The Cold War: A Hoax?

When I think about it, The US and Russia, never went to war directly. In Afghanistan there was a war, but the US never invaded Russia like they did Vietnam, or Iraq, or Afghanistan.

That's because unlike those other countries, the US knew the USSR had a bad ass military that can put a hurtin' on them and feared them.
 
This thread is another winner from winstar.

p.s. for red, the cold war was set in place by the 1930's. Much of the US hated the reds more than the Germans (read about Patton for example).

Wait...red talking about the reds? I think I smell a conspiracy!

so you are saying george had a patent on the cold war?
 
That's because unlike those other countries, the US knew the USSR had a bad ass military that can put a hurtin' on them and feared them.
and vis versa. Hmm, I do believe that is known as the doctrine of Mutually Assured Destruction.
 
P.S. To the credit of the OP, the bullshit part of the Arms Race or The Cold War, was that the intelligence agencies overestimated the strength of the Soviet Nuclear Arsenal, and that I'm sure the Military Industrial Complex (MIC) had something to do with the arms race/Cold War too for their own gain.

This whole thread reminded me of one more read from long ago. The Minotaur by Stephen Coonts. Essentially, the hero was involved in trying to track down a traitor who was revealing technical secrets from the latest air force planes - radar suppression skins, etc.

The trick in the novel was that the leaks were deliberate, and intended to show to the Soviets that the US was so far ahead, and could afford to manufacture extraordinarily expensive materials to go to the next level.

The fun part was that this came out in the fall of 1989, with the Berlin Wall coming down later that year. Fairly prophetic concerning the whole spend-them-into-the-grave approach.


Alright, so I read a lot. Sue me.
 
one thing I did know was that once the Cold War ended, the U.S. would need some excuse to keep that War Machine running. After all, you can only build so many nukes anyway.
What is the best way to keep that machine running? You would need to continually supply conventional weapons.

The best solution is to have an enemy that you can never defeat - terrorists.

Very true.

The Russian people would have never wanted to attack the United States, any more than the American people would want to attack Russia. There was no way either side could win. At the end of the day, the Russians and the Americans are more alike than they are different. (Contrast the Americans to say the Islamo Fascists - there is a massive cultural divide. No so with the Russians.) That said, the leaders of the day weren't necessarily as smart as their people. I remember reading that Stalin was hell bent on going to war with the Russians and as a result a group of level headed thinkers in the Kremlin poisoned him to death. Don't know if it's true, but a great story none the less.

I have a few off the boat Russian friends and they always get a perplexed look on their face if I say that the Americans truly believe that Reagan won the cold war and it was American policy (bankrupting the soviets) that was responsible for the fall of communism in Russia. They all (independently) say that the fall of communism had everything to do with the Russian people and nothing to do with Ronald Reagan or American policy. They find it both laughable and perplexing that the Americans would even think that they were somehow responsible for the fall of communism in the USSR.

I tend to agree.
 
Very true.

The Russian people would have never wanted to attack the United States, any more than the American people would want to attack Russia. There was no way either side could win. At the end of the day, the Russians and the Americans are more alike than they are different. (Contrast the Americans to say the Islamo Fascists - there is a massive cultural divide. No so with the Russians.). . . .

I have a few off the boat Russian friends and they always get a perplexed look on their face if I say that the Americans truly believe that Reagan won the cold war and it was American policy that was responsible for the fall of communism in Russia. They all (independently) say that the fall of communism had everything to do with the Russian people and nothing to do with Ronald Reagan or American policy. They find it both laughable and perplexing that the Americans would even think that they were somehow responsible for the fall of communism in the USSR.

I tend to agree.
I believe both are correct Captain. NATO, principally the U.S.A. had a technological and economic advantage that drove the USSR to the point of collapse. However, when the cracks developed in the facade, it was the People of the former Russian Empire who caused the Soviet system to collapse. Certainly they were not going to die for a bunch of aparachniks, for the Rodina yes, for a failed political theory no.


I must also add that most ordinary Russians I know, regrettably have very poor historical training, most Westerners with an interest in the country and who have studied its history generally know a great deal more.
 
To the credit of the OP, the bullshit part of the Arms Race or The Cold War, was that the intelligence agencies overestimated the strength of the Soviet Nuclear Arsenal.
Ironically it was the U-2 program that showed that the U.S. had dramatically (and of course the Soviets did their utmost to make it appear those higher numbers were the case) overestimated the advancement of the Soviet Strategic Rocket Forces and also the number of bombers in the Soviet Air Force. It was that which allowed JFK to negotiate knowing the real capabilities of the USSR rather than the higher numbers which had been believed.
 
Last edited:
Thoughts?

Instead of making irrational (and really dumb) comments you should do some homework and find out what the Cold War was really all about.

This is the problem with society today. Too many nutjobs who take 0.001% of the facts and base all their assumptions on that while blindly ignoring the other 99.999% of the evidence.

I don't mean to come across as rude but you really do come across as being dumb when making a statement like that. I'm sure there's lot of internet losers who will buy into the same silly conspiracy theories but that doesn't give it an ounce of legitimacy.
 
That has been speculated about for years. The end result it is true was that the (rapidly becoming obsolete) Jupiter Missiles were removed from Turkey, however, I don't recall (although I may be mistaken) ever reading of any direct quid pro quo.



Let me elaborate on that.


Imagine a Chinese spy plane were to be caught off the coast of the USA and Ameican fighter jets were sent to force it to land, in a game of chicken in the air the American fighter jet crashes into the nose of the Chinese spy plane and as a result the American jet pilot crashes and dies. The Chinese Spy plane is forced to land on American soil with all its spying equipment and a crew of 30.

An incient like this if occured on Ameican soild would result in a diplomatic incident that may precipitate into WW III.
 
Let me elaborate on that.


Imagine a Chinese spy plane were to be caught off the coast of the USA and Ameican fighter jets were sent to force it to land, in a game of chicken in the air the American fighter jet crashes into the nose of the Chinese spy plane and as a result the American jet pilot crashes and dies. The Chinese Spy plane is forced to land on American soil with all its spying equipment and a crew of 30.

An incient like this if occured on Ameican soild would result in a diplomatic incident that may precipitate into WW III.
Ah, that is a different thing entirely than what it appeared you were saying in #5.

Yes I think the Chinese would have reacted far more aggressively than the U.S. had the roles been reversed. Furthermore, any U.S. or Canadian pilot who had acted in the reckless manner of the Chinese pilot would have been at least grounded, if not discharged.
 
Ah, that is a different thing entirely than what it appeared you were saying in #5.

Furthermore, any U.S. or Canadian pilot who had acted in the reckless manner of the Chinese pilot would have been at least grounded, if not discharged.

The Chinese jet fighter pilot was ordered to force the American plane to land. it is common tactic to buzz a plane to heard it in the direction you want it to go in. It was the American plane that did not want the sophisticated electronics to end up in forien hands that moved his slow lumbering turbo prop plane in a dangerous fashion. and cause his nose to be sheared off and the Chinese fighter jet pilot to be killed.

It was only the promise of entry into the WTO that averted a big diplomatic incient. What does entry into the WTO mean for China?............................Billions and billions of dollars.



Per day!
 
Let me elaborate on that.


Imagine a Chinese spy plane were to be caught off the coast of the USA and Ameican fighter jets were sent to force it to land, in a game of chicken in the air the American fighter jet crashes into the nose of the Chinese spy plane and as a result the American jet pilot crashes and dies. The Chinese Spy plane is forced to land on American soil with all its spying equipment and a crew of 30.

An incient like this if occured on Ameican soild would result in a diplomatic incident that may precipitate into WW III.


And if it happened on American Soil it would have really caused problems.....:D
 
The Chinese jet fighter pilot was ordered to force the American plane to land. it is common tactic to buzz a plane to heard it in the direction you want it to go in. It was the American plane that did not want the sophisticated electronics to end up in forien hands that moved his slow lumbering turbo prop plane in a dangerous fashion. and cause his nose to be sheared off and the Chinese fighter jet pilot to be killed.
Of course the only problem is that the U.S. Navy EP-3 was in intenational airspace, the Chinese aircraft had no legal right to attempt to force it to go anywhere.
 
There are a few extremely important facts which I haven't seen mentioned yet.

First, Soviet Russia (the USSR) was bent on world domination with all authority emanating from Mother Russia. They successfully ran a disingenuous propaganda campaign trying to paint the West as similarly bent on world domination (ignoring the fact that the West wanted each part of the world to make their own decisions, preferably democratically). The USSR had invaded Czechoslovakia, applied its reach into Poland, and continually threatened Western Europe. The USSR and America were the two superpowers, backed up in turn by China and Britain, but the whole world hung in the balance. Thousands of East Germans were shot while trying to escape to the West. Even just this week we learned more details of the extent of control held by the Stasi.

For years, appeasement and Mutually-Assured Destruction were considered to be the means to control Russia (and to provide assurances to Russia that the West was also being controlled). The Russian economy was a shambles, with common stories reaching the West of long lineups for bread and store shelves being routinely empty. Many wanted to hobble the ability of the West to grow its economy or its military might, lest the Russian Generals use its arsenal before losing the "Cold War".

Reagan changed that. He invested heavily in America's military capabilities, forcing Russia to choose to either maintain similar levels of investment, or capitulate. Russia tried the former until it could no longer afford to maintain control over the vast empire it had amassed under its military might. Lech Walesa led a union strike in Poland - unheard of previously, and fortunately for history too far for Soviet Russia to crush from Moscow. The failure of the central authority from Russia emboldened those in Czechoslovakia, Poland, and the Baltic States to declare their independence. The Berlin Wall fell, and East Germany was reunited with West Germany.

With each new declaration of independence from Russia, the world held its collective breath whether there would be military action (as there had been as Russia took control over these territories). Even today, we see the Ukraine threatened by Moscow, and we forget how life was in East Germany before the fall of the Berlin Wall.

Was the Cold War fake? No. It was very real, in the sense of two belligerants fighting for the rights of the lives of billions. Was it a conventional, shooting war? No.

Today is a day for us all to remember history, not to claim our ignorance of it.
 
The origins of the cold war were in the Russian revolution not WWII. The wealthy elite in the western (ie. capitalist free market) countries were terrified at the prospect of a workers revolution spreading in Europe and the US and the subsequent loss of all private property. Wide spread, powerful workers movements were active in Europe, the US and Canada ( the violent BC mining strikes ) throughout the early 1900's .
The western powers (including the US ) did invade Russia in 1918 on the side of the Tsar though it did little good. From that point forward the Russians realized that the west was against them. Note that I'm not saying the Russian Revolution and what followed was a wonderful event, just that they had reasons to distrust the west. Check the link ...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allied_intervention_in_the_Russian_Civil_War

The Spanish paid a heavy price during their popular revolution when western countries refused to intervene and support the democratic government because of heavy communist involvement in the government - the west preferred a fascist gov't to the risk of a democratic worker based movement which was going to dismantle the status quo of the wealthy.

Educate yourself, it's not that hard and the information is out there whether you look on line or even read a book.
 
First, Soviet Russia (the USSR) was bent on world domination with all authority emanating from Mother Russia.

Using that in a sentence is probably the best support of the notion that Western elites' ability to produce largely non-government distributed propaganda to evoke a seemingly organic response, with a strong sense of 'false consensus' and a healthy notion of 'all the news that is fit to print', really is the superior propaganda model... It kind of makes Soviet propaganda look cute and childish. Especially when you factor in its emergent properties. That way you don't need a conspiracy or any real central planning at all. Drip, drip, drip...
 
so you are saying george had a patent on the cold war?

You're just spreading bolshevik. He's was just one prominent example of an pre-cold war American who would rather be dead than be like red.