Support For One State Solution Grows

A response to Levy's opinion piece from one of the 52% of Israelis who were chased out of Arab lands after generations of being second class peoples.

"Gideon Levy’s dream is the triumph of hope over experience. The 650,000 Jews who sought a haven in Israel and now form a 52 percent Jewish majority – some 300,000 others went to the West – did not escape violence and repression in Arab states in order to find themselves once more under Arab-Muslim dominion."
http://blogs.timesofisrael.com/if-gideon-levy-wills-it-it-is-a-nightmare/
 
A response to Levy's opinion piece from one of the 52% of Israelis who were chased out of Arab lands after generations of being second class peoples.

"Gideon Levy’s dream is the triumph of hope over experience. The 650,000 Jews who sought a haven in Israel and now form a 52 percent Jewish majority – some 300,000 others went to the West – did not escape violence and repression in Arab states in order to find themselves once more under Arab-Muslim dominion."
http://blogs.timesofisrael.com/if-gideon-levy-wills-it-it-is-a-nightmare/

Israel's Cabana Boy and Canada-Man are almost interchangeable.
 
Blind diatribe, no factual content, avoidance of issues, applauding terrorism. Typical gryf.
 
Of course the problem with the thinking is (according to Palestinian polling) the vast majority of Palestinians (71%) are opposed to a pluralistic one state solution.

It's the only way they will end up living in peace..... They could take over the country in two generations without firing a rocket or throwing a rock... Ghandi and MLK had it right, Malcom X not so much.

OTB
 
Equality terrifies Zionists. It is antithetical to simpering Zionists such as yourself.

Because they know its a death sentence.
 
It's the only way they will end up living in peace..... They could take over the country in two generations without firing a rocket or throwing a rock... Ghandi and MLK had it right, Malcom X not so much.

OTB

They won't end up living in peace until major factions in Palestinian society accept that Jews will live in the region with equal rights. That was the sticking point in the 1930s and it is the sticking point now and 71% of Palestinians are against it.

As a westerner, my preference would be everyone in the world has full and equal rights but that takes time and changes in ways of thinking.

Look at the examples of Jordan/Israel which were both part of the original British territory under Picot-Sykes and compare it to the governing of Lebanon. In both cases, separate and hostile groups were in the same region

Jordan was split from British control as a gift to the Hashemite clan. They were at war with Israel from 1948 to the 1990s but slowly have worked towards economic cooperation and somewhat positive relations. This sounds like a reasonable outcome. Palestinians give up on destruction of Israel. Israel gives up the West Bank. Two separate countries that over time will see the benefits of working together.

On the other hand, politics in Lebanon created a factional political system where despite hatreds, Sunni, Shia, and Christians became a part of a sectarian government which has been a source of violent conflict for decades. The lack of trust between groups grows and instead of a pluralistic open society, it is a battleground based on bloodlines and religion.

Which one seems a better way of moving towards peace?
 
They won't end up living in peace until major factions in Palestinian society accept that Jews will live in the region with equal rights. That was the sticking point in the 1930s and it is the sticking point now and 71% of Palestinians are against it.

As a westerner, my preference would be everyone in the world has full and equal rights but that takes time and changes in ways of thinking.

Look at the examples of Jordan/Israel which were both part of the original British territory under Picot-Sykes and compare it to the governing of Lebanon. In both cases, separate and hostile groups were in the same region

Jordan was split from British control as a gift to the Hashemite clan. They were at war with Israel from 1948 to the 1990s but slowly have worked towards economic cooperation and somewhat positive relations. This sounds like a reasonable outcome. Palestinians give up on destruction of Israel. Israel gives up the West Bank. Two separate countries that over time will see the benefits of working together.

On the other hand, politics in Lebanon created a factional political system where despite hatreds, Sunni, Shia, and Christians became a part of a sectarian government which has been a source of violent conflict for decades. The lack of trust between groups grows and instead of a pluralistic open society, it is a battleground based on bloodlines and religion.

Which one seems a better way of moving towards peace?

There isn't going to be peace. When the Israelis were moving that way some nut shot the PM.... there are multiple generations of Palestinians that have lived under occupation and in camps, settlers are stealing land every month... there is never going to be any peace. All the Palestinians can do is either go the way of Ghandi/MLK or do what they're doing now, make Israelis suffer as much as they can as often as they can (that's clearly the strategy).

We should pull our money out and give up on it, there are no US national interests in Israel, it's a small insignificant country that only causes our foreign policy pain.

OTB
 
There isn't going to be peace. When the Israelis were moving that way some nut shot the PM.... there are multiple generations of Palestinians that have lived under occupation and in camps, settlers are stealing land every month... there is never going to be any peace. All the Palestinians can do is either go the way of Ghandi/MLK or do what they're doing now, make Israelis suffer as much as they can as often as they can (that's clearly the strategy).

We should pull our money out and give up on it, there are no US national interests in Israel, it's a small insignificant country that only causes our foreign policy pain.

OTB
You have a simple view of the problems. The majority of Israelis support a two state peace even if some radical groups don't (BTW. That attack you mentioned was almost 20 years ago). Their only concern is security and since Hamas, Islamic Jihad, and the rest are rather anti-Gandhi it is a valid one.

As for their strategy of trying to make Israel hurt, that strategy seems to have hurt their own people more. In the words of your state department:

Hamas claims to have the best interests of the Palestinian people at heart, yet it continues to engage in violence that is counterproductive to the Palestinian cause. Attacking Israel on a near daily basis does nothing to help Palestinians in Gaza or to move the Palestinian people any closer to achieving self determination.
http://www.state.gov/r/pa/prs/ps/2012/11/200551.htm

I anxiously await a Palestinian Gandhi to get some traction but considering that 40% of Palestinians support attacks on Israeli civilians inside Israel (not settlers mind you) I fear it will be a long wait. Israel has a strong pro-peace camp and signs that the Palestinian factions will accept a real permanent peace would have a huge impact.

As for American support, that's for you Americans to decide but it seems that many disagree with you.
 
Pro Israeli people think a one state solution is some sort of major concession to the Palestinians. In fact it is the only way to avoid the inevitable next Holocaust against the Jews. If Israel remains a Jewish state, it is pretty much guaranteed that within the next 100 years, it will happen yet again. Perhaps with grave consequences for the rest of the world as well.
 
Pro Israeli people think a one state solution is some sort of major concession to the Palestinians. In fact it is the only way to avoid the inevitable next Holocaust against the Jews. If Israel remains a Jewish state, it is pretty much guaranteed that within the next 100 years, it will happen yet again. Perhaps with grave consequences for the rest of the world as well.

Most thinking people feel exactly the opposite, that "one state solution" is code for "giant pogrom to ethnically cleanse all Jews from the territory" -- the conclusion of the project the Palestinians started in 1947 when they went to war with the express purpose of cleansing all the Jews from Palestine, a goal that Palestinian militant groups as of yet have never renounced.
 
You have a simple view of the problems. The majority of Israelis support a two state peace even if some radical groups don't (BTW. That attack you mentioned was almost 20 years ago). Their only concern is security and since Hamas, Islamic Jihad, and the rest are rather anti-Gandhi it is a valid one.

As for their strategy of trying to make Israel hurt, that strategy seems to have hurt their own people more. In the words of your state department:

Hamas claims to have the best interests of the Palestinian people at heart, yet it continues to engage in violence that is counterproductive to the Palestinian cause. Attacking Israel on a near daily basis does nothing to help Palestinians in Gaza or to move the Palestinian people any closer to achieving self determination.
http://www.state.gov/r/pa/prs/ps/2012/11/200551.htm

I anxiously await a Palestinian Gandhi to get some traction but considering that 40% of Palestinians support attacks on Israeli civilians inside Israel (not settlers mind you) I fear it will be a long wait. Israel has a strong pro-peace camp and signs that the Palestinian factions will accept a real permanent peace would have a huge impact.

As for American support, that's for you Americans to decide but it seems that many disagree with you.

Most disagree with me, they see the issue as good guys vs bad guys - I see it as one set of bad guys vs a set of worse guys.

I don't think the radical Palestinians care much for their own people, their misery only fuels the hatred of Israel and is the motivation for spreading the misery. Every new settlement, shooting of a young Palestinian, incursion into Gaza only throws more fuel on the fire. You should really watch The Gatekeepers - the former heads of Shin Bet make this point convincingly.

I think if we are waiting on a Palestinian Ghandi we are waiting on Godot - that's the right answer but that doesn't mean it's going to happen.

OTB
 
OTB, there are an increasing number in Israel who are coming to view the conflict as something to be managed rather than resolved

So long as the Palestinians remain unwilling to quit the violence the issue really becomes one of supporting policies that minimize and contain the conflict.

As such the settlement building should stop or be pulled back as it creates flashpoints, while the blockade and walls should be enhanced.
 
OTB, there are an increasing number in Israel who are coming to view the conflict as something to be managed rather than resolved

So long as the Palestinians remain unwilling to quit the violence the issue really becomes one of supporting policies that minimize and contain the conflict.

As such the settlement building should stop or be pulled back as it creates flashpoints, while the blockade and walls should be enhanced.

The West Bank has been relatively peaceful now for a few years and all they got were more walls and settlements.
Managing the conflict just means more of the same, more settlements and more apartheid.

Clearly the US doesn't think that's viable, as they have told Israel that they only have 2 years left for a two state solution.