The Truth On Iraq: It's Devastated

red said:
no - its not the point. people are killed during a war- and no it was not a paradise. whether you support the war in iraq or not or in viet nam or not - lets not pretend that the north vietnamese were a bunch of nice guys and that everyone in the south wanted to live in a communist wonderland

That doesn't entitle the US to intervene when and where they choose to put the guys it likes in power.
THAT'S the point.
When they do so, they cause more problems than existed in the first place.
 
islandboy said:
No guys, the point is that there was an advanced organization in Vietman able to fill the vacuum. In Iraq all you have are disorganized gorrilla's/freedom fighters. There are to many groups who will want control if there is nothing viable in place. If you do not like the comparison to the Lebanese situation, then think of the Sudan. Another mess.
Ranger, as regards paradise, the war was no where near as hard on the general populace as the hard transition which followed but with no resisting civil groups the transition did work out. That is not the case here.

"Disorganized gorillas"??
Yikes.
LOL

Seriously, I think the US would like to portray it that way - that the Iraqis couldn't organize / defend / protect themselves, but I think that's far from the truth.

You're kidding yourself that the Viet Nam war wasn't as hard on the population as the transition that followed. Kidding yourself. The same applies here.
 
Manji said:

Blah Blah Blah!!!
My point was the invaders can win on foreign turf. A sucess is a sucess. Whether you want to put a time limit on a victory and how long that time limit should be is another debate altogether.

Not in recent memory, they can't.
Nope. Nuh-huh. Hasn't happened.
Unless the US is going to turn into a dictatorship and totally ignore popular opinion, which is becoming FIRMLY against the occupation.

In any case, your prognostications are proving false - as Powell said, the US is commencing withdrawal effective immediately. They'll be gone in a year.
 
Manji said:
The operation to take Fallujah was not designed to make friends. It was designed to take and pacify the city and elminate/capture insurgents.

The US military knew going in that Iraqis in Fallujah were going to hate them more than ever after the siege. The military can live with that as long as the citizens of Fallujah are incapable of assisting the insurgency.
The best the US can hope for after this operation is that by providing relief and reconstruction projects the people of Fallujah will be more preoccupied with living their lives then fighting the Americans.

Not just the Iraqis in Fallujah, my friend. But, that's the point - they won tactically, but have created more insurgents - a strategic loss.
 
Asterix said:
Too bad the Cambodians weren't quite so lucky once the US decided to cut and run.

Maybe the US should have just stayed out entirely, hmm?
Makes you think ......
Of course, the US was never *officially in* Cambodia. ;)
 
Manji said:

And you know what the Iraqis are thinking?
The opposition against the United States is already there but most of these Iraqis rather use non-violent actions to decide the fate of Iraq and their people.
Some of you people are making it seem that these Iraqi are violent and hate-filled creatures who rather forget about taking care of their families and go out kill Americans?

Put yourself in their shoes. What would you do? Would you make the best of a bad situation and provide for your family?
Or would you go grab an AK and run out and fight the Americans with the high probability of getting your ass blown off?

Somehow, Ranger; I don't think you would even leave your house to shake your fist at the Americans much less shoot at them....

Clearly, there are some who will choose non-violence. HOWEVER, there are some who will choose violence, especially given the poverty and sense of despair many of these people live with.

Nice argumentum ad hominem, though. ;)
Somehow, I don't think you're remotely capable of understanding the situation.

"The opposition against the United States is already there"?! With every Fallujah, every civilian killed, every mistaken bombing, the US creates MORE opposition - and yes, despite your best intentions, some of it will be violent. Some of it will come back to haunt the US, and all of us, in years to come.
 
Mcluhan said:
http://www.rjsmith.com/kia_tbl.html

Yes, somehow though, things were better during the war, when the US was there.
:rolleyes:
Yeah, just like things were worse under Saddam before the US came.
 
langeweile said:
Not strategic...political...unless that is what you mean...

Both. The US is fighting a war in Iraq, despite its declaration that "major combat operations have ended". Just like the US was fighting a war in Viet Nam.
Tactically, the Americans won practically every significant battle during the Vietnamese war. Strategically, they continued to lose ground while that was happening.
 
red said:
When did I call Mr. McCain a commie? - no where - you are putting words in my mouth to stay away from the point.

when did I say I was for killing anyone? - never- again -putting words in my mouth in an attempt to attack someone whose views you disagree with


Come to think of it, were you not putting words in my mouth when you said:

"as for iraq- the ones trying to rebuild their country are collaborators? nice. so you support civilian iraqis being killed by the "insurgents"?"
 
Ranger you nailed it. I thnk what manji *may* be missing, is what happens next, after a cluster bomb rips the legs of his little sister while she sleeps...
 
Ranger, you might be the one who does not understand the situation for the simple reason that you don't seem to understand people.
You got to get off your high horse and actually talk to people rather than talking down on them.

And just because I don't agree with you does not mean that I'm wrong.
Really, only time will tell who is right or wrong in this debate. This war can go either way.

And Mcluhan, with that kind of thinking that would mean more Iraqis would be against the insurgents than the Americans.
The insurgents have been killing more Iraqis than the Americans have with indisriminate bombings, attacks and executions.
 
Manji said:

And Mcluhan, with that kind of thinking that would mean more Iraqis would be against the insurgents than the Americans.
The insurgents have been killing more Iraqis than the Americans have with indisriminate bombings, attacks and executions.

Manji, I like your spunk! I'd like to play on your team...now, if we could get you pointed in the right direction! lol

The insurgents are killing civilians also, yes. But they do not account for the some 100,000 in friendly fire...nor the 1,000,000 under sanctions..

I will find some iraqi civilian blogs for you to read...standby pls... you can then absorb the true meaning of the words 'Iraqi Angst'
 
I think I understand people far better than you do - you who expect people whose lives are being ripped apart by a foreign invasion to all just peacefully go to the polls to register their opposition.

It is my stated, firm opinion that this war will go only one way. I'm sorry to tell you that. The US is already starting to withdraw, having stated that they don't partake in "nation building". Only "nation destroying", I suppose. When they leave, the pathetic excuse for a security organization they've left in place will prove totally inadequate to the task of protecting the government in power, which will fall within a month or two. It will be replaced, in time, by something organically chosen by the Iraqi people and those who *do* have the power - like in every other place on earth. The Iraqis will settle their own affairs. *AFTER* the US leaves. After the US leaves the place a shambles, I should say. The government which comes to power may very well be one which is very undesireable to the US administration. This is called "the law of unintended consequences". No matter how long the US stays, this will surely follow.

Fine - time will tell who is right and who is wrong. And someone *will be* wrong.

The problem with your final statement to mcluhan is that the invaders are foreigners. Its MUCH worse to have foreigners in your country killing your own citizens than for countrymen to kill countrymen. The insurgents at least might seem to be fighting for your country.
 
Introducing River's blog "Bagdad Burning"

manji...go here.. meet River!

Shes is my favourite iraqi blogger... if your read some of her posts..it will rip your heart out. I guarantee it!

http://riverbendblog.blogspot.com/

... I'll meet you 'round the bend my friend, where hearts can heal and souls can mend...
 
What some of you seem unable to grasp is the fact, that the war has been LOST. If you want any proof, consider the musings about creating death squads.
 
Monday March 29th was a post by River that really did rip my heart out...it took me awhile in the achives to find it...but here it is..in two parts

Baghdad Burning
... I'll meet you 'round the bend my friend, where hearts can heal and souls can mend...
Monday, March 29, 2004


Tales from Abu Ghraib...
At precisely 5 p.m., yesterday afternoon, my mother suddenly announced that we were going to go visit a friend of hers who had recently had a minor operation. The friend lived two streets away and in Iraqi culture, it is obligatory to visit a sick or healing friend or relative. I tried to get out of the social call with a variety of tired excuses. It was useless- my mother was adamant.

We left the house at around 5:40, with me holding a box of chocolate and arrived at the friend's house less than five minutes later. After the initial greetings and words of sympathy and relief, we all filed into the living room. The living room was almost dark; the electricity was out and the drapes were open to let in the fading rays of sun. "The electricity should be back at six…" my mother's friend said apologetically, "That's why we haven't lighted the kerosene lamps."

Just as we were settling down, a figure sitting at the other end of the living room rose in a hurry. "Where are you going?!" cried out my mother's friend, Umm Hassen. She then turned to us and made a hasty introduction, "This is M.- she's a friend of the family… she's here to see Abu Hassen…" I peered hard across the darkening room to get a better look at the slight figure, but I couldn't make out her features. I could barely hear her voice as she said, "I really have to be going… it's getting dark…" Umm Hassen shook her head and firmly declared, "No- you're staying. Abu Hassen will drive you home later."

The figure sat down and an awkward silence ensued as Umm Hassen left the living room to bring tea from the kitchen. My mother broke the silence with a question, "Do you live nearby?" She asked the figure. "Not really… I live outside of Baghdad… on the southern edges, but I'm staying with some relatives a few streets away." I listened to the voice carefully and could tell that the girl was young- no more than 20 or 25… probably less.

Just as Umm Hassen walked into the room with the tea tray, the lights in the house flickered back to life and we all murmured a prayer of thanks. As soon as my eyes adjusted to the glaring yellow lights, I turned to get a better look at Umm Hassen's guest. I had been right- she was young. She couldn't have been more than 20. She was wearing a black shawl, thrown carelessly over dark brown hair which was slipping out from under the head cover. She clutched at a black handbag and as the lights came back on, she shrank into herself at the far end of the room.

"Why are you sitting all the way over there?" Scolded Umm Hassen fondly, "Come over here and sit." She nodded towards a large armchair next to our couch. The girl rose and I noticed for the first time just how slight her figure was- the long skirt and shirt hung off of her thin body like they belonged to someone else. She settled stiffly in the big chair and managed to look even smaller and younger.

"How old are you,M. ?" My mother asked kindly. "Nineteen." Came the reply. "And are you studying? Which college are you in?" The girl blushed furiously as she explained that she was studying Arabic literature but postponed the year because… "Because she was detained by the Americans." Umm Hassen finished angrily, shaking her head. "She's here to see Abu Hassen because her mother and three brothers are still in prison."

Abu Hassen is lawyer who has taken on very few cases since the end of the war. He explained once that the current Iraqi legal system was like a jungle with no rules, a hundred lions, and thousands of hyenas. No one was sure which laws were applicable and which weren't; nothing could be done about corrupt judges and police and it was useless taking on criminal cases because if you won, the murderer/thief/looter's family would surely put you in your grave… or the criminal himself could do it personally after he was let out in a few weeks.

This case was an exception. M. was the daughter of a deceased friend and she had come to Abu Hassen because she didn't know anyone else who was willing to get involved.
 
Part II baghdad burning

On a cold night in November, M., her mother, and four brothers had been sleeping when their door suddenly came crashing down during the early hours of the morning. The scene that followed was one of chaos and confusion… screaming, shouting, cursing, pushing and pulling followed. The family were all gathered into the living room and the four sons- one of them only 15- were dragged away with bags over their heads. The mother and daughter were questioned- who was the man in the picture hanging on the wall? He was M.'s father who had died 6 years ago of a stroke. You're lying, they were told- wasn't he a part of some secret underground resistance cell? M.'s mother was hysterical by then- he was her dead husband and why were they taking away her sons? What had they done? They were supporting the resistance, came the answer through the interpreter.

How were they supporting the resistance, their mother wanted to know? "You are contributing large sums of money to terrorists." The interpreter explained. The troops had received an anonymous tip that M.'s family were giving funds to support attacks on the troops.

It was useless trying to explain that the family didn't have any 'funds'- ever since two of her sons lost their jobs at a factory that had closed down after the war, the family had been living off of the little money they got from a 'kushuk' or little shop that sold cigarettes, biscuits and candy to people in the neighborhood. They barely made enough to cover the cost of food! Nothing mattered. The mother and daughter were also taken away, with bags over their heads.

Umm Hassen had been telling the story up until that moment, M. was only nodding her head in agreement and listening raptly, like it was someone else's story. She continued it from there… M. and her mother were taken to the airport for interrogation. M. remembers being in a room, with a bag over her head and bright lights above. She claimed she could see the shapes of figures through the little holes in the bag. She was made to sit on her knees, in the interrogation room while her mother was kicked and beaten to the ground.

M.'s hands trembled as she held the cup of tea Umm Hassen had given her. Her face was very pale as she said, "I heard my mother begging them to please let me go and not hurt me… she told them she'd do anything- say anything- if they just let me go." After a couple hours of general abuse, the mother and daughter were divided, each one thrown into a seperate room for questioning. M. was questioned about everything concerning their family life- who came to visit them, who they were related to and when and under what circumstances her father had died. Hours later, the mother and daughter were taken to the infamous Abu Ghraib prison- home to thousands of criminals and innocents alike.

In Abu Ghraib, they were seperated and M. suspected that her mother was taken to another prison outside of Baghdad. A couple of terrible months later- after witnessing several beatings and the rape of a male prisoner by one of the jailors- in mid-January, M. was suddenly set free and taken to her uncle's home where she found her youngest brother waiting for her. Her uncle, through some lawyers and contacts, had managed to extract M. and her 15-year-old brother from two different prisons. M. also learned that her mother was still in Abu Ghraib but they weren't sure about her three brothers.

M. and her uncle later learned that a certain neighbor had made the false accusation against her family. The neighbor's 20-year-old son was still bitter over a fight he had several years ago with one of M.'s brothers. All he had to do was contact a certain translator who worked for the troops and give M.'s address. It was that easy.

Abu Hassen was contacted by M. and her uncle because he was an old family friend and was willing to do the work free of charge. They have been trying to get her brothers and mother out ever since. I was enraged- why don't they contact the press? Why don't they contact the Red Cross?! What were they waiting for?! She shook her head sadly and said that they *had* contacted the Red Cross but they were just one case in thousands upon thousands- it would take forever to get to them. As for the press- was I crazy? How could she contact the press and risk the wrath of the American authorities while her mother and brothers were still imprisoned?! There were prisoners who had already gotten up to 15 years of prison for 'acting against the coallition'... she couldn't risk that. They would just have to be patient and do a lot of praying.

By the end of her tale, M. was crying silently and my mother and Umm Hassen were hastily wiping away tears. All I could do was repeat, "I'm so sorry... I'm really sorry..." and a lot of other useless words. She shook her head and waved away my words of sympathy, "It's ok- really- I'm one of the lucky ones... all they did was beat me."