Support For One State Solution Grows

OTB, there are an increasing number in Israel who are coming to view the conflict as something to be managed rather than resolved

So long as the Palestinians remain unwilling to quit the violence the issue really becomes one of supporting policies that minimize and contain the conflict.

As such the settlement building should stop or be pulled back as it creates flashpoints, while the blockade and walls should be enhanced.

Israel has no intention of limiting settlements on the West Bank - let's at least be honest about that, nor is there any intention of sharing Jerusalem..... these are simply racist land grabs.

And yes, Israelis who view the conflict as needing to be manages are at leasts realists, it's never going to end.

OTB
 
Israel has no intention of limiting settlements on the West Bank - let's at least be honest about that, nor is there any intention of sharing Jerusalem..... these are simply racist land grabs.

Just out of curiosity, what is the reason for accepting a uti possidetis outcome when Jordan and Egypt captured and annexed territory in a war of aggression they started, but not when Israel captured territory in defending itself?

And why is it a racist land grab for Jewish people to reclaim places the Jordanians expelled them from?

You are OK with Jordan having razed synagogues but opposed to Jews rebuilding them?

What really is the justification for status quo ante bellum, other than an Israeli desire for a negotiated peace?

It seems that one rule, uti possidetis, is applied to Arab territorial gains, while a different rule, status quo ante, is applied to Jewish gains.

Please clarify why uti possidetis applies only for Arabs?
 
Pro Israeli people think a one state solution is some sort of major concession to the Palestinians. In fact it is the only way to avoid the inevitable next Holocaust against the Jews. If Israel remains a Jewish state, it is pretty much guaranteed that within the next 100 years, it will happen yet again. Perhaps with grave consequences for the rest of the world as well.

I could ask if you really think that turning the region into a state with a Jewish minority among people who widely don't want to live in equality with Jews will somehow help protect Jews but I know your post is just wishful thinking.
 
Israel has no intention of limiting settlements on the West Bank - let's at least be honest about that, nor is there any intention of sharing Jerusalem..... these are simply racist land grabs.

And yes, Israelis who view the conflict as needing to be manages are at leasts realists, it's never going to end.

OTB

You might of missed it but under Sharon, Israel was forcibly evacuating settlements. In return for giving land to the Palestinians they were met with increased attacks.

It should be obvious based on the number of times grog and gryf quote Israeli media and Israeli rights groups but Israel has a strong pro-peace movement. All they need to get traction is evidence that the Palestinians are willing to give up violence. Until then, the settler movement and the hard liners will find it easy to get the votes.
 
You might of missed it but under Sharon, Israel was forcibly evacuating settlements. In return for giving land to the Palestinians they were met with increased attacks.

It should be obvious based on the number of times grog and gryf quote Israeli media and Israeli rights groups but Israel has a strong pro-peace movement. All they need to get traction is evidence that the Palestinians are willing to give up violence. Until then, the settler movement and the hard liners will find it easy to get the votes.

Don't get me wrong, I don't think the Israelis have anyone to negotiate peace with - the radicals on the other side would never allow that (or either side, as we saw 20 years ago). My point is that Israel's behavior is making it easy for the radicals to recruits and keep the terror war going... and it's never going to stop.

OTB
 
Just out of curiosity, what is the reason for accepting a uti possidetis outcome when Jordan and Egypt captured and annexed territory in a war of aggression they started, but not when Israel captured territory in defending itself?

And why is it a racist land grab for Jewish people to reclaim places the Jordanians expelled them from?

You are OK with Jordan having razed synagogues but opposed to Jews rebuilding them?

What really is the justification for status quo ante bellum, other than an Israeli desire for a negotiated peace?

It seems that one rule, uti possidetis, is applied to Arab territorial gains, while a different rule, status quo ante, is applied to Jewish gains.

Please clarify why uti possidetis applies only for Arabs?

Under that argument the Palestinians should expel the Jews... not sure that's the point you wanted to make..... and exactly what the more radical Palestinians are trying to do.

OTB
 
Don't get me wrong, I don't think the Israelis have anyone to negotiate peace with - the radicals on the other side would never allow that (or either side, as we saw 20 years ago). My point is that Israel's behavior is making it easy for the radicals to recruits and keep the terror war going... and it's never going to stop.

OTB

It's not that often that I agree with Netanyahu but the settlements are not the reason behind Palestinian terror, it is simply Israel's existence.

Netanyahu: Conflict over recognition, not territory

"The root of the conflict isn't territorial. It began way before 1967," he told Israeli diplomats. "The Palestinians' failure to accept the state of Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people is the root of the conflict. If we reach a peace agreement, I want to know that the conflict won't continue - that the Palestinians won't come later with more demands."

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4374896,00.html

Hamas (Islamic Jihad, PFLP, Fatah's Al-Aqsa...) have repeatedly stated that their goal is not a Palestinian state beside Israel nor a state where Jews, Christians, and Muslims are equal. Until that changes, Israel would be stupid to sacrifice their security for peace with people who don't want peace.

I agree that the settlements for the most part aren't beneficial and I would like to see Israel evacuate most of them but that would not change the minds of the Palestinian leadership. At best it would help Israel's foreign image but I doubt that any change there would be significant.
 
Under that argument the Palestinians should expel the Jews... not sure that's the point you wanted to make..... and exactly what the more radical Palestinians are trying to do.

OTB

Thanks for clarifying that your position is one sided and racist, that you believe different rules should apply to Jews just because they are Jews, etc.

At least you're honest!
 
Thanks for clarifying that your position is one sided and racist, that you believe different rules should apply to Jews just because they are Jews, etc.

At least you're honest!

I was simply showing how silly your position was, funny that you can see the weakness in the position but not the source.

OTB
 
It's not that often that I agree with Netanyahu but the settlements are not the reason behind Palestinian terror, it is simply Israel's existence.

Netanyahu: Conflict over recognition, not territory.


Totally

They better recognize! If not, more settlements unitl they live at sea
 
It's not that often that I agree with Netanyahu but the settlements are not the reason behind Palestinian terror, it is simply Israel's existence.

Netanyahu: Conflict over recognition, not territory

"The root of the conflict isn't territorial. It began way before 1967," he told Israeli diplomats. "The Palestinians' failure to accept the state of Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people is the root of the conflict. If we reach a peace agreement, I want to know that the conflict won't continue - that the Palestinians won't come later with more demands."

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4374896,00.html

Hamas (Islamic Jihad, PFLP, Fatah's Al-Aqsa...) have repeatedly stated that their goal is not a Palestinian state beside Israel nor a state where Jews, Christians, and Muslims are equal. Until that changes, Israel would be stupid to sacrifice their security for peace with people who don't want peace.

I agree that the settlements for the most part aren't beneficial and I would like to see Israel evacuate most of them but that would not change the minds of the Palestinian leadership. At best it would help Israel's foreign image but I doubt that any change there would be significant.

That's simply a radicals cover for a territorial grab.

Again, I'm not arguing that Israel has a negotiating partner, just that it's making matters worse rather than better....
 
We should pull our money out and give up on it, there are no US national interests in Israel, it's a small insignificant country that only causes our foreign policy pain.

OTB


It gives much more reasons to meddle in the ME
 
I was simply showing how silly your position was, funny that you can see the weakness in the position but not the source.

Then, for real this time, why should status quo ante apply to the 1967 outcome, instead of the more traditional uti possidetis?

As you answer, recall that Jordan not only annexed East Jerusalem, not only declared East Jerusalem its capital, but actually razed synagogues, destroyed Jewish sites, and completely and totally ethnically cleansed the area.

That was OK, but Jews returning to the areas they were expelled from is not? It seems fishy to me.
 
As you answer, recall that Jordan not only annexed East Jerusalem, not only declared East Jerusalem its capital, but actually razed synagogues, destroyed Jewish sites, and completely and totally ethnically cleansed the area.

That was OK, but Jews returning to the areas they were expelled from is not? It seems fishy to me.

Are you trying to argue that ethnic cleansing is ok for Jews but not for Arabs?
The settlements, for instance, are ethnic cleansing. And you support their continued existence but complain about other cases of ethnic cleansing?
Are you really ok with ethnic cleansing based on which race is doing it?
 
The settlements are not ethnic cleansing, liar. Ethnic cleansing the settlements would be ethnic cleansing!
 
The settlements are not ethnic cleansing, liar.

The settlements replace an indigenous population with walled in housing for one race only, backed by a foreign army.
They are ethnic cleansing.

Even your argument that closing them would be ethnic cleansing only confirms they are built for one race only.
 
Then, for real this time, why should status quo ante apply to the 1967 outcome, instead of the more traditional uti possidetis?

As you answer, recall that Jordan not only annexed East Jerusalem, not only declared East Jerusalem its capital, but actually razed synagogues, destroyed Jewish sites, and completely and totally ethnically cleansed the area.

That was OK, but Jews returning to the areas they were expelled from is not? It seems fishy to me.

I think the 47 border is the only really defensible partition given that was the border at Israelis birth...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:UN_Partition_Plan_For_Palestine_1947.svg

Everything beyond that is Zionist expansion.

OTB
 
The settlements replace an indigenous population with walled in housing for one race only, backed by a foreign army.
They are ethnic cleansing.

Even your argument that closing them would be ethnic cleansing only confirms they are built for one race only.

Israel allows multiple races, it is the Arabs (and you) who want to cleanse Palestine of all Jews.
 
I think the 47 border is the only really defensible partition given that was the border at Israelis birth...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:UN_Partition_Plan_For_Palestine_1947.svg

Everything beyond that is Zionist expansion.

OTB

Is "zionist" a bad word?

But you are hilarious, blaming Zionists for the Palestinian war of aggression that resulted in the state forming along the final front lines of the war the Palestinians launched instead of along the 47 lines that were originally promoted by Zionists.