The "soccer players collapsing" thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not NBA, but there was a college player recently: https://www.usatoday.com/story/spor...florida-feels-blessed-to-be-alive/6772064002/

Also, NBA player sample size is tiny compared to all the professional soccer players around the world throughout the different leagues

Not sure if you are trying to link these to vaccine use but I can clearly state that the college basketball one above has nothing to do with the vaccine.

It occurred on December 12, 2020 before vaccines had even been used in the US yet.
 
Not sure if you are trying to link these to vaccine use but I can clearly state that the college basketball one above has nothing to do with the vaccine.

It occurred on December 12, 2020 before vaccines had even been used in the US yet
It could also be Covid thats causing it. But thats also concerning because vaccines are only 90% effective and that means 10% of the population could still get Covid and might go on to develop heart problems
 
Until I start seeing evidence the numbers have gone up, I wouldn't worry about it.
Like I pointed to above, in about 1/2 of the FIFA countries alone, the yearly average for collapses is about 150.
That's not even including other sports.
 
It could also be Covid thats causing it. But thats also concerning because vaccines are only 90% effective and that means 10% of the population could still get Covid and might go on to develop heart problems

No sure it's related to Covid.

Dr. Juneau of the Montreal Cardiology Institute is currently doing a study on why there so many heart failure casualties for athletes. Basic research proved that extensive training change the heart to bring more 'fibrillation' (not sure correct word in english) which can eventually lead to a stroke or heart failure. Another Dr. from the same institute is doing similar research with the Barcelone football team (barca) and other Spanish Olympic athletes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
No sure it's related to Covid.

Dr. Juneau of the Montreal Cardiology Institute is currently doing a study on why there so many heart failure casualties for athletes. Basic research proved that extensive training change the heart to bring more 'fibrillation' (not sure correct word in english) which can eventually lead to a stroke or heart failure. Another Dr. from the same institute is doing similar research with the Barcelone football team (barca) and other Spanish Olympic athletes
They've been training like that for decades though, so I dont see how that could be the cause
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
No sure it's related to Covid.

Dr. Juneau of the Montreal Cardiology Institute is currently doing a study on why there so many heart failure casualties for athletes. Basic research proved that extensive training change the heart to bring more 'fibrillation' (not sure correct word in english) which can eventually lead to a stroke or heart failure. Another Dr. from the same institute is doing similar research with the Barcelone football team (barca) and other Spanish Olympic athletes.

Fibrillation is the same word in English.
I presume these studies pre-date COVID?
(Like I said, this has been a thing going back quite some time.)
 
Fibrillation is the same word in English.
I presume these studies pre-date COVID?
(Like I said, this has been a thing going back quite some time.)

Not sure if it's pre covid or not.

It's proven that there has been much higher number of people affected (and dying) of blood clot since covid. But heart problem no. Not more then pre-covid I mean.

European football team make their player pass medical test few times per year. There is so much money involved they have no choice. The problem is current medical test are not enough for these highly trained player. The goal now is to find threshold or marks where a team will have to stop or slow down a players. Similar to the concussion protocol in the NHL.
 
They've been training like that for decades though, so I dont see how that could be the cause

Training yes I agree. But the style of playing has changed a lot. A 2016 study showed that players have increased sprinting by 50% in a decade. And since 2016 many teams adopt a schema with 2 lateral defender that makes continuous sprint up front... (like Davies...).

Is the extensive sprinting, and playing many more games per year then in the past, be the cause...?
 
Here is a study on athletes collapsing that was started in 2014.

Here's a 2016 paper.

2018: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12471-017-1061-5

Another 2016: https://www.acc.org/latest-in-cardi...ports-participation-and-sudden-cardiac-arrest
("In the United States, there are approximately 100 to 150 sudden cardiac deaths (SCD) during competitive sports each year." )

It seems particularly high in basketball, at least in the US from 2004-2008 according to this 2011 study.

Like I said, until I start seeing good numbers to compare year to year showing a significant rise, I am not going to think too much of this.
 
Couple of thoughts on this. We cannot say at all if these dudes collapsed because of COVID or the vaccine. There is a strong chance that is has nothing to do with any of that. Keep in mind, while these guys are in peak physical condition, certain heart conditions could be missed during routine examinations. I mean, if your a doctor looking at a ripped 22 year old, you're probably not going to be too concerned about their heart. So they miss something that happens later. Remember Jiri Fischer with the Red Wings. Dude was super healthy and nearly died on the bench due to an undiagnosed heart condition.

Also, there could be issues related to drug use. I mean, remember Len Bias? He didn't die or collapse on the court, but OD from cocaine. Or that dude who played for the Vikings and died of heat exhaustion during training camp. There are a lot of things that can happen and cause people to collapse.
 
Is the extensive sprinting, and playing many more games per year then in the past, be the cause...?
And a lot of this is driven by the ever increasing price to acquire and sign players. The owners have to maximize every revenue stream and squeeze out as much performance from the players as possible. The owners want (and rightfully so) to get their money's worth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jalimon
It’s not just happening more on the pitch, but also in the stands as well. I can’t remember any cases of fans having heart attacks in the stands before this year, but it’s happened several times at least this year in the premier league. Today 2 matches had to be suspended so fans could receive emergency medical attention and stretchered away to the hospital.

 
It’s not just happening more on the pitch, but also in the stands as well. I can’t remember any cases of fans having heart attacks in the stands before this year, but it’s happened several times at least this year in the premier league. Today 2 matches had to be suspended so fans could receive emergency medical attention and stretchered away to the hospital
I'm wondering though, is it happening more or are we just noticing it more??
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
I'm wondering though, is it happening more or are we just noticing it more??


I don’t know the exact stats and it could just be a coincidence but it’s more than I can ever remember.

Was also watching this match a month ago when it happened.

https://theathletic.com/news/fan-re...uspended-newcastle-vs-tottenham/0DKHojiOnxae/

A football stadium is one of the better places to have a cardiac arrest though. Most people don’t recover from it because they don’t have an emergency medical team on hand.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.