The NRA at it again

That's not what he's saying it all; converting a semi-auto AR to have full auto capabilities is not easy, cheap or legal. This is true regardless of what blackrock's friend of a friend says, to say otherwise is plain fear mongering. However, unpinning a magazine to revert it back to its original capacity is very simple. Again this isn't a semi-auto to full auto conversion he's talking about, it's a reduced capacity to normal capacity conversion.

More fairy tales. You've become the new FUJI with porridge in your ears. You been told and shown with references in this thread that it's not that hard and doesn't have be expensive. You've also been told more than once my personal source is not a 'friend of a friend'. Yes, it's illegal in Canada or the US, but people who wants this doe aren't really concerned about legalities. From what I understand, in some west European countries, the conversion is not legal , yet auto conversion parts are legally available. A conundrum I just don't understand.
 
I heard on the radio a very telling statement. "who protects the president's children? men with guns." A bright light came on in my head.
That's because you've been in the dark, this is a bill that protects all Presidents, their spouse and children, not because Obama wanted SS protection for his kids because of gun violence in schools.....the NRA knew this bill existed for almost 50 years as all Presidents get this but they were trying to make it look like only Obama is a hypocrite, why not Reagan or Bush, both NRA supporters...


Secret Service protection

Former presidents were entitled from 1965 to 1996 to lifetime Secret Service protection, for themselves and spouses and children under 16. A 1994 statute, (Pub.L. 103-329), limited post-presidential protection to ten years for presidents inaugurated after January 1, 1997.[SUP][5][/SUP] Under this statute, Bill Clinton would still be entitled to lifetime protection, and all subsequent presidents would have been entitled to ten years' protection.[SUP][6][/SUP]On January 10, 2013, President Barack Obama signed legislation reinstating lifetime Secret Service protection for himself, George W. Bush, and all subsequent presidents.[SUP][7][/SUP]
Richard Nixon relinquished his Secret Service protection in 1985, the first (and so far only) president to do so.[SUP][8][/SUP]
 
That's not what he's saying it all; converting a semi-auto AR to have full auto capabilities is not easy, cheap or legal. This is true regardless of what blackrock's friend of a friend says, to say otherwise is plain fear mongering. However, unpinning a magazine to revert it back to its original capacity is very simple. Again this isn't a semi-auto to full auto conversion he's talking about, it's a reduced capacity to normal capacity conversion.
There something that's always bothered me on this point and I have to ask now and let's see what the pro gun advocates have to say. I've heard Piers Morgan say on several of his programs directly to gun supporters, including members of the NRA and former military men who are experts on the AR 15 as they have them in their civilian life and used a M16 in the military, that he feels a basic AR 15 can shoot over a 100 runs in 90 seconds with minor changes and not one, I repeat, not one of the gun fanatics challenged him on that, not one!!! I find that unbelievable especially when someone from the military is familiar with both semi-auto and auto versions, and they are much more credible than any of you guys on this board. This has baffled me and based on crickets at this point I think Piers is right and it's not difficult to convert semi to auto.

That pissed me off as I really wanted someone to challenge Piers and get this cleared up once and for all. Obviously Piers is no expert, but his brother served in the military side by side with the Americans and his brother is the one who's educating him.

I just hired my own body guard........hmmmmm, I think my mind is changing, maybe AR 15's should not be banned, lol.

hellokitty_ar15assault_2.jpg
 
There something that's always bothered me on this point and I have to ask now and let's see what the pro gun advocates have to say. I've heard Piers Morgan say on several of his programs directly to gun supporters, including members of the NRA and former military men who are experts on the AR 15 as they have them in their civilian life and used a M16 in the military, that he feels a basic AR 15 can shoot over a 100 runs in 90 seconds with minor changes and not one, I repeat, not one of the gun fanatics challenged him on that, not one!!! I find that unbelievable especially when someone from the military is familiar with both semi-auto and auto versions, and they are much more credible than any of you guys on this board. This has baffled me and based on crickets at this point I think Piers is right and it's not difficult to convert semi to auto.

That pissed me off as I really wanted someone to challenge Piers and get this cleared up once and for all. Obviously Piers is no expert, but his brother served in the military side by side with the Americans and his brother is the one who's educating him.

I just hired my own body guard........hmmmmm, I think my mind is changing, maybe AR 15's should not be banned, lol.

Can't wait for the response either.

As far as your body guard is concerned, love the hello kitty touch.
 
AR 15 can shoot over a 100 runs in 90 seconds with minor changes

No changes...

AR15 can fire as fast as you can pull the trigger so 100 in 90 would imply you could pull the trigger that fast for that long, and that you had a magazine that big. It is a question of finger ability, can you really do it? Try now, how fast can you twitch?

Full auto would be much faster. A full auto M16 fires about 850 rounds per minute, exhausting a 100 round mag in about 7 seconds. No finger can twitch that fast.
 
No changes...

AR15 can fire as fast as you can pull the trigger so 100 in 90 would imply you could pull the trigger that fast for that long, and that you had a magazine that big. It is a question of finger ability, can you really do it? Try now, how fast can you twitch?

Full auto would be much faster. A full auto M16 fires about 850 rounds per minute, exhausting a 100 round mag in about 7 seconds. No finger can twitch that fast.

*crickets*
 
*crickets*

Really, so you and FUJI know more and then the gun advocates on the tv. The fact that a gun man wouldn't find it easy to pull the trigger a 100 times in one action doesn't mean he couldn't or that the gunman couldn't rip off a string of rounds in short order, even in semi auto setting. Then we still have the conversion question, which is still absolutely possible, can be easy and can be done at a reasonable cost.

As said in an earlier post no one has ever told Piers his claim is wrong on the conversion. Do you think they know something you don't?
 
Really, so you and FUJI know more and then the gun advocates on the tv. The fact that a gun man wouldn't find it easy to pull the trigger a 100 times in one action doesn't mean he couldn't or that the gunman couldn't rip off a string of rounds in short order, even in semi auto setting. Then we still have the conversion question, which is still absolutely possible, can be easy and can be done at a reasonable cost.

As said in an earlier post no one has ever told Piers his claim is wrong on the conversion. Do you think they know something you don't?

You can learn to "rip off a string of rounds in short order" with a manual action.


Still a far cry from actual full auto fire which is like 700-850 rounds per minute and making a big deal of firing "100 rounds in 90 seconds" is nothing but fear mongering.
 
You can learn to "rip off a string of rounds in short order" with a manual action.


Still a far cry from actual full auto fire which is like 700-850 rounds per minute and making a big deal of firing "100 rounds in 90 seconds" is nothing but fear mongering.


Really, more techno dribble? Why no drop into the conversation a tech report of the mini vulcan and say it could be worse? I'd love to see the size of the drum containing 700-850 rounds. A more practical rate of fire in full auto is around 150 rounds, but even then, the gun barrel might get a tad hot fast. any practical rate over 100 rounds runs a risk of heat damage.

mini vulcan gun - YouTube

It still doesn't take away the point that the AR-15 and its wannabes can easily be made a really deadly weapon, far more than most other rifles, meant for a basic purpose.
 
Are you unaware of the threat of assassination and/or kidnapping of himself or family members that the POTUS has to deal with?
Indeed as I've previously stated the First Family face real security threats. In what way does that fact make it untrue, that the President is perfectly comfortable with his own family having armed security, but seemingly doesn't feel that others could also benefit by having armed police in schools.
 
so 100 in 90 would imply you could pull the trigger that fast for that long, and that you had a magazine that big. It is a question of finger ability, can you really do it? Try now, how fast can you twitch?
Fuji although it has already been mentioned in this thread perhaps you should also have mentioned (yet again) that this is in common with ALL semi-automatic firearms. You can do the same thing with an M1 Garand.
 
It is hard to fathom what objective grounds there are for gun control in light of the fact that it doesn't work and isn't relevant.

It's hard to fathom in society in which has virtually no federal gun laws in effect and gun violence rate of 900 citizens dying monthly far outstripping most other modern countries (5 times that of Canada) - that there are people who instead of offering solutions argue for a status quo unless some other country proves more capable of protecting its citizens.

What a fucking, reckless position to accept the deaths of these kids and thousands of others without lifting a finger to effect a change. It doesn't take a high IQ to realize that no change will have zero effect. It isn't also a quantum leap of intelligence to realize that if the guns were not available - this crime wouldn't have happened and certainly not anywhere near the carnage level of the recent mass shootings. The NRA has removed the teeth to the ATF so that guns can flow unabated to every nut case in America and the response to mass shootings - blame the nut case - not the gun I gave him to murder the kids - is nothing short of evil self indulgence.

Any person who argues against the attempt to curb moves to remove assault weapons and limit their killing power is sociopath - what else can you possible conclusion for someone so callous about so many lives ?
 
Really, so you and FUJI know more and then the gun advocates on the tv. The fact that a gun man wouldn't find it easy to pull the trigger a 100 times in one action doesn't mean he couldn't or that the gunman couldn't rip off a string of rounds in short order, even in semi auto setting. Then we still have the conversion question, which is still absolutely possible, can be easy and can be done at a reasonable cost.

As said in an earlier post no one has ever told Piers his claim is wrong on the conversion. Do you think they know something you don't?

Sorry I think you fail at reading, I am agreeing with your advocates on TV that it can fire that fast. The claim you said was made on Piers was that you "can" fire it that fast, and that's true. I certainly can pull the trigger that quickly. After 100 pulls I bet my finger is getting pretty tired--certainly a 20 year old could manage it.

Now whether you could hit the broad side of a barn door while doing that is an entirely different question--the claim you made was simply that the AR15 could be fired that fast, and that's true--it fires as fast as you can pull the trigger, the limit here is human capability. The automatic version can fire 850 rounds per minute, and the AR15 could do that too if you could find a way to make a human finger move that fast.
 
Sorry I think you fail at reading, I am agreeing with your advocates on TV that it can fire that fast. The claim you said was made on Piers was that you "can" fire it that fast, and that's true. I certainly can pull the trigger that quickly. After 100 pulls I bet my finger is getting pretty tired--certainly a 20 year old could manage it.

Now whether you could hit the broad side of a barn door while doing that is an entirely different question--the claim you made was simply that the AR15 could be fired that fast, and that's true--it fires as fast as you can pull the trigger, the limit here is human capability. The automatic version can fire 850 rounds per minute, and the AR15 could do that too if you could find a way to make a human finger move that fast.

Isn't there a small add on (not sure what it is called) but which is readily available and which makes the AR15 fully automatic?
 
It's hard to fathom in society in which has virtually no federal gun laws in effect and gun violence rate of 900 citizens dying monthly

So first of all we need to be a little more careful with language here, "gun laws" can mean a variety of things. Gun control is only one type of gun law. Most people support some form of gun safety law--safety training to make sure people using firearms handle them properly, along with sensible background checks to make sure they aren't being given to people with criminal records or mental health problems. That stuff is not very controversial, most people agree with it.

The controversies all swirl around gun control, which is one particular type of gun law. Gun control are all those efforts to ban/confiscate/track/register firearms, even where they are owned and used by responsible people who have passed a background check and who have received appropriate safety training.

So your question reworded is whether it makes sense to have gun control in a nation that has a problem with gun crime.

For some reason I cannot fathom some of you seem to think it is "common sense" to have gun control as a reaction to gun crime, but it is not common sense at all, because there is literally no evidence that it does any good. So why would you enact a bunch of laws that you know will accomplish nothing, at great expense, and spend a lot of time and money on that, and inconvenience a whole lot of law abiding people, when you have no reason at all to think it makes a difference?

Let me say this categorically: The US does not have a gun crime problem, the US has a violent crime problem.

You have compared the US to other countries that have different gun policy, but if you are fair and honest, you will note that ALL crime categories are higher in the US, not only gun crime. Gun control policies are only capable of explaining gun crime. When you similarly see the US with higher rates of non-gun crimes, in the same proportion as gun crime, then it's clear that what's going on is some sort of general socio-economic/demographic crime problem, and not a gun problem.

As such, common sense says that if you have a socio-economic crime problem, you should be looking for socio-economic solutions. Let's be clear--the crime is primarily coming from street gangs involved in the drug trade, and other people in disadvantaged socio-economic situations. If we can fix those problems with better education, better opportunities, diverting trouble youth away from gangs with better after school programs, etc., we can probably make a big difference.

It is not clear that once someone is a criminal that you can stop them from committing acts of violence by trying to take away their tools.

Any person who argues against the attempt to curb moves to remove assault weapons and limit their killing power is sociopath - what else can you possible conclusion for someone so callous about so many lives ?

When you say "so many lives" let's be clear that you are talking about fewer people than are killed by lightning every year. It certainly makes for sensational TV news when it happens, but it kills very, very, very, very, very few people.
 
Stop for a moment and read what i write. Stop being ignorant and naive and so blinded by your hatred of guns that you don't even want to listen to the facts.

The above firearms i posted are IDENTICAL to each other in every aspect except looks. Both of them are NOT, i repeat are NOT an assault rifle. The second one looks like an assault rifle but it is not. You cannot own assault rifles in canada and there are very few in the united states, which btw cost upwards of 10,000 $ if you can get the government to allow you one and jump through all the hoops of paperwork to get it. Only realistic way you can have one is if you had it before 1986 and even then very few people had them.

If you are capable of understanding what i just wrote then you should be able to see the next point very clearly. You, the media, and other misinformed individuals point to the function of an AUTOMATIC ASSAULT RIFLE, which no one can pretty much have, and is not the AR 15, while trying to ban the AR 15. That's the equivalent of pointing to a dog while trying to ban a cat.

Automatic assault rifles and ar15s are a world apart, and no matter what anyone can tell you its not easy to convert it. Thats like saying a honda civic is essentially a ferrari once you swap the engine, transmission, all suspension components, wheels and modify the body to fit it all, therefore civics should be banned.

Do you see the stupidity in this?
You have been duped by the media and the law makers who want to appear that they are doing something, when in reality they just want the appearance of fixing the problem without doing anything at all, and its working since the average person has zero knowledge about firearms and will believe anything the are told.

Show a picture of a semi-auto dressed up in "assault-style" plastic, its evil and should be banned. Show the original gun in its normal formal and its a "hunting rifle" to them and they see nothing wrong with it.

"The ban is not based on appearance, but function and capability."/U]<---- That is the only difference! I can't stress this enough! The original assault weapon ban, the way it was written, banned any firearms that shared 2 cosmetic functions of assault riles.

The new law in new york proposes a ban on semi-auto firearms that share 1 cosmetic function of an assault rifle.

Here is the exact wording of the new law, im not lying to you, the media and law makers are, and you have fallen for it.

"Redefinition of an assault weapon from a two cosmetic feature test to a one feature test that includes any gun that meets the following criteria

1. Semiautomatic rifle that has an ability to accept a detachable magazine and has at least one of the following descriptions:

- a folding or telescoping stock
- a pistol grip that protrudes conspicuously beneath the action of the weapon
- a thumbhole stock
- a forward handgrip
- a bayonet mount
- a flash suppressor, muzzle break, muzzle compensator, or threaded barrel designed to accommodate a flash suppressor, muzzle break, or muzzle compensator
- a grenade launcher

2. Semiautomatic shotgun that has at least one of the following characteristics:

-a folding or telescoping stock
- a thumbhole stock
- a forward handgrip
- a fixed magazine capacity in excess of seven rounds
- an ability to accept a detachable magazine

3. Semiautomatic pistol that has an ability to accept a detachable magazine and has at least one of the following characteristics:

- a folding or telescoping stock
- a thumbhole stock (Please see above comment)
- a forward hand grip
- a capacity to accept an ammunition magazine that attaches to the pistol outside of the pistol grip
- a threaded barrel capable of accepting a barrel extender, flash suppressor, forward handgrip, or silencer
- a shroud that is attached to, or partially or completely encircles, the barrel and that permits the shooter to hold the firearm with the non-trigger hand without being burned
- a manufactured weight of fifty ounces or more when the pistol is unloaded
- a semiautomatic version of an automatic rifle, shotgun or firearm
"


hey blackrock still waiting for your response on this one.
 
Isn't there a small add on (not sure what it is called) but which is readily available and which makes the AR15 fully automatic?

Nope. The AR15 receiver is not capable of containing the automatic parts. To make an AR15 automatic you have to have heavy machine tools, and remove a lot of the metal from the inside of the receiver to make room for the automatic components. You then need to purchase those components (prohibited in Canada) and install them into your machined receiver.

A gun smith with a machine shop can do that work. Someone with machine tools at home MIGHT be able to do it as well--but there is a chance they could also weaken the integrity of the receiver by doing it improperly, with the possible result of having the entire gun explode in their face when they pull the trigger. A gun is essentially a pipe bomb that is open at one end, there are certain modifications you really should not try at home. Removing metal from the receiver is the firearms equivalent of tearing down walls without bothering to check whether they support the structure--you really want a gun smith to do it.

You maybe thinking of the FN FAL, which was Canada's service rifle before the AR15, and formerly a popular platform as well. There was a semi-automatic version of that rifle, but it turned out to be a simple drop-in modification to convert the semi- version back to a full-auto version. As a result the FN FAL is a prohibited weapon in Canada. While the AR15 can be made full auto by machining out the receiver, the fact that it requires metalworking means that it is not considered an easy modification and therefore the AR15 is not prohibited. (Even if some metalworking geeks claim they can do it easily, which maybe they can.)
 
Really, more techno dribble? Why no drop into the conversation a tech report of the mini vulcan and say it could be worse? I'd love to see the size of the drum containing 700-850 rounds. A more practical rate of fire in full auto is around 150 rounds, but even then, the gun barrel might get a tad hot fast. any practical rate over 100 rounds runs a risk of heat damage.

mini vulcan gun - YouTube

It still doesn't take away the point that the AR-15 and its wannabes can easily be made a really deadly weapon, far more than most other rifles, meant for a basic purpose.

Wow, your guise of having even some rudimentary gun knowledge is wearing thin, because now you're just making shit up about the M16/M4's cyclic rate in full auto. 700-850 rounds per minute is quite common, I'll give you the opportunity to save face and look it up on Wikipedia or ask your "gunsmith friend". But sensationalizing the cyclic rate of a semi-automatic firearm and trying to compare it to a fully automatic firearm is merely an exercise in fear mongering to the ignorant.
 
Indeed as I've previously stated the First Family face real security threats. In what way does that fact make it untrue, that the President is perfectly comfortable with his own family having armed security, but seemingly doesn't feel that others could also benefit by having armed police in schools.

because other people face a minimal possibility that a gunman will attack their children. The President would face a major possibility if not for the guards. Can you not distinguish between major and minor?
 
For some reason I cannot fathom some of you seem to think it is "common sense" to have gun control as a reaction to gun crime, but it is not common sense at all, because there is literally no evidence that it does any good. So why would you enact a bunch of laws that you know will accomplish nothing, at great expense, and spend a lot of time and money on that, and inconvenience a whole lot of law abiding people, when you have no reason at all to think it makes a difference?
But fuji, it's not just us. It is the majority of law abiding, peaceful, citizens of the U.S. that are pushing this agenda.

It looks like their version of common sense differs from yours. They want things done and done soon, because their common sense tells them that guns are dangerous. They are scared of what a gun does and want the number of guns reduced and/or better controlled. That is the version of common sense being played out right now by mostly law abiding rational citizens.