Support For One State Solution Grows

I think the 47 border is the only really defensible partition given that was the border at Israelis birth...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:UN_Partition_Plan_For_Palestine_1947.svg

Everything beyond that is Zionist expansion.

OTB

That would be an interesting precedent in business. You are offered a deal, turn it down and try to get better deal but in the end you lose out. Then decades later you go back and demand the original deal. Sounds fair.


Your thought has about as much basis as fuji's plan to return the West Bank to Jordan (and your comments completely ignore that the 'zionist expansion' was land won in wars they didn't start.
 
Is "zionist" a bad word?

But you are hilarious, blaming Zionists for the Palestinian war of aggression that resulted in the state forming along the final front lines of the war the Palestinians launched instead of along the 47 lines that were originally promoted by Zionists.

Or the even smaller state that the Jews agreed to under the 1937 Peel Commission. I wonder if the Palestinians ever look back and see the deal they refused in '37 would have created a Palestinian state on 85% of the region.
 
Is "zionist" a bad word?

But you are hilarious, blaming Zionists for the Palestinian war of aggression that resulted in the state forming along the final front lines of the war the Palestinians launched instead of along the 47 lines that were originally promoted by Zionists.

Zionist isn't a bad word, or a good word, it's like Liberal or Conservative (or progressive if your too much of a pussy to use Liberal) - is simply a one word term for a political viewpoint/policy position.

Not blaming the Zionists for the wars, just the land grab after.... does the US still control half of France, half of Germany, all of Italy?

OTB
 
That would be an interesting precedent in business. You are offered a deal, turn it down and try to get better deal but in the end you lose out. Then decades later you go back and demand the original deal. Sounds fair.


Your thought has about as much basis as fuji's plan to return the West Bank to Jordan (and your comments completely ignore that the 'zionist expansion' was land won in wars they didn't start.

See WWII points above. Conquerers keep the spoils of their wars, if your comfortable with that characterization of Zionism I am....

OTB
 
See WWII points above. Conquerers keep the spoils of their wars, if your comfortable with that characterization of Zionism I am....

OTB

Was the US at war with France? Did they make peace deals with Germany and Italy? Was it the victors who re-drew the map after WWII or the losers? Can you see how this is a very different situation?



p.s. Map before WWII
http://www.diercke.de/bilder/omeda/501/100790_036_3.jpg
Map after
http://media.web.britannica.com/eb-media/62/64262-004-A047E14C.gif
See how war changes borders?
 
Is "zionist" a bad word?

But you are hilarious, blaming Zionists for the Palestinian war of aggression that resulted in the state forming along the final front lines of the war the Palestinians launched instead of along the 47 lines that were originally promoted by Zionists.

Only if you consider a racist supremacist ideology bad, lickspittle.
 
If they refused to make peace, what choice would there be?

Running farmers off their land because the crazies want to push the Jews into the sea and the other crazies want to move over from Brooklyn isn't just - it's just a land grab.

OTB
 
Not blaming the Zionists for the wars, just the land grab after.... does the US still control half of France, half of Germany, all of Italy?

Nope. But the US still does control California, Arizona, Nevada, and Utah. Perhaps you should give them back to Mexico? Guam and a whole string of other islands.

Would you like some more examples? The US has a long history of recognizing captured territory as its own, after wars it "justly" fought.
 
Israel allows multiple races

Trying to change the subject?
The subject is the settlements, not Israel proper.
The settlements are ethnic cleansing, as they are replacing the indigenous population with another race, and building armed walls around them to protect them.
Isn't it time to end ethnic cleansing?
 
Nope. But the US still does control California, Arizona, Nevada, and Utah. Perhaps you should give them back to Mexico? Guam and a whole string of other islands.

Would you like some more examples? The US has a long history of recognizing captured territory as its own, after wars it "justly" fought.

It's been a while since that behavior was seen as civilized, outside of Israel....

OTB
 
It's been a while since that behavior was seen as civilized, outside of Israel....

OTB

Since when, exactly?

The day after the last US territorial acquisition by war?

A whole lot of borders were moved around just a few years prior to the 1948 war at the end of WW2 in 1945. Whole countries were carved out of other countries. By how many months did Israel miss this rule change?
 
Since when, exactly?

The day after the last US territorial acquisition by war?

A whole lot of borders were moved around just a few years prior to the 1948 war at the end of WW2 in 1945. Whole countries were carved out of other countries. By how many months did Israel miss this rule change?

Half a century and counting - at least.....
 
Half a century and counting - at least.....


Watching Netanyahu in power is like watching a cruise ship slowly crash into a dock.
He continues to stall any real peace talks while he can keep up with the settlement land grabs, without realizing that he's driving Israel into a one state solution.
Every settlement land grab just makes a two state solution that much harder, and with the water grabs now its pretty much impossible.