Outplaying vs. Winning

superquad1968 said:
But Ranger you can't have a dialogue if you continue to insult the intelligence of other's ideas. No one will have a meaningful debate with someone who thinks and says he knows more than other. It becomes a pointless exercise. That's when they pick their ball up and go home.

Just trying to help. :)

SQ

I have ONLY ever done this when I've been insulted, or ridiculed.

I have ALWAYS been open to intelligent debate on the topic.
 
Cnd-Guy said:
You just don't get it do you Ranger67.
Ah, well.
LOL
Have you considered other hobbies? Needlework, say?
Well, you obviously don't understand f*ck all about hockey

Of course, he doesn't answer my question. Why? Because he can't.

Next.

See my point, superquad?
 
F*ck you, new2game. It's clear you know nothing.

Go to the nearest ATM. Take out some money. Buy a clue. Repeat as necessary.

One more f*cknuts for the ol' Ignore list. I should thank these idiots for speaking so plainly - makes them easy to pick out of a crowd. :D
 
Ranger68 said:
Here's my premise:
it's almost IMPOSSIBLE - or, let's say, at least very rare - for a team that's outplayed to win.
Let's put this entire issue to bed.

I agree with the above statement. I just believe that the Ottawa/Toronto series (6 farking weeks ago!!!) was one of these rare times that the team that won was outplayed.

Okay?
 
Hey Ranger...... F**k You !!

Doesn't 17 pages...of not having one person agree with you show that your point of view is AFU???.....guess not............I guess everyone's an a/hole but you...right ?????

new2game
 
This is where we disagree, Goober.

When I said it was almost impossible, I even outlined some ways this could happen in a previous thread or post - grossly incompetent officiating (as in, far worse then I believe anyone has ever seen in the NHL), or perhaps just sheer luck - the goalie has a stroke to give up the only goal in the game.

This wasn't one of those series. Toronto beat Ottawa based upon HOCKEY SKILL. Sure, most of that was GOALTENDING SKILL, but that's part of the game. The Leafs' goaltending prowess was able to overcome the obvious deficiencies of the rest of its game.

I've said it before, and I'll say it again:

taking into account goaltending, Toronto outplayed Ottawa - that's why they won - goaltending.

If Ottawa outplayed Toronto - taking into account goaltending, Goob - how come the Leafs won?

It's a very simple question. No need for harsh words, or throwing up your hands, or getting upset. A simple question and answer.
 
But Ranger68, I've given my opinion on that time and time again. Don't you actually read what I'm writing?

Where we seem to disagree is that you believe that goaltending trumps all other facets of the game. All a team needs to have is a good goaltender to outplay the competition day-in and day-out.

You can live with that flawed viewpoint of hockey, masturbating to your Eddie Belfour poster in your room. I'll analyze and enjoy hockey for its variation of positions and the importance of all those.
 
Well, despite my pleadings, you go and insult me again.
:rolleyes:

Goaltending trumps other facets of the game IF THAT'S WHAT LEADS TO VICTORY. If a team has superior goaltending, but is losing, that team is being outplayed, as a whole. They'd better figure something out. See this year's version of the Florida Panthers.

First of all, at least SOME other facets of the Leafs' game must have been reasonable - they weren't shut out in the series. In fact, overall, they scored more goals than the Senators, which doesn't happen for every team that wins a series.

But never mind that.

It's not a flawed viewpoint of hockey. It's a reflection of REALITY. The Leafs won - they outplayed them. Why? Goaltending. And the REALITY IS that lots of teams win lots of games just due to good goaltending. Lots of teams have excellent regular season records due to having good goaltending. Lots of teams win Stanley Cups due to having good goaltending. I'm sorry that the fact that having Eddie Belfour on my team caused your team to lose. Nothing I can do about it. I wouldn't change it if I could. But, it's a fact - Eddie cost you the series.

As for "analyzing hockey", I think it's VERY clear that my understanding of the analysis of hockey is much better than yours. You clearly DON'T REMOTELY understand how all the parts of a hockey team fit together - the synergies between scoring and defense, forwards and defensemen, goaltenders and skaters.

Answer my question, if you don't mind. If the Senators outplayed the Leafs - factoring in goaltending - why did they lose?

Or, just make the following statement:
"When I say outplay, I mean everything but goaltending. That is why I can say that the Senators outplayed the Leafs. When Ranger says that the Leafs outplayed the Senators, he's factoring in goaltending - something that doesn't make sense in my definition of the word outplay."
 
Why did I start this again?

If the Senators outplayed the Leafs - factoring in goaltending - why did they lose?
Simple. They ran into a hot goaltender. They didn't run into a hot defence, or a hot checking team, or a hot hustling team, or a hot passing team. They ran into a hot goaltender. That's all.

Now, for the last time, the Senators outplayed the Leafs in all facets of the game except goaltending. If you choose any 100 facets of the game, including goaltending, the Senators outplayed the Leafs in 99 of them. THEREFORE they outplayed the Leafs, on the whole, but still lost.

You clearly DON'T REMOTELY understand how all the parts of a hockey team fit together - the synergies between scoring and defense, forwards and defensemen, goaltenders and skaters.
I don't understand your reasoning, therefore, that if a team has better statistics in all facets of the game except one, that one trumps them all and makes the latter team outplay the other.
 
Sorry, guys.

So...how about that Ontario Budget yesterday?

*ducks and runs away from flying fruit and vegetables*
 
Definately more satisfying than reading:

DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
Asshat!
Moron!
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
DID!
DIDN'T
 
I'm still waiting for it to end in an ugly mess with the final post being..."If I stop saying Did! will you give me one of those famous hummers?" :D
 
Goober Mcfly said:
Why did I start this again?

Simple. They ran into a hot goaltender. They didn't run into a hot defence, or a hot checking team, or a hot hustling team, or a hot passing team. They ran into a hot goaltender. That's all.

I'm not sure why you started this again, but don't blame me.

But, anyway, my question was *FACTORING IN GOALTENDING*. You've essentially said that, when you DON'T factor in goaltending, they were outplayed. "Because of goaltending" doesn't answer the question of how a team can be outplayed and still win FACTORING IN GOALTENDING.

Goober Mcfly said:
Now, for the last time, the Senators outplayed the Leafs in all facets of the game except goaltending. If you choose any 100 facets of the game, including goaltending, the Senators outplayed the Leafs in 99 of them. THEREFORE they outplayed the Leafs, on the whole, but still lost.

I'm not sure I agree about "99 out of 100", but whatever. It's still a steaming pile of turd.

So, whoever played better in MORE areas of the game outplayed the other team, as a whole? Is that what you're really saying??

So, all those things count the same: shots, goals, hits, faceoffs, takeaways, giveaways, GOALTENDING (which, apparently, is only *one* category in your list), dekes, point shots, can-openers, breakouts, offensive zone faceoffs, defensive zone faceoffs, breakaways, penalty killing, power plays ... all those things are measured equally. Who chooses what those categories are?? Who decides that spitting, or intimidating the officials isn't a part of the game? How do you determine who did that better?

Don't you think that's a bit silly??
Don't you think that's a flawed interpretation of the game? I certainly don't think it reflects reality.
'Cause in my reality, in the series we're now talking about, goaltending was clearly the most important factor. In your *analysis* of the game, goaltending counts the same as, say, one-time shots. In that case, that someone "outplayed" someone else is a pretty useless statement.

Goober Mcfly said:
I don't understand your reasoning, therefore, that if a team has better statistics in all facets of the game except one, that one trumps them all and makes the latter team outplay the other.

Hey, if your definition of "outplay" is what I've outlined above, we can stop this discussion.
I think it's utterly useless to any meaningful analysis of the game, but whatever.

IF, on the other hand, you propose that "outplay" includes all facets of the game *outside of goaltending*, and *in proper proportions*, we might be able to wrap this up. That would be fine. The statement would have some meaning, and I'd agree with it, insofar as as agrees with your definition of "outplay".

Just admit that when you say "outplay" you mean everything but goaltending. Fine. I've said this before. This is what you really mean. Because, when you factor in goaltending in its proper proportion, you're then taking EVERYTHING into account, and obviously, taking EVERYTHING into account, the Leafs outplayed the Senators - the Senators lost. (Or, are you back to the argument that everything counts the same - all hundred (thousand?) things that guys can do to win games all count for the same in the end?)
 
Ranger68 said:
Just admit that when you say "outplay" you mean everything but goaltending. Fine. I`ve said this before. This is what you really mean. Because, when you factor in goaltending in its proper proportion, you`re then taking EVERYTHING into account, and obviously, taking EVERYTHING into account, the Leafs outplayed the Senators - the Senators lost. (Or, are you back to the argument that everything counts the same - all hundred (thousand?) things that guys can do to win games all count for the same in the end?)
Around and around we go! </getting dizzy>
Originally posted on page 13
Ranger68: Take a look at the thread that started all this nonsense -https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showth...;threadid=52866

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Goober Mcfly
Nuts.

As the third period was dying away last night, I felt a mixture of emotions...from sadness to anger to respect to hope.

I`m sad the Sens couldn`t make it past the Leafs again. I`m sad that they actually played mostly up to their potential but ran into an ultra-hot goaltender. I`m sad that I needed to log onto TERB the next day and listen to asshats like Johnnyhandsome rant and rave about how the Sens suck.

Which brings out the anger. I`m sick of people saying the Sens have no heart, no grit, no determination. I think they`ve proved otherwise. They won most of the battles, but lost the war. And not by much either. Last night was not the blow out of a few years ago, the final score withstanding. And as I listen to the echoing "woo-hoo!"`s emenating from the hallways and offices around me, I get pissed that the Leaf fans around here actually think that the result of this series makes it okay to chant "Sens suck" and belittle the team I love.

However, there were players on the Leafs team that deserve my respect. First and foremost, Eddie Belfour. This guy took the entire team and hopes of the entire Leaf Nation on his shoulder pads and still made save after glorious save. For that he deserves everyone`s respect. I also respect and admire Joe Nieuwendyk, Brian McCabe and Gary Roberts for playing their hearts out in the series. These four are the only Leafs deserving of my respect and admiration. I tip my hat to most of the Senator team though. With the exception of Bonk (where the fark was he?) and a few others, the fact that the Sens out-shot, out-chanced, out-hit, out-hustled and out-most everything else except out-scoring is admirable.

Which leads me to where I am now. With a sense of hope. I hope the Leafs are eliminated in four. I hope that Calgary or Montreal wins the Cup. I hope that there will be hockey next year. And I live in the hope that the Senators are a young(er) team with many good years left in them.

Well done Toronto.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Since then you have been arguing that solely because Belfour played awesome, the entire team played awesome. That is simply not true.

I have admitted before that the Leafs won the series, obviously. I have admitted that because they won the series, they *by definition* outscored the Senators. But the game of hockey is more than the final score. Plain and simple. Therefore, I can say that the Senators outplayed the Leafs, but lost the games because they were either a) outscored or b) didn`t score enough themselves.


quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by DenWa
When people say a team outplayed another despite losing, we all understand that generally means they did everything better than the other team but just couldn`t get it in the fucking net.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



You have argued that a team can not lose if they aren`t outplayed. Semantics.

Happy?
I never said that the Senators out-goaltended the Leafs. I know that simply isn`t the case. I have said repeatedly that in most of the facets of the game, except goaltending, the Senators outplayed the Leafs.

That`s my entire point, and I haven`t wavered from it.

See, the problem is that you consider goaltending to be the be-all and end-all of hockey. Let me ask you, is this true? If you say "Yes" or "No", my point is still the same.

I consider goaltending as just one part of hockey. But there are many more parts, most of which the Senators outperformed (or ouplayed) the Leafs. EXCEPT GOALTENDING.

For the last time, a team who has a goaltender who does his job correctly does NOT mean that the entire team did their jobs correctly.

</done with this dead horse>
 
Goober Mcfly said:
Around and around we go! </getting dizzy>

I never said that the Senators out-goaltended the Leafs. I know that simply isn't the case. I have said repeatedly that in most of the facets of the game, except goaltending, the Senators outplayed the Leafs.

That's my entire point, and I haven't wavered from it.

See, the problem is that you consider goaltending to be the be-all and end-all of hockey. Let me ask you, is this true? If you say "Yes" or "No", my point is still the same.

I consider goaltending as just one part of hockey. But there are many more parts, most of which the Senators outperformed (or ouplayed) the Leafs. EXCEPT GOALTENDING.

For the last time, a team who has a goaltender who does his job correctly does NOT mean that the entire team did their jobs correctly.

</done with this dead horse>

And my point has always been that since goaltending is a part of hockey, in any reasonable analysis of the game, it must factor in to whether or not A TEAM outplays another. Yes, it's one facet. The only things more important than it are team offense and team defense. Nobody gives a rat's ass whether or not the Senators outhit and outface-offed the Leafs - in the series just concluded, IT DIDN'T MATTER. The Leafs outplayed the Senators thanks to their goaltending.

No, I don't consider goaltending to be the be-all and end-all. I've said this repeatedly.

There have been lots of series in the past where other things have been more important - scoring, namely. The Oilers and Penguins, for instance, were teams that, for the most part, outplayed their opponents due to great offensive output. I guess YOU'D say that, well, since they only did ONE thing well, the other teams often outplayed them.
LOL
"If only that Gretzky weren't playing, we woulda won! We skated circles around everyone else!"
The corollary is that you'd say the losing team outplayed the winning team in EVERY SERIES in which the winning team's goaltender was much better than the losing team's. Thrilling analysis. Not much value there.

I assign values to individual team components BASED UPON PERFORMANCE and IMPORTANCE. In this series just past, it was the Leafs' goaltending that turned the tide.
Nobody gives a shit that Tie Domi played well - in the end, it didn't make that much difference. Or whether or not Chris Neil did. Or whether or not the Sens "outskated" the Leafs. How important were any of these in the final analysis?! Not very. It was the Leaf's goaltending that was the OBVIOUS DIFFERENCE IN THE SERIES. Any other conclusion is idiotic.

I have never said that every component of the Leafs' team outplayed the Senators. In fact, I've denied this, from the outset. As a whole, however, the Leafs, factoring in goaltending, outplayed the Senators. Yup - just because ONE GUY was that important. Enough components outplayed the Sens (maybe just one) that the team, AS A WHOLE, outplayed them (despite most individual components being outplayed). This led to the Leafs beating the Sens.


Period.

Your definition of outplay is focussed solely on skaters and may be so ridiculously constructed as to be useless in any meaningful analysis of hockey.
(Making everything a player does of equal value. LOL)

If your point is that the Senators, factoring in goaltending, outplayed the Leafs, YOU'RE DEMONSTRABLY WRONG. They lost.

:)

Get over it, Goober. There's always next year.