Should Bertuzzi be re-instated?

Should Bertuzzi be re-instated?

  • Yes

    Votes: 15 28.3%
  • No

    Votes: 31 58.5%
  • Last season shouldn't count...

    Votes: 8 15.1%
  • Don't care.

    Votes: 3 5.7%

  • Total voters
    53
the rusty tromb said:
...It's stuff like that that makes so many people consider the NHL to be nothing but a bush league joke.

I here ya, but the bush league jokes can be applied to all major sport in any country.

Why use Bertuzzi to prove to the masses whats wrong with the NHL? Whats that going to solve?

Sending Bertuzzi packing isn't going to change how the league deals with this conduct. There will be another Bertuzzi!! And then what?

Bertuzzi needs his ass kicked around the block for what he done. And then the NHL needs to address 'fully,' means in shutting this type of conduct down.
 
Cnd-Guy said:
Yes what ? It is or isn't my fault ?

Anywho I say he gets re-instated by the league , even though he should be suspended for a year like that guy from the Hamilton Bulldogs for clubbing another guy over the head. This is the NHL, they never do anything right

If they don't re-instate him, then what happens to his salary against the Canucks cap ?

A fascinating experiment. You really didn't go back to read my original post! :rolleyes:
 
21pro said:
should he be reinstated at all? i mean, he has viciously attacked other players in a like manner in his earlier days as a junior, etc. ...in each instance, he apologized in a 'deeply sorryful' way, got suspended, and yet, he still did it again... do you think he will not do this again? why can't he just stick to good ole canadian hockey... a few fisticuffs and lots of goals and good hits... to me he looks like he can be the ideal canadian role model... but this other shit has to go...

This might have been mentioned before, but I only got to your post 21pro...

Heatley drunkenly drives a car and his best friend dies in the accident. Who should be held more accountable, Heatley or Bertuzzi?... Heatley's suspension was not nearly so severe... Granted, it was an off ice incident in HEatley's case...

I think that Bertuzzi's act was given an appropriate punishment. However, it's not his fault that the season was cancelled... obviously he has gotten off lightly because of the lock out... but that should not be his problem....

I guess it all depends on how the suspension was worded... but I am pretty sure that it did not account for a full season being cancelled...
 
the rusty tromb said:
He wound up and punched Moore in the back of the head. What the fuck did he think was going to happen?

He probably thought what would happen is what usually happens when you punch someone in the head with your hockey glove on - Moore would either turn around and start fighting, or he would fall on the ice and turtle. What Bertuzzi did happens a thousand times a season in the NHL. The only time this sort of punch ended up the way it did for Moore in the entirety of last season was in that one incident. I think its pretty fair to say that no-one, including Bertuzzi could have predicted Moore's injury from those punches.

the rusty tromb said:
As I said earlier, if you end someones career as viciously as Bertuzzi has, you should be kicked out of the league.

It's not as if he layed a clean hit on Moore, or anything like that.

I don't really have a problem with the League being tough on offenders like Bertuzzi, because its bad for business if they aren't. I don't view hockey players or hockey itself as so sacred that someone like Bertuzzi needs to be kept on the ice or the world will end!

the rusty tromb said:
It's stuff like that that makes so many people consider the NHL to be nothing but a bush league joke.

I'm not sure any professional sport has a reputation for being "tough on crime", so I guess they're all bush league on that analysis. However, I think everyone should remember that the NHL and the other professional leagues are only sports/entertainment organizations and we really shouldn't look to them for "moral leadership" or enforcement of criminal law. I think the focus of the NHL in disciplinary matters should be on preventing unfair competition.
 
fun-guy said:
For all of you guys who think he should be reinstated, I wonder what you would say if Moore was your son or brother.

If Todd caused the same damage to Moore and it was a fair fight, face-to-face, toe-to-toe, then I would agree he should be reinstated. However, I have a real problem when someone attacks another defenseless person, smashes and grinds his head into the ice, keeps on punching his head when he's out cold, god forbid what would have happened to Moore if his team mates didn't come to pull Bertuzzi off. Bertuzzi lost it, he needs anger management help bigtime, he probably had no idea what the hell he was doing when he kept punching.

Todd has no right to take away another person's earning potential for life the way he did, his punishment should be alot more severe than a year off from playing when Moore will lose 10 to 15 years from playing. Is that fair in our just society? :confused:

Your reply begs the question of what you would think if Bertuzzi was your brother or son???? What types of things have you forgiven your family for??

I do not know Bertuzzi personally, so I do not know what type of idiot he is therefore I will not comment..

I am not excusing Bertuzzi's actions... they give criminals who beat up people on the streets, or rob people with guns less time that Bertuzzi received in a suspension......

Financially, Moore will sue for damages and get a decent compensation... the physical injuries, I do not know about...

Unfortunately, it's not fair to Moore, but then again most of our criminal punishments are not fair to the victims... that's why the US has so many civil lawsuits going on...

Based on precedents, Bertuzzi should be allowed to play again.. but he should/will be monitored and god forbid that there is a next time, he will probably not only get suspended for life, but he will probably be brought up on criminal charges..
 
slowandeasy said:
Heatley drunkenly drives a car and his best friend dies in the accident. Who should be held more accountable, Heatley or Bertuzzi?... Heatley's suspension was not nearly so severe... Granted, it was an off ice incident in HEatley's case...

I was waiting for when someone would bring up the Heatley incident.


Heatley's situation is completely different in my mind. It was an accident, both parties were in the car and both new the potential consequences. They were friends and like you say, it was an off ice incident so he is treated just like anyone else in this society.

With Bertuzzi, it was pre-meditated. He went after Moore to hurt him, plain and simple. Bertuzzi suckered punched him and wanted to hurt him and Moore didn't even know he was coming up from behind. Bertuzzi wanted to hurt him, there's no question, but I'm sure he didn't want the outcome to be what it was. Too bad, when you attack someone, the worst can happen and you should be prepared for the worst, or else don't do it. I still think he deserves to be banned from the league, and everyone else that causes the same damage, in any sport. I realize the league management is gutless and inconsistent in their decisions, and that's the biggest problem I think. We have to start somewhere, so Bertuzzi is just as good as anyone to start with setting an example.
 
slowandeasy said:
Heatley drunkenly drives a car and his best friend dies in the accident. Who should be held more accountable, Heatley or Bertuzzi?... Heatley's suspension was not nearly so severe... Granted, it was an off ice incident in HEatley's case...
Interesting point... but obviously Heatley never intended to hurt Snyder. He was just young and stupid. But at the same time... I don't believe Bertuzzi intended to paralyze Moore... just rearrange his face for what he did to Naslund. Two different situations.
 
fun-guy said:
I was waiting for when someone would bring up the Heatley incident.


Heatley's situation is completely different in my mind. It was an accident, both parties were in the car and both new the potential consequences. They were friends and like you say, it was an off ice incident so he is treated just like anyone else in this society.
...

With all due respect...Heatley's situation was not an accident... Anyone even close to the age of 18 knows that the consequences of drinking and driving can be very severe. When you take the wheel of a car after you have had a few drinks you are taking that responsibility.

fun-guy said:
Bertuzzi suckered punched him and wanted to hurt him and Moore didn't even know he was coming up from behind. Bertuzzi wanted to hurt him, there's no question, but I'm sure he didn't want the outcome to be what it was.

I still think he deserves to be banned from the league, and everyone else that causes the same damage, in any sport. I realize the league management is gutless and inconsistent in their decisions, and that's the biggest problem I think. We have to start somewhere, so Bertuzzi is just as good as anyone to start with setting an example.

I believe that Bertuzzi hit Moore with his gloves on, and then tackled him driving his head into the ice...

My argument is that Bertuzzi has been given the harshest suspension possible
However, I do agree that the league should clean up this kind of violence... Then again, hockey is a violent sport, and in the heat of battle these things can happen.... I do not feel that Bertuzzi meant to cause such damage... it looked to me like he was just trying to get Moore to fight with him.. but Moore skated away from him...

Regardless of his intent, the damage was done and he has paid his dues... its time to move on...
 
Last edited:
Heatley wasn't drunk, he had 1 drink and was well under the legal limt for impaired driving (dwi). However he was reckless and his recklesness caused the death of Dan Snyder, Should he be punished by the league? Don't forget a few years ago Craig Mactavish killed a woman while driving drunk. He served a year in jail and resumed his career when he was released.
What about Marian Hossa? He was careless with his stick and took Brian Berard's eye out. No punishment from the league. Were Bertuzzi's actions premeditated? Does that make a difference than carelessness when the actions cause serious damage to another player?
Did anyone see Off The Record? Larry Robinson wondered why Bertuzzi was suspended, and made some interesting comments about the NHL, including asking for the elimination of the instigator rule. here is a Hall of Famer who is known for being intelligent and insightful, yet his comments were definitely not politically correct. If, say Don Cherry said those things he would be hung out to dry by the media.
On OTR, everyone, Roenick, Robinson, Mike Peca, Andrew Peters and Ric Nattress all said Bertuzzi should be back, he paid his dues.
 
slowandeasy said:
I believe that Bertuzzi hit Moore with his gloves on, and then tackled him driving his head into the ice...

Not quite accurate. Bertuzzi did not "tackle" Moore. Bertuzzi was tackled by Moore's teammate and the two of them fell on top of Moore. Also, Bertuzzi did not "drive Moore's head into the ice", except by virtue of falling on top of him.

I don't think it's necessary to embellish Bertuzzi's actions or intent to justify his suspension from hockey. It's enough that he caused the harm he did while breaking the rules of hockey.

However, I think if this case went to trial in court there would be some serious doubt as to whether Bertuzzi is responsible for the full extent of Moore's injuries.
 
Bud Plug said:
However, I think if this case went to trial in court there would be some serious doubt as to whether Bertuzzi is responsible for the full extent of Moore's injuries.
There would be NO doubt he is responsible. Whatever the actual physics were that occurred to cause the injury, there is no denying the sequence of events was initiated by Bertuzzi. And how did he initiate events? By delivering a blow (the purpose of which was to to have a negative physical impact on Moore) from behind when the victim couldn't defend himself, which means there is more of a chance of injury occurring, even if that wasn't his intent. An average person would have to be considered rational enough to consider that under those circumstances there is a possibility of more injury occurring than Betuzzi may have envisioned.

He started it, he had mal-intent, and being of sound mind he should have known there was potential for injury. He's 100% responsible.
 
Bud Plug said:
He probably thought what would happen is what usually happens when you punch someone in the head

Back of the head with Moore unable to defend himself. Don't make it sound like Moore had a chance to react.

Bud Plug said:
Moore would either turn around and start fighting, or he would fall on the ice and turtle.

You think Bertuzzi thought Moore would respond to a sucker punch to the back of the head? Come on, you don't think Bertuzzi is that stupid, do you? He knew what he was doing.He just didn't think Moore would be as badly injured as he was.

Bud Plug said:
What Bertuzzi did happens a thousand times a season in the NHL.

Umm, no, it doesn't. Please provide me all the examples of where another player wound up and sucker punched another player in the back of the head last season. The only one I can think of is when Matt Johnson punched Beukeboom in the back of the head, and surpise, it ended Beukeboom's career.
 
the rusty tromb said:
The only one I can think of is when Matt Johnson punched Beukeboom in the back of the head, and surpise, it ended Beukeboom's career.
Johnson was suspended for a grand total of 12 games for a deliberate attempt to injure. Is Johnson paying for Beukeboom's pain and suffering today? I don't even think he was fined. Beukeboom never played another game... Moore might. Bertuzzi's fine and suspension were the most severe penalties ever handed out by the NHL. He'll also lose a fortune in endorsement revenue... and will end up paying Moore in the civil case.

Shouldn't your argument be with the NHL and not Bertuzzi? Why is Bertuzzi now the poster boy for how the NHL should have dealt with these issues? They are the ones to blame.
 
Last edited:
12 games? I guess that shows how serious the NHL is of getting rid of such vicious acts.

They have to make an example of somebody so the players get the message that sort of thing will not be tolerated. Might as well start with Bertuzzi.
 
Larry Robinson asked the question the other day, "why was he (Todd Bertuzzi) even suspended"?

This from a man who knows more about hockey at a pro level then all of us on TERB combined.

I would say Larry, Todd or anyone else for that matter shouldn't be allowed to do what he did. But the NHL addressed the situation and put him in the penalty box. Fair enough, time served, lets let him play.

A life time ban for Bertuzzi? Some of you need some serious medication.
 
shack said:
There would be NO doubt he is responsible. Whatever the actual physics were that occurred to cause the injury, there is no denying the sequence of events was initiated by Bertuzzi. And how did he initiate events? By delivering a blow (the purpose of which was to to have a negative physical impact on Moore) from behind when the victim couldn't defend himself, which means there is more of a chance of injury occurring, even if that wasn't his intent. An average person would have to be considered rational enough to consider that under those circumstances there is a possibility of more injury occurring than Betuzzi may have envisioned.

He started it, he had mal-intent, and being of sound mind he should have known there was potential for injury. He's 100% responsible.

I can't buy the logic. If I let an empty shopping cart go rolling down a hill I can predict the kind of damage that might result. If a third party throws a 200 lb set of weights in the cart as it rolls along, much more serious damage will be done. How could I predict that?

He will be responsible, but he will not be responsible for the entirety of the injuries.
 
the rusty tromb said:
You think Bertuzzi thought Moore would respond to a sucker punch to the back of the head? Come on, you don't think Bertuzzi is that stupid, do you? He knew what he was doing.He just didn't think Moore would be as badly injured as he was.

Umm, no, it doesn't. Please provide me all the examples of where another player wound up and sucker punched another player in the back of the head last season. The only one I can think of is when Matt Johnson punched Beukeboom in the back of the head, and surpise, it ended Beukeboom's career.

It doesn't sound like you like the NHL much, so I'm not sure how much hockey you've played or watch. Watch most scuffles on the ice and you'll see many blind punches, punches to the back of the head, etc. Usually there isn't much force behind these punches. They're done to instigate, primarily. That's why there aren't more serious injuries. I can't tell from watching the Bertuzzi video whether Bertuzzi hit Moore any harder than the kind of scuffling that you see all the time. Again, the evidence seems to be that the collision with the ice and the piling on did most if not all of the damage.

As to whether Bertuzzi expected Moore to react, it's hard to say. I would guess that he expected Moore to turtle, based on Moore's avoidance of a fight up till then. But who knows? Moore was an agressive player, normally. Remember that he committed the original vicious illegal hit in the previous game between the two teams. I would say that Moore was probably trying to draw Bertuzzi into a penalty by not accepting his instigation into a fight.
 
Cnd-Guy said:
Moore already fought a Canuck player earlier in the game. Was he suppose to fight each and every player on the Canucks except Naslund ?
Yes... especially when he was an average player at best with very little ice time and then decides to go after the captain and leading scorer of the opposing team to try and make a favourable impression on the home crowd and teammates.

Cnd-Guy said:
I don't think Moore's hit on Naslund was illegal or vicious. If Naslund didn't lower his body and strech for the puck he would probably got nailed in the chest instead of the head.
You're blaming Naslund? Moore lined him up and went for the head. Great sportsmanship Moore... but the home crowd loved the sight of blood as Naslund was carried away. Well under your theory... I guess Moore should be partially responsible for his own injuries because he never braced his fall to the ice better?
 
Bud Plug said:
I can't buy the logic. If I let an empty shopping cart go rolling down a hill I can predict the kind of damage that might result. If a third party throws a 200 lb set of weights in the cart as it rolls along, much more serious damage will be done. How could I predict that?
The point is not that the perpetrator has to know the exact outcome to be guilty. The point is that the perpetrator very well knew beforehand that throwing a punch at someone from behind "could possibly" cause injury even if he doesn't know the extent. The purpose of a punch is to cause harm. He threw a punch at a man, who at that very moment could not defend himself, of his own volition. He willingly initiated an action intended to cause harm. Unfortunately, he got more than he bargained for.
 
Last edited: