The Cold War: A Hoax?

I don't know if I'd go so far as to say that.
He would never been able to negotiate (and I'm talking in general not just the Missile Crisis) if he had not been able to show the Intelligence Committee's I'm not selling us out.

Yes, you are entirely correct that a thermonuclear exchange would've killed not just millions of Americans but tens of millions of people.

Believe me, it is a very strange feeling when you are in a major Russian city to realize that somewhere in the upper mid-west there is a missile targeted on where you are standing, and to say what a tragedy it would be where all this destroyed. That does not mean that I have any love for the current Russian Government.
 
The origins of the cold war were in the Russian revolution not WWII.

Note that I'm not saying the Russian Revolution and what followed was a wonderful event, just that they had reasons to distrust the west. Check the link.
Gee that's a bit of an oxymoron. Even the Russians don't believe that.

And yes, I’ve spent time in Russia.
 
Of course the only problem is that the U.S. Navy EP-3 was in intenational airspace, the Chinese aircraft had no legal right to attempt to force it to go anywhere.

Yeah, Yeah! Thats why just a year after the incident the USA lets China into the WTO ( World Trade Organization ) and now my computer, television, stereo, digital camera, and my Lagostina pots and pans are all from China.

The Americans let China into the WTO, just cause they are nice folks.

25g9n6g.jpg
 
Yeah, Yeah! Thats why just a year after the incident the USA lets China in to the WTO
What on earth are you trying to say?

That you don't trust the PRC - in which case I'd agree with you.
That the U.S. sometimes behaves in a contradictory manner - again I’d agree with you
Or that it's ok for the PRC behave like some gang thug.
 
No, no! What I am saying is that you should believe everything you read in the newspapers or see on television!...................................It is all true!!!

It is all true!

It is all True!

It is all True!

It is all true!

It is all True!

It is all true!

It is all true!
 
There are a few extremely important facts which I haven't seen mentioned yet.

First, Soviet Russia (the USSR) was bent on world domination with all authority emanating from Mother Russia. They successfully ran a disingenuous propaganda campaign trying to paint the West as similarly bent on world domination (ignoring the fact that the West wanted each part of the world to make their own decisions, preferably democratically). The USSR had invaded Czechoslovakia, applied its reach into Poland, and continually threatened Western Europe. The USSR and America were the two superpowers, backed up in turn by China and Britain, but the whole world hung in the balance. Thousands of East Germans were shot while trying to escape to the West. Even just this week we learned more details of the extent of control held by the Stasi.

For years, appeasement and Mutually-Assured Destruction were considered to be the means to control Russia (and to provide assurances to Russia that the West was also being controlled). The Russian economy was a shambles, with common stories reaching the West of long lineups for bread and store shelves being routinely empty. Many wanted to hobble the ability of the West to grow its economy or its military might, lest the Russian Generals use its arsenal before losing the "Cold War".

Reagan changed that. He invested heavily in America's military capabilities, forcing Russia to choose to either maintain similar levels of investment, or capitulate. Russia tried the former until it could no longer afford to maintain control over the vast empire it had amassed under its military might. Lech Walesa led a union strike in Poland - unheard of previously, and fortunately for history too far for Soviet Russia to crush from Moscow. The failure of the central authority from Russia emboldened those in Czechoslovakia, Poland, and the Baltic States to declare their independence. The Berlin Wall fell, and East Germany was reunited with West Germany.

With each new declaration of independence from Russia, the world held its collective breath whether there would be military action (as there had been as Russia took control over these territories). Even today, we see the Ukraine threatened by Moscow, and we forget how life was in East Germany before the fall of the Berlin Wall.

Was the Cold War fake? No. It was very real, in the sense of two belligerants fighting for the rights of the lives of billions. Was it a conventional, shooting war? No.

Today is a day for us all to remember history, not to claim our ignorance of it.

You watch too many TV news programs, Anynym, and maybe don't read enough books.
 
You watch too many TV news programs, Anynym, and maybe don't read enough books.

I read plenty of books, articles, news, and verify my facts from available sources.

But remember that very few books are peer reviewed, and opinions replace facts in most, never being challenged.

Or are you trying to say that Moscow did not order their tanks into Czechoslovakia? That the Politburo did not want to get rid of Walesa?
 
Hi Anynym,

I respect your explanation.

But, the Soviets invading a European country to further it's growth, dominance, and resources is not incompatible with the "war" between the US and Russia as a hoax. What I have read from all the posts are either what the US did in response to their perceived threat of Russia, and what Russian did in response to their perceived threat of the US. Ergo the Cuban Missile Crisis, and the development and deployment of weaponry. What I am arguing is that key people on both sides may have been working together as a means to further each individual country's interest. When things escalated, as in Cuba, or with respect to nuclear armament, they were negotiated away. I am not arguing it was a large government conspiracy where the military, CIA, and defense contractors knew, because I believe all of them used fear to their advantage to benefit financially (on both sides of the world map), but all the instruments and machinery of the war (including the military-industrial complex) were manipulated by both sides merely for it's own growth, all the time being a publicity stunt on both sides, carefully controlled, monitored, and crafted by both sides. The reason I say this, is because often things are not as they seem, and with respect to military secrets, things remain hidden for a very long time. Politicians and the military lie to its citizens all the time, so I don't just give them the benefit of the doubt. Also the cold war appeared to spiral out of control on both sides, and the only reason I feel we are still here rather than being re-materialized into a radioactive isotope was for the control exercised by both sides. To have that level of control to prevent the war from getting out of hand required careful planning, co-ordination, and co-operation on both sides by one another. This also require regular meetings and co-operation to a mutually agreed upon end. I think somewhere along the line, both countries realized they could use this to each others advantage by mobilizing it's citizens toward a common end, and to provide a scapegoat for anything. For example, if someone said you're spending too much on the military, the response would be: "Do you want Russia to attack?" End of argument. Everything could be explained away by saying "the Russians are coming, the Russians are coming (insert EE sp joke here). But this kind of action is unsustainable, which is why it could not go on indefinitely. Eventually one of the countries would have to bow out, ergo the economic collapse if the USSR. The party was over and the cold war had to end. Now someone could say "You spent too much on the military" and no one could then say "The Russians are coming! The Russians are coming!"
 
Cold war a hoax? Why the hell would the US have pumped trillions of dollars into the armies of unfriendly to US nations who also opposed the USSR? Including the Taliban in Afghanistan in 1980? Remember that? Russia tried to stop Al Qaida before they became too powerful. US accused Russia of trying to grab a foothold in an oil rich nation. Carter boycotted the Olympics in Russia over it. Regan laundered Trillions more in 1980-1984 to Iran Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan to aid them in defending against the evil empire. USA Armed the Taliban and enabled them to become more powerful than they ever were.

No the super powers did not go to war directly, but they were true enemies.
 
Cold war a hoax? Why the hell would the US have pumped trillions of dollars into the armies of unfriendly to US nations who also opposed the USSR? Including the Taliban in Afghanistan in 1980? Remember that? Russia tried to stop Al Qaida before they became too powerful. US accused Russia of trying to grab a foothold in an oil rich nation. Carter boycotted the Olympics in Russia over it. Regan laundered Trillions more in 1980-1984 to Iran Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan to aid them in defending against the evil empire. USA Armed the Taliban and enabled them to become more powerful than they ever were.

No the super powers did not go to war directly, but they were true enemies.


I guess I would say, that they used that to their advantage to gain natural resources (such as oil) or as an ally, or as a trading partner. This type of investment usually requires a higher up front fee (ergo "trillions" of dollars) to secure natural resources for future growth. And you'll notice no one said:

"Why the hell would the US have pumped trillions of dollars into the armies of unfriendly to US nations who also opposed the USSR" when it was occurring.

All the US had to say was that "The Russians are coming, The Russians are coming!" and that was enough.
 
that if not the truth, then it's very close to it

coincidentally both countries citizens are generally somewhat alike: shauvinistic, arrogant, not traveling abroad much, not wanting to learn a foreign language, dressed like crap (although in a different way)...the list goes on
 
Casting the whole Arms Race as a big conspiracy theory seems to stretch credulity, even for the most ardent conspiracy theorists.

Especially considering the limited communication between the two primary superpowers at the time. We didn't exactly have cellphones and text messaging at the time.

Do you really think that Gorby and Ronnie lied about the topic of their conversation when they isolated themselves from their top advisors? Or were they out of the loop for this massive conspiracy?
 
coincidentally both countries [The U.S. and Russia] citizens are generally somewhat alike: shauvinistic, arrogant, not traveling abroad much, not wanting to learn a foreign language, dressed like crap (although in a different way)...the list goes on
Ah, Canada sartorial capital of the world :rolleyes:

Besides Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver what parts of Canada don't largely fit the above as well?

Other than that what you write is in a general sense true, most Russians rather like Americans once they get to know them. However, one is always going to have the kulturny - nekulturny divide.
 
Casting the whole Arms Race as a big conspiracy theory seems to stretch credulity, even for the most ardent conspiracy theorists.

Especially considering the limited communication between the two primary superpowers at the time. We didn't exactly have cellphones and text messaging at the time.

Do you really think that Gorby and Ronnie lied about the topic of their conversation when they isolated themselves from their top advisors? Or were they out of the loop for this massive conspiracy?

I think Gorby said to Reagan, "Ronald you need to visit Moscow, the girls there are Hawt!" to which Reagan replied, "Mr. Gorbachev...tear down this wall!"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YtYdjbpBk6A

Reagan was referring purely to having access to Eastern European women. Listen to the speech. "Freedom for all mankind" Notice, how all the men are cheering and waving their flags.

Just Kidding. I wouldn't know what to say about the actual logistics of how it all happened, I am just putting the idea out there. I think Reagan and his top advisors, and Gorbachev and his advisors would probably have known. How many people actually knew, I don't know, but it couldn't have been too many, otherwise they wouldn't have been able to keep their actual motives secret for long.

Btw, email and text messaging were going on at that time, just through military channels. It is very possible this was the covert method of communication used.
 
Last edited:
Ah, Canada sartorial capital of the world :rolleyes:

Besides Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver what parts of Canada don't largely fit the above as well?

Other than that what you write is in a general sense true, most Russians rather like Americans once they get to know them. However, one is always going to have the kulturny - nekulturny divide.

Canada to US is what Belarus is to Russia - fucked-up peripheral territory that gets no respect from Mainland
 
Cold war a hoax? Why the hell would the US have pumped trillions of dollars into the armies of unfriendly to US nations who also opposed the USSR? Including the Taliban in Afghanistan in 1980? Remember that?
umm to make zillions as kickbacks from military contracts comes to mind
 
umm to make zillions as kickbacks from military contracts comes to mind

Exactly.

Or more accurately, the Americans gave billions of dollars in Gift Certificates to various tin pot Dictators / Despots all over the world redeamable at General Dynamics, Northrop, Lougheed, et al.
 
JFK desired to make peace with the Soviets, not use any perceived military superiority to win the war on ideology because that only bumps up the doomsday clock.

However, he did say in his inaugural address that the nation is secure when the strength of its arms is formidable.

good point not a whole bunch of people going to kick sand in the face of the cop on the beach.

This whole thread reminds me strangley of the 60's , colours you can taste souinds you can see all sorts of interesting things that never really existed