Wow, what a debate. Different things work for different people.
I can only summarize what has worked for me in over 50 years of all kinds of diets that all failed other than low carb Atkins/Keto.
Over time, I dropped 50 lbs and have maintained it. I ignore calories because without the carbs/insulin etc reaction fat is burned not stored. Without the carbs (not none, but try and stay under 25 carbs a day), I am rarely very hungry since there is no sugar/insulin spike. Also the high amount of fat also makes you not hungry and is burned first not last absent many carbs.
I eat Keto bread with about 2 net grams of carbs, lots of Atkins meals I microwave. My breakfast is Atkins scrambled eggs package - 4 min in the microwave with bread, often with Keto peanut butter. Remember it is net carbs that is important from the nutrition label on most all foods, at least in the US. You ignore fiber and artificial sweaters (but don't eat too much, or it will come out the rear end). I also like grilled cheese sandwiches on Keto bread using 2 slices of Sargento Chedear which has 0 carbs - microwave 5-10 seconds. There is also Breyers Carb Smart Ice Cream with 4g net carbs per serving.
Dinner often is an Atkins meal or I eat a lot of Jimmy Dean Fully Cooked Pork Sausage Patties with 1 gm of carbs that I microwave for 2 minutes.
I monitor my Ketone level by test strips keeping between 15-40 mg/dl. I am age 77 luckily without any major health issues other than maintaining my weight.
Yes I sometimes go off it. As I write this, I just returned from a Phoenix strip club and am writing a review. On the way home, I had to go to 3 McDonalds to get an Oreo McFlurry and a hot fudge sunday. It probably had 3 times the daily limit of carbs, but I do splurge sometimes, and when I travel, I do not stay on the diet. It was close to midnight, and the first two had their soft serve machine down, which often happens late at night, close to midnight for those closest to me versus some open 24 hours.
In Canada, I enjoy Tim Hortons! Or Denny's, especially since open late at night since I am a night owl - it's in my genes, per Ancestory.com.
When I am in Canada, for example, for a week, I usually gain 5-7 lbs since off diet, but I can get back down to 195 lbs fairly quickly. I am 6-1, and this seems to be an ideal weight to maintain vs lower when a Dr said I looked too thin.
I get a full blood panel every six months and all is perfect as is blood pressure etc. Some studies show that Atkins/Keto helps many get off diabetes meds.
To answer an earlier question Atkins is available in most of the major grocery stores in Canada per their website. But when in Canada I have not looked for it since part of "vacation" is being off diet. But anything Keto should be low in carbs. Now "Keto" is the more popular name for low carb and lots of products available not just from Atkins which was popular decades ago when I started going low-carb after all the silly calorie counting diets were worthless for me.