Support For One State Solution Grows

This should be fun.
Ok, give us the comparison UN resolutions on the creation of Italy and Israel.

I said "essentially" because the Paris process began prior to the UN, but the UN recognized it.

The Italian Republic was negotiated by an occupier and ratified by the international community.
 
Fail.
A peace treaty negotiated between parties is quite different from a UN resolution.
Start the music up again...

There is essentially no difference. The process was carried out through the Paris peace treaties and recognized by the UN a few years later when Italy was admitted as a member in 1955.

But in both cases you have a military occupier (both times including the British) negotiating the formation of a number of sovereign states out of captured territory. In both cases ultimate recognition was conferred by the UN, and in both cases that recognition came sometime after the defacto formation of the state.

Whatever point you were trying to make by saying Israel was somehow different has been totally and utterly destroyed.
 
Watching Netanyahu in power is like watching a cruise ship slowly crash into a dock.
He continues to stall any real peace talks while he can keep up with the settlement land grabs, without realizing that he's driving Israel into a one state solution.
Every settlement land grab just makes a two state solution that much harder, and with the water grabs now its pretty much impossible.

While I find Bibi a tremendously unsympathetic player I don't see Hammas or Fatah coming to the table with a credible peace initiative. The Israelis are playing for time (and more importantly, land) the Palestinians are just trying to make them miserable and look like occupiers - sadly for most of the population both are being successful in their misdirected strategy.

OTB
 
While I find Bibi a tremendously unsympathetic player I don't see Hammas or Fatah coming to the table with a credible peace initiative. The Israelis are playing for time (and more importantly, land) the Palestinians are just trying to make them miserable and look like occupiers - sadly for most of the population both are being successful in their misdirected strategy.

OTB

Fatah just made an announcement saying they would go for land swaps, based of the 1967 borders, Israel then called them terrorists.
Hamas has had a voluntary ceasefire going for a while now, in exchange for an end to the blockade, but all Israel has done is call them terrorists and shoot them.
 
Fatah just made an announcement saying they would go for land swaps, based of the 1967 borders, Israel then called them terrorists.
Hamas has had a voluntary ceasefire going for a while now, in exchange for an end to the blockade, but all Israel has done is call them terrorists and shoot them.

Pretty low bar after 60 years, has Hammas recognized Israel's right to exist?
 
Pretty low bar after 60 years, has Hammas recognized Israel's right to exist?

Has Israel recognized Palestine's right to exist?
Why does that even matter?
Its just a phrase used to avoid peace talks, if its that important talk about it during negotiations.
I thought Israel was the one that said they didn't want any preconditions to talks.
 
Has Israel recognized Palestine's right to exist?
Why does that even matter?
Its just a phrase used to avoid peace talks, if its that important talk about it during negotiations.
I thought Israel was the one that said they didn't want any preconditions to talks.

You should have higher expectations of those you so emphatically support.
 
You should have higher expectations of those you so emphatically support.

You might want to explain how kowtowing to the party that occupies you, ethnically cleansed you, stole all of your property, blockades you, and murders you and your children satisfies any notion of a higher expectation.

This demand from Israel is just part of Zionism's continuum of greed and narcissism.
 
You might want to explain how kowtowing to the party that occupies you, ethnically cleansed you, stole all of your property, blockades you, and murders you and your children satisfies any notion of a higher expectation.

This demand from Israel is just part of Zionism's continuum of greed and narcissism.

Perhaps this is the core of the problem, two sides, both see themselves as victims, both demand the other side take the first step, neither holds themselves accountable..... Sounds like a middle school hissy fit between two girls.
 
Perhaps this is the core of the problem, two sides, both see themselves as victims, both demand the other side take the first step, neither holds themselves accountable..... Sounds like a middle school hissy fit between two girls.

Except one side has nukes, drones and one of the more sophisticated armies around.
But they won't talk peace unless the other side says the magic words.
 
Hamas has had a voluntary ceasefire going for a while now, in exchange for an end to the blockade, but all Israel has done is call them terrorists and shoot them.

In fact there have been multiple missiles fired from the territory, and Israel has NOT carried out any more lethal strikes.

What Israel HAS done is carried out non-lethal retaliatory strikes for every missile fired by the Palestinians, missiles which so far have missed.

You can guess that if the Palestinians succeeds in injuring any civilians--and they appears to be trying hard to do that--that the follow on Israeli strike will be lethal too.

It's all up to the Palestinians -- do they want to turn away from violence, and try negotiations that increasingly build confidence and create relationships -- or do they want to go back to killing people and war? Their choice.
 
Has Israel recognized Palestine's right to exist?

Yes. Clearly. And Fatah has recognized Israel's right to exist. In fact, that was the reason why Hamas left the PLO -- they disagreed with recognizing Israel and seeking a peaceful resolution.

It's Hamas and Islamic Jihad who have not recognized Israel's right to exist -- everybody else has stated clearly that they prefer a negotiated peace. Everybody but Hamas and Islamic Jihad.
 
They voted against the UN resolution giving them observer statehood status.
Clearly they don't recognize Palestine as a state.

Your question was whether they recognized Palestine's right to exist. Clearly they have. It was a key part of the Oslo Accord. They do not agree with the way that it was done. Fatah has done the same, recognized Israel's right to exist, while disagreeing over the details of how it exists.

Hamas on the other hand refuses to accept the existence of Israel in any way, shape, or form, and is committed to the use of violence against Israel and Israeli's.