Some American's Lose.....

DonQuixote said:
Not the founding fathers.

Go to Washington and the federal buildings
are devoid of Christian symbols.

I'm not saying there wasn't a religious
practice in the US. Read DeToqueville
and you will find that underlying religious
sensitivity.

I'm saying something quite different.
Religious principals did not motivate the
Founding Fathers in the documents they
created.

The influence of religion in America would
require several tomes to explain.

Its not a simplistic issue to deal with.

Ours is the practice of religious tolerance
for the religion of others who may practice
a different faith

The separation of church and state actually
spawned all sorts of religious practices without
the dominance of one over all others.

There is an argument that the separation
actually fostered religious beliefs among
all citizens regardless of faith or denomination
since there was no one dominant faith.

Quite the opposite of England at the time.
Much of what you are saying I entirely agree with Don. But having done Post-Graduate study on the period, I think the "well the founding fathers" argument is frequently taken "a bridge too far" and that those making it, basicly make the argument of the Anti-Federalists for them some 220+ years later. Namely that the U.S. Constiutuion will be a document imposed by elites upon the masses. Nether historicaly nor politicaly do I believe this can be justified. I'm reasonaly sure you aren't making it, however one hears it FAR too often.

de Tocqueville was writing of a U.S. some four decades later, but many of his comments and conclusions about the importance of religion in America can be applied to the last decades of the eighteenth century as well.

Further de Tocqueville is describing the formation of "Civil Religion" in the U.S. a concept that many Canadians' just don't get unless they have lived in or studied the U.S., one sees this regularly acted out on TERB.


Finaly, you are right that Washington is a remarkable city truly "Alabaster." in the words of Katherine Lee Bates. On the Bottom's daughter should have a wonderful time. I hope her school gives them the time to actually see the city. I find the three sites particularly moving, for a first time visitor, the view of the city from Arlington National Cemetery, The National Cathedral (The Cathedral Church of Sts. Peter and Paul), and the Lincoln Memorial.
 
DonQuixote said:
We go through these periods of "The Great Awakening"
when we shift from Evangelicanism to Secularism and
then back again. The 4th wave started in the late '70s
that still lingered on until this election.

Culture wars may have ended in this election.

It may be we are in a post "Great Awakening" period.

I still think the Hegelian view of history is at play.

The 20-30 yr old group is rejecting the Awakening paradigm


I find it interesting and somewhat ironic, that religion plays such a large part in
american politics, with everybody having to confirm their faitgh, and a president (W)
professing that it is his christian faith that guides his foreign policy.

In scandinavia, where there is no separation between state and religion, on
the contrary, there is a state religion, with the Queen head of both the state and
the church.

But in scandinavia, religion has little place in politics.
 
danmand said:
I find it interesting and somewhat ironic, that religion plays such a large part in
american politics, with everybody having to confirm their faitgh, and a president (W)
professing that it is his christian faith that guides his foreign policy.

In scandinavia, where there is no separation between state and religion, on
the contrary, there is a state religion, with the Queen head of both the state and
the church.

But in scandinavia, religion has little place in politics.

Oddly enough it's my view that because there is such division between religion and state that religion is stronger.....

OTB
 
In a nation of laws, where cause should be shown in any limitation of personal rights I can't see A SINGLE CAUSE that should stop Gays from marrying. I think the gay community should look back to MLK and model their protest and disobedience after the Civil Rights Movement in the 60s.

As strongly as I view that Roe v Wade was bad judgement (the creation of a right where none existed in the Constitution) I believe that Gay marriage is a civil liberty and the SCOTUS should strike down any limitation to it in any state. We are a nation of laws and government by and for the people, but we are also a nation of core principles, the most fundamental of which is equal protection under the law for all people.

OTB
 
danmand said:
I find it interesting and somewhat ironic, that religion plays such a large part in
american politics, with everybody having to confirm their faitgh, and a president (W)
professing that it is his christian faith that guides his foreign policy.

In scandinavia, where there is no separation between state and religion, on
the contrary, there is a state religion, with the Queen head of both the state and the church.

But in scandinavia, religion has little place in politics.
There are several reasons. Just superficially: History plays a huge role, as does the very fact that there is a state church in both Denmark and Sweden. As does the fact that not so much Denmark, but certainly Sweden exhausted itself while being the "bully boy" of Northern Europe in the late 17th and early 18th centuries.

The very fact that there was no State Church in the U.S. lead to “civil religion” a concept that is quite alien in Canada and most of Europe.
 
onthebottom said:
As strongly as I view that Roe v Wade was bad judgement (the creation of a right where none existed in the Constitution)
Can you explain this? Not trying to pick a fight, but I simply don't understand your POV.

How can a woman's right to control over her own body and destiny not be an inalienable right? Is self-determinism not a right that should be protected?
 
Captain Fantastic said:
Can you explain this? Not trying to pick a fight, but I simply don't understand your POV.

How can a woman's right to control over her own body and destiny not be an inalienable right? Is self-determinism not a right that should be protected?

You don't have a right to kill yourself (a bit of self-determinism)....

IMHO the SCOTUS invented a right by morphing the Right to Privacy into the right to an abortion.

I'm in the minority and the learned justices of the Supreme Court disagree with me - it's just my opinion, and one that won't ever be law.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
I happen to think that, for a vast majority of people, sexual preference is not a choice, you're born that way, like being right or left handed. I think to think otherwise is a Herculean exercise in the suspension of reality.
I entirely agree.

However, that then leads to Civil Union (which I agree with) as opposed to same sex marriage (which I do not agree with).

One can then proceed to tell me I'm prejudiced, unfair, etc. . . but basically what that says is that my belief is without value and the opposing belief is correct.
 
The state should get entirely out of the business of registering marriages. The state should ONLY register civil unions. If some people want to call their civil union a marriage because they also got it blessed in a church that's up to them--the government should have nothing to do with it.

Churches could then independently determine for themselves under what circumstances they would bless a civil union and call it a marriage.

Some churches would then be OK with marrying gays, some would not, but in neither case would it have anything to do with the law or the government.
 
That said, Aardvark I can't believe that you're not intelligent enough to realize that the ONLY viable position for the government is the least common denominator.

Elevating one particular church view of marriage above all other views and making it the law should be something that is offensive to EVERYONE, even adherents of that faith.

The notion that a marriage can only be between a man and a woman is particular to a few sects. Other sects see it differently, and many people don't adhere to any sect.
 
fuji said:
The state should get entirely out of the business of registering marriages.
The problem Fuji is what you describe has never been the Anglo-American-Canadian-Australian-New Zealand way of doing things. From just about the day "one rabbit" the English State gave the Church the authority of solemnize marriages.

With the French Revolution & the First Empire etc. . . France and many other continental states required a civil marriage before the religious marriage - however that (before two years ago) has never been our way.

Canada, has now decided to more or less go the continental way, then again Canada is in a legal sense far more continental than the other four countries mentioned..
 
All of the above is not to say that perhaps we should adopt the Continental pattern of marriage - but it certainly shouldn't be don't without plenty of discussion - and an absence of brow-beating - oh, you prejudiced person you.
 
Aardvark154 said:
The problem Fuji is what you describe has never been the Anglo-American-Canadian-Australian-New Zealand way of doing things.

Lots of prejudiced things have been done by the state in the past, that are not done now. This is another one.

There are two non-prejudiced ways forward:

(a) Expand the definition of marriage to be non-prejudicial

(b) Remove it from the sphere of government entirely and replace it with a non-prejudicial civil union for everyone

Since it seems there are people who would be offended by (a) then I'm offering up (b) as an alternative.

What is unviable is to continue with state sponsored discrimination.

From just about the day "one rabbit" the English State gave the Church the authority of solemnize marriages.

Note churches would STILL have the power to solemnize marriages. No-one would take that away. There would simply be NO legal consequences to having a marriage solemnized. The legal consequences would come entirely from registering a civil union, whether solemnized or not.

Equally you could have a marriage solemnized but NOT register it as a civil union. You would be married in your eyes and in the eyes of your church, but there would be no legal consequences until you went and registered a civil union.

Other than for tax purposes, inheritence, etc., the government really shouldn't give a damn whether you are married or not.
 
fuji said:
Note churches would STILL have the power to solemnize marriages. No-one would take that away. There would simply be NO legal consequences to having a marriage solemnized. The legal consequences would come entirely from registering a civil union, whether solemnized or not.

Equally you could have a marriage solemnized but NOT register it as a civil union. You would be married in your eyes and in the eyes of your church, but there would be no legal consequences until you went and registered a civil union.
Good luck ever getting this passed into law in the U.S.A.


Your first paragraph is roughly the situation in Continental Europe as well as a number of other countries around the world. You must be civily married before you are religiously married since only the civil marriage matters in law.


In your second paragraph you are in no-man's land - netiher here nor there. I don't think anyone is going to buy into that - believe me given U.S. law on K-1 Fiancée Visas couples have tried this, and most religious bodies have said - NO WAY!
 
DonQuixote said:
__________

UNENUMERATED RIGHTS

Amendment 9 - Construction of Constitution. Ratified 12/15/1791.

The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people


______________________________________________________________

The Ninth Amendment of the United States Constitution protects all of the rights of the people which are not mentioned specifically elsewhere in the Constitution. It was a part of the original Bill of Rights drafted in 1787 and ratified in 1791. The rights protected are referred to as “unenumerated” rights, and include those inferred by other legal rights, as well as natural, fundamental, and background ones. The Ninth Amendment combines with the tenth to protect the rights and situations not provided for in the previous eight amendments.

The Ninth Amendment is used to protect the citizenry from any expansion of governmental power because of the limited nature of the Bill of Rights. Because every right of the people of the United States could not possibly be mentioned in the Constitution, the Ninth Amendment was added to supplement the rights already mentioned. The amendment protects many rights implied in a universal civil code, and those which are linked to other rights already declared. It protects these personal liberties from state and federal infringement.

The Supreme Court is bound by a common sense guide when interpreting the fundamentals of the rights covered by the Ninth Amendment. They have in some cases used the Ninth Amendment to their advantage, declaring actions of the people as natural, unenumerated rights, like the right to abortion in Roe v. Wade. Others, Supreme Court judges among them, have argued that the Ninth Amendment simply prohibits the denial of rights not mentioned in the first amendment. It does not, argued Antonin Scalia in 2000, give judges the power to determine what these additional rights are.

The history of the Ninth Amendment was one of the most controversial of the Bill of Rights. It was strongly supported by Alexander Hamilton and James Madison. Many among the ratifying conventions in 1787 proposed the allowance for further amendments as the need for additional rights arose, which was implemented. For some, however, this was not enough. The Virginia Ratifying Convention attempted to appease the Federalists of Hamilton and Madison by proposing an amendment which would give Congress the power to make exceptions to rights not enumerated, but not to extend the powers of Congress.

The first eight amendments of the Constitution provide for the means for Congress to address the rights listed. The Ninth Amendment, however, addresses the rights which have not been put into the hands of the governments, and these rights have been the subject of many Supreme Court decisions, as well as many arguments over levels of power and discretion in the higher ranks of the judicial and executive branches.

Thanks DQ, I've always heard roe v wade as a right to privacy expansion.

Thanks for the knowledge, I guess I'm in the minority with Scalia.

OTB
 
DonQuixote said:
Scalia and Lawrence Tribe are worthy opponents
whose debates are worthy of grand chessmaster
ranking.

Both are brilliant students of the Constitution.

They are what all lawyers should strive for.

Then again, lawyers are nothing but scumbags, eh. :rolleyes:

PS: When I say my beloved Constitution
I mean My Beloved Constitution.

Come on, you can't be a lawyer and be sensitive about lawyer jokes... it's a profession with the best and the worst among us.....

I have a great lawyer, he can be a bastard, but he's my bastard.

The Domestic Relations court down here is an old boys network of 3 guys who all have pictures of themselves with the judge's arm around them in the fricking courthouse..... (the Judge presiding over this old boy network being a stern black female). I hate that you have to hire one of these three guys to represent you or your really at risk... not the blind justice I'd like to see.

I have a very jaded view of the entire legal process, it always seems stacked in the wrong direction.

OTB
 
Aardvark154 said:
Good luck ever getting this passed into law in the U.S.A.

What is far more likely is that the definition of marriage will be expanded to include gays. Anyone who doesn't like that essentially has a window of opportunity at this moment in history to enact (b) instead, but the tide of history means that if that doesn't happen (a) will.

If you look at the votes on this matter progressively more and more of the population has come to support gay rights and to support gay marriage.

Take California for example--the last time it was put to a vote it was 60% against gay marriage. This time it was only 52%. Give it another ten years and it'll be 60% in favour.

In some states it'll happen fast, in others it'll take a long time, but it will eventually happen everywhere.

The tide of history is, thankfully, to date, on the side of tolerance and equality and against prejudice and discrimination.

Those for whom the word "marriage" carries special significance and who insist that it should only include a man and a woman should seize the moment and enact (b) before the opportunity slips from their grasp.