such a massive intellegence failure, one that promoted/justified the acts of war...and in fact, how is it that an administration such as this one can get away with warping an agency like the CIA, to a point where based on lies, an invasion can occur and to such a disasterous outcome .. things like that are sort of important not to be swept under the rug...that is if you want a credible leadership in charge of the most powerful military in the world...

For example the asbestos law suit that haliburton just settled for a couple of billion in damages, which had its engineering division under bankruptcy protection...now out BTW..reasons like that, and more.

http://msnbc.msn.com/id/6814437/
Long before President Bush gave the orders, using force to topple Saddam was a glint in the eye of the civilians who would become key players in the Bush administration.

In 1998, a neoconservative think tank called the Project for the New American Century wrote to President Clinton, “The only acceptable strategy is one that eliminates the possibility that Iraq will be able to use or threaten to use weapons of mass destruction. In the near term, this means a willingness to ‘undertake military action.’�

A list of those who signed the 1998 letter include Donald Rumsfeld, Paul Wolfowitz, Richard Perle, Elliot Abrams, and John Bolton.

In addition to those who signed the 1998 pronouncement, Perle and two of his top associates had already urged an aggressive new strategy in 1996. Perle’s group embraced overthrowing Iraq’s Saddam and replacing him with a monarchy that would “redefine Iraq.�

In 1998, after Iraq severed ties with the U.N. commission in charge of weapons inspectors, Congress passed the Iraqi Liberation Act. It called for arming rebel forces, but did not advocate U.S. military involvement.
 
Ranger68 said:
The Islamists are NOT in power in Iran - this was an Islamic Revolution, with little to do with the Islamists involved in these affairs.
The VAST majority of the Islamists are Arab. Iran is primarily Persian. It is no surprise that few of the Al Qaeda or associated Islamist terrorist operatives who have been captured or are being sought are Iranian. There is little doubt that the Iranians sponsor terrorism - they aren't part of the Islamist movement, though. The Islamists detest the ruling Shia theocracy as much as anybody.

Afghanistan is the one example - and it may be a telling one, since they came to power after a very similar episode to the one we're looking at - the defeat and withdrawal of the USSR.

May there be something akin to an *Islamic Revolution*? Involving Iranian influence? Drawing them closer into the Iranian sphere? Perhaps. Again - the law of unintended consequences. This would *still* have nothing to do with the Islamists.

This is taking a very narrow view of the Islamist movement, which can easily work simultaneously within government and oppositionist factions - the dominance of Wahabism in Saudi society for example, both among those who support and those who oppose the ruling monarchy. The fact is the Iranians were thee Islamists-du-jour in 1979.

The divide by racial lines is certainly a reality, although it is worth noting that the population of Iran is in fact only 51% Persian. I'm sure the Iranian government - and people - feel much of the push and pull of radical Islam that is felt in many other countries.

The point that there is no unified "Islamist" movement or that just because a government is a theocracy must mean it supports Al-Quaeda is well-taken.
 
yychobbyist said:
Well, give the guy a break. He could be having dinner or spending time with his kids or doing something productive.

Or maybe he is taking time of from the political forum to see an SP? This is afterall the Toronto Escort Review Board.
 
Question for Langeweile

Mcluhan said:
is it fact or fiction? As you are a proud funding source, you would probably know..

" As much as 50 percent of federal income taxes (which does not include trust funds like Social Security or Medicare) go for past and present military spending, according to a federal budget analysis.

Langeweile, in case you missed this question... I am interested to know if you support this 'way of life'. ..does it conflict with 'the dream' etc.
 
Mcluha,

Not the first time I've answered a question I wasn't asked;-). While I've supported the war from Day 1 I can understand why some do not (that was the question I answered).

So, I'll take another shot, your question is what do I think.

I'll answer this (on my blackberry so it may come in a series of posts with typos) in two way, why I supported the war on Day 1 and why I still support it.

Cont...

OTB
 
YYC was right, been with the family.

Day 1 reasons:

A) I thought Iraq had WMD and would use them again against their neighbours.

B) I viewed this as a threat to US interests, a threat to the global economy and eventually Israel and the US.

C) I belived that containment would continue to crumble, that the humanitarian crisis the oil-for-stuff program caused (or was scapegoated with by Iraq) ment that sooner or later (I thought sooner so France, Germany and Russia could get paid on their contracts)
OTB
 
D) I belived that after containment Iraq would accelerate it's WMD program (I was most worried about Nuke) and it's delivery options (missle - artillary, terror). In fact a ship going anywhere in the world would be a simple delivery mech for a nule. I'd read an article that one CIA estimate said Iraq was within 5 years of having a nuke - that kind of did it for me.

E) There was no way to control Saddam after containment - deterence wouldn't work (he had no care for the loss of his people).

Cont

OTB
 
F) Many on this board made me realize the cost of containment - I was referred to a UN site that said 35,000 children under 10 were dieing every year. This says nothing of the costs to the adult population, the Stalinst government that Saddam had brought to Iraq.

G) A critical calculation for me - there was no low cost (in human terms) solution. If containment worked many died, if containment ended (as it leagally should have given Blix was right - more on that later) I thought many would die

OTB
 
G cont) many would die because Saddam would go back to attacking the Shiits, Kurds and his neighbours.

H) I don't think Iraq was involved in terrorism (beyond paying kids in Palistine to blow themselves up) it was too incompetant to work outsides it's borders.

Cont...

OTB
 
I) 911 chaned my mindset regarding threats to the US, better to do what the troops call FISH (fight in someone elses house) and take Saddam out while we could. I thought he was a threat, I thought there was no low-cost (humanitarian) solution and I thought that we would leave a democracy behind after we left.

Cont...

OTB
 
J) I thought if the US was so comitted in the ME we would put our full weight (insert fat American joke here) behind getting the Palistinians their own country.

If you really have no life you can find each of these points in TERB posts by me in 2003 and 2002.

Cont...

OTB
 
Now, why do I still support the war:

I think Saddam would have reconstituted a WMD program and kill hundreds of thousands and threaten our interests. There was no low-cost solution to Saddam. I think the Iraqi people will be better off after we leave than they would have been had we never invaded. It also really pisses off the French - not a reason, just a bonus.

What worries me:

In war innocent people die, and they didn't get to make this decision.

Cont...

OTB
 
Worries cont... It has caused a rift with old europe and we really need unarmed socialists as allies - that was a joke. We need to work closer with europe and Russia and this has made that harder. This war is a great tool for OBL to spread hate of the US. This has hurt US credibility - and made it harder for us to get consensus going forward.

Flame away!

OTB
 
you complain about U.S. - bashing and then write crap like this!

HC - Bland,

Go rent a sense of hummor as I'm quite sure you can't afford to buy one.

And I don't worry about US bashing.

OTB
 
Originally posted by Mcluhan Pissing off the French is some level of achievment. These two republics have a love hate relationship. :) I used to live with a Frenchwoman...I understand!

If you can't slag the French and have fun you are living a sad and shallow life.

OTB
 
yychobbyist said:
I don't know where to start on this one because starting necessarily means I'll have to write fourteen posts worth of response. So, I will say this. I disagree. I stand by my earlier post.

Okay. But the Islamists - as representative of those in Al Qaeda, say - are most certainly NOT in power in Iran. They're *Islamic*, not Islamists.
Anyway ........