The NRA at it again

There are people on this thread who called a complete ban of all guns "utopia". Plainly, no matter what gun laws we have, those people will ALWAYS think one more round of restriction would be reasonable....

And what evidence do you have that the US (or Canadian) government has any intent of doing that?
 
That view does not have to be supported by a majority to be dangerous. It may be supported by a a large or perhaps small minority. It is frightening nonetheless. I just git back from Dallas on Monday and i can tell you that those views would be commonly held among the people I was meeting with and they were for the most part bankers.
First of all I didn't say it wasn't dangerous, I just wanted to clarify their extreme, outlandish views does not reflect the majority of gun advocates. I consider them quite irrational in their thinking, bordering on mentally unstable and that alone is dangerous when they have a weapon in their hands,

Second, Texas is one of the top gun supporting states so yes you would see a lot of support for guns but I don't think most Texans would consider a tank is their right to own. There are certain states that are more anti gun, ie. New York, where you would have a different experience than Texas.
 
Sorry but I don't want to dress up like a mall ninja, just give me my 20 round box mag. Banning it will never save even a single life.
and of course you have evidence of that as usual, lol. Common fuji, you're sounding just like the rest of them, getting too emotional, back up your claims, lose the rhetoric.
 
Well common sense tells me that someone who has decided to be a serious criminal by carrying a loaded gun won't be deterred by a high cap magazine law.
Doesn't mean we still shouldn't have a law to limit capacities of gun magazines.... police and the crown need this law to prosecute without red tape in the system. Still won't effect you or law abiding citizens.

fuji said:
I have properly limited magazines at home and I will never break the laws by using a dremel to remove the rivet in the magazine case.
I believe you but you're only one person, you can't guarantee that for the approximately 300 million people can you?

fuji said:
I am less sure that the laws will prevent a would be mass killer from removing the rivet...
Common sense would tell you the risk is lower to minimize mass murders, nothing will guarantee this, whether gun or no gun controls, but as I said risk is lower based on rational thinking. We make many decisions in life based on risk, ie. trading stocks, providing insurance, etc..., we all evaluate risk and try to make the best decision possible.
 
Doesn't mean we still shouldn't have a law to limit capacities of gun magazines....

So, you admit that it won't deter anyone from carrying out mass killings or any other crime, and yet you somehow think there is still a reason to ban them? Uh huh...

police and the crown need this law to prosecute without red tape in the system. Still won't effect you or law abiding citizens.

Absolutely it affects me as a law abiding citizen. All my magazines are unreasonably limited to 5 rounds, it affects me very much. And for no detectable benefit to society!

Why on earth would the police and crown want to prosecute law abiding citizens?!!?!? Makes no sense.

I believe you but you're only one person, you can't guarantee that for the approximately 300 million people can you?

Did you just miss the point? The magazine capacity limit can be moved in 5 minutes with a dremel. Only law abiding people like me are going to leave the rivet there.
 
So, you admit that it won't deter anyone from carrying out mass killings or any other crime, and yet you somehow think there is still a reason to ban them? Uh huh...
fuji, you're really losing it, something has happened to you recently. Stop trying to guess and interpret what you think someone is saying, just read what the person is saying at face value.

I'm going to repeat again for you, high capacity gun magazines should be limited in rounds so the criminals when caught can be easier and quickly prosecuted. Yes they should be banned, period.



fui said:
Absolutely it affects me as a law abiding citizen. All my magazines are unreasonably limited to 5 rounds, it affects me very much. And for no detectable benefit to society!

Why on earth would the police and crown want to prosecute law abiding citizens?!!?!? Makes no sense.
Who in the world said the police and crown want to prosecute law abiding citizens, my lord you make up things too. I said criminals, not law abiding citizens.
You have not said how it effects you, just rhetoric, your trademark. Tell us the pain this will cause. I propose whatever inconvenience you come up with, if you come up with anything, is a very small price to pay considering the effectiveness to limit access and expedite prosecutions. btw, the limit proposed is 10, not 5 rounds.



fuji said:
Did you just miss the point? The magazine capacity limit can be moved in 5 minutes with a dremel. Only law abiding people like me are going to leave the rivet there.

Are you trying to make a point or reinforcing your law abiding status. Actually you're now hurting your argument that AR 15's should not be banned, I heard they can be converted to automatic in 3 minutes, not 5, but let's use your 5 min, now you know why Obama wants to ban them, too easily converted to automatic and it happened to be the weapon of choice for the recent spade of mass murders by young males.
 
Remember when the NRA said the government should look at everything, except gun control of course, to reduce gun homicides? One of the main recommendations by the NRA was to look at all these video games as they feel it has an impact on young males by encouraging gun violence. Well, talk about hypocrisy, the NRA released a gun shooting app for iphone and ipad for kids to play with less than a month after the Newtown massacre.

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/nra-spits-graves-new-shoot-em-up-app-article-1.1240207
 
NRA’s threats over gun buyback tied to ALEC legislation



When an NRA official threatened legal action over the destruction of guns from a gun buyback event, he cited an Arizona law that sprung from a partnership between the NRA and the American Legislative Exchange Council, the conservative shop that pushes model legislation in state legislatures across the nation.
It began earlier this month in Tucson, Ariz., when city officials organized a gun buyback to mark the two-year anniversary of the Gabrielle Giffords shooting. Locals turned over their guns to law enforcement, and got a $50 Safeway gift card for each gun in return. Officials wound up destroying a total of 212 guns.
Before the guns were destroyed, Todd Rathner, an Arizona lobbyist and NRA national board member, threatened to file a lawsuit. “We do believe that it is illegal for them to destroy those guns,” he told NPR. “If property has been abandoned to the police, then they are required by ARS 12-945 to sell it to a federally licensed firearms dealer, and that’s exactly what they should do.”
The Tucson city attorney called Rathner’s interpretation a misreading of the law, and the city went ahead with destroying the guns anyway. Rathner, for his part, told the Arizona Daily Star: “If we can pass legislation faster, we’ll pass a law that says we’ll charge the city of Tucson and the Police Department some exorbitant amount of money for every firearm they destroy.” He added: “We’ll pursue it either through litigation or legislation.”
The threat brings light to a series of laws, pushed by the NRA and ALEC, that prevent states from destroying guns, and instead require law enforcement to auction them off (or, in some states, use the guns themselves). Arizona’s version of the law was signed by Gov. Jan Brewer, R-Ariz., herself a former member of ALEC, in April, 2012, as Brendan Fischer from ALEC Exposed points out.
But, as Bloomberg News reported in August, 2011, Arizona was not the only state to receive the model legislation, a “brainchild” of the NRA that was adapted by ALEC. The law, called the ”Firearms Destruction Prevention Act” and occasionally the “Disposition of Firearms in State and Local Custody Act,” also passed in Kentucky, Tennessee and Alaska, for instance, though failed in Alabama.
From Bloomberg at the time:
The model legislation was drafted and approved by ALEC’s public safety task force, which included representatives from stun-gun maker Taser International Inc. (TASR), energy conglomerate Koch Industries, the American Bail Coalition, and the NRA, according to ALEC documents. Corporate and special interest group members seeking to serve on task forces charged with writing legislative language can pay as much as $35,000 or more to get a seat at the table, according to ALEC’s web site.
​
ALEC’s public safety task force, which was also responsible for the “Stand Your Ground” laws, was technically broken apart in April of 2012 after some bad press in the wake of the Trayvon Martin shooting in Florida. The group said it would instead focus on economic issues and job creation.
But, Republican State Rep. Jerry Madden of Texas, who chaired the task force, admitted that work on the same issues will be transferred to other committees. ”ALEC’s decision won’t impact the important issues we’ve worked on,” Madden told the Christian Post.




 
I heard on the radio a very telling statement. "who protects the president's children? men with guns." A bright light came on in my head.
 
Back in post 35 I asked Fuji for data that he claimed he had that would prove his point.

One hundred someodd posts later still nothing.

That's the type of guy he is.

Here's an interesting article on where illegal guns come from in the US.

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/guns/procon/guns.html

Ask a cop on the beat how criminals get guns and you're likely to hear this hard boiled response: "They steal them." But this street wisdom is wrong, according to one frustrated Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (ATF) agent who is tired of battling this popular misconception. An expert on crime gun patterns, ATF agent Jay Wachtel says that most guns used in crimes are not stolen out of private gun owners' homes and cars. "Stolen guns account for only about 10% to 15% of guns used in crimes," Wachtel said. Because when they want guns they want them immediately the wait is usually too long for a weapon to be stolen and find its way to a criminal.


In fact, there are a number of sources that allow guns to fall into the wrong hands, with gun thefts at the bottom of the list. Wachtel says one of the most common ways criminals get guns is through straw purchase sales. A straw purchase occurs when someone who may not legally acquire a firearm, or who wants to do so anonymously, has a companion buy it on their behalf. According to a 1994 ATF study on "Sources of Crime Guns in Southern California," many straw purchases are conducted in an openly "suggestive" manner where two people walk into a gun store, one selects a firearm, and then the other uses identification for the purchase and pays for the gun. Or, several underage people walk into a store and an adult with them makes the purchases. Both of these are illegal activities.


The next biggest source of illegal gun transactions where criminals get guns are sales made by legally licensed but corrupt at-home and commercial gun dealers. Several recent reports back up Wachtel's own studies about this, and make the case that illegal activity by those licensed to sell guns, known as Federal Firearms Licensees (FFLs), is a huge source of crime guns and greatly surpasses the sale of guns stolen from John Q. Citizen. Like bank robbers, who are interested in banks, gun traffickers are interested in FFLs because that's where the guns are. This is why FFLs are a large source of illegal guns for traffickers, who ultimately wind up selling the guns on the street.


According to a recent ATF report, there is a significant diversion to the illegal gun market from FFLs. The report states that "of the 120,370 crime guns that were traced to purchases from the FFLs then in business, 27.7 % of these firearms were seized by law enforcement in connection with a crime within two years of the original sale. This rapid `time to crime' of a gun purchased from an FFL is a strong indicator that the initial seller or purchaser may have been engaged in unlawful activity."


The report goes on to state that "over-the-counter purchases are not the only means by which guns reach the illegal market from FFLs" and reveals that 23,775 guns have been reported lost, missing or stolen from FFLs since September 13, 1994, when a new law took effect requiring dealers to report gun thefts within 48 hours. This makes the theft of 6,000 guns reported in the CIR/Frontline show "Hot Guns" only 25% of all cases reported to ATF in the past two and one-half years.


Another large source of guns used in crimes are unlicensed street dealers who either get their guns through illegal transactions with licensed dealers, straw purchases, or from gun thefts. These illegal dealers turn around and sell these illegally on the street. An additional way criminals gain access to guns is family and friends, either through sales, theft or as gifts.


While many guns are taken off the street when people are arrested and any firearms in their possession are confiscated, a new study shows how easily arrestees believe they could illegally acquire another firearm. Supported by the National Institute of Justice and based on interviews with those recently arrested, the study acknowledges gun theft is common, with 13 percent of all arrestees interviewed admitting that they had stolen a gun. However a key finding is that "the illegal market is the most likely source" for these people to obtain a gun. "In fact, more than half the arrestees say it is easy to obtain guns illegally," the report states. Responding to a question of how they obtained their most recent handgun, the arrestees answered as follows: 56% said they paid cash; 15% said it was a gift; 10% said they borrowed it; 8% said they traded for it; while 5% only said that they stole it.


ATF officials say that only about 8% of the nation's 124,000 retail gun dealers sell the majority of handguns that are used in crimes. They conclude that these licensed retailers are part of a block of rogue entrepreneurs tempted by the big profits of gun trafficking. Cracking down on these dealers continues to be a priority for the ATF. What's needed, according to Wachtel, is better monitoring of the activities of legally licensed gun dealers. This means examining FFL paperwork to see where their guns are coming from, and making sure that those guns are being sold legally. But he says, "Let's be honest. If someone wants a gun, it's obvious the person will not have difficulty buying a gun, either legally or through the extensive United States black market."
 
http://www.mayorsagainstillegalguns.org/downloads/pdf/trace_report_final.pdf

If you combine the stuff below with my previous post it becomes quite clear that the US could control the flow of illegal guns. The key here is control rather than stop. The problem right now is that due to the inconsistancies of the various states you have an environment where criminals have easy access to guns.

It's not the final answer but a move in teh right direction.

5 Laws that have affected access to guns

States that do not require background checks for all
handgun sales at gun shows have an average crime
gun export rate that is about twice the rate of states
that do require such background checks.

States that require purchase permits for all handgun
sales export crime guns at less than one-third the rate
of states that do not.

States that require gun owners to report lost or
stolen guns to law enforcement export crime guns at
less than one-third the rate of states that do not
require such reporting.

States that allow cities to enact their own gun laws
export crime guns at roughly one-fifth the rate of
states that preempt local control of gun laws in cities.

States that do not require or permit inspections of
gun dealers export crime guns at a rate that is 50
percent greater than the average export rate of
states with these regulations.
 
Criminals would then smuggle their guns in. They don't now because if is cheaper to get them in the US. But they easily could.

The same dealers who smuggle drugs would add guns to their pruduct line and then sell through the same distributor network.
 
Criminals would then smuggle their guns in. They don't now because if is cheaper to get them in the US. But they easily could.

The same dealers who smuggle drugs would add guns to their pruduct line and then sell through the same distributor network.

Slippery slope. You cannot assume that all criminals would get guns through smuggling.
 
Criminals would then smuggle their guns in. They don't now because if is cheaper to get them in the US. But they easily could.

The same dealers who smuggle drugs would add guns to their pruduct line and then sell through the same distributor network.

PS still waiting for hte data
 
You are waiting for data that guns can be had in Columbia and Mexico? Is that a desperation ploy?

No waiting for the data that your alluded to long ago that supported your side..... let me go find that post for you.
 
Really? Armed people in fox holes?

This is what I mean about a lack of objectivity.



Maybe when the anti gun religion stops making purely emotional argument and agrees to base policy on an objective look at the data.



You have it backwards. In a democracy freedom is the default position and it is up to this who wish to limit freedom to justify their interference.

That's the data I'd love to take an objective look at.
 
That I believe shows projection on your part, rather than a statement on the part of the NRA. What I see the NRA saying is the President sees no problem with his daughters being protected by armed U.S. Secret Service Agents, but says he objects to schools having armed police in them. That does seem rather hypocritical on the part of the President.

you are an imbicile....do you get bothered by the fact that the President has armed security with him at all times? Are you unaware of the threat of assassination and/or kidnapping of himself or family members that the POTUS has to deal with? Yet you feel he deserves no more protection than you or I??????????????? WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Somebody can't separate their grudge against the man from established protocol. Bush, Reagan and Nixon got the same protection no doubt.... even Ghandi needed it!
 
Are you trying to make a point or reinforcing your law abiding status. Actually you're now hurting your argument that AR 15's should not be banned, I heard they can be converted to automatic in 3 minutes, not 5, but let's use your 5 min, now you know why Obama wants to ban them, too easily converted to automatic and it happened to be the weapon of choice for the recent spade of mass murders by young males.

That's not what he's saying it all; converting a semi-auto AR to have full auto capabilities is not easy, cheap or legal. This is true regardless of what blackrock's friend of a friend says, to say otherwise is plain fear mongering. However, unpinning a magazine to revert it back to its original capacity is very simple. Again this isn't a semi-auto to full auto conversion he's talking about, it's a reduced capacity to normal capacity conversion.
 
That's the data I'd love to take an objective look at.

It's all over the other thread, how could you have missed it? The point is though to start with an agreement that a policy that restricts freedoms should NOT be implemented unless there is real evidence that it's going to be a benefit. Not just fluffy "we have to do something" nonsense where there is no real reason to believe that a difference will be made. What we have are people who don't own guns asserting that gun owners ought to be significantly inconvenienced in case for some unlikely and improbable reason it might make a small difference that "saves even one life". That is not objectivity.

Just to recap some of the topics that we did cover in detail there on the other thread, with numbers and data provided there:

-- Rates of gun crime and non-gun crime dropped by the same amount in areas where there were gun policy changes (gun control can only explain changes in gun crime)
-- Between the US and other nations, rates of gun crime and non-gun crime differ by a similar amount (again gun poilcy can only account for differences in gun crime)
-- All gun homicides INCLUDING gang violence result in less violence and death than cars do, and therefore should face at best a similar level of regulation
-- Gun homicides involving legal firearms owners show the sport to be about as safe as many other sports that no-one is proposing to ban

We had detailed numbers for all the above on the other thread, along with quite a bit more.

We can do it all over again, or at least go back and requote all the posts on the other thread, but the picture that emerges is clear:

-- NO evidence that gun control has any meaningful impact on crime rates
-- Evidence that the US in particular has a crime problem, not a gun problem, and that it relates to gangs and persecuted/disadvantaged minorities
-- Outside of the gang problems guns have a good safety record

It is hard to fathom what objective grounds there are for gun control in light of the fact that it doesn't work and isn't relevant.