The Truth On Iraq: It's Devastated

Ranger68 said:
Its MUCH worse to have foreigners in your country killing your own citizens than for countrymen to kill countrymen. The insurgents at least might seem to be fighting for your country.

Pol Pot. I generally agree with you on Iraq, it's just that you tend to make broad statements in black and white. Some of thw worst genocides in history have come from people killing their own countrymen. It took a foreign invasion from Viet Nam to finally put a stop to him. after he had killed hundreds of thousands if not millions.
 
Ranger68 said:
That doesn't entitle the US to intervene when and where they choose to put the guys it likes in power.
THAT'S the point.
When they do so, they cause more problems than existed in the first place.

in your opinion
 
Pol Pot was a *dictator*, not an insurgent fighting against a foreign aggressor, and he was pursuing a campaign of effective genocide.
Plus, I'd bet that if the US had invaded *there* the Cambodians would have fought with more tenacity against the Americans than against Pol Pot.
In what way does this disprove what I'm saying? That people will much more readily take up arms against a foreign aggressor than against a native one?
 
Originally posted by Ranger68
That doesn't entitle the US to intervene when and where they choose to put the guys it likes in power.
THAT'S the point.
When they do so, they cause more problems than existed in the first place.


red said:
in your opinion

And mine... as well I think Ranger speaks for 98.7% of the thinking, literate population of Canada on this one..not that it matters much to the scheme of things...add Sweden, denmark, Italy, france etc etc... lol..
 
Mcluhan said:
Originally posted by Ranger68
That doesn't entitle the US to intervene when and where they choose to put the guys it likes in power.
THAT'S the point.
When they do so, they cause more problems than existed in the first place.




And mine... as well I think Ranger speaks for 98.7% of the thinking, literate population of Canada on this one..not that it matters much to the scheme of things...add Sweden, denmark, Italy, france etc etc... lol..

while most canadians did not support the invasion of iraq- its a stretch to say that 98.7% of canadians believe that the US causes more problems than existed in the first place. but even if they did- doesn't make it true
 
danmand said:
Come to think of it, were you not putting words in my mouth when you said:

"as for iraq- the ones trying to rebuild their country are collaborators? nice. so you support civilian iraqis being killed by the "insurgents"?"

yes- i guess I did misinterpret what you were saying. So then - do you think those working to rebuild their country are collaborators?
 
red said:
while most canadians did not support the invasion of iraq- its a stretch to say that 98.7% of canadians believe that the US causes more problems than existed in the first place. but even if they did- doesn't make it true

An Iraqi is 2.5 times more likely to die now than before the war started, most likely by violence.
You got anything to back up *your* opinion?
 
If the civilian population is not part of the equation of war, then war is out of hand. War has been out of hand for quite some time now. Everything went on the table in WWII, including civilian casulties as an acceptable consequence, if not outright strategy. It was a departure of human consciousness, away from what civilization might have otherwise been, had they not gone down that road. The Japanese killing civilians in China probably started the ball rolling. The Americans put the the big cherry on the cake by nuking cities. It doesn't make it right. In my book, its wrong.
 
Let's put this poll another way, 50% of Americans now agree with Canada's position on the War in Iraq.

New Gallup Poll Finds 50% of Public Saying Invasion of Iraq a Mistake

By E&P Staff

Published: January 12, 2005 10:20 AM ET

NEW YORK
A new Gallup poll released this morning finds Americans tilting against the war in Iraq, with 50% now saying it was a mistake to send U.S. troops into Iraq, while 48% say it was not. These results show a slight increase since mid-November in the percentage saying it was a mistake.

Last year at this time, 59% said it was worth going to war in Iraq.

The poll, conducted Jan. 7-9, finds 56% of Americans disapproving the way President Bush is handling the situation in Iraq, up from 51% in November. Just 42% approve.

When Americans were asked how well things are going for the war in Iraq, 40% say they are going well, and 59% say they are going badly. This is a decline of 6% in optimism since September.

There is a clear partisan divide, with 82% of Republicans saying it was not a mistake to send troops to Iraq, while 79% of Democrats say it was a mistake.

In another finding, 71% say it is unlikely peace and internal security will be established in Iraq in the coming year.

In an intersting sidelight, the Gallup organization provided results from past polls showing how the public viewed the Vietnam War while it was still underway, contrasting this with the current view that 50% of Americans feel it was a mistake to invade Iraq.

This chart showed that the share of Americans who believed it was mistake to send troops to Vietnam did not reach 50% until August 1968, three years into the heavy U.S. troop involvement in Vietnam, meaning the criticism of the Iraq decision is a year ahead of that schedule.

In November 1966 the negative view in Vietnam was only endorsed by 31%, and in July 1967 it reached 41%. After reaching 53% in August 1968, it hit 60% in January 1971.

Polls in 1995 and 2000 found about 70% holding this negative view.
 
Ranger68 said:
An Iraqi is 2.5 times more likely to die now than before the war started, most likely by violence.
You got anything to back up *your* opinion?

Well - I am not sure how accurate any statistics under saddam's ministry of information are, so I can't comment on whether your quoted statistic is true or not. but

is this the americans fault? do you blame the violence on the americans rather than on the "insurgents"?
 
Mcluhan said:
If the civilian population is not part of the equation of war, then war is out of hand. War has been out of hand for quite some time now. Everything went on the table in WWII, including civilian casulties as an acceptable consequence, if not outright strategy. It was a departure of human consciousness, away from what civilization might have otherwise been, had they not gone down that road. The Japanese killing civilians in China probably started the ball rolling. The Americans put the the big cherry on the cake by nuking cities. It doesn't make it right. In my book, its wrong.

civilian populations have been put to the sword many times before wwii

I don't think anyone is walking around saying this is great.
 
red said:
yes- i guess I did misinterpret what you were saying. So then - do you think those working to rebuild their country are collaborators?

I think that the Iraqis working for the american occupation forces are trying to support their families in a desperate situation. I also think that they will be abandoned when the US leaves, and that they then will be considered collaborators and delt with rather harshly. Personally, I would not judge them.

PS: And I am sorry I misinterpreted your position on the war.
 
red said:
Well - I am not sure how accurate any statistics under saddam's ministry of information are, so I can't comment on whether your quoted statistic is true or not. but

is this the americans fault? do you blame the violence on the americans rather than on the "insurgents"?

These people weren't being killed until the Americans invaded. So, yes - it's the Americans' fault. It is the Americans' fault that many insurgents feel the need to fight.

Do you really think that a similar number of people was being killed on a daily basis in Iraq before the invasion? If you do, there's probably no hope for you.

Again, do you have anything to back up *your* opinion? ...... No? ...... Not surprising.
 
red said:
civilian populations have been put to the sword many times before wwii

I don't think anyone is walking around saying this is great.

Civilian populations have generally *not* been "put to the sword", except during "barbarian" invasion.

The Second World War reached new lows of genocide and *massive* civilian massacre. NEVER in warfare have such a high percentage of the casualties been civilian. Never.
 
danmand said:
I think that the Iraqis working for the american occupation forces are trying to support their families in a desperate situation. I also think that they will be abandoned when the US leaves, and that they then will be considered collaborators and delt with rather harshly. Personally, I would not judge them.

" ...Three weeks ago, a friend of mine who is a sheikh from Baquba visited me in Baghdad and we had lunch with Abdulla, an older professor who is a friend of his. As we were eating, Abdulla expressed a sentiment now widely heard. "The mujahideen," he said, "are fighting for their country against the Americans. This resistance is acceptable to us."

Dahr Jamail, reporter.

]
 
bbking said:
The Iraqis fighting the Americans and the current Iraq government are very much the minority - mind you a very loud minority but a minority never the less.

Your so called collaborators are the majority and as such - no matter what happens will never face harm.

As usual, you have no clue. The insurgents in occupied Europe during WW2 were a very small minority, much smaller than the number of people who collaborated with the Germans. After the war ended, the collaborators were delt with very harshly, indeed.
 
Mcluhan said:
Manji, I like your spunk! I'd like to play on your team...now, if we could get you pointed in the right direction! lol


Thanks Mcluhan...
No hard feelings I hope....

Maybe its my youth (though I don't really know how old you guys are...) but I am a little feisty....
Or as you said, I do got a lot Spunk which is why I'm on this board...

(Sorry, been drinking tonite and I should not be on the P&IA section at all .... especially with Ranger jumpin on my ass for every little mistake....)

Will continue this heated debate tomorrow when I'm a little more coherent....


Take it easy...