Sugar free diet?

I dont know if what you said is true or false, but a lot of it sounds like Thomas DeLauer BS. lol.

Although I wasn't thinking of him when I wrote the post but I find him evidence based and thought provoking.

What would make you think otherwise?
 
Please read Zoe Harcombe's book The Obesity Epidemic where she covers this in detail and tell me where she is wrong.
She is not an expert in thermodynamics. End of story. I taught thermodynamics courses, and especially thermodynamics of open systems. So, don’t try to tell me I am wrong with what I said about your statement on open and closed systems.
 
She is not an expert in thermodynamics. End of story. I taught thermodynamics courses, and especially thermodynamics of open systems. So, don’t try to tell me I am wrong with what I said about your statement on open and closed systems.
 
Your link confirms that she doesn’t know squat about thermodynamics, nor does she understand open versus closed systems. For that matter, medical people don’t have enough understanding of thermodynamics, either. She should never try to claim expertise in a subject that she has no background in. Economics and math, or working with blue chip organisations, do not make one an expert in physical chemistry or thermodynamics.
The problem with accounting for energy in versus energy out in a human body system is that these ’experts’ have not accounted for the inputs and outputs correctly. Nor do they account properly for accumulation in the case of open systems. There are also effects of associated water with fat cells that add up to weight effects. You tend to lose about four to five kilos with every kilo of fat that you ‘burn’. So, from the point of view of a scientist and engineer, she is wrong, and so are the so-called analyses that are referred to in your link.
 
Last edited:
Makes calories count don't count calories...

Although I wasn't thinking of him when I wrote the post but I find him evidence based and thought provoking.

What would make you think otherwise?

You are buying into the cons who manipulate studies to suit their wanting of clicks and followers.

Again, if you take in 3000 calories of "clean healthy food" every day for a week and your daily maintenance calories are 2500 a day. At the end of that week, you have gained 1lb. of most likely pure fat. Where it went in the body, is up to the individual's body.
 
I'd avoid packaged foods and drinks where possible including in cans, boxes, jars, celophane bags or bottles. You have to read labels very carefully these days especially for high fructose corn syrup, fructose, glucose, sucrose or dextrose. They're all sweeteners aka sugars. You would have to be very deligent to avoid this stuff.

If think it's safe to say that just about all packaged food has some form of sugar in them.
 
The calories in vs calories out module. The rules of thermodynamics and all, work fine in a closed system, but your body isn't a closed system. Think hormones and inflammation.

There's a thought that insulin spikes are needed to absorb minerals. Sugar within a food matrix seems to be much better tolerated than processed sugar. Eating too much sugar can promote the increase of ghrelin. Which drives hunger. high sugar diets are associated with leptin resistance. Which also increases appetite. Sugar releases dopamine and is therefore thought to have addictive potential..Of course the big food conglomerates figured this out years ago and combined sugar wit fat and salt to maximize its effect and in tow their profits.

Some of the carnivore space podcasters are adding fruit and organic honey into their menu these days. They're finding that their blood work after long term constant zero carb intake wasn't coming out to well. Hormone profiles were affected as well as electrolytes.

Most everyone seems to accept that processed foods are a deterrent to good health. There's a growing trend of belief that claims seed oils are right there as well. So safflower, sunflower,corn, canola, cottonseed, soybean and rapeseed. Their marketed as vegetable oils but are really seed oils. the thought is that they cause massive inflammatory responses within the body.

Here's another aspect that doesn't get talked about much...Your microbiome. Sugar consumption can lead to changes in your gut microbiota that can lead to inflammation thus affecting your immune system which leads to metabolic disease and deleterious health outcomes.

As I'm typing this I'm just finishing a bowl of white rice, mixed vegetables, squash , mixed with some coconut oil. So there's that.


You explain it well and what you are saying is accurate.

Here is a classic bestseller that explains the above known science in the simplest, laymans terms I've read. No cheerleading, gimmicks etc. Just biology, hormones, matabolic processes etc.

Funny that the Kindle Edition isn't on the amazon.ca site that i could find. Best $10 and three hours you will spend.


71sQe9kn-uL._SL1500_.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
I enjoy sugar in my coffee and tea. Try not to eat a lot of it though.
But also, I walk fast and/or run for a big chunk of the day.
 
Again, if you take in 3000 calories of "clean healthy food" every day for a week and your daily maintenance calories are 2500 a day. At the end of that week, you have gained 1lb. of most likely pure fat. Where it went in the body, is up to the individual's body.


A short 8 minute video explaining why counting calories in ineffective for weight loss...
 
I would disagree with this based on personal experience alone. By the way didnt you say calories in, calories out? How would you know how many calories to take in without counting?

You obviously didn't watch the video so there's no point in responding at this point.
 
Please don’t make statements about thermodynamics and open versus closed systems unless you have studied thermodynamics. A an engineer, I will tell you that your statement is wrong.


Respectfully, engineering is inapplicable, if not outright inappropriate to human metabolism. Yes, calories in- calories out is absolutely true.

But humans are not closed systems. There is nothing more complex and involves more combinations of metabolic, neurological hormones, chemistry, thermodynamics and even variable bio-mechanical factors such as the differing lengths of everyones small intestine. Those skinny bastards and bitches often have a shorter than average small intestine and therefore absorb less calories and shit more down the toilet. Evolutionarily superior humans have longer than average small intestines and therefore take up more calories of whatever they put in their mouths. They can survive famine longer due to their superior ability to not shit out valuable calories.

This is the foundation of bariatric weight loss surgery. Surgically engineered and reduction/bypass of most of the small intestine resulting in malabsorption.

.

  • Malabsorptive bariatric surgery limits the amount of nutrients the body absorbs by bypassing a portion of the small intestine.

Having said that, sugar and high carb diets can thwart even highly restrictive malabsorptive procedures.

types-of-bariatric-surgery.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
I enjoy sugar in my coffee and tea. Try not to eat a lot of it though.
But also, I walk fast and/or run for a big chunk of the day.

If you enjoy a little sugar, you are gonna luuuuuuuuuvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv another seemingly harmlessly enjoyable white powder! A little of it goes a long way too!

You are gonna walk reeeeeeellllleeeeeeeeyyyyyyyyy fast but for a small chunk of the day....
 
  • Haha
Reactions: jimidean2011
Respectfully, engineering is inapplicable, if not outright inappropriate to human metabolism. Yes, calories in- calories out is absolutely true.

But humans are not closed systems. There is nothing more complex and involves more combinations of metabolic, neurological hormones, chemistry, thermodynamics and even variable bio-mechanical factors such as the differing lengths of everyones small intestine. Those skinny bastards and bitches often have a shorter than average small intestine and therefore absorb less calories and shit more down the toilet. Evolutionarily superior humans have longer than average small intestines and therefore take up more calories of whatever they put in their mouths. They can survive famine longer due to their superior ability to not shit out valuable calories.

This is the foundation of bariatric weight loss surgery. Surgically engineered and reduction/bypass of most of the small intestine resulting in malabsorption.

.

  • Malabsorptive bariatric surgery limits the amount of nutrients the body absorbs by bypassing a portion of the small intestine.

Having said that, sugar and high carb diets can thwart even highly restrictive malabsorptive procedures.

types-of-bariatric-surgery.jpg
I don’t understand what your statement about the inapplicability of engineering to the human body has to do with what I said. Your statement contradicts the entire realm of the discipline of biomedical engineering and cross-disciplinary work in the general understanding how the human body works. Whatever system within the human body you consider, science and, engineering as a part of science, can describe how it works. Your example of bariatric surgery, kidney function, cardiology, skeletal structure, eye optics, nerve functions and signal transmissions, are possible due to our scientific understanding of how the human body works.

Longer intestines provide greater surface area for absorption of nutrients. That is an engineering axiom of mass transport across semipermeable barriers. Surgically engineered were words you used in your post. Human metabolism is definitely an area where the physicochemical processes can be understood through engineering, physics and chemistry.

The artificial kidney, dialysis, is a medical life saver for those whose kidney function is severely compromised. It exists due to the understanding of mass transfer across a specific type of semipermeable membrane, and was invented by using chemical engineering principles. Just read what you wrote about all the complex processes that occur in the human body with respect to metabolism. Just because it is a very complex system doesn’t mean engineering and science can’t be applied to it. God’s greatest creation is the human body. He is the ultimate engineer.

There are many who work in this area. Don’t belittle their work. That reference to closed-system thermodynamics earlier on demonstrated how ignorant that person was to science, as she tried to sound really smart. It was inapplicable to the subject of weight loss.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kautilya

A short 8 minute video explaining why counting calories in ineffective for weight loss...

I completely disagree and ask any bodybuilder going into a contest trying to shred and lean out if calorie counting isn't important. Sure, many who have calorie counted for a while can look at a plate of food and estimate very closely to it's caloric content but one must follow the rule of science. Take in more calories than you burn, don't complain about the love handles or the manly bitch tits and I am not referring to Gyno Nipps.LOL
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Kautilya
Sugar always calls me back.

Everything from coke on down to Bacon [yes I capitalized it on purpose].

It is 100 percent exactly like pookie from the Movie New Jack City talking about crack
It's calling me, it's calling me.


I find the only way to curb the eating is to treat problem foods like alcoholics treat booze. Not one drop, not allowed, forbidden.
Otherwise I get a pie, or some ice cream or a 24 of coke to avoid the corner store figuring I'll a have a bit every day. Have my allotement go on the computer and then my brain hits
There's pie, there's pie
There is pie
There's pie, there's pie
There is pie
Therehre is pieie

[To the tune of Rock me Amedeus]

Or sometimes my skull meat gets more classical with Beethoven's 9th
Pie Pie Pie Pie
Pie Pie Pie Pie
Pie Pie Pie
Pie Pie... Pie Pie
 
  • Love
Reactions: jimidean2011
He is a quack. Not evidence based. He uses fancy language that sounds scientific but it isn't. DeLauer has a bachelors degree in communications. Dr. Layne Norton has a PhD in nutritional science along with some bodybuilding titles and accomplishments.


Norton kind of shifts from his condescending tone here, lol

Right off the bat he admits he had Fruit Loops for breakfast...Oh man,lol.

I guess though you can know what you are talking about while not practicing it. So there's that.

I look forward to viewing the video.
 
Last edited:
It is all about thermodynamics and calories in calories out. Of course, it is easier to stay in a calorie deficit if one sticks to lean protein with lots of veggies as opposed to a plate of pasta and meatballs with a hunk of cheesecake for dessert LOL.

One can eat a Big Mac for Breakfast, lunch, and Dinner, hit the gym for muscle retention or not if it's just about losing fat and be guaranteed they will start shedding weight and look great. I wouldn't say it would be a great idea for long-term health but to lose weight, it would work.

The Twinkie diet, supplemented with multi vitamins but with an variety of corner store junk food
Improved blood work, coming from weight loss via restraint

Ditto for people who have done the supersize me diet, but showing restraint and not being a raging alcoholic like the original guy.

Weight loss seems to be even more powerful than what you eat. People more educated and even funnier than I have pointed it out, there was a lecture by Dr Mike Isertel who said the same thing.

I suspect a Twinkie diet or a Big Mac diet would be effective for weight loss. If you can eat nothing but twinkies and other Vachon like treats, I'd figure you would get pretty sick of it after a while, while the 3 Big Mac a day diet about 1650 calories, is not only something that one would get board with, but it is easily regulated. I mean you don't need to be a puppet vampire to count to 3 blah.
 
Dr. Layne Norton has a PhD in nutritional science a

He is the man, one of 4 people I trust

Dr. Carvalho https://www.youtube.com/@NutritionMadeSimple
And Dr Mike https://www.youtube.com/@RenaissancePeriodization who sometimes comments on nutrition.

All 4 actually look at all the studies instead of jerking off to one and getting all sex nuts and retard strong before coming to a conclusion and don't fall into the camp of the diet cultists. Unless they are commenting on a single study making the rounds but they will usually refer to the whole body of evidence.

The comment sections however are full of diet cultists sadly of all sorts.