The NRA at it again

“Are the president’s kids more important than yours?”

The answer to that NRA question is pathetically obvious. Of course they are.

Highly unlikely a genuine terrorist operation will target Joe Nobody's kids in order to force POTUS into political/military action. Same goes for the kids of NRA spokesman Andrew Arulanandam.
 
You may be a responsible gun-owner and user (I'm sure there are many of you) but you're talking about a political pressure group formed to advance the interests of all gun folks, makers, sellers, collectors, obsessives and gun-crazed loonies. Add those to the need to be comic-book clear and rigidly uncompromising that is true of any pressure group, and mix in a closed circle of the converted talking to the convinced that characterizes anyone who's bought into a siege mentality and you get the NRA.

As likely to be rational and reasonable as any jihadist.
 
Saw that ad last night and my immediate reaction was how vile the NRA is and to what lengths they will go to preserve their revenues. I think this will back fire on them.

Also heard that gun and ammunition manufacturers are not too pleased with New York's state passing of more gun laws, they see a drop in sales.
 
You may be a responsible gun-owner and user (I'm sure there are many of you) but you're talking about a political pressure group formed to advance the interests of all gun folks, makers sellers and looneys. Add them to the need to be comic-book clear and uncompromising that is true of any pressure group, and the closed circle of the converted talking to the convinced that characterizes anyone who's bought into a siege mentality and you get the NRA.

As likely to be rational and reasonable as any jihadist.

Compromise is not a viable strategy in the current political climate.

Most of the anti gun crowd thinks of an assault rifle ban, a long gun registry, or enhanced background checks merely as the first step towards an eventual ban and confiscation of all privately owned firearms.

If instead we could have a conversation about what are the major causes of violent death and what are the least intrusive ways of addressing that, well we could propose all sorts of reasonable things.

But in the current climate it would just be a front to try and reduce gun ownership as much as possible with a view towards pushing for even more reductions later.

Politically therefore it makes sense for pro gun people to oppose any regulation at all until some future when the conversation becomes more reasonable.
 
Compromise is not a viable strategy in the current political climate.
This is why nothing gets done in Congress, not only in guns but it seems everything that goes in front of Congress, that attitude has got to change.

fuji said:
Most of the anti gun crowd thinks of an assault rifle ban, a long gun registry, or enhanced background checks merely as the first step towards an eventual ban and confiscation of all privately owned firearms.

If instead we could have a conversation about what are the major causes of violent death and what are the least intrusive ways of addressing that, well we could propose all sorts of reasonable things.

But in the current climate it would just be a front to try and reduce gun ownership as much as possible with a view towards pushing for even more reductions later.

Politically therefore it makes sense for pro gun people to oppose any regulation at all until some future when the conversation becomes more reasonable.

I don't think that, or do you mean the anti gun control crowd? This slippery slope argument is such a weak argument IMO.
 
This is why nothing gets done in Congress, not only in guns but it seems everything that goes in front of Congress, that attitude has got to change.

I don't think that, or do you mean the anti gun control crowd? This slippery slope argument is such a weak argument IMO.

I mean that in an environment this polarized compromise is a bad strategic move.

Most of the anti gun advocates know nothing about firearms and simply want them banned completely without any objective look at the actual risks.
 
Most of the anti gun advocates know nothing about firearms and simply want them banned completely without any objective look at the actual risks.
I don't agree, most of the gun advocates want some additional gun laws, not to completely ban guns all together. They might think that in a perfect world, but they know that will never happen.
 
I don't agree, most of the gun advocates want some additional gun laws, not to completely ban guns all together. They might think that's complete utopia and know that will never happen.

And if they get those additional gun laws they will then start lobbying for still more restrictions.

Their arguments aren't based on the actual risks and issues but rather in a never satisfied desire to see more and more anti gun laws enacted for no other reason than "guns are scary".

Therefore the pro gun side should resist any law and work to roll back the ones we have.

Until the debate switches to objective analysis it really is just political tug of war.
 
The answer to that NRA question is pathetically obvious. Of course they are.

Lol, no they aren't. They're just at greater risk. Besides which, the secret service is just a tad more trained and professional than the "volunteers" the NRA was suggesting placing in their schools.
 
When oh when will people learn?

It's only okay to bring the kids of conservatives into the picture. Remember the drubbing Sarah Palin's kids took?

Keep the kids out if necessary but the N.R.A.'s point still stands. Somewhat.

The chances of the children of family of any POTUS being a target of kidnapping or worse is higher than the general public, requiring special attention. Only the double digit IQ crowd, don't get that fact. The ad will backfire just like when some idiot TERB member brought it up some time back.
 
pathetic and shows you how the NRA doesnt see Obama as a legitimate president....he doesnt deserve the protection that, Reagan,Nixon , both Bushes, Clinton, etc.etc.etc.
That I believe shows projection on your part, rather than a statement on the part of the NRA. What I see the NRA saying is the President sees no problem with his daughters being protected by armed U.S. Secret Service Agents, but says he objects to schools having armed police in them. That does seem rather hypocritical on the part of the President.
 
What was interesting about the President's speech today was that it was a typical Obama production: reasonable executive orders almost all of which organizations such as the NRA agree with, accompanied by lots of inflammatory rhetoric.
 
pathetic and shows you how the NRA doesnt see Obama as a legitimate president....he doesnt deserve the protection that, Reagan,Nixon , both Bushes, Clinton, etc.etc.etc.

“Are the president’s kids more important than yours?”

The answer to that NRA question is pathetically obvious. Of course they are.

Highly unlikely a genuine terrorist operation will target Joe Nobody's kids in order to force POTUS into political/military action. Same goes for the kids of NRA spokesman Andrew Arulanandam.


:thumb:
 
As a responsible gun owner and user, I can't believe that the NRA would actually put this out there. Ok , maybe I can believe it .... A very low blow!

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-politics/wp/2013/01/15/nra-obama-ad/

How is it a low blow? the dems ran ads claiming mitt romney was responsible for peoples deaths I didnt see the media outraged over that. Obama is an elitist hypocrit, for those that say his children are in greater danger than the average child a) no first family has ever been attacked in american history, and b) they are admitting that obviously guns in schools are a deterrent. total insanity, obama has armed guards protecting his kids incase the VERY UNLIKELY happens
 
Compromise is not a viable strategy in the current political climate.

Most of the anti gun crowd thinks of an assault rifle ban, a long gun registry, or enhanced background checks merely as the first step towards an eventual ban and confiscation of all privately owned firearms.

If instead we could have a conversation about what are the major causes of violent death and what are the least intrusive ways of addressing that, well we could propose all sorts of reasonable things.

But in the current climate it would just be a front to try and reduce gun ownership as much as possible with a view towards pushing for even more reductions later.

Politically therefore it makes sense for pro gun people to oppose any regulation at all until some future when the conversation becomes more reasonable.


The NRA ad is unreasonable.


And if they get those additional gun laws they will then start lobbying for still more restrictions.

Their arguments aren't based on the actual risks and issues but rather in a never satisfied desire to see more and more anti gun laws enacted for no other reason than "guns are scary".

Therefore the pro gun side should resist any law and work to roll back the ones we have.

Until the debate switches to objective analysis it really is just political tug of war.


Yes, guns are scary and so is the lack of regulations in the U.S.
 
Compromise is not a viable strategy in the current political climate.

Most of the anti gun crowd thinks of an assault rifle ban, a long gun registry, or enhanced background checks merely as the first step towards an eventual ban and confiscation of all privately owned firearms.

If instead we could have a conversation about what are the major causes of violent death and what are the least intrusive ways of addressing that, well we could propose all sorts of reasonable things.

But in the current climate it would just be a front to try and reduce gun ownership as much as possible with a view towards pushing for even more reductions later.

Politically therefore it makes sense for pro gun people to oppose any regulation at all until some future when the conversation becomes more reasonable.
The idea of the armed people taking a no-compromise position is not a vision that inspires any sort of 'wait for things' to get better view in anyone else. It calls to mind stuff like barricades and foxholes. Just how is the conversation ever going to get more reasonable as you imagine, if you guys have already decided no compromise is possible?

If there is an impasse, the way to break it is for guys who believe guns are useful and have a proper place in our society to speak up for the first time ever and outline how they believe we can have confidence that these weapons are in the hands of those we can know and trust to use them responsibly, and available to no one else. A perfect role for a body like the NRA.

'Compromise' has to begin with the guy holding the gun. Absent his voluntary input, force is the only possible response.