Response(s)
Captain Fantastic said:
I've seen no mention of your involvement in gay rights, but I will take your assertion at face value.
"Speaking for myself, I know I could be recruited for such a cause. I actually joined a political action group that was making itself ready to fight against a FEDERAL amendment banning gay marriage, because I (like the majority of Americans) thought that was perversion of the constitution."
Captain Fantastic said:
That is the issue for the majority of gays and lesbians - it is not a "we'll show you" point for most.
And for the majority of Americans, it isn't a matter of wanting to deny gays any rights whatsoever. It is that they do not wish to have the definition of marriage changed.
Marriage is not a universal and scared right. There are all sorts of guidelines that govern who can marry and who cannot. And those of evolved over time. No doubt further evolution will take place.
Captain Fantastic said:
For "civil union" to work, every law that contained the term marriage, etc., would have to be changed to include the term civil union and domestic partnership and whatever else it may have been called in a respective jurisdiction. It has already reared its head in many court cases where fundamental marriage rights were ignored because the term "civil union" did not meet the standard for "marriage" in the eyes of the courts. That is why civil union has been rejected by many in the gay community - because it would have meant that they would have had to accept not being afforded the same rights, benefits and privileges that others had. It was, in essence, a bargain that they would have been forced to live with for a long time - because once you make a set of laws, it is nearly impossible to "upgrade" - without gaining the same rights, all the while having huge technicalities that could come back and bite them in the ass (and not in a fun way - LOL!) in the long run.
And all this is to varying degree true....and all of it could have been dealt with in due time. Woman's rights evolved over time...starting with suffrage and ending with laws outlawing discrimination in the work place based on gender. Same with civil rights laws. Gays wanted everything NOW...and didn't not care about the social upheaval they were asking for.
Captain Fantastic said:
The fundamental and Constitutional rights of gay Americans have been denied. Since that document is held sacrosanct by both the people and government, it needs to be upheld, above the interests of any religion or group.
I disagree. The right to marry is not protected by the constitution, and it is in fact restricted. You feel the way you do...but clearly you have a biased opinion. Most people feel differently.
Change is possible...indeed change is probably inevitable...but you aren't going to get it if you belittle the concerns and fears of those you are asking to change. You mock the beliefs, fears, concerns, questions of those whose support you require...and I am betting you don't get their support. You address them...and they probably come onboard.
Captain Fantastic said:
Marriage has a different meaning for every religion and culture, with different ceremonies, vows and duties. It is not a singular institution, but a fluid one that is held together by a thread of two people who love each other and are committing themselves to one another for life. In most religions, divorce is not allowed, and yet the divorce rate is over 50%. That does not sound like an institution.
See...you did it again...you mocked the other side. They believe it an institution. Your saying "NO IT ISN'T BECAUSE YOU PEOPLE GET DIVORCES HALF THE TIME ANYWAY" isn't going to make them warm and fuzzy....
Captain Fantastic said:
Gay marriage is fundamentally the same thing as any other marriage, except that the parties involved are of the same sex.
Agreed. But...not everybody would agree....more than likely because they have...say it with me...concerns, fears and beliefs that are barriers to acceptance. Now...are you going to win them over by calling them stupid for being of average intelligence and not particularly well read, or are you going to try to understand where they are coming from so you can make a better and more effective case for yourself?
Captain Fantastic said:
People are not gay because they choose to be (every gay person I know have claimed they would never have chosen to be homosexual, but they accepted that is who and what they are and moved on)
And again...not everyone would agree...especially in a world where people say they are gay...then say they are not gay. Where people live there entire lives as heterosexuals...then decide they are gay. And certainly not in a culture where denial of sexual latitude is almost a sacrament.
Homosexuals maintain that sexual orientation is ingrained in their DNA...but no "gay gene" has been found, and sexual orientation SEEMS to be fluid for at least some...on both sides. Add to that bi-sexuals (who catch more hell from gays than straights), and no, this is not as absolute in the minds of everyone as it is in yours.
So...again...do you scoff....or do you address?
Now...you can scream about how stupid those people are...or you can try to understand why and how they feel the way they do. One is going to be a lot effective to winning their support than the other.
Captain Fantastic said:
They just want the same guarantees that their rights are exactly the same as those in so-called conventional marriages.
And most Americans would gladly grant them that.
Captain Fantastic said:
Unfortunately there are those that have riled up the masses, spreading misinformation and outright lies about gay marriage, trying to influence those who are more moderate, using God and morality and even ideas like gays not taking marriage seriously and being a drain on the system to push their agenda.
And there are gays who openly and regularly mock heterosexuals, who purposely do and say things that they know most heterosexuals would find offensive. There are bad actors on both sides. But...since it is the gays who want change...they might consider dealing with their bad actors.
Captain Fantastic said:
They have manipulated and bastardized the legal and political systems, using their "power" as church and community leaders to gain the ear of lawmakers. And yes, they have used some of the more vocal militant minority against the gay community's push for equal rights, ignoring the majority of more temperate homosexuals who just want what they consider fair - the same rights as others.
Agreed.
Captain Fantastic said:
Actually, gays did try to quietly get the same rights, but were outright rejected at first. Then they tried lobbying, followed by using the media and other means to gain rights that others have had for many years. Frustrated by the unbending "civil union" legal language issue (and the hardcore right wing that have fought gay rights tooth and nail), some have now become more vociferous and have made this a constitutional issue.
And it hasn't worked.
If it took 100 years to get from Emancipation to the Civil Rights movement...if it took 50 years to get from suffrage to legal equality in the work place...why did gays think that their efforts would be completed inside of 20?
Captain Fantastic said:
My point is simply we are at a stage in our development as a nation that this issue should not even be on the table for discussion.
So
YOU think. And again, you are dismissive of those who aren't of the same mind, and who WANT to talk about about. And so...since you don't think it should be discussed...they won't. They will simply vote their conscious since no one bothered to persuade them to change it.
Captain Fantastic said:
Would MLK have settled for a watered-down version of civil rights, where black Americans would have their own set of codified laws and rights that were mostly equal but different from the existing laws of the land?
Depending on your definition of "settle"...he did.
Regarding "separate but equal"...the problem was not really separate..the problem was that there was no equal. And again - I do not believe it is the desire of most Americans to have there be anything but equality.
It will all take time. Gays don't have to like it, but not liking it won't change it.